Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Gone With the Wind really isn't a romantic film?

185 replies

FestiveFruitloop · 27/12/2023 13:10

Just finished watching it, hadn't ever seen it all the way through before. Toxic/abusive relationships, marital rape depicted positively (WTF??), racism and misogyny, manipulative characters... all I can say is I hope it's no longer considered romantic in this day and age. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
NonPlayerCharacter · 27/12/2023 21:29

So you can see, despite the film supposedly being "of its age", its portrayal of slavery shocked and offended people even in the 1940s

A young black extra went to Clark Gable as filming began to complain about the racially segregated toilets and Gable threatened to walk off set if they were not desegregated. He also initially refused to attend a premiere where Hattie McDaniel, to whom he had become close, was barred (she eventually persuaded him to go).

crackofdoom · 27/12/2023 20:55

Interestingly, this thread has sent me on a Google deep dive, and I have found out some fascinating things, about both the movie and the book (but I can't C & P links due to my stupid phone):

The book was extremely popular with the Nazis in Germany

There were, in fact, several scenes depicting the brutality of slavery originally included in the film, but these were cut- along with many other random scenes- and nobody really seems to know why. David O. Selznick was concerned about not making a film that showed black people in a derogatory light- as a Jewish person on the eve of WW2 he drew parallels with antisemitism- but the finished film drew a lot of criticism from black people and organisations, including the NAACP, so you can't say he really succeeded.

10 year old Martin Luther King was part of a gospel choir at the premier in Atlanta- all dressed up as old time slaves. His dad was the church pastor, and loads of people from his congregation begged him not to let the choir get involved, but he went ahead.

So you can see, despite the film supposedly being "of its age", its portrayal of slavery shocked and offended people even in the 1940s 🙄.

PaperDoIIs · 27/12/2023 20:40

The whole story is about the fall of the South through the eyes of those who lived there at the time

This really. That's what it comes down to. It's easy to portray criticism when you're on the opposite side. Like "The help" for example. Could the story have been told from Mammie or Prissy's perspective? Or one dissenting southern voice? Or a northerner's? Sure. But it wouldn't have been the same story. It could still have been a great story, but not the same. And this was Scarlett's story.

As for the whole romantic thing, there are people that find romance anywhere and everywhere, for example some people think the Joker and Harley have a great romance. Plus some people do find drama,hot and cold, hard work and "fighting for it" passionate and romantic. Fucked up is as fucked up does.

CuttingMeOpenthenHealingMeFine · 27/12/2023 20:19

crackofdoom · 27/12/2023 20:07

NonPlayerCharacter do you not remember the bits in postwar Atlanta where steady, mild mannered Frank is found out to be heavily involved with the KKK, and if I recall correctly Scarlett has to hide them and lie to the authorities about their movements (think Frank got shot?) I think Rhett is only very peripherally involved, if at all, the implication being that he doesn't care enough about protecting his own.

There's quite a lot of moral outrage about freed slaves roaming the place, often in tandem with carpetbaggers- I think there's one bit where a couple of black scoundrels try to grab the reins of her buggy.

As the book is written from the perspective of those in the South, particularly women, I think that it is reasonable to expect that they believe the men in the KKK are indeed ‘protecting them’.

I imagine Atlanta, post war, must have been quite a scary place for those citizens who had previously been used to a certain way of life. Yankee soldiers everywhere, carpetbaggers and freed slaves (some of whom may indeed have been dangerous - or are we to pretend that just by virtue of having been on the victors army/previously a slave, they were morally superior to everyone else?). They had been raised to believe certain things and their education was also dependent on how affluent their parents were and whether they were male/female. Our modern beliefs of diversity and inclusion wouldn’t even have entered their thoughts. Again you don’t have to agree with how the characters think in order to appreciate the story being told.

The whole story is about the fall of the South through the eyes of those who lived there at the time, and it depicts how Scarlet adapts and thrives rather than clinging to the old way of life.

