Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To speak my own language to my child despite what my PIL think

564 replies

imnotfromroundhere · 27/12/2023 21:21

I'm from Country X but I moved here when I was 14 so effectively speak fluent English and I'm fully bilingual. I realise what a privilege it is and want my children to be bilingual too.

I've got 2 DDs - 2.5yrs and 7mo. The youngest one doesn't speak, the older one speaks X language better (says mini phrases in X but only single words in English). We've committed to doing one parent one language so I speak only X to them and my husband speaks only English. I'm a SAHM, neither goes to nursery, DH works full time so mostly they're just around me.

DH is close to his family so we see them about once a month. Every time I speak to either of my DDs in X they give me a look as if to say "huh?" or "you doing it again?" (Ie speaking in a language we don't understand) or they'll stop their own conversation and stare at me if for example they're talking and I say something to her like "let's put a jumper on" or "don't touch that" etc. Obviously my children's abilities and making them bilingual is far more important than making PILs comfortable. But still makes me feel horrible like they're all judging me and hate me.

DH says he doesn't notice it. Definitely there though. He's quite close to his family and scared to offend them.

OP posts:
CuriousGeorge80 · 28/12/2023 00:37

Genuinely amazed by the people arguing you are unreasonable because it would be rude in the work place 😂😂😂 - also the people worried that a child living with an English dad and who will go to school in England won’t speak English because their mum speaks a different language to them. What planet are people on? Have they never met bilingual people?!

You are 100% in the right OP. I work in a multinational company and what I wouldn’t give to be bilingual - what a gift you are giving them. OPOL has clear rules.

Presumably there is nothing stopping the PIL speaking in English to the children and helping their development. Or learning some of the basic language to support their development. I think I would sit them down and explain it once, in case they don’t understand, although amazed that your husband hasn’t done it to be honest.

GoingOverToTheDarkSide · 28/12/2023 00:33

So many questions about OPOL here!
several people have said that once a child realises they can speak to their mum in English (for example) they give up on their second language- but don’t they hear you speaking the other language in shops, on teh phone etc etc? And don’t they then make the connection that they can talk at home in the same language as school?
How the heck does it work with play dates? Or in a park/soft play etc where one parent is likely to be talking to various children? You give a guest child an instruction or ask what they want for tea in one language then say it to your own children in another?
am genuinely intrigued

PassMeTheCookies · 28/12/2023 00:13

YANBU. I think you're doing the right thing.

My SIL is French and she and my brother had the same agreement when my niece was born. She speaks only to my niece in French and my brother in English. Earlier on, she spoke more French as she was around her mother more, but now she's at nursery she speaks English mostly but can converse with her mum/grandparents in French.

I think had my SIL prioritised English when she was younger, she'd have missed that window for getting her to understand French from early on, given the majority of her exposure to language is English. They knew she'd have plenty of time and opportunity to expand her English skills whereas her access to French is just at home.

It's done her no harm, only good. She's 1.5 years younger than my son but is more advanced in both English and French than he is in just English!

penjil · 28/12/2023 00:10

Onceuponaheartache · 27/12/2023 21:23

Sorry I think it is rude to use a language they don't speak in their presence.

However you are not wrong to encourage your kids to be bilingual, it sill be an excellent advantage to them

You think it's rude to speak in f not of your young children in a language they don't understand?

But young kids don't understand much in any language, so does it matter?

WhatdoIdoTree · 28/12/2023 00:08

Keep it up OP! I couldn't speak English until I started school, went on to get a string of A*s at GCSE including English language.

I then went onto a Redbrick uni to do Law.

I love the fact I speak my mum's mother tongue, it has only enhanced my relationship with my Grandparents and their country.

meganorks · 28/12/2023 00:07

I completely understand what you are doing and of course you want your kids to be bilingual. I also think, that especially while they are so little, you want to stick to your language. But have you even explained to your PILs? I do also think, as they get older, you should speak English in front of other English speakers. Maybe not for little phrases, but if you are having a conversation.

I have some friends who are not English, with different native languages to each other. They both speak their own language to their children, but then English when around other English speakers. I think this makes more sense

AllIsWellish · 27/12/2023 23:58

Well I only speak one language but from everything I've read you are doing the correct thing only speaking to dc in your language so I say carry on as you are. Dc will soon pick up more English once they are at nursery

UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 27/12/2023 23:57

Branleuse · 27/12/2023 21:25

Keep doing opol. My husband didn't keep up with his language with the kids past toddlerhood, and it's a big regret now

THIS.

