Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Gone With the Wind really isn't a romantic film?

185 replies

FestiveFruitloop · 27/12/2023 13:10

Just finished watching it, hadn't ever seen it all the way through before. Toxic/abusive relationships, marital rape depicted positively (WTF??), racism and misogyny, manipulative characters... all I can say is I hope it's no longer considered romantic in this day and age. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
MammaTo · 27/12/2023 18:47

I watched it today too and I loved it just as much as the first time. For me personally I quite like watching films that are a product of their time - where there’s no equal opportunities tick boxes to complete like every Netflix film going these days - sometimes we need to see how it used
to be to be able to see how far we’ve came.
Scarlett’s resilience is something to be admired. Plus when Rhett takes her out the horse and buggy for a kiss when he goes to join the war as the south’s burning behind them is very romantic IMO.

CuttingMeOpenthenHealingMeFine · 27/12/2023 18:43

If someone can't watch a film that was made more than 80 years ago (depicting a view from more than 150 years ago) without thinking that this is the current world view on slavery and women's rights, they really shouldn't be allowed to have a telly

This 100 times over. You can’t pretend that these views didn’t exist just because you don’t like them today. Of course people in the South thought salvery was perfectly ok, or they wouldn’t have owned slaves. Of course they thought the KKK were hero’s and women, for whom the main goal in life was to marry ‘well’ had no choice really but to put up with all manner of misogyny and violence from men because what other choice did they have? Women still put up with crap like that today, in this country.

The book is far better IMO, it explains Scarlett’s thoughts and motivations better. She is a phenomenal female character.

Thehonestbadger · 27/12/2023 18:29

GWTW is one of my favourite pieces of literature because of how widespread the misunderstanding of it is.

It is a story about strength, resilience and ultimate will to survive. It’s also a story about gritty and gruelling realities of transitioning from idyllic childhood to adulthood woman hood in that time period. It depicts all of those spectacularly.

It is a love story, technically, but not a romance. Love is a key feature and lots of characters feel is very strongly for different things/people at different times. The love Scarlet has for Tara, Ashley, her parents, her past and eventually Rhett. But no one is ever really in love with each other at the same time so it’s not exactly a romantic love story no.

By now a days standards it’s grotesque but it hate censoring things retrospectively just because they don’t comply with today’s standards otherwise how do we partake in historical education. The trick is the educated and liberal enough to read terrible things and think ‘wow that’s awful so glad that isn’t acceptable anymore’

HawthornLantern · 27/12/2023 18:25

With apologies for an essay…

I remember when GWTW was broadcast on BBC over two nights (I think) at Christmas as the “big film” and sat down to watch it with Mum. It was a big event – the first UK TV showing of the film - if not quite as big as the original showing. I loved it. And I do think there was a lot of “romance” about the film, the romance about Selznick’s hunt for the actress to play Scarlett, the sweeping cinematography, and the film posters of Rhett with Scarlett in his arms – which were re-cast with Reagan and Thatcher by student protesters.

But I’m also looking forward to reading one of my Christmas books – “The Wrath to Come” by Sarah Churchwell, an American academic. She also loved the book and the film as a child but, my (pre-reading her book) understanding, based on listening to her on the Rest Is History podcast, is that for all that there are strengths in GWTW, the strength of Scarlett as a female character, problematic though she is, the resilience, and particularly how powerful that theme was when it came out in Depression America and the London Blitz, that its portrayal of the “lost cause,” the decent, honourable (kindly, slave-owning) South is a distortion that needs to be challenged. She does not see Mitchell as progressive in any sense.

Churchwell doesn’t want the film or book to be banned or supressed. It’s a major film in the history of film making. Atlanta burning and the fields of casualties are imprinted on my memory as much as any scene from a war film. But she says she wants its false history, its romantic mythmaking challenged. “American fascism was never exorcised,” Churchwell says, “but merely obscured beneath romantic mythmaking that displaced a reckoning with vicious aspects of the nation’s past.” And she sees a link with that failure to exorcise and the violent riots at the Capitol on 6 January 2021.

I’ve worked in the US for 10 years, albeit in a liberal city, and have a mixed race (step) grandchild, but I don’t have any secure sense that you are an “equal” citizen if your face is not white. The minute (morning after) Trump was elected, non-white friends were shouted at and sometimes spat at. So, my prior bias is that I think Churchwell is onto something and I’m looking forward to reading her book.

TheWernethWife · 27/12/2023 18:17

We love GWTW and still quote from it like "oh fiddle de dee" and when squeezing through a narrow gap in person or in the car "breath in miss scarlett"

User135644 · 27/12/2023 18:13

heartofglass23 · 27/12/2023 13:34

Most women would be better off with a Rhett than the porn addled incel men of today.

We are in no way superior enough to be looking down our noses at that culture.

Same for the state of films.

This was back in an era where it was worth going to the pictures. Culture is worse now.

stemmedroses · 27/12/2023 18:09

I suspect it's more that people don't want to see/hear it being normalised...

If someone can't watch a film that was made more than 80 years ago (depicting a view from more than 150 years ago) without thinking that this is the current world view on slavery and women's rights, they really shouldn't be allowed to have a telly.

I just don't see the issue with films and books depicting the actual views of people, regardless of how unpleasant those views are; particularly when those events are in the past and the film can be seen in the context of the progress or otherwise since then.

kerstina · 27/12/2023 18:08

I watched it again this morning.Must be the longest film ever ! I had watched it years ago but had forgotten most of it .Just remembered there was no happy ending. In my eyes it was a love story though. They did love each other.
It made me want to watch the original Little Women film which I think Vivienne Leigh played Meg although I think her character in GWTW was very much an Amy .

