Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To speak my own language to my child despite what my PIL think

564 replies

imnotfromroundhere · 27/12/2023 21:21

I'm from Country X but I moved here when I was 14 so effectively speak fluent English and I'm fully bilingual. I realise what a privilege it is and want my children to be bilingual too.

I've got 2 DDs - 2.5yrs and 7mo. The youngest one doesn't speak, the older one speaks X language better (says mini phrases in X but only single words in English). We've committed to doing one parent one language so I speak only X to them and my husband speaks only English. I'm a SAHM, neither goes to nursery, DH works full time so mostly they're just around me.

DH is close to his family so we see them about once a month. Every time I speak to either of my DDs in X they give me a look as if to say "huh?" or "you doing it again?" (Ie speaking in a language we don't understand) or they'll stop their own conversation and stare at me if for example they're talking and I say something to her like "let's put a jumper on" or "don't touch that" etc. Obviously my children's abilities and making them bilingual is far more important than making PILs comfortable. But still makes me feel horrible like they're all judging me and hate me.

DH says he doesn't notice it. Definitely there though. He's quite close to his family and scared to offend them.

OP posts:
Abricot1993 · 27/12/2023 22:29

keep going in your language OP

pinkhousesarebest · 27/12/2023 22:29

For the little time you spend with your PIL, I would think it courteous to speak in the common language when you are with them. My dc very quickly learned which households spoke which language and added to their flexibility.
I don’t think anyone is disagreeing with the value of being bi/ multilingual but it doesn’t need to alienate family members - it will be a very natural process.

MargotBamborough · 27/12/2023 22:28

crumblingschools · 27/12/2023 22:25

How does OPOL work if you are having a conversation say at the dining table with parents speaking to each other but children are also sitting at the table. Which language do you use?

I would probably send the eldest to nursery for a few hours a week if they are not getting the exposure to language from DH

My husband and I just continue to both speak in our own languages but we both speak/understand each other's language.

If your passive understanding of the other person's language is better than your ability to speak it, and the same is true for the other person, this is actually the easiest way to hold a conversation.

Kanelsnegl · 27/12/2023 22:28

It's not rude 🙄 it's not like she's doing it to exclude anyone it's to ensure they learn the language.
They'll pick up the community language as they're surrounded by it and you need to work a bit harder at making sure they learn yours, one parent one language is a good way of doing that and as far as I understand its something yiu have to be really quite consistent with.
I'm trying myself, though I sometimes forget as I think in English after 9 years here, and I've just explained it to my in laws so they understand, have you done that?
If it's something involving them I'll explain in English to the adult what I was saying to the child my language.

Livelovebehappy · 27/12/2023 22:27

Most work places don’t allow this - speaking in a different language between themselves when others around cannot understand. Obvious reason being that it’s not inclusive, and is rude. No different when speaking with family and friends. Great to be bilingual and will be hugely advantageous for your dc, but it’s really not okay to do so when in the company of others who don’t know the language.

Renamed · 27/12/2023 22:26

Your PIL are silly. It’s right now that the children have the best chance of becoming bilingual and you should carry on.

crumblingschools · 27/12/2023 22:25

How does OPOL work if you are having a conversation say at the dining table with parents speaking to each other but children are also sitting at the table. Which language do you use?

I would probably send the eldest to nursery for a few hours a week if they are not getting the exposure to language from DH

MargotBamborough · 27/12/2023 22:24

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 27/12/2023 22:16

Yeah, you're being really bloody rude.

You see their grandparents once a month, and on that day for the few hours you are there, all communication with their grandchildren, you do in a language only you understand.

Because the other 99% of the month when you speak to them in language X would be ruined otherwise right Hmm

It's like a weird passive superiority thing you've got going on, that you're bilingual, and DC are, but PIL aren't, but you enjoy demonstrating this every time you visit.

I am also bilingual and would never dream of actively excluding my own children's grandparents like this.

Yes, speaking English to her kids from time to time in order to be "polite" to her in laws absolutely will undermine her efforts to get them to be bilingual the rest of the time.