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/12/2023 20:13

crackofdoom · 27/12/2023 20:07

NonPlayerCharacter do you not remember the bits in postwar Atlanta where steady, mild mannered Frank is found out to be heavily involved with the KKK, and if I recall correctly Scarlett has to hide them and lie to the authorities about their movements (think Frank got shot?) I think Rhett is only very peripherally involved, if at all, the implication being that he doesn't care enough about protecting his own.

There's quite a lot of moral outrage about freed slaves roaming the place, often in tandem with carpetbaggers- I think there's one bit where a couple of black scoundrels try to grab the reins of her buggy.

Yes, but again, historically those attitudes are accurate... and Frank was always meant to be a bit of a wuss (I think Scarlett thought of him as an "old maid in breeches" when he first started courting Suellen) and not massively bright. Never got the impression he was supposed to be a hero. Rhett wasn't a hero either; he said it himself several times, he's a scoundrel. The only man who would ever love Scarlett after knowing who she really was.

I seem to recall a white man and a black man both attacked Scarlett in the buggy, in both the book and the film.

crackofdoom · 27/12/2023 20:07

NonPlayerCharacter do you not remember the bits in postwar Atlanta where steady, mild mannered Frank is found out to be heavily involved with the KKK, and if I recall correctly Scarlett has to hide them and lie to the authorities about their movements (think Frank got shot?) I think Rhett is only very peripherally involved, if at all, the implication being that he doesn't care enough about protecting his own.

There's quite a lot of moral outrage about freed slaves roaming the place, often in tandem with carpetbaggers- I think there's one bit where a couple of black scoundrels try to grab the reins of her buggy.

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/12/2023 20:03

GWTW is too significant culturally, historically and cinematically ever to be cancelled. Won't happen. Education and notes on its historical context, absolutely. Cancellation, never.

chattyness · 27/12/2023 19:50

crackofdoom · 27/12/2023 19:43

So where are these mythical "cancel culture lovers" then, chattymess?

And why the need to start banging on about it on this thread if no one was actually....y'know... loving cancel culture? 🤔

not mythical at all ,if you go on twitter ,read the papers cancel culture is all over the place I'm not banging on either, I made one comment & a reply to you. I'm allowed an opinion even though it's different to yours.

zigzag716746zigzag · 27/12/2023 19:49

crackofdoom · 27/12/2023 19:43

So where are these mythical "cancel culture lovers" then, chattymess?

And why the need to start banging on about it on this thread if no one was actually....y'know... loving cancel culture? 🤔

I think mostly the point of a chat forum is to … chat. And that can include opening a topic up with other relevant themes.

I haven’t seen anyone “banging on” either.

Lorac23 · 27/12/2023 19:49

For those of you interested in a big budget mini series, there is North and South, based on the novels by American author John Jakes. Way more context, gorgeous costumes and settings, and plenty of complex characters and situations. Plus Patrick Swayze and James Read as the two central characters. Just stop after book two and don't continue to watch the dreadful book three adaptation....

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/12/2023 19:43

crackofdoom · 27/12/2023 19:31

Also, I'm going to give posters the benefit of the doubt here, and assume they haven't read the book, because I'm pretty sure the KKK bit of the story didn't make it to the big screen...

Nobody's against the depiction of "history", or denies that "things were different then", although at the time of the Civil War Britain had already abolished slavery, along with the Confederate North.

My objection is how MM interprets history, and who she paints as "heroes", and why. Remember that this was written in the 1930s, at a time when the KKK had given ample evidence of what they had turned out to be- this was the era of "Strange Fruit", remember?

Yet she asks the reader to feel sympathy for the honest guys forced to start the KKK, to protect their families in the face of a wave of rape and violence perpetrated by dangerous emancipated black men.

Weirdly enough, this is the kind of defence still used by white people in the USA who feel the need to "protect their families" by shooting black people doing scary things like jogging in their neighbourhood, doing U turns in their drive or knocking on their door for help. So no, I don't agree that MM's stance was OK because it was "of its time" 😡

Who does she portray as heroes? She was clear that Melanie was the moral protagonist and actual heroine of the book, and while Melanie had slaves as they all did, I don't recall her ever complaining about emancipation. She said she would go with whatever Ashley thought best, and Ashley tells Scarlett that he was planning to liberate all his slaves once his father died.

