Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To speak my own language to my child despite what my PIL think

564 replies

imnotfromroundhere · 27/12/2023 21:21

I'm from Country X but I moved here when I was 14 so effectively speak fluent English and I'm fully bilingual. I realise what a privilege it is and want my children to be bilingual too.

I've got 2 DDs - 2.5yrs and 7mo. The youngest one doesn't speak, the older one speaks X language better (says mini phrases in X but only single words in English). We've committed to doing one parent one language so I speak only X to them and my husband speaks only English. I'm a SAHM, neither goes to nursery, DH works full time so mostly they're just around me.

DH is close to his family so we see them about once a month. Every time I speak to either of my DDs in X they give me a look as if to say "huh?" or "you doing it again?" (Ie speaking in a language we don't understand) or they'll stop their own conversation and stare at me if for example they're talking and I say something to her like "let's put a jumper on" or "don't touch that" etc. Obviously my children's abilities and making them bilingual is far more important than making PILs comfortable. But still makes me feel horrible like they're all judging me and hate me.

DH says he doesn't notice it. Definitely there though. He's quite close to his family and scared to offend them.

OP posts:
Plinkplonkplink · 28/12/2023 07:38

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 28/12/2023 07:16

And for those who suggested it was rude to speak your own language to your children - imagine moving to France or Thailand and being told it was 'rude' of you not to speak to your own children in French or Thai! Nuts!

imagine moving to France and being able to speak French yet when in the company of the children's French speaking relatives, for a few tiny hours per month, deliberately only spoke English. Rude!

There fixed it for you.

OP not speaking X for a few hours a month is going to change bugger all. As well she knows. The xenophobia isn't from the in laws.

Wow.

Sourisblanche · 28/12/2023 07:33

My parents didn’t mind dh speaking his language to dc in front of them. They even picked up some phrases in his language which they still use.

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 28/12/2023 07:16

And for those who suggested it was rude to speak your own language to your children - imagine moving to France or Thailand and being told it was 'rude' of you not to speak to your own children in French or Thai! Nuts!

imagine moving to France and being able to speak French yet when in the company of the children's French speaking relatives, for a few tiny hours per month, deliberately only spoke English. Rude!

There fixed it for you.

OP not speaking X for a few hours a month is going to change bugger all. As well she knows. The xenophobia isn't from the in laws.

Clearlyneedwine · 28/12/2023 07:15

keep up the one parent one language, if you were on the continent people would understand much better as its common for multi language households. In the UK its not as common which is probably why you have a lot of people saying its rude. If you want a langauage to be truly bi lingual each parent needs to consistent.

Kittybythelighthouse · 28/12/2023 06:54

@buckingmad you’re absolutely right that being bilingual is brilliant. Using OPOL consistently is how bilingualism is achieved. This is what so many are missing here. Everyone agrees that having another language is wonderful, but many don’t understand how that is achieved. What OP is doing is a critical step towards the goal of having bilingual children. Consistency is so important, especially at this age. Very soon English will take over entirely unless OP is really consistent in sticking to OPOL.

BananaSplitX · 28/12/2023 06:50

Omg. So many ignorant replies. Of course you should continue doing what you’re doing. It’s the only way your kids will speak their mother tongue. It’s so hard to have one non British parent and kids are surrounded by English every step of the way, apart from when they are with you. His parents should embrace it, encourage it, and should try to learn a few words. Keep doing it. It will make ALL the difference when their older and they will thank you for it. And I really dislike this “conform to the country you’re in” advice. Coming from a country where majority don’t speak a second language. Arghh

Kittybythelighthouse · 28/12/2023 06:34

So many loud and wrong comments from people who clearly do not understand OPOL or how raising bilingual children works. You are doing the right thing for your children, OP. If you’ve explained how important the OPOL approach is to your PIL they should just accept it and learn to cope. Your child is two for goodness sake. You’re not exchanging hot gossip or having scintillating conversations with her. I would not sacrifice the chance for my child to be bilingual because some grown adults ‘feel uncomfortable’ about being left out of a conversation with a two year old.

