Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Gone With the Wind really isn't a romantic film?

185 replies

FestiveFruitloop · 27/12/2023 13:10

Just finished watching it, hadn't ever seen it all the way through before. Toxic/abusive relationships, marital rape depicted positively (WTF??), racism and misogyny, manipulative characters... all I can say is I hope it's no longer considered romantic in this day and age. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
FestiveFruitloop · 27/12/2023 14:15

stemmedroses · 27/12/2023 14:05

the Ku Klux Klan effectively being heroes are pretty jarring

But that was the case in the South during the Civil War. The Southern States wanting to maintain slavery was one of the reasons for the war.

It's so ridiculous that people don't want to see/hear the unsavoury parts of history.

I suspect it's more that people don't want to see/hear it being normalised...

OP posts:
zigzag716746zigzag · 27/12/2023 14:14

Maireas · 27/12/2023 14:06

I think people are very aware of history, the American Civil War and the issue of slave owning states. Conflating it with a romantic melodrama is I suspect what people have an issue with.

But how do you get “romantic melodrama” from Gone With the Wind? It never was a romantic melodrama. What bits of it do you think are romantic?

It is and always has been, both as a novel and as a film, a harrowing depiction of a time of huge upheaval in history and how that affects a central (but not hugely likeable) character.

Maireas · 27/12/2023 14:14

Scarlett saw poverty and vowed never to be poor or hungry again. It was unusual to have a young woman with that mindset at the heart of a film.
I agree that it's all very pro Confederacy, but you have to see it within that context, not excuse or overlook it.

JanewaysBun · 27/12/2023 14:12

It's also interesting that (melanie and the dead mum excluded) there's no "good guy" white characters, they're all different levels of flawed, self centered beings.

TyotyaKlava · 27/12/2023 14:11

You can’t think of this in modern terms. The book was written /movie filmed in the last century, about the events that happened even earlier. It is about the past events and the reality that it all happened, and it was the norm back then. You can criticize it but it wouldn’t be fair comparison to the current norms.

JanewaysBun · 27/12/2023 14:10

I think it's fascinating. Scarlett isn't pleasant, she uses people gor her own ends, but is someone who will always come out fighting. She's not sympathetic and i think that. And Hattie McDaniel is phenomenal in the film.

I'm sure I read somewhere that Margaret Mitchell based the idea of moments in her childhood where her grandmother would drive her round the old burned out mansions of Atlanta and explain that this is what happens when you think your world will stay still and you don't adapt to thr changing world. Iirc the book is quite heavy on that theme, it's Scarlett who moves with the times whilst so many just watch as the world they know collapses.

It's only really Gable who makes it seem "romantic" because he was so charasmatic.

Smugandproud · 27/12/2023 14:07

HappyBusman · 27/12/2023 13:38

Do we get brownie points for not owning slaves and riding off to fight a war in the glorious cause of being allowed to own, buy and sell human beings, though? Hmm

You should be very proud of Lancashire Mill workers who supported the fight against slavery refusing to touch raw cotton picked by slaves even though it meant they had little work and therefore no wages to support their families.

Maireas · 27/12/2023 14:06

I think people are very aware of history, the American Civil War and the issue of slave owning states. Conflating it with a romantic melodrama is I suspect what people have an issue with.

DNAexpert · 27/12/2023 14:05

Just reread my message, I want to edit it but am on the app. I meant to say that I was shocked by its depiction that martial rape was a good thing.

FuzzyPuffling · 27/12/2023 14:05

And don't forget, marital rape was legal in the UK until 1991.

stemmedroses · 27/12/2023 14:05

the Ku Klux Klan effectively being heroes are pretty jarring

But that was the case in the South during the Civil War. The Southern States wanting to maintain slavery was one of the reasons for the war.

It's so ridiculous that people don't want to see/hear the unsavoury parts of history.

DNAexpert · 27/12/2023 14:04

Completely agree about the depiction of martial rape and it being a good thing. I was pretty shocked by that, I saw it a couple of years ago and still remember that scene.