Her kids are surrounded by English all the time. With their dad, their grandparents, out in the street, everywhere they go. They're not even at school yet and already they will be hearing English all the time. When they start nursery/school, their days will largely be in English, their friends will all speak in English, their teachers will speak English and the OP will be fighting a pretty lonely battle to get them to see the point in speaking her language.

Can you not imagine how much harder that battle will be if she speaks English to her kids sometimes? They'll learn that they can communicate with her just fine in English, which will be much easier for them at that point, so why would they bother to speak her language?

It's depressing to see so many people who don't understand this point giving ill informed advice which isn't backed up by any research on this subject.

Getting her children to be fluent in her language is more important than not offending her in laws! Or anybody else, for that matter.

LegoDeathTrap · 27/12/2023 22:24

YANBU, but you’re on a British forum where most people can say “goood mourning” in french and consider that speaking a foreign language.

Don’t give up. You have such a short time and the odds are against you with the DH and the schools all being in English.

DS1 started in language X, was fully bilingual at 2.5, and then I started slipping into English to make the fucking irrelevant people around me comfortable, he realised Mum speaks English and it’s easier, and now neither DS1 nor DD2 speak a word of X. It makes me so sad.

Mushroomwithaview · 27/12/2023 22:23

Gosh there is some idiotic advice at the start of this thread. If you live in an English-speaking country and your children go to school here they will definitely absolutely without a doubt speak English. You are absolutely 100% right to only ever speak to them in your own language. I remember my SiL doing the same and having a really hard time as the kids got older and replied to her in English or only wanted to speak English, but I admire her for being steadfast and insisting that the only language she would speak with them was her own language. She now has truly bilingual children. What a gift!

OP I suggest doing a bit of reading. There are some great resources for bilingual families that will talk about language acquisition and how it all works. Might be useful to have some facts up your sleeve when people make you doubt yourself.

And for those who suggested it was rude to speak your own language to your children - imagine moving to France or Thailand and being told it was 'rude' of you not to speak to your own children in French or Thai! Nuts!

queenmeadhbh · 27/12/2023 22:22

Possimpible · 27/12/2023 21:35

Err, judging by this post I'm not sure you're the best person to assess what's rude and what isn't...

Tbf I wouldn’t have put it as insultingly but I do find it tends to be English people who get all offended by people speaking another language. I have a German friend, she speaks German to her kids, I don’t speak German. It would be so unreasonable of me to demand she speaks English to them when I am there that I can’t quite believe people actually feel like that.

theadultsaretalking · 27/12/2023 22:20

OP, if your in-laws are judging you for this, then they are probably judging you for other things also, so I wouldn't sweat it - at least your children are getting something out of it! Keep going, you are doing nothing wrong!

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 27/12/2023 22:19

FWIW it is NOT rude to speak in a language others can’t understand. The only people who think that are ignorant British who can’t speak any other languages

100% this. So many British people are very weird about hearing other languages spoken in front of them. It's ignorant, small-minded and insular and is the result of living on an island and of feeling arrogantly confident that Englisy is internationally understood. I'm English myself, but am a languages teacher and sometimes despair at this country's attitude to foreign languages.

justchristmas · 27/12/2023 22:18

Abricot1993 · 27/12/2023 22:02

As someone who is British and has brought up their children in a country with 4 national languages I absolutely agree with the posters who say a) speak your mother tongue b) give them a bit more exposure to the local language English but you speak your mother tongue c) most British don’t get the process to being multilingual, as it just doesn’t have the same importance in the uk d) it helps your children and gives them advantages cognitively by being bilingual. Courage.

Are you in CH?

(And I agree with you 100%!)

ACynicalDad · 27/12/2023 22:17

Cinateel · 27/12/2023 22:09

I think you should speak x to your children except when you are with people who don't speak x. It won't hinder your children learning your language, and you will be teaching your children to be considerate of others. You could also just repeat in English, for the benefit of others in the room.

OPOL is very simple I wouldn’t speak to the child in the other language until they’re quite secure. If you have to offer brief translations.

ArchetypalBusyMum · 27/12/2023 22:17

MalcolmsMiddle · 27/12/2023 22:10

You see them once a month but absolutely have to be bi-lingual 24/7?

