Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Gone With the Wind really isn't a romantic film?

185 replies

FestiveFruitloop · 27/12/2023 13:10

Just finished watching it, hadn't ever seen it all the way through before. Toxic/abusive relationships, marital rape depicted positively (WTF??), racism and misogyny, manipulative characters... all I can say is I hope it's no longer considered romantic in this day and age. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
MadWifeInTheAttic · 31/12/2023 14:03

Many artists are and they still don't spew out that kind of shite.

If she'd been satirising the attitudes of entitled little rich girls, it would have been another matter.

BIossomtoes · 31/12/2023 14:00

She. Was. Ill.

MadWifeInTheAttic · 31/12/2023 13:58

The only black character in The Bell Jar was "the Negro," an orderly in a mental hospital who serves dinner. He is described thus:
"The Negro kept grinning and chuckling in a silly way."
"All the time the Negro was banging down the tureens and then the dinted silver and the thick, white china plates, he gawped at us with big, rolling eyes."
"The Negro made me an insolent bow."
"I could see the Negro’s face, a molasses-colored moon, risen at the window grating, but I pretended not to notice."
Finally, he commits the apparently unspeakable outrage of serving her two different types of beans at dinner, so she gives him a "hard, sharp kick," whereupon he yelps and moans "Miz, miz" while rolling his eyes.

Sure, it's not racist if it's a poor little rich white girl with ishoos. It's a cri de coeur.

She makes my fucking skin crawl.

BIossomtoes · 31/12/2023 13:48

MadWifeInTheAttic · 31/12/2023 13:18

Plath's, of course.

A novel written by a woman deep in the clutches of mental illness. If all you got from that cri de cœur was racism you haven’t even begun to understand it.

Wateroverwine · 31/12/2023 13:19

I felt so bad for the horse. Scarlet was a menace I would have left her too!

MadWifeInTheAttic · 31/12/2023 13:18

Plath's, of course.

Char65 · 31/12/2023 12:25

MadWifeInTheAttic · 29/12/2023 15:51

The book is as appallingly racist as The Bell Jar.

I know these attitudes existed and still do, but I hate to see them admired.

Are you making reference to Sylvia Plath's Bell Jar or another book with the same title?

Char65 · 31/12/2023 12:23

ChristmasEvemaddness · 30/12/2023 20:31

It's an historical document. It's about the south holding onto old values and not agreeing with losing them and the progress of the north.. It's also about how entwined slaves became with their "masters" and family members scarlets shows genuine affection to some but disdain to others and mammy doesn't holdback from calling scarlet a mule. Also the other house slaves refuses to go into belle Watlington, with interesting views on social class she says her mother would whipp her

Often books or films about the south don't show that actual relationship were made between slaves and white folk.

It shows people preaching to the former slaves that they can now own land etc.

The klan to them was a political meeting just as stalin had "political meetings" about his atrocities and Hitler and so on.

Rhett loves scarlet from the day one but he knows what she is like. He constantly helps her, saves her life and so on... And she certainly happily rejects his advances.
I think the book and the film a re tremendous. My dd will study US black history at a level and I think this is an important document.

Vivien leigh is spectacular in the role.

@ChristmasEvemaddness This is a very good post and if I could write like this I would have written it! Agree with every word!

ChristmasEvemaddness · 30/12/2023 20:31

It's an historical document. It's about the south holding onto old values and not agreeing with losing them and the progress of the north.. It's also about how entwined slaves became with their "masters" and family members scarlets shows genuine affection to some but disdain to others and mammy doesn't holdback from calling scarlet a mule. Also the other house slaves refuses to go into belle Watlington, with interesting views on social class she says her mother would whipp her

Often books or films about the south don't show that actual relationship were made between slaves and white folk.

It shows people preaching to the former slaves that they can now own land etc.

The klan to them was a political meeting just as stalin had "political meetings" about his atrocities and Hitler and so on.

Rhett loves scarlet from the day one but he knows what she is like. He constantly helps her, saves her life and so on... And she certainly happily rejects his advances.
I think the book and the film a re tremendous. My dd will study US black history at a level and I think this is an important document.

Vivien leigh is spectacular in the role.

PaperDoIIs · 29/12/2023 17:37

MadWifeInTheAttic · 29/12/2023 15:51

The book is as appallingly racist as The Bell Jar.

I know these attitudes existed and still do, but I hate to see them admired.

Who exactly is admiring the "attitudes"?

BIossomtoes · 29/12/2023 17:09

MadWifeInTheAttic · 29/12/2023 15:51

The book is as appallingly racist as The Bell Jar.

I know these attitudes existed and still do, but I hate to see them admired.

You know what? You can admire some aspects of something and abhor others. Nobody posting here has admired racism, they have admired the invention of a strong female character at a time when women’s place was widely considered to be in the kitchen or its aristocratic equivalent. Society in the 1860s Deep South was racist, how could a book in that setting not reflect those values? If it didn’t you’d doubtless be complaining about airbrushing the racism out.

MadWifeInTheAttic · 29/12/2023 15:51

The book is as appallingly racist as The Bell Jar.

I know these attitudes existed and still do, but I hate to see them admired.

