Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does your child have a teacher to go back to next week?

448 replies

fuckityfuckityfuckfuck · 27/12/2023 22:47

My reception child doesn't.
There are 12 unfilled primary teacher vacancies within a 10mi radius of us. Only 1 of those I could perhaps be reluctant to work in due to reputation. There are also another 16 vacancies with later start dates.

Primary has historically been oversubscribed. I know this has been an ongoing issue for a while in secondary maths/science but now it's seeping into primary which has always been more desirable, I don't see how parents can continue to ignore the issue.

Gillian Keegan has warned the independent advisory board to "consider school budgets" when recommending a pay rise for 24-25 so I would imagine there will be even more classes without teachers next year!

As its AIBU... its time parents started complaining to their MPs to protect state education.

OP posts:
Scarletttulips · 30/12/2023 09:42

Or they put TAs in to teach for a few days - I have done this and whilst I could manage behaviour etc I’m not a teacher!
It’s unfair on the TA who’s job is never permanent and the children who deserve a qualified teacher.

crumblingschools · 30/12/2023 09:35

@Shinyandnew1 problem with schools unlike some organisations you need an adult in the room. In my profession if someone left management would make the decision whether that person needed to be replaced or if the existing team could take on the workload. But if a teacher leaves, especially at Primary school they need an adult in the room, so if they have 7 classes and pupil numbers are such that it is difficult to merge classes they may have to resort to cheapest but not always best staff

TheMotherSide · 30/12/2023 09:29

It's workload.

Pay is poor compared to equivalent professions but it's not the reason colleagues are leaving.

For me, teaching has been a vocation, I have striven to be the very best I can be for each individual pupil and colleague for 25 years, often at the expense of my own DC and my own health, which I bitterly regret. But teachers' contracts clearly stipulate that you work whatever hours are necessary to discharge your duties. I feel quite queasy when I look back on the opportunities I have missed and turned down because work has demanded my time and energy in order to discharge those duties. No doubt, my pupils and their families have benefited, but I wish teachers weren't contractually bound to be put in situations where it is down to individuals to decide they effectively need to cut corners in order to achieve some semblance of a work life balance. A friend once asked me if I my partner was controlling me as I was always turning down invitations. Of course he isn't, I just know I will need the time for planning, preparation, fulfilling multiple subject leadership roles and there is always some unforeseen issue that needs to be resolved. It's galling.

Shinyandnew1 · 30/12/2023 09:29

Tereo · 28/12/2023 10:04

In Ireland schools don't pay the teachers so there's no downside to having experienced teachers.

This is a huge problem in English schools-which leads to heads being forced to save money by getting rid of expensive/experienced teachers (usually by suddenly declaring their teaching is inadequate). I have heard of a new head locally some years back (who was laughing to one of his SLT and overheard) that there were 4 teachers on UPS at his new school and he’d have them gone by Christmas. Reader: they were! He was vile, but he got what he/the academy wanted-a cheaper staffing bill. This is obviously completely short sighted as there is if there is nobody left to support the new teachers, they often sink, rather than swim-and need replacing. But…as long as it’s cheap, that’s all some heads seems to care about. If you can afford only 8 experienced teachers or 10/11 new ones-they are to go for the most possible. Quality and experience is not only not valued, it is actively targeted for removal.

When did teachers in England used to get paid directly from the LEA? Who changed this!?

Philandbill · 30/12/2023 09:19

Desecratedcoconut · 30/12/2023 08:53

There were almost 120k fewer births between 2011 and 2022, surely there will be a point whe, given the falling birth rate, fewer teachers will be required?

Eventually, but the government can't fill planned recruitment places for teachers and where children are isn't evenly spread around the country. In the local authority I work within there are children who have moved here and are at home because there is no school place for them. Or siblings at schools a distance apart because there is space for only one child in each school.

And the falling birthrate shouldn't be a way to solve the crisis in education. Teachers are unhappy enough to vote with their feet and leave the profession and that's not a good state for an education system to be in.

waterdusky · 30/12/2023 09:14

FishyTree · 29/12/2023 12:33

There is a lot of talk about ‘rights’ but in my view there has to be a bit of come and go on both sides. While lunch duty may technically not be compulsory, it is widely accepted by teachers that this is a vital part of making schools run smoothly.

DH expects staff to work in a flexible and agile manner in line with the school ethos. However, he is also receptive when flexibility is required the other way, such as for medical appointments or sick leave.

