Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Gone With the Wind really isn't a romantic film?

185 replies

FestiveFruitloop · 27/12/2023 13:10

Just finished watching it, hadn't ever seen it all the way through before. Toxic/abusive relationships, marital rape depicted positively (WTF??), racism and misogyny, manipulative characters... all I can say is I hope it's no longer considered romantic in this day and age. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Haydenn · 27/12/2023 14:47

As a story about women’s survival in a world where they have little agency it is unparalleled.

Scarlett is dependent on men and uses them to carve out a place in the world. It is a story of survival

Startingagainandagain · 27/12/2023 14:46

It is a story about resilience and flawed characters.

Not everything you see has to be moral and sugar-coated and end up as a perfect love story.

It also I think gives a fair idea of what the Southern societ was like in those days.

Of course that society was racist and misogynist, what do you expect?

I never understand people who look at films representing a specific period of history, the American Civil War, but expect it to show modern values.

It does not work like that...

The character of Scarlett is deeply unlikable, selfish and spoilt but she also shows great courage, resilience and strength. Same with the male character. He is not a hero.

Same with a Streetcar named Desire. Great film but again characters doing really questionable things.

I really wish people would stop trying to 'cancel' everything and obsess about reframing/criticising everything with today's values, rather than seeing them as something of their time.

Shf · 27/12/2023 14:45

One of my favourite books of all time. Scarlett is an incredible character; unlikeable, but yet somehow admirable in her determination to survive. The book is far more complex and the film missed some of the best characters, notably Will, who runs Tara for her in the end.

It’s not meant to be remotely romantic. Rhett has romantic notions of Scarlett and believes he can change her but in the end he realises it’s a foolish dream. She will never change, she’s been forged by the world around her, spoiled and petted and then suddenly forced to rely on her own wits. It makes a character that will never be softened or redeemed, even if we can understand why she makes the decisions that she does.

I always thought though that she should have just married Cade Calvert at the beginning…

Pemba · 27/12/2023 14:44

I thought the book was awful..Margaret Mitchell was writing in the 1930s wasn't she, not shortly after the Civil war period the novel is set in. The book is basically dishonest and gives a distorted picture of what was going on at the time. Rhett and the other men are involved with the KKK and yet are depicted as dashing romantic heroes. The enslaved people are depicted as childlike and happier and safer when they were living on the plantations. The northern soldiers are depicted as uncivilised scoundrels destroying the harmonious civilisation of the south.

Yes it sold well at the time and was considered a romance. Margaret Mitchell's world view was warped though. The main black actress, Hattie something (?) was given an Oscar but at the Oscar ceremony she was shoved onto a table right at the back, as the venue was normally segregated.The other actors did not stick up for her. Later she died in poverty. I think that says a lot.

The cinematography in the film was lush and Vivien Leigh was gorgeous. That's about all I can say for it. A lot of people quite rightly see it as offensive now.

Oxfrog · 27/12/2023 14:42

Others have already said this, but I do think it’s important - we lose empathy when we reject anything that doesn’t align with our worldview. If we don’t understand that the ‘baddies’ have complex emotional justifications for what they do then we can’t spot those self-serving hypocrisies when they appear in ourselves or in our society. I personally hate an antihero for the sake of an antihero, i’d never read American psycho, but GWTW isn’t that, it’s a study in humanity, like all the best fiction. We can learn from (proper, complex) antiheroes, and to understand different times and radically different perspectives. There’s very little to learn from a story about perfect, or trivially flawed people, behaving well, in a society that supports and encourages that…

Tilllly · 27/12/2023 14:42

Ktime · 27/12/2023 14:26

It’s definitely problematic but I used to watch it as a teen and swoon over Rhett Butler. Vivienne Leigh was stunning.

And Mammy was one of the best characters and I was so happy Hattie Macdonald won an Oscar. Through my teenage eyes I thought the depiction of Mammy was positive as I saw that Scarlett treated her well but now I see it differently as an adult.

She is one of the best things in it

The irony that she didn't go to the first showing, because it was at a white only cinema ... and she had to sit at a segregated table at the Oscars

In fact, I vaguely think she couldn't be buried in the sort of Hollywood stars cemetery, because it was for white people only

I also think she got married quite a lot of times, she was a bit of a goer was our Hattie!!

Teddleshon · 27/12/2023 14:41

I love it. A wonderful epic and a great tale and obviously it has never been regarded as being a “romantic” film.

I have no difficulty reading books written many hundreds of years ago or indeed watching a film like this (made over 80 years ago) and understanding that they reflect different times. Even films made in the 1980s and 1990s can jar now with their values but it’s a useful reminder how attitudes change.

zigzag716746zigzag · 27/12/2023 14:40

Maireas · 27/12/2023 14:34

Sorry, @zigzag716746zigzag - it was the way you worded it, we're obviously in agreement! 😊

No it was me! My teens distracting me and being annoying 😅.

BIossomtoes · 27/12/2023 14:38

TyotyaKlava · 27/12/2023 14:11

You can’t think of this in modern terms. The book was written /movie filmed in the last century, about the events that happened even earlier. It is about the past events and the reality that it all happened, and it was the norm back then. You can criticize it but it wouldn’t be fair comparison to the current norms.

This. It’s a depiction of the 1860s viewed through the lens of the 1930s. It’s absurd to judge it by 2023 standards.

Tilllly · 27/12/2023 14:37

@GreatGateauxsby
I did not know that about Clark Gable!! That's a shock

Wasn't OdH's sister also famous, but they didn't get on?

