Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To speak my own language to my child despite what my PIL think

564 replies

imnotfromroundhere · 27/12/2023 21:21

I'm from Country X but I moved here when I was 14 so effectively speak fluent English and I'm fully bilingual. I realise what a privilege it is and want my children to be bilingual too.

I've got 2 DDs - 2.5yrs and 7mo. The youngest one doesn't speak, the older one speaks X language better (says mini phrases in X but only single words in English). We've committed to doing one parent one language so I speak only X to them and my husband speaks only English. I'm a SAHM, neither goes to nursery, DH works full time so mostly they're just around me.

DH is close to his family so we see them about once a month. Every time I speak to either of my DDs in X they give me a look as if to say "huh?" or "you doing it again?" (Ie speaking in a language we don't understand) or they'll stop their own conversation and stare at me if for example they're talking and I say something to her like "let's put a jumper on" or "don't touch that" etc. Obviously my children's abilities and making them bilingual is far more important than making PILs comfortable. But still makes me feel horrible like they're all judging me and hate me.

DH says he doesn't notice it. Definitely there though. He's quite close to his family and scared to offend them.

OP posts:
AllProperTeaIsTheft · 27/12/2023 23:28

Have you been to any countries where the main language isn't English? If you have, did anyone hear you speak English? Did you make sure they understood English before you started speaking?

Exactly. British English-speakers are terribly offended at the idea of anyone speaking foreign languages in front of them, but it usually doesn't even occur to them to abide by that rule when they themselves are speaking English abroad.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 27/12/2023 23:25

Yes. It is very rude to speak a different language in front of PIL. You are excluding them.

No it isn't rude to speak a different language to the dc in front of the PIL. Are their delicate ears offended by the mere sound of foreign words?! It certainly would be rude to speak to the PIL in a different language, or to have an adult conversation in which they were involved, but speak a language they didn't understand.

sunflowerdaisyrose · 27/12/2023 23:24

As you said you only see them once a month, Id speak in English mostly on those occasions. If you saw them multiple times a week id think differently. We have some Italian friends - children always lived in UK so are bilingual - they all talk in English to each other too when they're with us and I think that's very kind of them.

Your children being bilingual will be fantastic!

autienotnaughty · 27/12/2023 23:22

Can't you translate for them or speak English for the short periods of time you are with them. They ideally need English as their first language if they are attending a English school so maybe they would benefit from 50:50 on languages rather than people

Freshstarts24 · 27/12/2023 23:21

Dotjones · 27/12/2023 21:23

You should speak in the language of the country you live in so I think YABU. You can still teach them the other language as a second one but the main language should be the local one e.g. French if you're living in France or Italian if you're living in Italy.

You are completely wrong. From a child development and speech and language point of view the parent should speak in their native tongue as this will be how they are most likely to model the correct use of language and grammar.
The children live in England, they will learn English. How do you expect them to be fluent in language X if the parent that speaks it, doesn’t use it.

HappyBusman · 27/12/2023 23:21

MargotBamborough · 27/12/2023 21:46

This.

It would be really useful if all the people responding could make it clear whether they are actually raising bilingual children or not.

I suspect most of the comments about rudeness are coming from people with absolutely no clue about this subject who just don't like other people speaking languages they don't understand in their presence.

This. The predominant Mner view is monoglot and has an ingrained sense that people who can speak English and opt not to in front of English speakers are being freakishly rude and exclusionary.

Keep doing what you’re doing. Raising your children to speak your language as well as English is way more important than your ILs’ prejudices.

Daisybuttercup12345 · 27/12/2023 23:18

MargotBamborough · 27/12/2023 21:27

WTF.

🙄

Yes. It is very rude to speak a different language in front of PIL. You are excluding them.
Are you generally a controlling character?

Heartofglass12345 · 27/12/2023 23:17

I think it'll be great if they can be bilingual.
I live in wales but can't speak Welsh. My sons go to a Welsh school and they start them off by saying things in Welsh then in English (such as put on your coat) could you do that when you're around them? Could you explain why you're doing it? Maybe not everything you say to her but some of the things.
It's surprising how quickly they pick up another language though, its amazing!

anicecuppateaa · 27/12/2023 23:16

Totally disagree with some of the replies suggesting you are rude. I was an au pair for an English/ Spanish family for two dc aged 3 and 6 months. The parents followed OPOL and both girls could easily swap languages by the time I left, and used to translate for their parents (although they were both bilingual) from a young age. Keep going, being bilingual is an amazing skill for your dc to have.