Ladysodor · 29/12/2023 10:10

Firstly it isn’t a romance and was never meant to be. Also there is no ‘rape scene’. It is completely open to interpretation.
I have read the book many times and it still has pride of place on my bookshelf. GWTW is of its time and the language is a bit jarring in parts but it’s how it was with a little ‘fluffing up’ obviously.
If you’re seriously offended then don’t watch it or read it (although the book is a corker of a story).

beguilingeyes · 29/12/2023 07:40

SammyScrounge · 28/12/2023 19:38

Go woke, you mean? You can never successfully impose modern attitudes on the people of the past. Film or book become weary diatribes and sound ridiculous. If your temperament is not up to facing reality, stick to modern, up to the minute fiction where everyone fights against all the correct phobias.

See the recent version of Persuasion which has the heroine swigging wine from the bottle ana talking about her exes.
Margaret Mitchell was born a mere 35 years after the Civil War ended, and knew people who lived through it so it may be told from the.perspective of relatives and neighbours.

NahHumBrag · 28/12/2023 20:57

Tootytoot78 · 28/12/2023 19:56

The scene where Hattie McDaniels is speaking to Olivia de Havilland after Bonnie is killed has to be one of the most heartbreaking in cinematic history.
McDaniels was an awesome actress.

It really is. Gut wrenching.

The whole concept of Bonnie dying and the aftermath destroying her parents marriage always felt incredibly real and awful.

NahHumBrag · 28/12/2023 20:54

‘You needn’t go. I won’t have you all starve simply because I threw myself at your head. It won’t happen again.’

Chin high class. I aspire.

NonPlayerCharacter · 28/12/2023 20:02

Tootytoot78 · 28/12/2023 19:56

The scene where Hattie McDaniels is speaking to Olivia de Havilland after Bonnie is killed has to be one of the most heartbreaking in cinematic history.
McDaniels was an awesome actress.

It really is heartbreaking. And she could still make the role so funny when it was required. I cry when I see her telling Melanie about Bonnie's death and I crack up when I see her in this clip. I like to do an impression of her here when I'm trying to do up a dress that's too small 🤣

It ain't fittin', it just ain't fittin'.avi

It just ain't fittin'

https://youtu.be/tIUlx9mMcXs?si=8a_nDl1b8uoUcFqx

Tootytoot78 · 28/12/2023 19:56

The scene where Hattie McDaniels is speaking to Olivia de Havilland after Bonnie is killed has to be one of the most heartbreaking in cinematic history.
McDaniels was an awesome actress.

CarolinaInTheMorning · 28/12/2023 19:52

I have read that Clark Gable recommended Hattie McDaniel for the role; it's certainly well documented that he and she had a bond.

NonPlayerCharacter · 28/12/2023 19:47

FestiveFruitloop · 28/12/2023 19:15

I didn't know that. Kudos to him. 👍

I said on a thread the other day about Band Aid that progress isn't always a perfect and problem free line, and I thought of GWTW at the time. Hattie McDaniel became the first African American woman to win an Oscar for her absolutely phenomenal performance as Mammy. Winning the Oscar and paving the way for black actresses, fantastic. Doing it by performing a stereotype, not so fantastic...but it just isn't realistic for society to go straight from black people being treated as inferior and denied their rights, to being cast all the time in brilliant, strong, powerful, problem-free roles (although I'd argue Mammy is a bloody strong character, especially as McDaniel played her). McDaniel was criticised at the time but she said she could make seven dollars a week being a maid or seven hundred by playing one...

I think it's interesting that Mammy is one of the few people Rhett Butler respects and admires, and it's most certainly not because she's servile and obedient!

SammyScrounge · 28/12/2023 19:38

crackofdoom · 27/12/2023 13:18

I wonder how a modern remake, perhaps seen through the eyes of different characters and informed by current attitudes on female oppression, racism and slavery would go down? Could be really interesting....

Go woke, you mean? You can never successfully impose modern attitudes on the people of the past. Film or book become weary diatribes and sound ridiculous. If your temperament is not up to facing reality, stick to modern, up to the minute fiction where everyone fights against all the correct phobias.

FestiveFruitloop · 28/12/2023 19:15

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/12/2023 21:29

So you can see, despite the film supposedly being "of its age", its portrayal of slavery shocked and offended people even in the 1940s

A young black extra went to Clark Gable as filming began to complain about the racially segregated toilets and Gable threatened to walk off set if they were not desegregated. He also initially refused to attend a premiere where Hattie McDaniel, to whom he had become close, was barred (she eventually persuaded him to go).

I didn't know that. Kudos to him. 👍

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 28/12/2023 19:07

It is a story about survival.
I would not see it as a romantic film.

And this scene is so powerful.

I wonder how many women in conflicts can relate to this

"I will never be hungry again" scene - GONE WITH THE WIND

One of the best scenes of Vivien Leigh in Gone with the Wind, 1939.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C2jR62cTTKo

NahHumBrag · 28/12/2023 18:34

Rewatching off the back of this thread.

Scarlett is a fucking superstar. She’s hard as nails when she needs to be. Imagine being a highly pampered product of your 17 year old environment and having to assist in an operation without any form of anaesthesia. Or being an impromptu midwife. Or travelling across battle fields. And then being seen as the saviour of one’s entire war PTSD’ family. At SEVENTEEN / EIGHTEEN.

Like I said: #nails

And despite her ‘hatred’ (really, love) for Melanie, she puts her first, delivers the baby and gets her back to their rural roots to recover (via a war torn country)

Despite the many many many failings of the southern states of America, I Iove that GWTW movie is a female war film.

Swipe left for the next trending thread