Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To speak my own language to my child despite what my PIL think

564 replies

imnotfromroundhere · 27/12/2023 21:21

I'm from Country X but I moved here when I was 14 so effectively speak fluent English and I'm fully bilingual. I realise what a privilege it is and want my children to be bilingual too.

I've got 2 DDs - 2.5yrs and 7mo. The youngest one doesn't speak, the older one speaks X language better (says mini phrases in X but only single words in English). We've committed to doing one parent one language so I speak only X to them and my husband speaks only English. I'm a SAHM, neither goes to nursery, DH works full time so mostly they're just around me.

DH is close to his family so we see them about once a month. Every time I speak to either of my DDs in X they give me a look as if to say "huh?" or "you doing it again?" (Ie speaking in a language we don't understand) or they'll stop their own conversation and stare at me if for example they're talking and I say something to her like "let's put a jumper on" or "don't touch that" etc. Obviously my children's abilities and making them bilingual is far more important than making PILs comfortable. But still makes me feel horrible like they're all judging me and hate me.

DH says he doesn't notice it. Definitely there though. He's quite close to his family and scared to offend them.

OP posts:
birdglasspen · 28/12/2023 20:17

Keep doing as you are. Your PIL need to grow up and realise how great it is for their grandchildren to be bilingual. I’ve been a guest in a house where parents do this, all I’d say is if it may be important that the PIL know just repeat it in English? For example I was chatting away to my nephew about a game we could play or something while his dad was telling him to get ready to bed….it took me a while to realise what he was being told! But taking off a jumper etc….they don’t need to know and just need to get use to it! Also, at 45 my DH is a fluent English speaker but grew up till age of 5 with a different language in the UK. Then went to school and was taught solely in English. What you’re doing is great. I asked my MIL to do the same for my kids but she never seemed to get over the not wanting to speak a different language infront of me despite me asking her too! I hope your PIL come around to the fact it’s fantastic for your kids!

Kittybythelighthouse · 28/12/2023 20:09

@Mintygoodness you don’t see why because you haven’t read any of the thread and the many many responses from people who know about the One Parent One Language approach and stated that it is harmful to the child’s language development to be inconsistent. Her kids are far less likely to be fluently bilingual if she switches like that. This is how it works. You really do need to be consistent in the language until it is established. The first few years before they go out into English speaking schools etc are crucial.

Tribblesarelovely · 28/12/2023 20:08

My children are bilingual, it’s a brilliant talent to have, but, I don’t speak my husband’s language, and his family would consider it very rude to converse in Turkish in front of me.

MargotBamborough · 28/12/2023 20:07

Mintygoodness · 28/12/2023 20:00

I don't see why you can't speak to them in X language the majority of the time unless in the presence of others, such as family and friends who only speak English. I think it rude and unfriendly and puts a barrier between you and your ILs that's unnecessary.
I think it's fantastic that your kids will be fluently bilingual.

Oh for God's sake.

Can you not at least skim read the thread?

If the OP does what you are suggesting her kids are unlikely to be bilingual for reasons that many posters have explained.

Parker231 · 28/12/2023 20:05

Mintygoodness · 28/12/2023 20:00

I don't see why you can't speak to them in X language the majority of the time unless in the presence of others, such as family and friends who only speak English. I think it rude and unfriendly and puts a barrier between you and your ILs that's unnecessary.
I think it's fantastic that your kids will be fluently bilingual.

OPOL doesn’t work like that - it’s one parent, one language - all the time. Perhaps the IL should learn the language their grandchildren will be speaking much of the time.

Glipsy · 28/12/2023 20:02

Also anyone wringing their wee hands over the toddler having less English for now, that’s totally normal. Instead of seeing it as ‘behind’ see it as them having more words - they have all the words your average toddler does in one language plus some extras, and before long Peppa Pig will take care of the rest….

Mintygoodness · 28/12/2023 20:00

I don't see why you can't speak to them in X language the majority of the time unless in the presence of others, such as family and friends who only speak English. I think it rude and unfriendly and puts a barrier between you and your ILs that's unnecessary.
I think it's fantastic that your kids will be fluently bilingual.