Actually it's against the law. It just takes one teacher to tell ofsted, ACAS or their union before your husband faces losing his job.

crumblingschools · 30/12/2023 08:59

@Desecratedcoconut problem is that there aren’t enough teachers now, and schools can’t afford them even if they were available. Although there is a falling birth rate at the moment there is currently a bulge going through Secondary school

Desecratedcoconut · 30/12/2023 08:53

There were almost 120k fewer births between 2011 and 2022, surely there will be a point whe, given the falling birth rate, fewer teachers will be required?

napody · 30/12/2023 08:46

Anotheranonymousname · 28/12/2023 00:38

I've been teaching over 20 years in some of SE London's more tricky primary schools and have been in an EBD school for the past few years. I'm moving out of primary in the new year, not because I don't love the teaching itself but because as time has gone on I feel less trusted and more micromanaged. I don't want the font size of the pre-printed learning objective to be the thing SLT care about when they do a book-look, nor do I want them to pick holes in why it is that X (who was excluded from mainstream and arrived in Y6) hasn't filled in their self-evaluation sticker for every lesson. I want them to be excited that X has any work at all to evaluate! I want to be trusted to make adjustments to the planned curriculum/timetable so if it's windy, we take advantage of that and measure wind speeds on that day, or measure shadows in the playground on a sunny Wednesday instead of on a rainyTuesday just because that's what SLT has decreed I must teach on a Tuesday afternoon. I want to be involved in mid-year rewrites of the curriculum map, not told after Christmas that the RE unit that had been carefully planned to link with the next book we're doing in English has been canned...

I know that SLT is running scared of Ofsted and are under the impression that the font size of the LO and the rigidness of my timetable will make or break (spoiler, neither was mentioned when Ofsted came and did their thing in the summer term). I believe their hearts are mostly in the right place but as well as the perceived pressure from Ofsted, they are stressed about school improvement officers, the school's reputation in the LA and seemingly, what to include in the next passive-aggressive email designed to shame most of the teaching staff. Gaslighting is commonplace and it's not a good look.

Pay is part of what makes teaching unattractive and/or unsustainable but it's not why I wouldn't encourage anyone to go into the job at the moment. Primary teaching has lost so much of its spark, the opportunities for awe, wonder and following a thread have been shrunk so much as to be barely there.

I'm excited about moving on to pastures new but will miss being a primary teacher.

This is such a great explanation.

The frustrating thing is it SHOULD be the best, most satisfying job in the world! All the ingredients are there. And when teachers love their jobs the benefits for children are off the scale- their experience of school is completely different. Teachers just need to be supported.

Ukrainebaby23 · 30/12/2023 08:24

Sherrystrull · 27/12/2023 23:48

It's not the pay.

It's workload, expectations of parents and slt. No money, large class sizes, high level of need in terms of SEND, ofsted, SATs, lack of flexibility.

THIS, Dh is a teacher, exactly what he says.
Children aren't a priority if you don't support their education.

Tories don't care, their kids go private.

mde1982 · 30/12/2023 06:38

I'm training to be a driving instructor.

TrolleyCase · 30/12/2023 06:33

Redvelvet24 · 28/12/2023 10:03

I’m a teacher who is seriously considering quitting. Yes, the workload is immense. I’m exhausted all of the time and literally cannot do anything in the evenings as I’m exhausted and spend At least 3 hours on a Sunday planning.

Worse is the attitudes of a lot of parents. Complaining about everything. It’s a thankless task.

We have vacancies we can’t fill. Some of the staff we’ve appointed do not have the skills or experience to do their jobs properly but they are all we can get.

If you are the parent of a school aged child and you cannot afford private education then you should be very worried.

A big part of my reason for deciding to go private was reading the comments from state school teachers on MN. Of course issues with recruitment will affect the private sector eventually. But for now my kids are at a fab place with lots of fully-qualified permanent teaching staff. It’s terrifying what’s happening.

Jeannie88 · 30/12/2023 00:00

I wouldn't want to go in to teaching as a career now, it's changed a lot, especially when MATS took over. Workload, double thinking every word you say, micro management, ridiculous observations criteria, deep dives, never being on top of marking books of huge classes, unnecessary and pointless tick box meetings, pressure for results, no escape from being contacted anytime, often poor and entitled behaviour, so much more...

elfintinsel · 29/12/2023 23:04

lapsedrdwhoenthusiast · 29/12/2023 18:07

Can teachers afford to live in your area?

