Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you or your child had private education, was it worth the money?

413 replies

edithfg · 28/12/2023 08:37

Just that really. We can afford it with relative ease but would mean one less holiday a year and we’d always be in the home we are in now. It’s nice and lots of room but essentially means we could go further up the ladder. Small sacrifices really and I want to do best for dc. Was it worth the money?

OP posts:
TheaBrandt · 28/12/2023 11:10

It is a good thing of course. Just that for generations the upper class elite have given their children the best jobs through net working and as soon as we are able to do so…rules change 😀.

PrivateSchoolTeacherParent · 28/12/2023 11:09

For me, taking a subject that was offered at A-level in my private school completely changed the course of my life, and I now teach that same subject. That isn't entirely due to the private nature of my education, but independents do tend to be better at offering offbeat subjects with small classes.

darisdet · 28/12/2023 11:08

Going to your local private school really doesn't open up that network. That network applies to schools like Eton and Harrow.

True. The top public schools rather than your average private school.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 28/12/2023 11:08

@TheaBrandt
'Dd will be going into Dh profession but no way could he give her a job as he could have a decade ago.'

Surely that's a good thing overall though, it should be a more level playing field for everyone. The exception, of course, would be if it were a family business and they choose to keep the running within their own family.

DewHopper · 28/12/2023 11:07

Draconis · 28/12/2023 11:00

"Sorry but this is a really silly post. This network you speak of is only really alive in public schools. And I would also say that lots of people mistake confidence for arrogance because they lack confidence themselves and feel intimidated by it."

Going to your local private school really doesn't open up that network. That network applies to schools like Eton and Harrow.

This is precisely the point I was making.

OVienna · 28/12/2023 11:06

The connections thing is overstated if you mean British private schools as a whole. I am not saying that contacts and connections don't matter in the UK but if this is what you're after it's very doubtful it will result in a 'return on investment' in most cases. In those that does, I'd venture the parents contacts would have done the job anyway, without the school fees.

TheaBrandt · 28/12/2023 11:06

Depends on state offering. Ours go to all girl academically pushy state and are thriving.

That said talked about this yesterday dd2 wants to go private at 6th form because said state school is full of “tragic neeks” and her mates all go to the local private schools. They are the cool party set. I want to encourage the neek thing I must say.

MandyFriend · 28/12/2023 11:05

Yes, as long as you choose the right one for your kids! My daughters spent from year 3 to year 11 in private school and then went on to the local grammar school for sixth form. It was the right decision for both of them. They’re both dyslexic and were struggling to get even a basic education at the local state primary school. I was told in no uncertain terms by the school’s SENCO, that to get any kind of help, I’d have a fight on my hands. We were lucky to find a private school with a specialist dyslexia centre. We could afford the fees, although not without making a few sacrifices. Both girls thrived educationally and ended up going to university (one of them got a first!) One is now working as a social worker and the other is doing her PGCE, so I’m a very proud mummy!

On a more selfish level, I made friends with some of the Mums at the private school and we’re all still very close friends, despite our kids long since leaving school and graduating university! I found the parents at the Grammar school much more stuck up and unfriendly than those at the private school, which is quite mind boggling!

AnneValentine · 28/12/2023 11:05

Howbizarre22 · 28/12/2023 10:59

I believe it may offer you connections/job prospects as someone up thread referenced the powers of “the old boys club” and I believe yes it means your education years were more comfortable-you had better facilities and more concentrated teaching etc but as an adult-what differences do you think it actually makes? Iv got a lot of friends from both backgrounds and there’s isn’t any notable difference between their professional career paths, salaries, intelligence, attitudes, communication abilities or outlook in the world.
I think if you’ve got the money and you want your child to have more opportunities/learning experiences in a more comfortable environment then go for it. But will it make a huge difference to who they are/what they do as an adult? Not really. That’s a lot down to parenting, life experience and other factors I believe.
Perhaps that’s not what people want to hear after spending a catastrophe proportion of their life’s earnings on their child’s education but this is my honest experience of it.

https://ifs.org.uk/inequality/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Private-schools-and-inequality.pdf

https://ifs.org.uk/inequality/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Private-schools-and-inequality.pdf

HoneyMobster · 28/12/2023 11:05

All 3 if my DC have been privately educated and it's been worth it for us a family.