Melassa · 28/12/2023 19:58

thatsnotmywean · 28/12/2023 18:25

My DGM was from a European country and was a SAHM whilst DGF worked long hours. She only spoke her language to DM and my uncle. My DGM only socialised with people from her country, who came over after the war and settled in the same area. A kind of expat community. DGM could speak English but would only use it in eg shops etc but still make mistakes well into old age.
When DM went to school, she was badly bullied and struggled to read and write in english although she could speak it. The teacher had to phone DGF to ask that DGM spoke English at home as DM was using non English words to count, to describe animals etc.
DGF put a stop to it, mostly, and arranged for his sisters to visit regularly to help, which DGM resented, even though they were older and not local so it sadly was only like once a week that they visited to babysit / read stories etc.
It really held DM back academically and socially and she gets tearful when she remembers. She left school with no qualifications whilst DF is degree educated.
Please dont do this to your children. If you want to teach them your language, balance this out more by giving them more opportunities to learn English eg playgroup and nursery for interaction.

This is such utter bollocks. This was the way of thinking back in the dark ages. My own British GPs thought the same and bullied my DM out of teaching us her language.

you have a whole thread of people’s lived experience to the contrary, yet you focus on a flawed way of thinking from ages ago. it doesn’t even make sense, if you think of (for example) refugee children who arrive in school with little to no English yet manage to get top grades at A level.

FYI bilingual children tend to have a neural advantage over their monolingual peers so speaking another language certainly does not hold you back. If anything, it helps with learning all subjects, encourages lateral thinking and broadens the mind.

HappyBusman · 28/12/2023 19:56

Teder · 28/12/2023 19:31

I’m going to take a shot every time someone who doesn’t understand OPOL says “oh it’s so great but it’s rude in front of English people” and see how long I remain conscious. 😂

Do people even read a thread or do they wade in on a topic with zero knowledge and understanding and repeat the same uninformed and incorrect opinion? It’s a long thread, chances are you’re not saying anything new. Have a little skim read unless you’re an expert in this area.
The OP is teaching her young children the correct way. Incidentally, perhaps the English speaking adults can learn some basic words and simple phrases. That’s much easier than teaching children to be bilingual!

You will be absolutely bladdered within about ten minutes.

Kittybythelighthouse · 28/12/2023 19:55

@Teder lol I’m with you! It’s soooo frustrating. The exact same uninformed comment over and over again. I feel like I’m going slightly mad. Cheers 🥂 😂

Glipsy · 28/12/2023 19:55

I actually wouldn’t even make the ‘it’s really important to be strict about OPOL’ argument. In theory I’m sure maybe kids could learn a special rule for PIL house. But why on earth should they!

Charitably, I’m going to assume a proportion of people saying they’d find it rude haven’t seen this in practise, it’s really not a major. When hanging out with a friend and kids, friend and I will speak the language we share. I’ll speak to her kids in that language, the majority of conversation is conducted in that language. If a child wants something, or she wants something from them, it will be conducted in a different language. If there’s a relevance to me, I’ll get a translation, eg ‘she wants to go home so I’ve said we’ll leave in 10’ but other times not. It’s SO far from disruptive or ‘rude’ seeming, it’s really no more disruptive than if the kid occasionally whispered something and I didn’t know what it was, which is also a thing kids do!

Teder · 28/12/2023 19:31

I’m going to take a shot every time someone who doesn’t understand OPOL says “oh it’s so great but it’s rude in front of English people” and see how long I remain conscious. 😂

Do people even read a thread or do they wade in on a topic with zero knowledge and understanding and repeat the same uninformed and incorrect opinion? It’s a long thread, chances are you’re not saying anything new. Have a little skim read unless you’re an expert in this area.
The OP is teaching her young children the correct way. Incidentally, perhaps the English speaking adults can learn some basic words and simple phrases. That’s much easier than teaching children to be bilingual!

Pollywoddles · 28/12/2023 19:00

MargotBamborough · 27/12/2023 21:26

Ignore other people's opinions.

Bilingualism is one of the greatest gifts you can give your children but if you are the minority language parent you need to speak it to them consistently. Switching to the community language every time it's more difficult to speak the minority language will undermine your efforts and reduce your children's chances of being truly bilingual.

This! We’re in the same boat and most of our extended family have bi or tri-lingual kids. None of our English speaking family have issues with the kids being spoken to in another language. Keep up the OPOL and ignore the in-laws.

Anywherebuthere · 28/12/2023 18:57

Keep speaking your own language OP. Its the best way for them to pick it up and become bi or multi-lingual.

If necessary you can translate to PIL.

And no you shouldnt just speak the language of the country you live in. Thats such backward thinking.

It's crucial to hold on to your mother tongue, your culture, your roots. It's a part of your and childrens identity. Your children will thank you for it one day.