Maireas · 27/12/2023 14:34

Sorry, @zigzag716746zigzag - it was the way you worded it, we're obviously in agreement! 😊

Tilllly · 27/12/2023 14:33

FestiveFruitloop · 27/12/2023 13:36

Yeah, content-wise I can't see why it was ever considered romantic either. I've heard various people rhapsodise about it being supposedly romantic over the years (even heard someone describe it as the most romantic film ever, once!) - it's beyond me how it could be viewed that way. I think there's a generational element to this, though.

derxa I take your point about resilience. I guess I just wish that theme was showcased within a less obnoxious story (to me anyway).

Oh I don't know

Rhett telling her she needs kissing badly, and by someone who knows how, is pretty romantic

In fiction anyway... I don't think that'd make me go weak kneed in reality!

zigzag716746zigzag · 27/12/2023 14:32

Maireas · 27/12/2023 14:16

Nope. I never said it was a romantic melodrama, other folks have depicted it as such. (Hence the word conflating)
I know exactly what it's about, @zigzag716746zigzag

I was actually agreeing with you, but phrased it wrongly. Should perhaps have been “But how does one get “romantic melodrama” from Gone With the Wind?”

Tilllly · 27/12/2023 14:31

Great minds @HappyBusman

Ktime · 27/12/2023 14:30

Kannet111 · 27/12/2023 14:26

I've always been surprised one hasn't been made. Not a direct remake but a big budget mini series about the old south. Could be very interesting

There was that TV series sequel with Timothy Dalton., don’t think it was very good.

Ktime · 27/12/2023 14:26

It’s definitely problematic but I used to watch it as a teen and swoon over Rhett Butler. Vivienne Leigh was stunning.

And Mammy was one of the best characters and I was so happy Hattie Macdonald won an Oscar. Through my teenage eyes I thought the depiction of Mammy was positive as I saw that Scarlett treated her well but now I see it differently as an adult.

Kannet111 · 27/12/2023 14:26

crackofdoom · 27/12/2023 13:18

I wonder how a modern remake, perhaps seen through the eyes of different characters and informed by current attitudes on female oppression, racism and slavery would go down? Could be really interesting....

I've always been surprised one hasn't been made. Not a direct remake but a big budget mini series about the old south. Could be very interesting

Goingtothinkofone · 27/12/2023 14:22

FestiveFruitloop · 27/12/2023 14:15

I suspect it's more that people don't want to see/hear it being normalised...

I don’t think an old movie normalises it though. I actually think for our empathy as a society it’s really helpful to look through the eyes of history’s losers or bad guys. So yes, the confederates thought they were fighting to protect a way of life they thought was good. It’s important to understand that so we can take a step back and understand fully that yeah, they had that view but it was wrong. The film doesn’t need to do that last bit for us, we can do that ourselves.

There’s a danger with editing history to distill down history as ‘good guys’ and ‘bad guys’ because of course then we’re at massive risk of repeating the mistakes of the past. And telling the stories of the bad guys, from the perspective of what they thought they were trying to achieve, is important too.

beguilingeyes · 27/12/2023 14:22

crackofdoom · 27/12/2023 13:18

I wonder how a modern remake, perhaps seen through the eyes of different characters and informed by current attitudes on female oppression, racism and slavery would go down? Could be really interesting....

It would be bloody awful, IMO. I think it should be left in the period it was set. People are (mostly) smart enough to know that things were different back then.
The recent adaptation of Poldark tried to make it 'modern' to appeal to young audiences and it was awful.

Mittens1717 · 27/12/2023 14:22

It's my absolute favourite movie, seen it so many times, never meant to be a romance, it's definitely of its time

GreatGateauxsby · 27/12/2023 14:22

heartofglass23 · 27/12/2023 13:34

Most women would be better off with a Rhett than the porn addled incel men of today.

We are in no way superior enough to be looking down our noses at that culture.

I agree with this actually.
Also Clark gable despite being an arsehole and drunk driver murderer! IRL has so much charm and charisma in this movie it's just unreal...

Hattie McDaniel is also just amazing. She has fantastic screen presence and gives such an accomplished performance.

I also enjoy how I view Melanie/Olivia de Havilland differently as I get older. She is a very nuanced character and there are several shades.

This film has several complex female characters that were developed and had purpose and motives and desires in a way that even often cinema fails to capture well.

The worst character is IMO Ashley.
I always want to punch Aaaaashley in his stupid uncharismatic face. He is an infuriating character.

Char65 · 27/12/2023 14:21

Maireas · 27/12/2023 14:14

Scarlett saw poverty and vowed never to be poor or hungry again. It was unusual to have a young woman with that mindset at the heart of a film.
I agree that it's all very pro Confederacy, but you have to see it within that context, not excuse or overlook it.

Yes exactly this, well put.

Char65 · 27/12/2023 14:20

I love it! Its one of my favourite films of all time! I love old films generally and GWTW is right at the top of my list. I know there are elements which are not PC but as others have said it is a film about resilience and who could not argue that Scarlett O'Hara is not a strong female character?

PS I agree that Margaret Mitchell's book is far better, very long but worth it.

Goingtothinkofone · 27/12/2023 14:17

it’s not a romantic film or intended to be.

It is a great film and the fact our moral codes have changed since then doesn’t change that. We don’t need to agree with what it’s saying to appreciate the storytelling.

I personally really appreciate Scarlett as a total anti-heroine. She’s unashamedly a massive witch to most people around her. She’s so complex and unsympathetic which even now where so many female characters are just one dimensionally nice / mothers / eye candy is refreshing.

Maireas · 27/12/2023 14:16

Nope. I never said it was a romantic melodrama, other folks have depicted it as such. (Hence the word conflating)
I know exactly what it's about, @zigzag716746zigzag

Swipe left for the next trending thread