Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Complaint from neighbour re my tenant

120 replies

Belinda5 · 27/12/2023 21:45

I own an apartment that I let out through an agency. I've just had a message from someone in the block complaining that they've had the police knocking on the door today trying to get in touch with my current tenant and asking questions about his movements. This neighbour is saying he's been a nuisance for a while, is on drugs and they've made several complaints to the management company and I need to be more careful about who I let my property to as I'm putting other tenants at risk. Apart from one communication from the management company saying he was causing disturbance at night time, and smoking in communal areas I knew nothing about this. It's really upset me and has ruined a lovely evening with my extended family.
AIBU to think this neighbour shouldn't have texted me like that out of the blue. I will follow up tomorrow but am really shaken at being accused of putting other people at risk. I have handed the letting out of my apartment to an agency and have no say or decision over who it is let out to.

OP posts:
2jacqi · 28/12/2023 02:34

@Belinda5 this is one of the reasons I dont use a lettings agency!! I want to vet my tenants myself to see if they are suitable. an agency only wants to get a tenant into the flat to make some money.

Poppyseason · 28/12/2023 02:06

@Belinda5 you are sounding immensely privileged accusing this person of ruining your evening. Please remember this tenant is likely ruining a whole lot more than one evening for them and made them feel unsafe at home.

Not your fault per se. But please see it from their perspective and be less in your head about yourself.

Send a nice text back, speak to the management company make it clear you do not want to create difficult living environment for the neighbours and expect good tenants going forward or you will find another company. Be kind.

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 28/12/2023 00:16

missmollygreen · 27/12/2023 21:59

Im so sorry you are going through this, it must be so difficult for you.
Im saying that to the neighbour, not you, OP

You did not know about it, now you do. You chose to be a landlord. You take the money, now take the responsibilty.

👏👏👏
So. Much. This.

Nocturna · 27/12/2023 23:32

I suspect this thread is a joke, or a reverse

On the off chance it is serious, then how dare you. This really highlights the view that landlords are parasites

Jackiebrambles · 27/12/2023 22:58

RatatouillePie · 27/12/2023 21:50

You're the LL. You have an antisocial tenant.
I'd be issuing an S21 to expire at the end of his fixed period and find yourself a better tenant that doesn't annoy the neighbours.

This. I’m a LL too and i know it’s stressful but you have quite a responsibility.

YireosDodeAver · 27/12/2023 22:56

Sheesh. Your reaction to finding out that your failure to act as a decent lamdlord is putting innocent people at risk, and your reaction is to blame the person who told you for unreasonable behaviour because what? The damage to your ego because you are such a nice person? The damage to your frail nerves from hearing such criticism?

An agent is someone who acts (or doesn't) on your behalf under your instructions. Whatever they do or fail to do is still your responsibility. If they aren't acting ethically that is on you, and it's your job to sack the agency and appoint a different one if they are failing this badly. You have previously been told there were problems and you didn't act. Now it has got worse. Quelle surprise.

LdnReno · 27/12/2023 22:53

Me me me
Yes you're the victim in all of this..

Arkestra · 27/12/2023 22:47

OP - let me give you some motivation to do something about the underlying situation, rather than wasting your time worrying whether the neighbours have been sufficiently polite to you.

The last time I came across this kind of situation (drug-dealing tenants, letting company allowing things to slide and not forwarding complaints to the landlord), the aftermath was not pretty. The tenants eventually ran off owing several month's rent. The interior of the flat was effectively destroyed - internal doors smashed, dog shit all over every carpet and most of the walls.

If the tenants are behaving sufficiently badly for your neighbours to hassle you in your home at Christmas, then there is a decent chance your properly is being taken apart at the seams RIGHT NOW. If I were you I would treat this as a wake-up call and take urgent action.

Ask the letting agency what complaints they have received. Ask the neighbours what complaints they have made to the letting agency. Based on the answers you get, you can take appropriate action. Maybe the neighbours dislike the tenants and are making a fuss over nothing. But you have the equivalent of a bright red signal flare being shot into the night sky here and I would really advice you to act upon it as soon as you possibly can.