As for worrying about children going to nursery with less English, this really doesn’t matter one bit. They will be totally fluent in a matter of months. It’s so clear that the people pushing English first really don’t have a clue how quickly kids pick up language or how raising truly bilingual children works. I am bilingual btw.

newstart1234 · 28/12/2023 06:09

I'd just carry on doggedly. When they start school English will be very dominant and if they can they may resist their other language. It's so important to be fluent to be able to keep it up once they are aware English is the most useful language for them. I'd not care about the in laws. Aside from the advantages of bilingualism for the dc, it's also important for you to be able to communicate with your 'heart language' to your children if you want to- so they need to be completely fluent. This is way more important then whether other people feel it's rude. I have know many many many people do this. When my dc were little we lived in an international community no everyone spoke to their children in their first language regardless of the company they were keeping. There was an unspoken acknowledgment that English would become dominant for them so it's best to grab at any chance when they were little to help them learn their parent/s language/s. I'd suggest and explicit conversation between the DH and the IL to iron this out.

Plinkplonkplink · 28/12/2023 05:58

s4usagefingers · 28/12/2023 05:33

Just wanted to add that I’ve seen this where the child knows and understands the mother tongue but refuses to speak it and replies only in English. This happened because the mother tongue was spoken only when they were alone together and then English spoken when around others so she only had confidence in speaking in English.

Yep, that’s also important. If your kids are replying in English, just keep going in your own language, don’t be put off. Well done OP, you’re doing an amazing job.

Tintackedsea · 28/12/2023 05:57

It's not in the least bit rude. Don't let English speakers tell you this. Allowing English to be the default language is how other languages are erased. If you don't speak X to them they won't ever learn it. They will learn English eventually and although their language acquisition will be patchy at first they will catch up very quickly. If it bothers your in laws that much they can make an effort to learn some X so that they can communicate with their grandchildren.

"Hate" is pretty strong though. Maybe you should discuss this more with your Dh.

Twicemother · 28/12/2023 05:37

Your Fil can ask to learn your language too, if he would like to understand your communications with your own children.

Great job, it's really hard committing to teaching your children another language when in this country as so many ppl feel insecure and feel the need to know what a mother is telling a toddler, when usually it's obvious( don't climb the table, sit back from the tv, careful that can hurt) just so they can feel included!

There are more ways to include ppl then to stop you from teaching your kids your language.
If DH had said its a none issue go with it, or as others have suggested translate if it makes you more comfortable.

s4usagefingers · 28/12/2023 05:33

Plinkplonkplink · 28/12/2023 05:23

OP - please ignore these type of posts they are well meaning but they are incorrect. Research shows that speaking your language is the best way to help your child become naturally bilingual. If you start feeling you can’t do this in front of other people you may begin to stop doing it and your children may begin to show a preference for you speaking English. These early months and years are crucial for language acquisition so please keep it up. I have friends who didn’t (because of feeling judged etc) and their children didn’t become bilingual. It’s such a wonderful opportunity. Please keep doing what you’re doing. You’re doing great. Maybe try and find some information/research to show your in-laws. Once the children are older and it is more embedded then you can be more flexible with which language you speak in front of others.

Just wanted to add that I’ve seen this where the child knows and understands the mother tongue but refuses to speak it and replies only in English. This happened because the mother tongue was spoken only when they were alone together and then English spoken when around others so she only had confidence in speaking in English.

Plinkplonkplink · 28/12/2023 05:23

GenXisthebest · 27/12/2023 21:28

I would speak to your DC in X when you're at home and in English when you're with your PILs. I think it's a bit rude to speak in a language they can't understand.

OP - please ignore these type of posts they are well meaning but they are incorrect. Research shows that speaking your language is the best way to help your child become naturally bilingual. If you start feeling you can’t do this in front of other people you may begin to stop doing it and your children may begin to show a preference for you speaking English. These early months and years are crucial for language acquisition so please keep it up. I have friends who didn’t (because of feeling judged etc) and their children didn’t become bilingual. It’s such a wonderful opportunity. Please keep doing what you’re doing. You’re doing great. Maybe try and find some information/research to show your in-laws. Once the children are older and it is more embedded then you can be more flexible with which language you speak in front of others.

justchristmas · 28/12/2023 05:22

Glipsy · 28/12/2023 04:52

the thing I love best (ie hate most) is the idea that it’s ‘so lovely’ or ‘so enriching’ to be bilingual, rather than the far more common ‘this child will never be able to talk to their cousins, their grandma, exist in a meaningful way in their parents home country UNLESS they’re bilingual’. It’s not violin lessons!