They're all bright children and, I think, would have achieved similar results at a local state school. I suspect they'd have gone to a state grammar. DD sat the 11+ and got a place, the two DS didn't as they were already in a 'through' school. Two are at Oxford and one is at an Ivy League college.

The VFM has come through the experience rather than the academic results. DS1 played cricket and rugby to a good level and has continued at university. He sang and performed and has also done this at university.

DD played hockey and did a lot of music. She's now singing in an Oxford College Choir and performs in shows there.

DS2 took up a sport and has represented GB at it. This led him to be recruited to a US college.

All 3 could have done all these things at a state school but it was all there for them at school. And, most importantly, they loved their school and the overall experience.

Both DH and I work full time and having everything available at school made life easier. All 3 DC were / are very much the type to try things out though, if they hadn't been maybe it wouldn't have been VFM.

twistyizzy · 28/12/2023 11:04

margotrose · 28/12/2023 10:58

I was privately educated and think it was a complete waste of money.

If I was going to have children I certainly wouldn't bother to send them to private school.

Maybe you aren't aware of the current dire situation in many state schools then with temporary classrooms due to RAAC, classes with no teachers etc.

Draconis · 28/12/2023 11:00

"Sorry but this is a really silly post. This network you speak of is only really alive in public schools. And I would also say that lots of people mistake confidence for arrogance because they lack confidence themselves and feel intimidated by it."

Going to your local private school really doesn't open up that network. That network applies to schools like Eton and Harrow.

Howbizarre22 · 28/12/2023 10:59

AnneValentine · 28/12/2023 10:46

I didn’t say it was an absolute statement but if you think it doesn’t make much difference you’re wrong.

I believe it may offer you connections/job prospects as someone up thread referenced the powers of “the old boys club” and I believe yes it means your education years were more comfortable-you had better facilities and more concentrated teaching etc but as an adult-what differences do you think it actually makes? Iv got a lot of friends from both backgrounds and there’s isn’t any notable difference between their professional career paths, salaries, intelligence, attitudes, communication abilities or outlook in the world.
I think if you’ve got the money and you want your child to have more opportunities/learning experiences in a more comfortable environment then go for it. But will it make a huge difference to who they are/what they do as an adult? Not really. That’s a lot down to parenting, life experience and other factors I believe.
Perhaps that’s not what people want to hear after spending a catastrophe proportion of their life’s earnings on their child’s education but this is my honest experience of it.

Spirallingdownwards · 28/12/2023 10:59

State educated myself.

Private educated kids. Definitely worth it for us.

margotrose · 28/12/2023 10:58

I was privately educated and think it was a complete waste of money.

If I was going to have children I certainly wouldn't bother to send them to private school.

CrapBucket · 28/12/2023 10:58

DewHopper · 28/12/2023 10:54

Sorry but this is a really silly post. This network you speak of is only really alive in public schools. And I would also say that lots of people mistake confidence for arrogance because they lack confidence themselves and feel intimidated by it.

Don’t be sorry you’re entitled to your opinion. My post is written from many years of experience in the workplace though. I’m glad if your life has been different but I definitely know what I’m talking about here.

MummyJ36 · 28/12/2023 10:58

I went to a private school for secondary education and I can say in all honesty I truly do not believe it set me up for life or offered me anything a state school couldn’t have done. My friends who went to state school have all achieved more and had a much better work ethic than my friends from private school. Unless you are absolutely rolling in it and private school is the norm within your social circles I would not recommend blowing thousands of pounds on an education your child could get for free.