Bilingualism in a mono-lingual country is hard. Equally, it’s great for the children and an important part of their heritage. Those posters saying it’s rude don’t get how important it is to keep up the one-parent-one-language approach. English will come, absolutely inevitably, and the DCs will be able to converse with their DGPs.

A friend of mine was over today. We spoke English with each other. I spoke French with my DCs. She spoke Yoruba with hers. “Rude” didn’t cross my mind.

My FIL has tried to learn French for the sake of our DCs, and speaks very slow English with them when he has reached the limits of his French (…after about 20 seconds!) I had never thought of him as an especially supportive DGP (he is very distant and sees my DCs once every 2 years), but I’m beginning to reconsider!

Anele22 · 27/12/2023 23:57

Okay, hands up those of you who don’t know anything about bilingualism or OPOL but still felt qualified to give advice and judgement??
So much passive racism on this thread.

Thereislightattheendofthetunnel · 27/12/2023 23:57

OP don’t worry. Children are sponges at that age. Keep talking to them in yours. They may talk longer to talk but they get both languages eventually.

Unless you are talking to your in laws in your language YANBU. I would keep on doing it. They may even learn something too.

BlueFlint · 27/12/2023 23:56

Absolutely brilliant for your kids that are being raised bilingual, well done!

However - my in-laws speak another language as their mother tongue, and also fluent English. They often speak amongst themselves in their mother tongue when I'm there and I do find it quite isolating. You miss out on so many small social clues and context when people choose to speak around or over you in a language you don't understand and it's hard not to feel like they just don't care enough to ensure they're being inclusive. That said, we do have a difficult relationship anyway, so perhaps my feelings are coloured by that, and it's not exactly the same situation.

(I have for the record tried to learn their language, but it's a really tricky one and I felt like they just kind of made fun of me for not being great at it, so I gave up a bit.)

I don't think for a minute you're being rude here, or that you should stop speaking your own language when around your in-laws. Maybe your husband can chip in occasionally to translate, just to keep everyone in the context loop?

LinnieM · 27/12/2023 23:55

Dotjones · 27/12/2023 21:23

You should speak in the language of the country you live in so I think YABU. You can still teach them the other language as a second one but the main language should be the local one e.g. French if you're living in France or Italian if you're living in Italy.

You should speak in the language of the country you live in so I think YABU.

Says who? I’ll just forget about my mother tongue and speak in the colonisers language because I live in the UK? I think the fuck not

Melassa · 27/12/2023 23:51

olympicsrock · 27/12/2023 23:47

I think it’s brilliant for the kids to be bilingual but also rude to exclude others from a conversation.
Could you make an exception here?

That’s the worst thing she could do with OPOL, especially when they’re very small.

the in-laws need to get over it. If they are so worried they’re being talked about then maybe they could try to learn some of the OP’s language.

macaronicheezepleeze · 27/12/2023 23:50

You should stick with OPOL but I would mix in some English when with your PIL or others. A direct comment to child "go get your shoes" etc is in your language, also if they come to you upset, for comfort etc, use your own language. Your language is the primary language and should come first.

However, when talking to your PIL or other English speakers outwith your home and they're involved in the conversation, speak English. I.e "isn't that a lovely jumper granny bought for you" or "shall we tell grandpa where we went last weekend?"

Your children will learn to code switch.

GrumpyOldCrone · 27/12/2023 23:50

My children (young adults now) are bilingual. I’m the English speaker. OPOL is absolutely the way to do it. We never really cared if anyone thought we were rude because people who think that way are usually ignorant monoglot anglophones so their ‘opinions’ don’t really matter.

Escapaid · 27/12/2023 23:49

I am surprised at the number of people telling you you're being rude! Presumably you speak to your PILS in English and do not totally ignore them when you are with them and have your DC with you.

I know how it feels as my PILS do not speak a word of English. When we were living in their country, the language of which I speak fluently, I always spoke to my PILS, my DH and anyone else in their language, but DH and I had decided to do OPOL and I always always spoke English to DD. I got a few funny looks in the supermarket (very rural area) but I ignored them. My child's bilingualism is more important than others' ability to understand us, and I include my PILS in that.

