Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Gone With the Wind really isn't a romantic film?

185 replies

FestiveFruitloop · 27/12/2023 13:10

Just finished watching it, hadn't ever seen it all the way through before. Toxic/abusive relationships, marital rape depicted positively (WTF??), racism and misogyny, manipulative characters... all I can say is I hope it's no longer considered romantic in this day and age. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
Tilllly · 01/01/2024 07:38

@steff13 yes some others posted earlier
Phew! 😮‍💨

steff13 · 01/01/2024 05:07

Tilllly · 27/12/2023 14:37

@GreatGateauxsby
I did not know that about Clark Gable!! That's a shock

Wasn't OdH's sister also famous, but they didn't get on?

Snopes said it's not true.

Tilllly · 01/01/2024 04:47

PaperDoIIs · 01/01/2024 01:25

I ended up buying the book to reread.Grin

🤣👏🏻🤣👏🏻🤣👏🏻

It's already on my kindle 😁

PaperDoIIs · 01/01/2024 01:25

I ended up buying the book to reread.Grin

PaperDoIIs · 31/12/2023 17:04

@NonPlayerCharacter the thing Scarlett wasn't on her own. She had a kid, Melanie and her baby, her sisters,her dad , plus the slaves. That is a lot of people to be responsible for (and their futures) with absolutely no income . And of course, the fact that Tara was more to her than just a roof over their heads. From the attachment and symbolism , the past it represents to the fact that it could become a source of food and income one again.

BIossomtoes · 31/12/2023 17:03

keiratwiceknightly · 31/12/2023 16:28

I think the true love story is Scarlett's love for Tara. Her father says something about it in the first chapter - something like "land is the only thing worth fighting and dying for". She dismisses him then but comes to understand it when everything else is collapsing around her. And in the end, when she has lost Melanie and Rhett, it's Tara she wants.

Absolutely. She’d have done anything in her power to protect Tara.

CinnamonCoffee · 31/12/2023 16:45

Should add it is a period drama but from a more modern POV

CinnamonCoffee · 31/12/2023 16:41

My dearest is a modern take on Gone with the wind. It's a Korean drama with really good reviews. It was released this year and honestly it's amazing!! Available to watch in Viki

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/My_Dearest

keiratwiceknightly · 31/12/2023 16:28

I think the true love story is Scarlett's love for Tara. Her father says something about it in the first chapter - something like "land is the only thing worth fighting and dying for". She dismisses him then but comes to understand it when everything else is collapsing around her. And in the end, when she has lost Melanie and Rhett, it's Tara she wants.

Mairzydotes · 31/12/2023 16:26

The friendship between Scarlet and Melanie is the ' love ' story in the film . Its so obvious after having seen Maleficent and Frozen. I think any remake should focus on that .

Also , the scene where I think scarlet, Melanie and Rhett ride horses past fire scares me. I don't think modern cgi would have the same impact.

ActuallyChristmas · 31/12/2023 16:19

Terrible film - waste of a great cast

FestiveFruitloop · 31/12/2023 16:17

MadWifeInTheAttic · 31/12/2023 13:58

The only black character in The Bell Jar was "the Negro," an orderly in a mental hospital who serves dinner. He is described thus:
"The Negro kept grinning and chuckling in a silly way."
"All the time the Negro was banging down the tureens and then the dinted silver and the thick, white china plates, he gawped at us with big, rolling eyes."
"The Negro made me an insolent bow."
"I could see the Negro’s face, a molasses-colored moon, risen at the window grating, but I pretended not to notice."
Finally, he commits the apparently unspeakable outrage of serving her two different types of beans at dinner, so she gives him a "hard, sharp kick," whereupon he yelps and moans "Miz, miz" while rolling his eyes.

Sure, it's not racist if it's a poor little rich white girl with ishoos. It's a cri de coeur.

She makes my fucking skin crawl.

TBF it was common to see 'the Negro' in that sort of context in fiction from those days. Taken together with the characterisation and the way Plath mocks his mode of speech, it's definitely racism, but if we were talking about a different book I'd be reluctant to draw too much context solely from use of 'the Negro' in something written in the 1960s.

OP posts:
NonPlayerCharacter · 31/12/2023 16:14

Melanie doesn't fully understand Scarlett - she has no idea that Scarlett is obsessed with Ashley and refuses to believe it when they are found in each other's arms (although that time truly was only as friends). But she does get Scarlett's survival instinct and her willingness to do what's necessary for it. She absolutely gets why Scarlett shoots the Yankee and would have done the same herself.