It's hard to say what Mitchell herself really thought because there are so many characters with different viewpoints.

crackofdoom · 27/12/2023 19:43

So where are these mythical "cancel culture lovers" then, chattymess?

And why the need to start banging on about it on this thread if no one was actually....y'know... loving cancel culture? 🤔

chattyness · 27/12/2023 19:39

crackofdoom · 27/12/2023 19:20

People here frothing about people wanting to "cancel" either the book or the film of Gone with the Wind...

Please quote a single poster - one- who has called for that.

Nobody's asking to "cancel" GWTW, but we're allowed to criticise it. Or are you against free speech? 🤔

I never said anyone on here had and I was generalising about cancel culture not specifically talking about GWTW .I didn't notice anyone "frothing" either 🤣

I'm not against free speech, that's what cancel culture lovers want to do all the time shut down what they don't like.

zigzag716746zigzag · 27/12/2023 19:38

crackofdoom · 27/12/2023 19:20

People here frothing about people wanting to "cancel" either the book or the film of Gone with the Wind...

Please quote a single poster - one- who has called for that.

Nobody's asking to "cancel" GWTW, but we're allowed to criticise it. Or are you against free speech? 🤔

Just out of curiosity, who do you think is “frothing”, and who are you asking the question about free speech to?

I haven’t seen anyone “frothing”, or objecting to free speech.

DataPestle · 27/12/2023 19:37

FestiveFruitloop · 27/12/2023 13:36

Yeah, content-wise I can't see why it was ever considered romantic either. I've heard various people rhapsodise about it being supposedly romantic over the years (even heard someone describe it as the most romantic film ever, once!) - it's beyond me how it could be viewed that way. I think there's a generational element to this, though.

derxa I take your point about resilience. I guess I just wish that theme was showcased within a less obnoxious story (to me anyway).

I think it’s romantic with a big R, as in the style and content being lush and large, rather than it being a slushy love story. A sweeping epic is “Romantic”, but the plot points in this specific epic are about war, loss, famine, exploitation, power, and violence outside conflict. Just because Scarlett marries a lot of men doesn’t mean the film is about romance, and as others have said the politics are of a very specific time and place and are frequently repulsive to us now.

Excellent book, and a good film too.

NahHumBrag · 27/12/2023 19:36

(Huge Shame at slavery, of course).

NahHumBrag · 27/12/2023 19:35

It’s also worth watching knowing the family are Irish, like so many who’d sailed to the USA over the centuries.

Emigrants who’d escaped British rule but went on to be slave owners. A moment of shame and pride for us from Ireland.

And also worth noting that Katie Scarlett was 16 at the start of the story / the start of the Civil War. I could barely wipe my nose, let alone make a frock from curtains and set up a shop.

MadWifeInTheAttic · 27/12/2023 19:32

It's appalling shite but, amazingly, the book is fifty times worse.

FixItUpChappie · 27/12/2023 19:31

You should be very proud of Lancashire Mill workers who supported the fight against slavery refusing to touch raw cotton picked by slaves even though it meant they had little work and therefore no wages to support their families.

This ruins the modern "progressive" narrative that neatly divides everyone and everything into good and bad though SmugandProud

crackofdoom · 27/12/2023 19:31

Also, I'm going to give posters the benefit of the doubt here, and assume they haven't read the book, because I'm pretty sure the KKK bit of the story didn't make it to the big screen...

Nobody's against the depiction of "history", or denies that "things were different then", although at the time of the Civil War Britain had already abolished slavery, along with the Confederate North.

My objection is how MM interprets history, and who she paints as "heroes", and why. Remember that this was written in the 1930s, at a time when the KKK had given ample evidence of what they had turned out to be- this was the era of "Strange Fruit", remember?

Yet she asks the reader to feel sympathy for the honest guys forced to start the KKK, to protect their families in the face of a wave of rape and violence perpetrated by dangerous emancipated black men.