Nicesalad · 27/12/2023 23:15

Livelovebehappy · 27/12/2023 22:27

Most work places don’t allow this - speaking in a different language between themselves when others around cannot understand. Obvious reason being that it’s not inclusive, and is rude. No different when speaking with family and friends. Great to be bilingual and will be hugely advantageous for your dc, but it’s really not okay to do so when in the company of others who don’t know the language.

Have you been to any countries where the main language isn't English? If you have, did anyone hear you speak English? Did you make sure they understood English before you started speaking?

LightDrizzle · 27/12/2023 23:12

You are doing the right thing. Have to explained OPOL to them? It’s a shame they haven’t seen the value yet.

We have Portuguese friends who live in England but speak Portuguese to their children (so not OPOL) and the children are bilingual at 7 and 2.5. I visited the mum’s parents back in Portugal with them while they were on holiday with them and as my DH doesn’t speak Portuguese, the children were slipping between English and Portuguese. It was the first time the grandparents had heard them speak English, they themselves can’t speak or understand any English, and they were bowled over by how clever their grandchildren are! Even though they know they live in England and the eldest is in school there. It was so sweet to see how proud they were.

Unless you are having protracted conversations in your 1st language in front if your in-laws then you are fine. OPOL couples I know where one partner didn’t know the other’s language, usually the English half of the couple, have pointed out that context and tone usually helps you know what someone is saying to a young child anyway, so it’s not as jarring or opaque as it sounds.

JaninaDuszejko · 27/12/2023 23:09

Just to offer some encouragement my nieces (who only spoke SILs language when they started nursery) would by the time they were at primary school watch Disney films in their Mum's language and translate them into English for me so I could understand.

The other thing to remember is that it is very very common for kids to refuse to speak the minority language as school kids but that doesn't mean they don't understand or can't speak it. I remember a friend being very worried about taking her kids to visit her parents as neither had spoken her language for over a year (she was still exclusively speaking it to them). They got off the plane, very quickly remembered their family didn't speak English and so started speaking in their mother's language. It's all there even if they refuse to use it.

grumpycow1 · 27/12/2023 23:07

Mushroomwithaview · 27/12/2023 22:23

Gosh there is some idiotic advice at the start of this thread. If you live in an English-speaking country and your children go to school here they will definitely absolutely without a doubt speak English. You are absolutely 100% right to only ever speak to them in your own language. I remember my SiL doing the same and having a really hard time as the kids got older and replied to her in English or only wanted to speak English, but I admire her for being steadfast and insisting that the only language she would speak with them was her own language. She now has truly bilingual children. What a gift!

OP I suggest doing a bit of reading. There are some great resources for bilingual families that will talk about language acquisition and how it all works. Might be useful to have some facts up your sleeve when people make you doubt yourself.

And for those who suggested it was rude to speak your own language to your children - imagine moving to France or Thailand and being told it was 'rude' of you not to speak to your own children in French or Thai! Nuts!

This!

FussyPud · 27/12/2023 23:05

It is very well documented that if a child is to have a decent chance of true bilingualism, OPOL is the best route. That means no switching between languages for the parents. The damage is long lasting, and much worse for the child than some family members having their noses put out of joint because they’re too lazy to make an effort too.

Copperoliverbear · 27/12/2023 23:03

@MargotBamborough this is a forum for opinions.
What lovely rude language you use.
I'm all for bilingual as I do this myself but try to do an equal amount of both.

grumpycow1 · 27/12/2023 23:02

Dotjones · 27/12/2023 21:23

You should speak in the language of the country you live in so I think YABU. You can still teach them the other language as a second one but the main language should be the local one e.g. French if you're living in France or Italian if you're living in Italy.

What a ridiculous reply- so if you live in a country you can’t ever speak other languages?! So if you moved to Spain you’d not speak English at home - sure 🤔

The dad speaks English to them so they’re not missing out.

PILs sound a bit ignorant (op maybe you could follow up sometimes with a ‘I said this’ to get them used to it?)

Madameprof · 27/12/2023 23:01

Whatevershallidowithmylife · 27/12/2023 21:31

So as you are predominantly with the children and already one is are more fluent in your home language how are they going to get on in nursery and school? Great to be bilingual but they really need to learn English as a first if you intend to stay in UK.

They will honestly learn English so easily growing up in Britain going to nursery and school. The minority language is the one that needs the work or it can easily be lost.
OP, you're right and loads of people on this thread know nothing about language learning.

edwinbear · 27/12/2023 23:01

I’m as British as they come. I only speak one language (which I find a bit embarrassing). I work for a Spanish bank, in London, where unsurprisingly, many of my (lovely) colleagues are Spanish. They switch between English & Spanish, mid conversation, without even realising they are doing it sometimes, it’s the most wonderful thing to hear and whilst sometimes, I don’t necessarily understand what they are saying, because they are kind people, I know they are not being rude. They are intuitive at knowing when people are a bit confused and always make sure to translate if people look a bit uncomfortable. It’s fun! Languages don’t need to be intimidating, if your in laws want to know what you’ve said, they can ask!