That said, I always made an effort to include my PILS by translating my conversations with DD for them. This was pretty exhausting during the toddler years but DD now speaks confidently with her grandparents in their language since DH has only ever spoken that language to her. I still speak exclusively English to my DD no matter who we are with. Don't give up.

Melassa · 27/12/2023 23:48

C8H10N4O2 · 27/12/2023 23:33

Let's see - 2.5 yr old should be able to code switch two languages to pander to DGPs who don't value language skills for their DGC or the DGPs could learn a few words of the mother's language for the benefit of that 2.5 yr old?

Except here we are largely in the UK where being able to say "bonjour" is considered bilingualism and bloody foreigners should just learn English so obviously DGPs learning a few simple words outside of English is ridiculous and the 2.5 yr old is rude.

OPOL doesn't work when the parent switches language for convenience - it confuses the child and in extreme cases can cause semi lingualism where the language is clearly not valued. Its particularly a problem when the parent switching is the minority language.

The children are getting English from their father, they are surrounded by it on every source of media and every random person they meet. The problem is not learning English in an English dominant society - its learning anything else.

Exactly this. My DD is bilingual and I unashamedly spoke in English (we are in a non English speaking country) at every opportunity, whether there were other people there or not. Especially when she was tiny as you do need to insist. Most people were fine with it, unlike in Britain all I ever heard was “how lovely” and “isn’t she lucky growing up with 2 languages”

My DM had disapproving British in-laws too, so what would have been my mother tongue ended up being very diluted and I have an accent when I speak it. I was determined this wasn’t going to happen to my DD.

English being the community language will
always end up stronger, if all schooling is going to be local there’s plenty of time to pick
it up.

olympicsrock · 27/12/2023 23:47

I think it’s brilliant for the kids to be bilingual but also rude to exclude others from a conversation.
Could you make an exception here?

Oceanrudeness · 27/12/2023 23:45

To bring up children bilingual, as I think other posters have said, the advice is for one parent to speak in one language only and the other to speak in the other language.

Have you actually explained this theory to your PIL though?! They may not have any idea that's what you're doing and find you really rude.

On a side note, my friend at uni was brought up in Germany with a German dad and English mum. He was bilingual but no one ever thought to teach him the names of animals in English. So maybe make sure dad is covering all typical toddler subjects i.e. colours, shapes, animals etc.

Zonder · 27/12/2023 23:42

I wonder if anyone has told all the Brits living in Spain or France that they must always speak the language of the country they're living in.

ArchetypalBusyMum · 27/12/2023 23:42

@C8H10N4O2 well said 👏👏

OnionRings82 · 27/12/2023 23:41

Dotjones · 27/12/2023 21:23

You should speak in the language of the country you live in so I think YABU. You can still teach them the other language as a second one but the main language should be the local one e.g. French if you're living in France or Italian if you're living in Italy.

How backward.

C8H10N4O2 · 27/12/2023 23:33

PurpleOrchid42 · 27/12/2023 22:48

Exactly.

Let's see - 2.5 yr old should be able to code switch two languages to pander to DGPs who don't value language skills for their DGC or the DGPs could learn a few words of the mother's language for the benefit of that 2.5 yr old?

Except here we are largely in the UK where being able to say "bonjour" is considered bilingualism and bloody foreigners should just learn English so obviously DGPs learning a few simple words outside of English is ridiculous and the 2.5 yr old is rude.

OPOL doesn't work when the parent switches language for convenience - it confuses the child and in extreme cases can cause semi lingualism where the language is clearly not valued. Its particularly a problem when the parent switching is the minority language.

The children are getting English from their father, they are surrounded by it on every source of media and every random person they meet. The problem is not learning English in an English dominant society - its learning anything else.

OhChristmassTree · 27/12/2023 23:31

My ex is from a Portuguese speaking country and I said he should speak to our kids in Portuguese but he didn't because he said it would confuse them.

I really wish that he had though and that I'd pushed him more to do it.

HappyBusman · 27/12/2023 23:29

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 27/12/2023 23:25

Yes. It is very rude to speak a different language in front of PIL. You are excluding them.

No it isn't rude to speak a different language to the dc in front of the PIL. Are their delicate ears offended by the mere sound of foreign words?! It certainly would be rude to speak to the PIL in a different language, or to have an adult conversation in which they were involved, but speak a language they didn't understand.

It’s because a certain kind of person thinks that the person speaking another language is secretly slagging them off, using their Sinister Other Language Powers.