Weirdly enough, this is the kind of defence still used by white people in the USA who feel the need to "protect their families" by shooting black people doing scary things like jogging in their neighbourhood, doing U turns in their drive or knocking on their door for help. So no, I don't agree that MM's stance was OK because it was "of its time" 😡

crackofdoom · 27/12/2023 19:20

People here frothing about people wanting to "cancel" either the book or the film of Gone with the Wind...

Please quote a single poster - one- who has called for that.

Nobody's asking to "cancel" GWTW, but we're allowed to criticise it. Or are you against free speech? 🤔

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/12/2023 19:13

Margaret Mitchell said it was a story about survival and it is. It's not about slavery being fantastic (those in the book who can't adapt to losing it don't thrive), it's about losing the entire world that you thought would last forever and had an easy place in, and what you do then. She also never originally intended to publish it.

There are episodes of Friends that we now find unacceptable so a book of almost 100 years ago, depicting an even earlier world, isn't going to chime with what we know now. That's a good thing, but historical context matters too.

It isn't a love story. It's a survival story. Mitchell was descended from southern families and her family was very interested in the American Civil War, so that was the context she knew for a story like that.

It's also the most successful film ever made, adjusted for inflation. From a filmmaking history perspective, it's extremely significant.

GreatGateauxsby · 27/12/2023 19:10

Tilllly · 27/12/2023 14:37

@GreatGateauxsby
I did not know that about Clark Gable!! That's a shock

Wasn't OdH's sister also famous, but they didn't get on?

I know!!!!
He also had shocking halitosis that he purposefully made worse as he hated Vivien Leigh!!!!
Watching the kissing scenes where she is resisting him knowing that makes you see it in a different light too! 🤢🤮 Poor Vivien!!!

Weirdly! I rewatched this at Christmas and was googling about OdH and discovered / was reading about her and sister!!!! They really did NOT get on 😅

chattyness · 27/12/2023 19:03

GWTW is one of my favourite films, it wasn't meant to be a sugar coated cookie cutter romantic movie.
Yes Scarlett was awful most of the time, but she was a strong woman, a survivor, showing that in tough times you have to be stronger than ever, you can't just tell the nasty man to put his gun down and go away because that's not allowed, or weep and rock in the corner, that won't cut it, you have to act.

The good thing about movies like this that have so many unlikeable characters is that you not meant to like them and if you don't like them they've done their job well, told the story, drawn you in and made you believe.
.
I think films like this should continue to be shown they're a great talking point & something to learn from, just as OP has opened up the discussion here, it's a good way to get the perspectives of others.

I'm really fed up of cancel culture. If you don't like it switch over switch off, you don't have to try and stop others from seeing it. Nobody seems to want to agree to disagree anymore, they either don't know how or don't want to know. They're all "shut it down, ban it, you can't say that ,see that ,hear that" etc.. That's not progressive, it's a backward attitude imo

To think Gone With the Wind really isn't a romantic film?
AnonyLonnymouse · 27/12/2023 18:50

I have always liked it as an epic film portraying a deeply problematic era. But what part of history isn’t problematic? A WWI film where men were conscripted on pain of imprisonment, or worse, in the case of desertion?

I suppose I appreciate it for the idea that there are no moral absolutes. Good people (Melanie and Ashley) are complicit in and benefit from the appalling system of slavery. The Christian-minded, gentle Melanie shoots and kills a man who threatens Scarlett. The good-time privateer Rhett, at the peak of his success, then risks his life to join the lost-cause Confederate Army.

Scarlett fills that screen and grapples with her circumstances in a way that is far beyond what might be predicted from her upbringing or education. If it wasn’t for her help Melanie would have died in childbirth and they would have all perished on their way out of Atlanta.

There are some very funny segments, particularly the part where she wears the curtain fabric and another scene where she is babbling on at Ashley as he goes upstairs but he is clearly desperate to get into the bedroom and have sex with his wife!

It also makes clear the risks faced by women as soon as any war breaks out. Scarlett is threatened with rape and assault on two occasions in the course of the film, which may have given rise to discussion amongst a 1930s audience.