EasternStandard · 28/12/2023 10:56

Having used both sectors I think the network part is over stated a bit

I think the difference between various state schools and which school fits the child best is more relevant

KnackeredBack · 28/12/2023 10:56

3 DC, all were independently educated. DC1 - worth every penny and he would have struggled massively in many other schools (including less supportive indies). DC2, would likely have been fine in either. DC3 blossomed hugely in school and although again, would likely have been fine in any school, she definitely gained a great deal from it.

DewHopper · 28/12/2023 10:54

CrapBucket · 28/12/2023 10:52

Private school is a way into a financially privileged bubble / old boys network.

In a lot of cases the ‘confidence’ is actually arrogance, ime of working with ex private school people.

Give me a free school dinners kid anyday, for a much better attitude.

Sorry but this is a really silly post. This network you speak of is only really alive in public schools. And I would also say that lots of people mistake confidence for arrogance because they lack confidence themselves and feel intimidated by it.

TheaBrandt · 28/12/2023 10:53

Everywhere is so right on now with recruitment - blind CVS etc not sure how much help these school “connections” would actually be in reality as they no doubt were 20 years ago.

Pretty annoying as our family has clawed it’s way up over the generations to be in positions where we could really help the younger generation but it’s strictly forbidden. Which is as it should be I guess. Dd will be going into Dh profession but no way could he give her a job as he could have a decade ago.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 28/12/2023 10:53

CrapBucket · 28/12/2023 10:52

Private school is a way into a financially privileged bubble / old boys network.

In a lot of cases the ‘confidence’ is actually arrogance, ime of working with ex private school people.

Give me a free school dinners kid anyday, for a much better attitude.

While this is a bit of a generalisation, it's one with some truth in it (sadly).

CrapBucket · 28/12/2023 10:52

Private school is a way into a financially privileged bubble / old boys network.

In a lot of cases the ‘confidence’ is actually arrogance, ime of working with ex private school people.

Give me a free school dinners kid anyday, for a much better attitude.

DewHopper · 28/12/2023 10:51

There was no stigma in “trying” or “achieving”

This point made by PegasusReturns is one of the absolute key differences that I have found between state and private. You cannot overestimate the difference it makes.

squirrelnutkin10 · 28/12/2023 10:51

There are good and bad in both sectors but imo, if you were to put the best state school beside the best Independent school, then the Indie would top the state school.
It HAS to fit your child though or it is a complete waste of money. Look at the child you have and really consider what they need to bring the best out of them.

Mine are completely different children,
DD, very quiet, but fiercely academic, driven and competitive, fits in with somewhat nerdy, geek,y independent friends with drive, her current private school (6th Form) has allowed her to excel, Prefect, Head of Debating, Subject ambassador etc. Her confidence has rocketed and the opportunities to excel where she is strong have been very good.

Her Prep school took her from a quiet, shy, child and gently but persistently helped her to come out of her shell, take part in discussions and school plays and give speeches to an audience. They found her intellect and developed it.
Particularly important as she has a chronic health condition and missed a lot of early school years. They were very accommodating of this.

But we looked very hard to find what would fit her, and have for years driven her 35 minutes each way to school and back daily.

DS, sociable chatty and a bit lazy academically but has lots of energy, his Prep offered lots of exposure to music of all kinds, he has been playing an unusual instrument for 10 years now and loves being part of an orchestra. He was taught every sport imaginable and decent academics. But was bullied eventually, so we removed him straight away, and he went to a tiny Prep with little facilities but really good academics, which prepared him for Senior school.

We decided on a family feel co-ed small Private school with solid academics but a very warm inclusive ethos and it has been great for him, rebuilt his confidence, and he has a great group of friends. He is now confident enough to look at a more academic 6th form nearby.

Each school has given them something important, and built their characters in a very positive way, we listened to their input and reacted accordingly, but always made the final decision. It gets easier as they get older and their personalities shine through.
I do not like the rather woke leanings of some state schools, and wanted both to have the aspiration and character that we believe in, luckily the schools have done this admirably.