Smugandproud · 27/12/2023 14:01

AnnaMagnani · 27/12/2023 13:51

The racism is overwhelming.

However age 10 I loved it and just saw Scarlett's awesome wardrobe.

The racism is a fair depiction of the time portrayed.
When Sammy Davis jnr performed with The Rat Pack in the 60's the theatre tried to prevent him entering through the front doors with Frank Sinatra and Dean Martin.
The US is still very racist imo.

AnnaMagnani · 27/12/2023 13:51

The racism is overwhelming.

However age 10 I loved it and just saw Scarlett's awesome wardrobe.

Maireas · 27/12/2023 13:44

Well, that cotton just didn't pick itself, @HappyBusman . Rhett Butler sure had to attend a lot of "political meetings".

HappyBusman · 27/12/2023 13:38

heartofglass23 · 27/12/2023 13:34

Most women would be better off with a Rhett than the porn addled incel men of today.

We are in no way superior enough to be looking down our noses at that culture.

Do we get brownie points for not owning slaves and riding off to fight a war in the glorious cause of being allowed to own, buy and sell human beings, though? Hmm

Allfur · 27/12/2023 13:38

Yes resilience it's its main message - tomorrow is another day

FestiveFruitloop · 27/12/2023 13:36

Yeah, content-wise I can't see why it was ever considered romantic either. I've heard various people rhapsodise about it being supposedly romantic over the years (even heard someone describe it as the most romantic film ever, once!) - it's beyond me how it could be viewed that way. I think there's a generational element to this, though.

derxa I take your point about resilience. I guess I just wish that theme was showcased within a less obnoxious story (to me anyway).

OP posts:
heartofglass23 · 27/12/2023 13:34

Most women would be better off with a Rhett than the porn addled incel men of today.

We are in no way superior enough to be looking down our noses at that culture.

LadyMacbethssweetArabianhand · 27/12/2023 13:34

Scarlett was not a likeable heroine but a strong woman who did everything she could to hang onto Tara. She became responsible for everyone at a time when that would have been seen as unusual. I like how Melanie was a fool to her. Equally strong in a different way. I agree it wasn't a romantic film but an epic one. Filmed in 1939, of course it reflected the mores of the time and was a faithful rendition of the novel, if watered down.

x2boys · 27/12/2023 13:29

I don't think it was ever supposed to be a romantic film.

GreatGateauxsby · 27/12/2023 13:28

derxa · 27/12/2023 13:15

It’s one of my favourite films. It’s a story about resilience.

Agreed.

It's an absolutely incredible and epic movie.
Possibly one of the best ever made.

Scarlett is a complex and evolving character.

Yes a huge amount of it isn't "palatable" especially by modern standards.

Shawshank redemption is another AMAZING movie. Huge amount of it is based around very unpleasant topics too.

Maireas · 27/12/2023 13:25

I like the way they refer to the Klan meetings as "political meetings".

HappyBusman · 27/12/2023 13:23

Tilllly · 27/12/2023 13:20

It's a product of its time

I'm not sure I ever thought of it as romantic, anymore than wuthering heights

@derxa is right, it's a story of resilience
Of tenacity, of women looking after themselves after generations of being cosseted

The book is better by far than the film but the film is an epic

That it reflects attitudes we have moved on from, should be a cause for us to celebrate. Not ban it in shocked outrage, which I think has happened before

X-post, WH is a good comparison.

HappyBusman · 27/12/2023 13:22

It was never tended as a ‘romantic film’, though — it’s a historical epic and family saga with a woman’s romantic decisions as a central thread. Peoole forget how many people Scarlett actually makes a pass at/ marries. She’s obsessed with Ashley, marries his younger brother, is widowed, uses Rhett to make Ashley jealous, makes another pass at Ashley, then marries her younger sister’s dopey fiancé, is widowed again, and even after she finally marries Rhett, she’s still involved with Ashley etc etc.

It was just the star casting of Clark Gable that makes his role more prominent than n the novel, especially as Leslie Howard was such a weed as Ashley.

Thinking it’s supposed to be a romance is like thinking Wuthering Heights is a romance.