Grow up.

Or the pils could grow up.

The reason we have the manners not to speak in another language or whisper in company is so not to exclude or have someone ill at ease winding what you're saying.
But in this situation, the pils should trust their dil not to be bad mouthing them, or to translate anything that is worth sharing so as not to exclude them - that would include some things but not the 'get your shoes on' stuff... and at the tender age the children are at the consistency is very important, she is raising their GC and giving them a huge gift.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 27/12/2023 22:16

Yeah, you're being really bloody rude.

You see their grandparents once a month, and on that day for the few hours you are there, all communication with their grandchildren, you do in a language only you understand.

Because the other 99% of the month when you speak to them in language X would be ruined otherwise right Hmm

It's like a weird passive superiority thing you've got going on, that you're bilingual, and DC are, but PIL aren't, but you enjoy demonstrating this every time you visit.

I am also bilingual and would never dream of actively excluding my own children's grandparents like this.

Moveoverdarlin · 27/12/2023 22:16

Of course you should teach them to be bilingual. You speaking your language, and DH speaking English is the most logical plan. BUT surely for a couple of hours once a month when you’re in the presence of your in-laws you could speak English? It’s a little bit rude to exclude them in the conversation when you can speak perfect English. It’s not going to harm your child’s language development if once a month you say ‘put your jumper on’ in English and speak your language for the rest of the time.

VisitationRights · 27/12/2023 22:16

YANBU you are doing exactly what you should to raise bilingual children, keep going.
I find U.K. particularly insular compared to continental Europe so your PIL’s reaction is par for the course.

Rumplestrumpet · 27/12/2023 22:16

Are you an expert Cinateel?! It absolutely WILL impact her kids learning her language of she switches all the time. There is extensive research to prove it.

Parker231 · 27/12/2023 22:15

Dotjones · 27/12/2023 21:23

You should speak in the language of the country you live in so I think YABU. You can still teach them the other language as a second one but the main language should be the local one e.g. French if you're living in France or Italian if you're living in Italy.

OPOL doesn’t work like that - the parents have to be consistent. DT’s grew up in London but English is their third language as DH and I spoke to them in our separate languages.

ACynicalDad · 27/12/2023 22:13

My greatest regret with bringing up our children is that we didn’t do what you’re doing. Although my wife’s language isn’t much use outside her own country it’s so good for brain development and leading subsequent languages. Your child will catch up with English very quickly when they join school. It may frustrate the in laws but they aren’t the most important people here. We have a ground who switches to another language to speak to her child, we can’t understand what they are saying but it really doesn’t matter.

titchy · 27/12/2023 22:13

Cinateel · 27/12/2023 22:09

I think you should speak x to your children except when you are with people who don't speak x. It won't hinder your children learning your language, and you will be teaching your children to be considerate of others. You could also just repeat in English, for the benefit of others in the room.

Except it will damage their ability to be fluent in OP's language.

KvotheTheBloodless · 27/12/2023 22:13

MargotBamborough · 27/12/2023 21:26

Ignore other people's opinions.

Bilingualism is one of the greatest gifts you can give your children but if you are the minority language parent you need to speak it to them consistently. Switching to the community language every time it's more difficult to speak the minority language will undermine your efforts and reduce your children's chances of being truly bilingual.

This is correct. If you speak the majority language you cannot switch it up to be polite - it is hard enough to get your DC to maintain their 2nd language once they reach school age. You must keep going!

Rumplestrumpet · 27/12/2023 22:13

As demonstrated by this thread, most people don't understand how OPOL works as the best way to raise bilingual children. The key is engaging your in-laws, explaining it to them and seeing how they vest want to be involved or support. My parents will often say to me kids "oh what does that mean?", when daddy speaks to them.in his language, encouraging the kids to translate and thereby reinforcing the bilingualism. They've even goty daughter to teach them some phrases and she tests them on it 😄 But that's because they're on board.

Include your in-laws, communicate with them (with your DH of course) and hopefully they'll be less judgemental and support your efforts

Swipe left for the next trending thread