Your DH can communicate in his language so they can pick that up too as that is also part of their indentity. They will very easily pick up English as its everywhere so you dont need to worry about that.

But if you dont use your mother tongue they will easily lose it.

Nicesalad · 28/12/2023 18:55

SandandSky · 28/12/2023 18:44

I am also in a friendship group where 2 people speak a language the rest of us don’t understand and they often speak to each other in X language when we are in a group. We all think this is really rude.

But why do you need to understand their private conversation?

lolomoon · 28/12/2023 18:54

Absolutely not! And your PIL should be understanding of the situation and want the best for their grandchildren. (Which is undoubtedly having two languages spoken by each parent in mother tongue.)
They can always ask you to translate things if they are interested.
I have a bilingual son as father is Greek and we've always tried to speak our native languages with him. Me English & husband Greek. Nobody ever complained, if anything they ask for translations or become more engaged in learning Greek by asking husband/son what some words mean.

Ang69 · 28/12/2023 18:54

We did this with our kids, I spoke English and DH spoke only French to them regardless of where they were. He would however make sure he was including other people, so would translate if necessary so they weren't excluded. It got easier as the kids got older and could switch themselves between English and French. It's a great gift to your kids, my 16 yr old DD is on her way to speaking more languages now as she finds Spanish and Italian so easy!

SandandSky · 28/12/2023 18:44

I am also in a friendship group where 2 people speak a language the rest of us don’t understand and they often speak to each other in X language when we are in a group. We all think this is really rude.

SandandSky · 28/12/2023 18:43

I think absolutely fine when you are as a family or at home. We do this too.

I do not do this in front of my ILs though as it’s really rude imo.

FictionalCharacter · 28/12/2023 18:42

Onceuponaheartache · 27/12/2023 21:23

Sorry I think it is rude to use a language they don't speak in their presence.

However you are not wrong to encourage your kids to be bilingual, it sill be an excellent advantage to them

I agree. It's great that you are bringing the children up to be bilingual, but it's rude to speak to them only in your language in the home of people who don't speak it.

Characterbunting · 28/12/2023 18:40

Renamed · 28/12/2023 18:07

Extremely puzzled by the idea that it’s rude to speak another language in general if there are other people around. Of course if conversation is general and someone makes side comments in another language - rude. If 2 people are chatting together at work or anywhere else and someone walks by who doesn’t understand what they are saying, who cares, and what’s it got to do with the third person anyway?

It's not random passers-by or others who just happen to be nearby that people are talking about here. Of course it's okay to speak your own language then.
But it's grandparents, at family get-togethers, who feel left out here.
OP needs to explain just why she does need to take the approach she's taking. Otherwise the situation is ripe for misunderstanding.

AuxArmesCitoyens · 28/12/2023 18:38

Fuck em. It is hard hard work getting kids to be bilingual and opol consistency is crucial. They need to be able to have an equal relationship with your family in language B too.

Bambooshoot · 28/12/2023 18:34

You are absolutely right in what you are doing. You are giving them a huge gift, not just in being bilingual, but in being able to understand how languages work, so they can easily decipher new words, or even new languages in the future.

Another huge plus is that the mobility of their tongue, neck and throat muscles will not be fixed in “default English”, so they should be able to pick up another language and speak without (or with less of) an accent since the muscles are already more flexible, (think of the French R and how hard it is for the English because the tongue doesn’t usually work that way) so with any luck they won’t have to spend ages trying to perfect the accent.

You are raising perfect spies! Or in the real world, people who are hugely employable because of their language skills and understanding of cultural backgrounds. Why would anyone want to shut that down, unless perhaps it made them feel inferior?

Basically, keep going, and ignore the in laws’ disapproval, just translate where need be and emphasise how clever their grandchild must be to be able to speak both languages at their age, maybe say their intelligence must have been inherited, if you can manage to lie convincingly,

(and try not to ask if they’ve ever been abroad!) 🤣

Zonder · 28/12/2023 18:30

An example of this is a multilingual family I know where mum speaks X to children, dad speaks y to children but when they have whole family conversation they use y because X is the community language outside of the house. But if both parents didn't speak that language they could use the other as their family mode.

Zonder · 28/12/2023 18:28

imnotfromroundhere · 28/12/2023 18:12

@Zonder I think you're getting a little confused with "minority language at home" which works if both parents speak the minority language fluently. My husband can speak X but he's far from fluent (and wont exactly become bilingual enough to speak it in the next few months)

Nope. Read my post above.