Maireas · 27/12/2023 18:02

saltinesandcoffeecups · 27/12/2023 17:58

Not very well apparently

How unpleasant.
We'll just need to agree to disagree on how "progressive" they were.

Andywarholswig · 27/12/2023 18:01

HappyBusman · 27/12/2023 13:22

It was never tended as a ‘romantic film’, though — it’s a historical epic and family saga with a woman’s romantic decisions as a central thread. Peoole forget how many people Scarlett actually makes a pass at/ marries. She’s obsessed with Ashley, marries his younger brother, is widowed, uses Rhett to make Ashley jealous, makes another pass at Ashley, then marries her younger sister’s dopey fiancé, is widowed again, and even after she finally marries Rhett, she’s still involved with Ashley etc etc.

It was just the star casting of Clark Gable that makes his role more prominent than n the novel, especially as Leslie Howard was such a weed as Ashley.

Thinking it’s supposed to be a romance is like thinking Wuthering Heights is a romance.

Scarlett married Melanie’s younger brother Charles.

As many have said, it is more than just a film or a book that has aged badly, it’s a snapshot of its time and should be viewed in the context of the time it was written in.

It's one of my favourite books, I read it for the first time when I was 13 and have re-read it several times since. Scarlett is completely awful, but she is tough and determined to survive, I think of it of a survival story and what a woman can do to stay alive in the wreckage of the only society she’s ever known.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 27/12/2023 17:58

Maireas · 27/12/2023 17:55

Yes. By reading your attachment.

Not very well apparently

FraiseRoyale · 27/12/2023 17:58

Margaret Mitchell's mother was a very active suffragist; that aspect was progressive. But as to race relations, no.

There are feminist themes in GWTW.

Maireas · 27/12/2023 17:55

saltinesandcoffeecups · 27/12/2023 17:55

Well clearly you’ve made up your mind.

Yes. By reading your attachment.

FestiveFruitloop · 27/12/2023 17:55

kitsuneghost · 27/12/2023 15:58

We learn from the past. Whitewashing history is dangerous OP.

Totally agree re whitewashing, in fact it's something I feel strongly about. I edit republished old fiction for a living and I'm constantly coming up against/doing my best to resist the modern urge to whitewash literature. I'm not suggesting we do that to GWTW - merely commenting that I don't understand why some people claim it's romantic.

I do feel that if we leave certain types of content unchanged then we have to accept some/many people will find it repellent viewed from a modern context.

Some interesting responses on this thread, though, re the various aspects of the film and the book. I'm still not a fan but finding the various points interesting.

OP posts:
saltinesandcoffeecups · 27/12/2023 17:55

Maireas · 27/12/2023 17:50

I can't see anything progressive there?
Her knowledge of the Civil War was from the books of a white supremacist?.

Well clearly you’ve made up your mind.

Dotjones · 27/12/2023 17:54

The pro-slavery angle is what stands out to me, characters you are meant to feel sympathetic towards being involved in KKK activities for example (though it's toned down so as to be less blatant). It doesn't sit right today although I guess it makes a good point that everyone is an individual who experiences a variety of emotions, even a cross-burning racist will experience love and lost and their emotions are no less valid because of their other interests.

I've always thought the appropriate number of times to watch "Gone with the Wind" in one's lifetime is 0.8; you should watch it more than zero times, but once is too much.

Maireas · 27/12/2023 17:50

I can't see anything progressive there?
Her knowledge of the Civil War was from the books of a white supremacist?.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 27/12/2023 17:49

Maireas · 27/12/2023 17:46

Progressive? On what way?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margaret_Mitchell

Margaret Mitchell - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margaret_Mitchell

Maireas · 27/12/2023 17:46

Progressive? On what way?

saltinesandcoffeecups · 27/12/2023 17:38

You all should really read up on Margaret Mitchell, she and her family were quite progressive for their time. Would probably give a new perspective to her characters

THisbackwithavengeance · 27/12/2023 17:38

The book is wonderful as is the film starring one of the world's most beautiful women ever, the great Vivien Leigh.

You absolutely cannot view it though today's eyes/morals.

And I agree, it's not romantic at all. She doesn't even end up with her man at the end of it.

Poppysmom22 · 27/12/2023 17:08

Yeah it's not about romance at all. It's about triumphing in adversity. It's also about self sacrifice.

Boomer55 · 27/12/2023 16:58

One of my favourites - strong woman and a sense of history.

TellySavalashairbrush · 27/12/2023 16:50

Always reminds me of my mum. Without fail every time she watched it, she would
declare with conviction that Clark Gable
was renowned for having bad breath! 🤣🤣🤣

NahHumBrag · 27/12/2023 16:45

I agree with nearly all the previous comments about what a brilliant and epic film it is (and how it’s of its time).

Vivianne Leigh campaigned hard for the role - she knew she knew Scarlett and she was absolutely spot on. She played her brilliantly.

It’s also worth noting what a great movie it is in terms for film making. Nothing on that scale had been made before. The ‘buring of Atlanta’ is a real fire and was a true moment of cinematography history. I could watch the film over and over (and actually quite like SOH! Far more about her than her mealy mouthed sisters! Scarlett, Mammy, Prissy and Belle steal the movie.

Swipe left for the next trending thread