I think Mitchell said once that Melanie was the true heroine of the book.

ghostyslovesheets · 31/12/2023 16:12

I think for Scarlett giving up Tara would be giving up - it’s her one tie with her old life and her family home

ghostyslovesheets · 31/12/2023 16:09

I think Melanie feels sorry for her and is, perhaps, the only other character that understands her

MyNamechange2024 · 31/12/2023 16:09

I’m now wondering if you’re my sister - do did my mum :)

Butchyrestingface · 31/12/2023 16:04

I like how Melanie was a fool to her.

See, I always think Melanie was quite smart, and smarter in some ways than gobby Scarlett.

She just had a soft spot for Scarlett that blinded her to Scarlett's many, many flaws.

NonPlayerCharacter · 31/12/2023 16:02

ghostyslovesheets · 31/12/2023 15:55

I agree but what starts out as childish spite turns into real survival and backbone - that mean streak is what keeps everyone alive - marrying a man she doesn’t love and breaking her sisters heart is awful- but it keeps a roof over their heads and food on the table - she sacrifices herself.

I was always a bit unsure about that bit, actually. It may not be so clear in the film, but in the book, Rhett asks her why she doesn't just go and live with Pittypat, as she owns half that house. And Scarlett is clear that she won't give up Tara and have Jonas Wilkinson and Emmie Slattery living in it. They're not actually facing total homelessness, just the loss of Tara. Of course, to Scarlett that's like losing a parent, but it does still mean the situation isn't quite that desperate. She never even asks Suellen or Frank if they'd offer any provision after marrying.

HappyBusman · 31/12/2023 16:01

MadWifeInTheAttic · 31/12/2023 15:37

I have no difficulty in separating authors from their narrators and of course Nabokov wasn't advocating paedophilia (Lolita is one of his least interesting works, however). But Plath's racial thinking is pervasive in that work (unless you think belittling someone as looking like a bottle blonde negress is A-OK) and is also evident in her poetry (which is, however, much, MUCH better than her heavily autobiographical novel). There's not just a selfishness but a deep inhumanity in a lot of her work that has always really disturbed me.

Other "ill" writers (but really, I don't think writing is an occupation for the sane, ever, is it?) from her country, if not her milieu, also wrote novels from the point of view of sociopathic narrators, and broke my heart in the process, e.g. Shirley Jackson, drawing on her own crippling agoraphobia to pen We Have Always Lived in the Castle. No, of course I don't think Jackson advocates poisoning your family, but she helps you understand the broken little soul who may have found herself doing just that. Plath's narrator is an unmitigated cunt, though- and it is the one novel where I have no sense that the writer and the narrator are so very different in their attitudes.

You'd probably hate my belovedest writers, too. shrug

I don’t know why you’re assuming I haven’t read more Nabokov than Lolita, or why you think it’s relevant that Lolita is ‘one of his least interesting works’ — I don’t think that’s true, actually, I’d put it ahead of most of the Russian novels, but behind Pnin and Pale Fire).

You do sound as if you have difficulty distinguishing character from author in works you don’t like, though.

I don’t think SP’s own MH issues have anything to do with Esther’s racism or general unpleasantness, though.

I’m not particularly keen on Charlotte Bronte giving Lucy Snowe an entrenched and virulent anti-Catholicism that authorial comments intervene to approve of in Villette, but it’s not terribly surprising in the daughter of a C of E vicar whose Irishness he’d repudiated at Cambridge, writing at a time when poor Irish immigrants were flooding into Liverpool after the Famine, and in a novel drawing on a time in her own life when she felt beleaguered in a Catholic school in Brussels.

ghostyslovesheets · 31/12/2023 15:55

NonPlayerCharacter · 31/12/2023 15:51

She's pretty hard and mean by nature, I think... she marries Charles Kennedy purely to cock a snook at Ashley and ruin Honey's life. But hardness and meanness are pretty good for survival... although not so much for the necessary self awareness, introspection and softness that would make you more in tune with your own emotions and make you realise you love someone before you destroy everything.

I agree but what starts out as childish spite turns into real survival and backbone - that mean streak is what keeps everyone alive - marrying a man she doesn’t love and breaking her sisters heart is awful- but it keeps a roof over their heads and food on the table - she sacrifices herself.

NonPlayerCharacter · 31/12/2023 15:51

ghostyslovesheets · 31/12/2023 15:45

I agree - Scarlett HAS to be like that to protect and support the women around her - she is as much as victim in many ways but has to grow hard and mean to survive and ensure her families survival - in doing so she sacrifices a lot including her happiness.

