Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To speak my own language to my child despite what my PIL think

564 replies

imnotfromroundhere · 27/12/2023 21:21

I'm from Country X but I moved here when I was 14 so effectively speak fluent English and I'm fully bilingual. I realise what a privilege it is and want my children to be bilingual too.

I've got 2 DDs - 2.5yrs and 7mo. The youngest one doesn't speak, the older one speaks X language better (says mini phrases in X but only single words in English). We've committed to doing one parent one language so I speak only X to them and my husband speaks only English. I'm a SAHM, neither goes to nursery, DH works full time so mostly they're just around me.

DH is close to his family so we see them about once a month. Every time I speak to either of my DDs in X they give me a look as if to say "huh?" or "you doing it again?" (Ie speaking in a language we don't understand) or they'll stop their own conversation and stare at me if for example they're talking and I say something to her like "let's put a jumper on" or "don't touch that" etc. Obviously my children's abilities and making them bilingual is far more important than making PILs comfortable. But still makes me feel horrible like they're all judging me and hate me.

DH says he doesn't notice it. Definitely there though. He's quite close to his family and scared to offend them.

OP posts:
GrumpyPanda · 28/12/2023 12:28

Cinateel · 27/12/2023 22:09

I think you should speak x to your children except when you are with people who don't speak x. It won't hinder your children learning your language, and you will be teaching your children to be considerate of others. You could also just repeat in English, for the benefit of others in the room.

You are wrong. Yes it WILL hinder the kids' language learning because they don't distinguish between the languages but rather associate them with a specific speaker. It's fine for them to hear different languages from different people, but if one specific person suddenly switches code it gets very confusing to them.

FWIW I'm a multilingual adult and even I have moments of non-comprehension if somebody with whom I usually communicate in language x suddenly addresses me in y! Even if I speak y very very well.

Zonder · 28/12/2023 12:27

I think you speak your language in your own home, but when at your PIL it's fine for those short hours to speak English

This is the issue. People think all kinds of things. And then there's the well researched OPOL method which OP is going for. Really, what does it matter if she says put your jumper on in her language?

DisforDarkChocolate · 28/12/2023 12:27

Stick with it but throw in some simple translation for your in-laws when you are with them.

Despite you being at home with them as they grow up pretty soon English will be language they are exposed to the most. It's literally everywhere but in your conversations with them.

If you want them to be properly bilingual they system you're using is the one that's recommended.

Characterbunting · 28/12/2023 12:24

OP, I do think you and DH need to have a conversation with your PIL to explain what you are doing and why it is important at this developmental stage.

For people who don't have a background in bilingualism, switching to another language that your PIL don't understand can easily appear rude as many of the replies here have shown.
It's very clear they find your approach disconcerting, as would many people if it hadn't been talked through with them and explained.

Hopefully, they will be a lot more understanding when you have a chat about it all.

mondaytosunday · 28/12/2023 12:23

I think you speak your language in your own home, but when at your PIL it's fine for those short hours to speak English (snd when they visit your home) - after all you already say your eldest is more capable in your language so could probably have more practise. This will help when the child starts reception too.
I have relatives who used your approach but it was more equal as both worked, and they did modify it in the presence of others so all felt included (even if you are just saying 'put on your coat', people can be a bit worried that you might be saying 'I know her breath is stinky' if you get my drift).
The kids even attended daycare in a third language. They are trilingual now.

StripyHorse · 28/12/2023 12:19

I am an EAL (English as an additional language) teacher, and I think it is fantastic for children to be able to speak more than 1 language. It is so sad when children are effectively cut off from communicating with one side of their family because they don't know their home language? You haven't said OP if you ever see your side of your family, and if you have relatives who only speak X (I assume, as you moved here at 14, at least one of your parents can speak English).

YANBU to speak language X infront of in laws - perhaps translate for them if they are feeling excluded and it isn't obvious - I am saying this only to appease them. Once your DCs start school they will be exposed to English all the time so this will become much stronger.

It's not as if your conversations are going to be about your PIL at the moment - I can see why they might feel a bit more concerned with adults / teens, but at that point DCs should be well established in both languages so you can speak English when PIL are around. I would also be tempted to offer to help PIL learn some of language X so they can feel included.

Applesandpears23 · 28/12/2023 12:18

My friend is doing one parent one language and speaks to her child in her mother tongue. When she is with me she’ll give me a brief summary especially if it is relevant eg just explaining what we’re doing next or just gave my kids a 5 min warning as we’re going soon. You could do something similar for your inlaws.

wildwestpioneer · 28/12/2023 12:15

I think it's great that by our dc will be bilingual.

But I do think if you're in the company of friends or family you should speak the language used by all. Your dc will be in your presence far more than their df, as a sahp, and will be very experienced in X language so more exposure to English at the moment is a good thing.

CecilyP · 28/12/2023 12:14

Dotjones · 27/12/2023 21:23

You should speak in the language of the country you live in so I think YABU. You can still teach them the other language as a second one but the main language should be the local one e.g. French if you're living in France or Italian if you're living in Italy.

It’s not like she’s chatting to her in-laws in language X. It’s simply speaking to her DCs saying things totally irrelevant to PILs. I think they are the rude ones saying’huh’ when OP is obviously addressing DCs.

Characterbunting · 28/12/2023 12:14

MargotBamborough · 28/12/2023 12:05

I think it's unrealistic to expect them not to work out that she understands English, but they need to know that the language they must use to communicate with her is X language. And the only way to do that is to be consistent, at least until they are older and speaking both languages fluently.

Okay, I see, thank you.

BlackeyedSusan · 28/12/2023 12:12

If you start pandering to in-laws your kids not going to learn your language. It's beneficial to be truly bilingual.