Realistically it is very hard to be a single parent as a teacher. Both financially and workload are both huge factors.
I could just about afford to live and bring up my children alone but I would have to cook from scratch and use expensive childcare until 6.
I would be exhausted as would my kids and it would be a miserable existence in term time.

Meredusoleil · 29/12/2023 22:47

mde1982 · 29/12/2023 22:45

I'm a teacher and HoD in a secondary school. I leave full time employment on 31st December and will do 3 days a week whilst I retrain for my new career.

Teaching workload is insane and getting worse. It's a spiral because the more teachers leave, the more the workload increases for those left and then they leave too!

Just out of interest, what's your new career going to be?

mde1982 · 29/12/2023 22:45

I'm a teacher and HoD in a secondary school. I leave full time employment on 31st December and will do 3 days a week whilst I retrain for my new career.

Teaching workload is insane and getting worse. It's a spiral because the more teachers leave, the more the workload increases for those left and then they leave too!

Moll2020 · 29/12/2023 22:39

That’s a lovely dream!

Rockhopper81 · 29/12/2023 22:35

I left after over a decade teaching, when I had a breakdown. That was several years ago.

I've always said - if it was only the bit in the classroom, the actual teaching part, I'd go back in a heartbeat, because I loved all my kids and I honestly believe it was what I was meant to do. But it's not - not even close - so I'll never go back.

Lindyloomillion1 · 29/12/2023 22:28

My neighbour worked for.many years as a qualified teacher but gave that up for all the home life balance reasons cited. She is now a teaching assistant, earning much less but she leaves work behind at the end of the day.

PurpleBugz · 29/12/2023 22:18

I used to childmind for a TA who works in a tiny rural school 60 pupils and 3 teachers. Part of an academy. One teacher off sick frequently then another long term (was an operation the school had warning). Every time they had a teacher off sick the TA took the class she was doing it 3 days a week minimum by the time her child left me. She also had to supervise breaks and teach PE as part of her job. She was a young inexperienced 21 year old. Lovely lovely woman but she had literally no training and was teaching years 5&6. Even lesson planning.

LovelyIssues · 29/12/2023 21:47

Massive work load for the pay.

Not enough support for SEN children. Only a TA in the class in a child has an EHCP.

Classes are too big for one adult

Behaviours start to slip

Parents complain CONSTANTLY and demand more and more.

BarelyCoping123 · 29/12/2023 21:15

I work in a secondary school but not as a teacher - I can't see the situation improving, given the poor pay, bad working conditions, awful behaviour by students, terrible treatment by school management & parents, lack of respect, high stress, crazy high expectations etc etc
It will only get worse. Even when positions get filled now, the quality of the teachers is deteriorating (bar some amazing exceptions - and i cant see them lasting long, given the above). Awful situation all round

IPreferCatstoPeople · 29/12/2023 20:47

As a secondary teacher, it’s so good to hear a parent being fully aware of their child’s needs. The system is utterly broken. So much of my time is taken up with firefighting and behaviour management (yup, it actually has a formal name) that I am not entirely sure that even my mid level learners are getting what they need to make progress. If I didn’t actually love those moments each day when a child finally gets it, or says thank you (more often for listening to their worries than actually for teaching them), or just offers up a smile; and those moments when a class tells you they missed you when you have been off with the annual teacher virus, I would be looking for a faster exit route.

Moomieboo · 29/12/2023 20:42

I think my Son's PMLD school.has more Unquals than actually teachers.

Midsizegal29 · 29/12/2023 20:33

The short answer is that as long as education continues to be a political football then it will never improve. They love to put out headline figures about “record funding” etc but fail to acknowledge the actual issues impacting teacher recruitment AND retention (which they conveniently ignore). I left teaching this summer because the workload was physically impacting my health and o couldn’t see it getting any better. I taught for 7 years and loved being in the classroom, actually teaching, but I just couldn’t do it for the next 35 years of my life if I wanted to ever have my own family…

Believe it or not, the vast majority of teachers would rather a reduction in workload than a pay increase! Cap contact time at 80% of a full timetable (instead of the current 90%) giving teachers significantly more time to actually do the work required to do the job properly (and within the hours they’re actually paid for- not as free overtime in evenings/ weekends or holidays).