I love that she realises the romantic ideal (Ashley) is as much an illusion as the 'old South' is - she has to face the reality of change.

Yes it's totally awful when it comes to race - but so was the era - it would be worse I think to pretend that didn't happen.

With moder eyes it's a hugely problematic film but I still like it

She's pretty hard and mean by nature, I think... she marries Charles Kennedy purely to cock a snook at Ashley and ruin Honey's life. But hardness and meanness are pretty good for survival... although not so much for the necessary self awareness, introspection and softness that would make you more in tune with your own emotions and make you realise you love someone before you destroy everything.

NonPlayerCharacter · 31/12/2023 15:48

It's been a very long time since I read The Bell Jar (and I didn't much like it) but I read Plath's journals at the same sort of time and I remember thinking that she seemed to be deliberately putting the very worst of herself into Esther, probably because the novel was a form of catharsis and she was expressing self-loathing. I don't think there was any suggestion that you were supposed to admire or support Esther's racism, or indeed much else. Mental illness can make people unpleasant and unlikeable. She was also sometimes deliberately provocative in her poetry, for example comparing herself to a Jew in the camps. She knew she was being horrible and you weren't supposed to like her for it.

I don't think it's a brilliant book on its own but it's context for the rest of her oeuvre.

But as I said, it's been a very long time... I might be totally off the mark.

ghostyslovesheets · 31/12/2023 15:45

Goingtothinkofone · 27/12/2023 14:17

it’s not a romantic film or intended to be.

It is a great film and the fact our moral codes have changed since then doesn’t change that. We don’t need to agree with what it’s saying to appreciate the storytelling.

I personally really appreciate Scarlett as a total anti-heroine. She’s unashamedly a massive witch to most people around her. She’s so complex and unsympathetic which even now where so many female characters are just one dimensionally nice / mothers / eye candy is refreshing.

I agree - Scarlett HAS to be like that to protect and support the women around her - she is as much as victim in many ways but has to grow hard and mean to survive and ensure her families survival - in doing so she sacrifices a lot including her happiness.

I love that she realises the romantic ideal (Ashley) is as much an illusion as the 'old South' is - she has to face the reality of change.

Yes it's totally awful when it comes to race - but so was the era - it would be worse I think to pretend that didn't happen.

With moder eyes it's a hugely problematic film but I still like it

MadWifeInTheAttic · 31/12/2023 15:37

I have no difficulty in separating authors from their narrators and of course Nabokov wasn't advocating paedophilia (Lolita is one of his least interesting works, however). But Plath's racial thinking is pervasive in that work (unless you think belittling someone as looking like a bottle blonde negress is A-OK) and is also evident in her poetry (which is, however, much, MUCH better than her heavily autobiographical novel). There's not just a selfishness but a deep inhumanity in a lot of her work that has always really disturbed me.

Other "ill" writers (but really, I don't think writing is an occupation for the sane, ever, is it?) from her country, if not her milieu, also wrote novels from the point of view of sociopathic narrators, and broke my heart in the process, e.g. Shirley Jackson, drawing on her own crippling agoraphobia to pen We Have Always Lived in the Castle. No, of course I don't think Jackson advocates poisoning your family, but she helps you understand the broken little soul who may have found herself doing just that. Plath's narrator is an unmitigated cunt, though- and it is the one novel where I have no sense that the writer and the narrator are so very different in their attitudes.

You'd probably hate my belovedest writers, too. shrug

HappyBusman · 31/12/2023 14:11

MadWifeInTheAttic · 31/12/2023 13:58

The only black character in The Bell Jar was "the Negro," an orderly in a mental hospital who serves dinner. He is described thus:
"The Negro kept grinning and chuckling in a silly way."
"All the time the Negro was banging down the tureens and then the dinted silver and the thick, white china plates, he gawped at us with big, rolling eyes."
"The Negro made me an insolent bow."
"I could see the Negro’s face, a molasses-colored moon, risen at the window grating, but I pretended not to notice."
Finally, he commits the apparently unspeakable outrage of serving her two different types of beans at dinner, so she gives him a "hard, sharp kick," whereupon he yelps and moans "Miz, miz" while rolling his eyes.

Sure, it's not racist if it's a poor little rich white girl with ishoos. It's a cri de coeur.

She makes my fucking skin crawl.

You get that this is her flawed, unpleasant, selfish, suicidal character talking about a disliked orderly in a psychiatric hospital, right? And that this no more makes it Plath’s own take on Black people than Nabokov inventing Humbert Humbert means he thinks raping 12 year old is just fine?