Kokeshi123 · 28/12/2023 12:11

By the way, I do know some families where parents switch language depending on situation - the use of language may be linked to the situation rather than the individual person. That's fine if it works for that family. But the OP prefers OPOL and clearly finds this simple, easy to remember and conflict free. She has the right to use it.

MargotBamborough · 28/12/2023 12:09

Kokeshi123 · 28/12/2023 12:06

Doesn't matter. My kids know perfectly well that I speak Japanese (pretty fluently) and hear me using it all the time - to other people. They also know that I almost never use it to them. I've never had any issues with my kids refusing to use my mother tongue (English), and I think having a clear and consistent rule like this has really helped. Otherwise, the "school language" tends to take over as time goes on. I've seen it happen in some other families.

OP, it sounds like you are doing a good job. I recommend ONLY accepting advice about bilingualism from other people who also have bilingualism in their families; I'm laughing my head off at some of the stupid things some people are saying on here.

I would be laughing too if it weren't so damaging.

Think of all the children who have been denied the gift of bilingualism because their parents followed bad advice, especially bad advice about being polite to other adults.

Being polite to adults, even your in laws, is NEVER more important than supporting your child's language acquisition. In fact, the in laws of all people should understand this the most, because they are family and you should be able to explain to them how important this is and how the intention is not to exclude them but to support the children in acquiring two languages.

Kokeshi123 · 28/12/2023 12:06

Characterbunting · 28/12/2023 12:02

But won't they hear her speaking English anyway? To shop assistants, for example, or nursery teachers, or friends or neighbours who don't speak language X?

Doesn't matter. My kids know perfectly well that I speak Japanese (pretty fluently) and hear me using it all the time - to other people. They also know that I almost never use it to them. I've never had any issues with my kids refusing to use my mother tongue (English), and I think having a clear and consistent rule like this has really helped. Otherwise, the "school language" tends to take over as time goes on. I've seen it happen in some other families.

OP, it sounds like you are doing a good job. I recommend ONLY accepting advice about bilingualism from other people who also have bilingualism in their families; I'm laughing my head off at some of the stupid things some people are saying on here.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 28/12/2023 12:05

Threads like this make me wish that there was an opposite to the "thanks" button so that we could "boo" the really ignorant, xenophobic posts.

Ignorant monoglots who believe that it's rude for people to speak their mother tongue to their own children makes me feel quite stabby. Completely idiotic!

MargotBamborough · 28/12/2023 12:05

Characterbunting · 28/12/2023 12:02

But won't they hear her speaking English anyway? To shop assistants, for example, or nursery teachers, or friends or neighbours who don't speak language X?

I think it's unrealistic to expect them not to work out that she understands English, but they need to know that the language they must use to communicate with her is X language. And the only way to do that is to be consistent, at least until they are older and speaking both languages fluently.

MargotBamborough · 28/12/2023 12:03

WillYouPutYourCoatOn · 28/12/2023 11:01

So you genuinely think, for a few hours, once a month, to facilitate the only interaction the children have with the grandparents, this will stop your children from being bilingual.

You genuinely think this.

What research have you done to make you so confident that the reverse is true?

Characterbunting · 28/12/2023 12:02

MargotBamborough · 28/12/2023 11:58

The problem is that speaking English to her kids, even once a month, teaches them that they can communicate with her perfectly well in English and don't need to bother speaking her language if they don't feel like it.

But won't they hear her speaking English anyway? To shop assistants, for example, or nursery teachers, or friends or neighbours who don't speak language X?

SusanKennedyshouldLTB · 28/12/2023 12:00

CharmedCult · 28/12/2023 11:54

we see them about once a month.

Its once a month.

Your kids aren’t going to lose the ability to speak your language because you talk to them in English once a month when visiting your in-laws.

That’s not how it works with raising bilingual children. There are loads of papers on this.

MargotBamborough · 28/12/2023 11:58

CharmedCult · 28/12/2023 11:54

we see them about once a month.

Its once a month.

Your kids aren’t going to lose the ability to speak your language because you talk to them in English once a month when visiting your in-laws.

The problem is that speaking English to her kids, even once a month, teaches them that they can communicate with her perfectly well in English and don't need to bother speaking her language if they don't feel like it.

Random30 · 28/12/2023 11:57

Onceuponaheartache · 27/12/2023 21:23

Sorry I think it is rude to use a language they don't speak in their presence.

However you are not wrong to encourage your kids to be bilingual, it sill be an excellent advantage to them

yes, isn’t it rude of her PIL that she obviously been in their lives for years and they have put zero effort into learning her language.

Obviously also not bothered or interested in how bilinguality is actually achieved.

AxolotlEars · 28/12/2023 11:56

One parent, one language is fantastic. If you are only seeing your in-laws once a month, I would speak English while you are together

CharmedCult · 28/12/2023 11:54

we see them about once a month.

Its once a month.

Your kids aren’t going to lose the ability to speak your language because you talk to them in English once a month when visiting your in-laws.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 28/12/2023 11:54

Dotjones · 27/12/2023 21:23

You should speak in the language of the country you live in so I think YABU. You can still teach them the other language as a second one but the main language should be the local one e.g. French if you're living in France or Italian if you're living in Italy.

Ridiculous and so ignorant about how bilingualism works!

MargotBamborough · 28/12/2023 11:51

Daisybuttercup12345 · 27/12/2023 23:18

Yes. It is very rude to speak a different language in front of PIL. You are excluding them.
Are you generally a controlling character?

It's the ignorant comment about speaking the language of the country you live in as a priority. That's the best way to ensure your child doesn't become bilingual. Now I don't suppose the person who made that comment would ever do anything as wild as going to live abroad, but if they did, the idea that they would speak anything other than English to their own kids is laughable.