Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Gone With the Wind really isn't a romantic film?

185 replies

FestiveFruitloop · 27/12/2023 13:10

Just finished watching it, hadn't ever seen it all the way through before. Toxic/abusive relationships, marital rape depicted positively (WTF??), racism and misogyny, manipulative characters... all I can say is I hope it's no longer considered romantic in this day and age. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
VenusClapTrap · 27/12/2023 16:39

Personally I think it’s a fascinating film. I watched it as a child in the 80s, and it was the first time I’d seen a film with such complicated, flawed characters. A heroine who was horrid? This was new to me.

And more importantly, the juxtaposition of the destruction of their way of life = presented as sad, whilst knowing the end of slavery = obviously good, made me really think and ask lots of questions. It was an early lesson in life not being black and white, and that the perspective of a character/narrator/film maker wasn’t always to be trusted.

I think if this was glaringly obvious to a 10 year old in the 80s, we shouldn’t rush to ban the film now amidst accusations that it ‘normalises’ attitudes of another time. Give audiences more credit. Just switch it off if you don’t want to watch it.

WesselCups · 27/12/2023 16:38

One of my favourite films and books, both of which I own and give an airing occasionally.

SilverBranchGoldenPears · 27/12/2023 16:06

I. Love. This. Movie.

kitsuneghost · 27/12/2023 16:05

@theresnolimits
If you like books I would get reading fast before OP takes to Mumsnet to get books written before 2020 burned

LifeofBrienne · 27/12/2023 16:04

Pemba · 27/12/2023 14:44

I thought the book was awful..Margaret Mitchell was writing in the 1930s wasn't she, not shortly after the Civil war period the novel is set in. The book is basically dishonest and gives a distorted picture of what was going on at the time. Rhett and the other men are involved with the KKK and yet are depicted as dashing romantic heroes. The enslaved people are depicted as childlike and happier and safer when they were living on the plantations. The northern soldiers are depicted as uncivilised scoundrels destroying the harmonious civilisation of the south.

Yes it sold well at the time and was considered a romance. Margaret Mitchell's world view was warped though. The main black actress, Hattie something (?) was given an Oscar but at the Oscar ceremony she was shoved onto a table right at the back, as the venue was normally segregated.The other actors did not stick up for her. Later she died in poverty. I think that says a lot.

The cinematography in the film was lush and Vivien Leigh was gorgeous. That's about all I can say for it. A lot of people quite rightly see it as offensive now.

There’s a very good episode of The Rest is History podcast on Gone with the Wind which unpacks the mythologising and romanticising during the 20th century of slavery and the pre-war South.

Ponoka7 · 27/12/2023 16:03

Pemba · 27/12/2023 14:44

I thought the book was awful..Margaret Mitchell was writing in the 1930s wasn't she, not shortly after the Civil war period the novel is set in. The book is basically dishonest and gives a distorted picture of what was going on at the time. Rhett and the other men are involved with the KKK and yet are depicted as dashing romantic heroes. The enslaved people are depicted as childlike and happier and safer when they were living on the plantations. The northern soldiers are depicted as uncivilised scoundrels destroying the harmonious civilisation of the south.

Yes it sold well at the time and was considered a romance. Margaret Mitchell's world view was warped though. The main black actress, Hattie something (?) was given an Oscar but at the Oscar ceremony she was shoved onto a table right at the back, as the venue was normally segregated.The other actors did not stick up for her. Later she died in poverty. I think that says a lot.

The cinematography in the film was lush and Vivien Leigh was gorgeous. That's about all I can say for it. A lot of people quite rightly see it as offensive now.

Clarke Gable was going to refuse his Oscar because of the treatment of Hattie. She persuaded him to attend. He was friends with Marlon Brando who also spoke out against racism. Bette Davis supported and worked with her. She lost money via marriage, but wasn't in poverty. Butterfly McQueen (Prissy) was outspoken about segregation. She felt that all the blacks actors had been demeaned in the film and only did it for the money and exposure.

caringcarer · 27/12/2023 16:01

stemmedroses · 27/12/2023 14:05

the Ku Klux Klan effectively being heroes are pretty jarring

But that was the case in the South during the Civil War. The Southern States wanting to maintain slavery was one of the reasons for the war.