I agree, But imagine, even if it was an optional extra, such as violin lessons, it would basically boil down to this argument:

'I'm sorry, OP, but would you mind asking the children to not practice their violin as neither grandparent had the opportunity to learn violin during their lifetime.'

Or, if they were encouraged to practice, having to explain every single note to the grandparent, as they went along. 'That's A, G, and F sharp.'

Complete and utter madness.

I can understand the speaking the most commonly spoke language with older children, when we have a non English speaker in our household, now DC are aged 8-14, we tend to speak the language of the community we live in. Of course, despite best intentions, we lapse into English sometimes (especially as we don't know every single word in the second language vocabulary). But with younger children and at that age... no way.

justchristmas · 28/12/2023 05:08

crumblingschools · 28/12/2023 00:39

Does OPOL continue forever or just when DC are tiny?

Not at all. Just until the children have built up a strong foundational basis. I only spoke solid English until they were 7/8, and now we do a mixture of the two.

Now, when I attempt to speak X language to their friends, DC laugh and say 'oh excuse mama, she thinks she can speak X', or correct my pronunciation (in a loving, joking way).

Glipsy · 28/12/2023 04:52

the thing I love best (ie hate most) is the idea that it’s ‘so lovely’ or ‘so enriching’ to be bilingual, rather than the far more common ‘this child will never be able to talk to their cousins, their grandma, exist in a meaningful way in their parents home country UNLESS they’re bilingual’. It’s not violin lessons!

happyduckk · 28/12/2023 02:09

What a great thing you are doing for your children, OP. Being consistent with speaking a language is fundamental when teaching a child to be bilingual.
Your in-laws are being silent bullies with their behaviour.
You are doing great, keep going!

PurpleBugz · 28/12/2023 01:27

That said though if you are only seeing in laws once a month I'd mix some English in for their benefit just to smooth things over. But so long as you are speaking to them in English and your husband in English when they are there is most certainly is not rude to speak X to your children

PurpleBugz · 28/12/2023 01:25

I work in early years and did some training on how to support bilingual kids. The advice is exactly what you are doing you speak X to them your husband speaks English. Or you risk them growing up understanding X and having basic communication in it but not fluent

lifesrichpageant · 28/12/2023 01:21

Surprised (and not surprised) by folks who think it is 'rude' to converse with a toddler in a foreign language. Most of the world are bi-or-tri-lingual, please rise above the small minded attitudes and converse with your children in the way you like! Your in laws will get over it. Good luck.

CobbldyCook · 28/12/2023 01:09

Horrified by the ignorant notion that speaking in your own language to your children in the presence of others is rude. Just keep doing what you’re doing, OP!!

s4usagefingers · 28/12/2023 01:05

Keep doing what you’re doing! But maybe explain it to them and why. Some people find it intimidating, especially if they aren’t used to different languages. I’ve been in multi language households and honestly we could all sort of understand each other in whatever language was spoken once we became more comfortable with each other. I’ve seen children speak one language with mum, one with dad and one at school/with friends making them trilingual. It’s worth upsetting a couple of people over.

HMW1906 · 28/12/2023 00:53

I agree it’s rude that you’re speaking a language your PIL don’t understand around them, it’s once a month presumably for an hour or 2 can’t you speak English for that small amount of time, I doubt it’s going to erase all of the language X your child currently speaks.

FloofCloud · 28/12/2023 00:43

Good for you! They'll pick up English properly soon enough - kids are sponges they'll be fine

crumblingschools · 28/12/2023 00:39

Does OPOL continue forever or just when DC are tiny?

Swipe left for the next trending thread