Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex asking for too much - AIBU?

37 replies

PositivityNeeded · 27/12/2023 20:49

Can anyone help me with a legal matter. My ex partner and I bought our first house together back in 2008 and we both contributed £12,000 each towards the deposit. We never married and split, after 3 children 4 years ago. Both names were on the deeds of our first two properties but upon buying the third house we moved into, he had become self employed and it was advised to put the mortgage in my name only and subsequently on the deeds of the house. He couldn't pay his half of the mortgage some months so I paid his share each month that he couldn't.

We split 4 years ago (his decision) and he moved out and rented. He said I could stay in the house until our youngest becomes an adult (8 years time) and then we'd need to sell and he would like his £12,000 plus any equity earned on that portion up until he moved out.

Now he is asking me to sign a legally binding agreement to the effect of the above but I feel this is my home as my name is on the deeds and he chose to move out. I'm willing to give him his £12,000 once I sell in 8 years but no more as I've been paying the mortgage ever since he upped and left. We go halves on all childcare costs and neither ask the other for maintenance. Can he force me to sign? Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
macandroni · 27/12/2023 21:04

So if I've understood this correctly, you purchased 3 houses together (2 jointly and 1 with only you on the deeds) and it was the FIRST House he contributed 12k to the deposit?

I would assume that the two previous properties were sold to enable you to buy your third more expensive home (again, I assume as that's usually how it works).

So yes of course he should get more than the initial 12k he put in over a decade ago... its morally abhorrent imo to suggest giving him merely 12k in 8 years time?! When his joint buying of the last two properties are what has enabled you to live in your third house, which is in your name only due to a technicality.

By all means suggest a deduction due to the months he didn't pay the mortgage but bloody hell... he should have enough for his own deposit AT LEAST. And he should have it now, not in 8 years time. That's awful.

Babyroobs · 27/12/2023 21:02

Why can't you play fair ? He could easily have forced the sale when you split and you would then have had to find the money to buy him out. The house is half his unless you regularly paid all the mortgage ?

Sunshine997 · 27/12/2023 21:02

He's requesting his 12k plus the equity generated from it up from the time that you bought your first place until he moved out? I dont know the legal position given its your name on the deeds but morally I think hes being reasonable as hes not asking for it until the youngest is 18 and hes not asking for it accumulated until then. I think hes being more than reasonable and YABU.

Riverstep · 27/12/2023 21:01

I would look at how much equity was in the house four years ago ( you can use right move for comparable properties ) and give him 50% of that figure. I would not be waiting another 8 years.

WorriedMum231 · 27/12/2023 21:00

You’re being hugely unreasonable. I actually think it’s disgusting that you would try and do anything other the very reasonable amount he’s asked for.

Spirallingdownwards · 27/12/2023 21:00

StripeyDeckchair · 27/12/2023 20:58

If the property cost £100k his £12k gives him 12% ownership.

If you eventually sell for £200k his 12% will entitle him to £24k less 12% of the selling costs (Estate Agent fee & Solicitors fee)

This is incorrect. They both put in 12k. He would be entitled to half the equity at the m he moved out. However he would owe her for his share of mortgage payments he hadn't made until that date which she could legitimately deduct from that half share of actual equity.

travelallthetime · 27/12/2023 21:00

Yes, you are being unreasonable. He is asking for his share of equity up until he moved out. £12k from 2008 is about £20k today for a start

TheSnowyOwl · 27/12/2023 20:59

I think you are BU.

You both need legal advice.

Spirallingdownwards · 27/12/2023 20:58

Get the house valued at the date he moved out. He would be entitled to half the equity at that point less any mortgage payments that you paid his share of before then.

StripeyDeckchair · 27/12/2023 20:58

If the property cost £100k his £12k gives him 12% ownership.

If you eventually sell for £200k his 12% will entitle him to £24k less 12% of the selling costs (Estate Agent fee & Solicitors fee)

LordSnot · 27/12/2023 20:57

Of course he can't force you to sign. If you can't agree it will have to go to court.

Morally he's being fair.

CatherinedeBourgh · 27/12/2023 20:54

So you want to give him his deposit, without even accounting for inflation?

He is being more than fair. His 12k bought him a % of the property, and he is asking for that back. If he contributed at all to the mortgage, he should be entitled to more, that is what he should get if you had paid 100% of the mortgage since he put up that deposit.

You are really stealing from him if you are not even willing to give him that.