It's so ridiculous that people don't want to see/hear the unsavoury parts of history.

This. I think GWTW reflected life as it was in the South at a certain period of time.

theresnolimits · 27/12/2023 16:01

How great that a film made in 1939 and a book written in the 1930s are still inspiring debate. The power of art.

My twopenneth is that when I read the book at 15 in the 1970s I felt I really understood how hard war was for women. Scarlett is left to run the plantation whilst the men go off to fight and she uses all the means at her disposal to keep things afloat. She has to relearn all her societal norms and, for that, I find her an inspirational woman.

Is it romantic? I thought so at 15, but when Rhett leaves her at the end (spoiler alert), I totally believed she would rise about it and move on 'Tomorrow is another day' because she had such strength and resilience and who doesn't want to be that woman that will be able to cope and has such self belief?

As for the Confederates, I thought they were shown as weak and that their lifestyle was pampered and unsustainable. It is clear in the book that, whatever they thought of themselves, the 'North' was the superior force.

I wouldn't read it or watch it again now (too long!) but that's like much Dickens, George Eliot - of its time. As for Wuthering Heights -I hate that book with a passion now and yet loved it as a teenager. Such dislikeable characters. Now Jane Eyre - still a masterpiece.

God, I love books

kitsuneghost · 27/12/2023 15:58

We learn from the past. Whitewashing history is dangerous OP.

greengreengrass25 · 27/12/2023 15:57

Haven't seen it for years and read the book in the 80s

The worst bit of the film for me at the time was the amputation without anaesthetic and Scarlett was a nurse but quit

NotDoingOk · 27/12/2023 15:52

In large parts of the US, views on the end of slavery and the KKK are still the norm. I grew up with people whose fathers were in the klan. If it isn't written about, it becomes too easy to believe that it isn't still happening.

beguilingeyes · 27/12/2023 15:50

Olivia de Havilland's sister was Joan Fontaine who starred in Hitchcock's Rebecca and Suspicion. They were very alike

littleburn · 27/12/2023 15:48

Well both the book and the film are getting close to 100 years old and romanticise a period 70 odd years before that, in which slavery was a central tenet of society. So unsurprisingly, it's not at all aligned with our values today!

Ponoka7 · 27/12/2023 15:48

I've always loved the film. It was never meant to be a romance. Watch the documentaries on it and you'll appreciate it for what it is. We shouldn't stop showing how things once were, or we can't appreciate some of the pov of certain groups.

kitsuneghost · 27/12/2023 15:47

FFS. must everything be destroyed by political correctness. It's a bloody film and an old one at that. No 10 year old boys are taking relationship lessons from it

Mirrormeback · 27/12/2023 15:47

That's how things were in those days

Only worse

Goingtothinkofone · 27/12/2023 15:45

Pemba · 27/12/2023 14:44

I thought the book was awful..Margaret Mitchell was writing in the 1930s wasn't she, not shortly after the Civil war period the novel is set in. The book is basically dishonest and gives a distorted picture of what was going on at the time. Rhett and the other men are involved with the KKK and yet are depicted as dashing romantic heroes. The enslaved people are depicted as childlike and happier and safer when they were living on the plantations. The northern soldiers are depicted as uncivilised scoundrels destroying the harmonious civilisation of the south.

Yes it sold well at the time and was considered a romance. Margaret Mitchell's world view was warped though. The main black actress, Hattie something (?) was given an Oscar but at the Oscar ceremony she was shoved onto a table right at the back, as the venue was normally segregated.The other actors did not stick up for her. Later she died in poverty. I think that says a lot.

The cinematography in the film was lush and Vivien Leigh was gorgeous. That's about all I can say for it. A lot of people quite rightly see it as offensive now.

I haven’t read the book, though it’s on my list.