Or alternatively you can sit on your hands and run the risk of your property getting trashed. If things take that turn, your neighbours are unlikely to be very sympathetic, and I wouldn't blame them.

Diggerdriverless · 27/12/2023 22:40

You are upset at being accused of putting other people at risk. Imagine how upset your neighbours must be, feeling they are at risk. You have had a lovely evening ruined, imagine never enjoying spending time in your own home, feeling unsafe and unsettled because of the behaviour of a neighbour.

mummabubs · 27/12/2023 22:35

CharlieCoCo · 27/12/2023 21:47

if they have made several complaints to management and now had police around, its good they have messaged you to know, as your managment agency clearly arent being helpful, to your neighbours or you. Now you need to call your managment company and find out whats been going on and what the plan is now.

This. You say there have been several incidents of formal complaints to the management agency and pokice are now involved... But this is the first you've heard about any of this? The issue is with your management company, they're not doing the job you pay them to do or giving you the communication you need to have. Your poor neighbour is probably at the end of their tether, having tried to go down the usual route first and is just trying to regain a peaceful life without your tenant being antisocial.

Tagyoureit · 27/12/2023 22:34

Your flat, your tenant, your problem, it really is that simple. Just because you've gone through an agency doesn't abdicate you of responsibility.

You seem more upset that your 1 evening has been disturbed rather than the neighbours being continually disturbed

ActuallyChristmas · 27/12/2023 22:29

I think it’s right that you got the text. You need to know the management firm are not doing a proper job. I had this with a house near me that was let to drunken young fools (not students). One was sick in the shared passageway. He apologised when challenged the next morning but said he was late for work so could not clear it up. Fortunately, I knew the owners were relatives of neighbours. The owners live abroad. As soon as they knew it was sorted.

I appreciate it’s upsetting but you don’t want unsuitable tenants or bad management.

flowerchild2000 · 27/12/2023 22:29

From the neighbor's perspective they were in distress and didn't know the details of your arrangement. They were probably desperate. If I'm with company I put my phone away and don't look at it until the next day. I'm not criticizing you but I think it's unreasonable to blame the neighbor when it is your tenant and it's your phone. Both within your control whether you admit it or not. I hope you got it sorted and this won't be happening again! Sounds like the agency needs to do better so you're not put in this situation again. They're not doing their job!

Onabench · 27/12/2023 22:28

I am sure it is far more upsetting for your neighbours. How long is the tenancy? Don’t renew it and get them out

Bellyblueboy · 27/12/2023 22:27

this must be a joke- no one could have this little compassion and self awareness.

Caravaggiouch · 27/12/2023 22:26

The neighbour has done you a favour letting you know what’s going on! Even if you haven’t knowingly put people at risk, the behaviour of your tenant has put people at risk. This is your responsibility.

tara66 · 27/12/2023 22:26

You need to ask for references from previous landlords and good character refs from their employers or some professional person before you rent to anyone.

saraclara · 27/12/2023 22:23

My daughter had to do this. She lives in a row of terraced cottages, and the tenants two doors down made everyone's lives miserable. She had to phone the police twice because it actually sounded as though someone could be being murdered. And the police were called by others (or came for whatever reason) on many occasions.

She and other neighbours contacted the agent many many times to no avail. One of the neighbours managed to find the landlord's number from someone who had previously rented the place, and they contacted him. Unfortunately he couldn't have given a damn either.

The person who contacted you wasn't to know that you were in the middle of a nice extended family evening. She's probably been brought to her knees by their behaviour over Christmas. She did nothing wrong, and you need to take your responsibilities seriously.

purplehotdogs · 27/12/2023 22:23

OP, I've been this neighbour. Saved hard to buy my own house in a quiet peaceful road, but found out the landlord in my street let out the house opposite me to a dreadful tenant and it made me feel unsafe 24/7. Her first partner beat her and possibly her child too, the police would frequently come round knocking on doors to ask if anyone had seen anything or heard anything about various incidents between her and her partner, the guy living next to her suffered from havingt to listen to their screaming rows every day and her being hit, one time a police van and dogs came out to chase down a different man she was hiding in her house (still don't know what he'd done but when they caught him he went to prison), then she moved an Albanian drug dealer in which meant he was in the street loudly talking all night every night with cars pulling up constantly then leaving again, her drunk friends would come round at stupid hours and once crashed into another neighbour's parked car so nobody felt their vehicles were safe after that, and then there was a final incident which culminated in a group of men with an actual axe going into her house and doing something to a man in there that made him scream so loudly the whole street could hear.