Ionacat · 27/12/2023 22:58

My niece is being bought up bilingual. She didn’t do nursery and chats away in English to us and minority language to SiL, she was slower to speak English but it hasn’t held her back. They speak the minority language in front of us. No one has an issue with it, and I’ve brushed up that language so I can understand most of what is going on. It’s important that my niece doesn’t reject the minority language as SiL’s family don’t speak English. (They don’t live in the UK.)

There was a thread on here the other day, about bilingualism and children rejecting the minority language and if I remember the advice was to stick with it. Ignore those that have no experience and get your DH to explain how it works.

Zonder · 27/12/2023 22:56

Onabench · 27/12/2023 22:38

YABU. You admit that they don’t get exposure to English as they don’t attend nursery and you’re a SAHP so they mostly only hear language X but then you cut off your in laws by speaking a language they don’t know when you spend time together. I do think it is really rude and it obviously isn’t going to set your child back with your current set up.

They have a dad who can speak to them in English and who presumably gets evenings and weekends with them. It's a snippet of time. Before long they will be much more exposed to English than language X so if they don't get a good foundation in it now they never will.

Dragonsandcats · 27/12/2023 22:56

midtownmum · 27/12/2023 21:31

Once they start nursery/school, it'll be all English all the time, so you've no hope of them being bilingual unless you get your language really well-established now. I say crack on, though you could try talking to your in-laws and saying something like "I just realised we never spoke about this, I hope it doesn't seem rude me speaking to the kids in x, it's just that research has shown that this is the best way to ensure they're bilingual" (although actually wouldn't it be better in your DH learned your language and spoke it too?)
Obviously those saying you should just speak in English are wrong, but you can see from this thread how few people know what best practice is in this context, so I imagine your inlaws haven't thought about it and just feel a bit left out.

I think this. You’re doing an amazing thing for your children but I’d try and. get your PIL to understand the research so they can see that you’re not being rude.

ArchetypalBusyMum · 27/12/2023 22:54

Rumplestrumpet · 27/12/2023 22:13

As demonstrated by this thread, most people don't understand how OPOL works as the best way to raise bilingual children. The key is engaging your in-laws, explaining it to them and seeing how they vest want to be involved or support. My parents will often say to me kids "oh what does that mean?", when daddy speaks to them.in his language, encouraging the kids to translate and thereby reinforcing the bilingualism. They've even goty daughter to teach them some phrases and she tests them on it 😄 But that's because they're on board.

Include your in-laws, communicate with them (with your DH of course) and hopefully they'll be less judgemental and support your efforts

Absolutely!

StaunchMomma · 27/12/2023 22:54

It's well recognised in education that bilingual children tend to do well.

I take it your DH is British and speaks to them so there's absolutely no reason why you shouldn't speak to them primarily in your native tongue, no matter where you are.

As for it being 'rude' in company, from what you said you're not exactly having full conversations, just little instructions to the kids. They can hardly claim you're having conversations about them if you're just telling the kids to put on a jumper!

Bit of xenophobia from the in laws, I think.

celtiethree · 27/12/2023 22:53

YANBU - stick to one language for each parent. Anything else will confuse them, I would perhaps translate for your PIL after you have spoken to your DC or ask your DH to translate.

shreddednips · 27/12/2023 22:51

You should definitely carry on what you're doing, it's the best way to ensure your children become bilingual. And it's an enormous advantage for children, I wish I'd tried harder to speak to my DS in English and the other language I'm fluent in.

I'd ask your DH to talk to your PILs and explain the rationale for OPOL, they may well be being xenophobic but perhaps they just don't understand why it matters. You could explain it to them but I don't see why you should have to, you're not doing anything wrong. They could, if they wanted to, seize the opportunity to learn the language themselves so they can converse with your DC in both!

I also think people have a lot of misconceptions about bilingualism- i.e. PPs saying how will your kids manage at school. What matters is that children are proficient in a language and spoken to lots- it doesn't matter if it's the local language or not. They'll grow up completely fluent in English because of immersion- and they have their father speaking to them in English, so they will have ZERO difficulties. I've taught classes where the majority of students didn't speak English at home and almost all were fluent, especially those who were educated in English from reception. They pick languages up rapidly at that age.

Swipe left for the next trending thread