My perspective was she was writing from the perspective of plantation owners, many of whom, i’m sure, slept at night because they had that worldview. I’m sure many believed the slaves were fine and better off under their control. Hearing that story I think is still important. Because it’s a helpful reminder to us that our own worldview is also skewed and the importance of taking in objective evidence to counter our own experiences.

I read ‘12 years a slave’ and something which interested me was his experience that there were well run plantations where the slaves were happy enough. After all they didn’t have a frame of reference for freedom (this is his own experience of being a slave). He explained that the plantation owners in these places would have only their own experience to judge the practice of slavery by and would therefore think it was fine and everyone was fine and he didn’t judge them though of course made the case they were wrong. Only by taking a step back and looking at the big picture could you see the true evil of the whole enterprise.

CarolinaInTheMorning · 27/12/2023 15:34

The main black actress, Hattie something (?)

Her name was Hattie McDaniel.

FestiveFruitloop · 27/12/2023 15:27

Rhett telling her she needs kissing badly, and by someone who knows how, is pretty romantic

The ambiguity of 'needs kissing badly' always affords me a childish giggle, though. 😁

OP posts:
Justcallmebebes · 27/12/2023 15:27

FestiveFruitloop · 27/12/2023 14:15

I suspect it's more that people don't want to see/hear it being normalised...

But in its time and in its day, that was the norm. No one's suggesting that should be the norm now.

That's the thing with norms, they change and evolve Hmm

RatHammock · 27/12/2023 15:20

Clark Gable was not a “drink driving murderer”. 🙄

Pemba · 27/12/2023 15:04

Startingagainandagain · 27/12/2023 14:46

It is a story about resilience and flawed characters.

Not everything you see has to be moral and sugar-coated and end up as a perfect love story.

It also I think gives a fair idea of what the Southern societ was like in those days.

Of course that society was racist and misogynist, what do you expect?

I never understand people who look at films representing a specific period of history, the American Civil War, but expect it to show modern values.

It does not work like that...

The character of Scarlett is deeply unlikable, selfish and spoilt but she also shows great courage, resilience and strength. Same with the male character. He is not a hero.

Same with a Streetcar named Desire. Great film but again characters doing really questionable things.

I really wish people would stop trying to 'cancel' everything and obsess about reframing/criticising everything with today's values, rather than seeing them as something of their time.

It seems pretty obvious to me that Margaret Mitchell is the one doing the 'sugar coating'. Misplaced nostalgia for the old South where everyone was content in their role in life, gorgeous looking plantations and beautiful women in lovely frocks waited on happily by content black people, who were almost like family. Like hell it was! And she's hardly a great writer, it's just a pot boiler probably only remembered now because the film was so huge.

Other writers have problematic elements, eg Dickens and his unrealistic portrayal of women, for example, but he still has enough literary merit to be worth bothering with. Margaret Mitchell does not imo.

StickyProblem · 27/12/2023 15:01

It's a phenomenal film. Agree it's about how a woman can affect her own life and achieve her ambitions. You have Scarlett as a an example of a hard, unkind, selfish woman but also Melanie as an example of selfless, forgiving, cherishing womanhood, a great contrast.

It's also about change, and how those that lead in society may not be there through their own ability (see how Ashley is useless in the post war world, all he's fit for is drifting round Daddy's library). Scarlett's tenacity and ruthlessness are great qualities for success in the new world, but not needed by her class in the old world. The book makes this a lot clearer. I can't remember it but there's a great quote about how the largest amounts of money get made when society changes, and this is so relevant to today.

I'm not into "romantic" films anyway but I love the bit where Rhett has made her go to Melanie's party, because he knows she has to brazen it out otherwise nobody will ever talk to her again, and she arrives looking sulky in her red dress. Wonderful! In the book it's explained that she and Ashely just fancy each other, they aren't in love, but Rhett really understands her and loves her for who she is.

Yes, a lot of the attitudes and events depicted are more shocking year by year but it gives us in the UK some idea of the history of the US.

MissBuffyAnneSummers · 27/12/2023 14:54

It's historical fiction so of course the values are true to its time

I still love it.