It was terrifying and I felt unsafe in my own house 24/7. I imagine the neighbours of your tenant feel the same.

I called the landlord and let her know how unsafe we all felt and what was going on, and asked her to evict that tenant. To her credit, she did, and has since rented the house out to some wonderful people who are nice, normal neighbours.

How would you feel if it was you living with a nightmare neighbour and feeling unsafe in your own home? Please don't take this personally, just do the right thing and get rid of the problem tenant (or hand it over to the people you pay to deal with this stuff for you).

Sensibleandboring · 27/12/2023 22:22

I would say blame is on the agency as you outsourced the process to them. Did they not get referencing done?

NotDoingOk · 27/12/2023 22:21

Have you been carrying out inspections? If not, you need to give notice of an inspection straight away and see what's going on there.

Gnomegnomegnome · 27/12/2023 22:20

Surely it’s better to know?

Now you can do something about it.

Just reply and explain that you weren’t aware and thanks for letting you know.

LaughingCat · 27/12/2023 22:20

Oh, you poor thing! There you were, having a lovely evening with your family when some heartless randomer destroyed your peace and tranquility by bringing the repeated bad behaviour of your tenant to your attention, behaviour that’s attracted police attention and put other tenants at risk, and let you know that your letting agents are as useful as a chocolate fireguard. How on earth could any of that be your responsibility? It’s just too much for you to bear!

God, woman…I’d have been mortified if any of our tenants in our old flat had so much as crossed building management, never mind the police! I’d have been sending a sternly worded email to the letting company demanding to know the facts and followed it up with a visit in person the next day. And I would have been falling over myself to apologise to the poor person ringing up, promising to look into it immediately and making it absolutely clear that I’d had no idea what was going on but that I’d do everything in my power to get to the bottom of it and resolve the situation.

This person did you a massive favour by cluing you into this (unless it’s malicious, naturally, and untrue). Stop worrying about your fragile bloody sensibilities and sort out your mess.

PuzzledObserver · 27/12/2023 22:19

Good landlords provide decent quality accommodation, charge a fair rent, and deal with problems promptly once they are made aware of them. That includes problems with the property, and problems caused by the tenant.

Bad landlords fall down on one or more of the above.

You’re not a bad landlord, or a bad person, because someone who passed all the letting criteria turned out to be antisocial. But it IS up to you to deal with it appropriately.

Also perhaps have a word with your agency and find out what sort of references the tenant provided from a previous landlord. You might want to tighten up on process, e.g. ask to see them yourself in future and be more involved in the process of choosing future tenants.

We were once talked (by the agent) into accepting a tenant who was in a new relationship and had failed the credit check - they offered to pay a year’s rent up front. We accepted. At the end of the year, they paid one month’s rent, and that was it. By the time we got them out they had cost us £6K in unpaid rent, £1,500 in legal and court fees, and it cost £4,000 to put right the mess they had made of the property. At least we got to keep the deposit.

After that, we resolved to never again accept a tenant who didn’t pass all the checks and have immaculate references.

Asifiwouldnt · 27/12/2023 22:17

But you did know some of it. Smoking in communal areas puts them at risk. Causing a disturbance at night is a risk to their mental health.
You could have apologised and said you don’t realise it had escalated and thank her for alerting you and assure her you will investigate and act on the information.

Then talk to the agency to get the details of what’s been happening and if appropriate give the tenant notice and /or discuss the concerns with him and give a warning. You can do this via the agency but you have to take change here. And probably accept you might have an empty rent free flat for a bit.

Just sitting back and taking the rent and saying ‘nothing to do with me as I use an agency’ is a bit cowardly tbh OPH and you have to get involved in this one and protect the other people living there from the utter misery of an antisocial neighbour (if that’s what he is- you need all the info first)