Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so angry at how FAT my back and boobs are

293 replies

FatBack2023 · 27/12/2023 11:09

I'm raging.
I absolutely HATE my body shape.
I HATE how FAT my back gets when I gain weight.
And my neck.
And my chin.
And my abdomen.
And my BOOBS!! OMG. I'm carrying around 2 great pendulous gargantuan breasts that get more huge with every extra pound of weight I gain.
And I absolutely HATE how easily I gain weight. I put weight on thunderously fast compared to other people.
Why is this?
I basically have to sub exist on 1,200 cals a day to maintain my weight. If I go over this, my weight rapidly increases but it increases in an accelerated way. I put so much weight on so fast, it's completely disproportionate to the extra calories I eat. If I eat 2,000 cals a day for a few weeks, I gain 1 stone in weight. And my back, neck, chin, breasts and tummy BALLOON.
At the end of November, after maintaining my weight with 1,200 cals all year, the Christmas festivities began and I thought, I'm going to let myself go over 1,200 cals for the next month, and eat & drink Christmas things. So I've indulged. But I've carried on tracking (I use nutracheck) and I have stayed below 2,000 cals most days for the past month, but there have been days when I've gone up to 2,400. But interestingly, looking back at my tracking over the past month, on those days where I've gone above 2,000 cals a day, I've naturally eaten a lot less the following day without consciously thinking about it, back down to 1,500 or 1,200 for a day.
Anyway, over the past month, yes I've had mince pies. Yes I've had cake. Yes I've had trifle. Yes I've had biscuits. Wine. Roast dinners. I confess, I have indulged. But not all the time. And not everyday. I've also had home made vegetable soups and salads. And some days I've barely eaten anything. Some days I've had 1 meal only and tracked 800 cals for the whole day. I haven't just eaten Christmas foods all day every day. But yes I have had those foods over the past month. And still tracked every single thing.
And I have gained 18 POUNDS in weight in 1 month!!!!
And it's all gone on my back and boobs and chin and tummy.
I can literally grab handfuls of fat on my UPPER BACK!!
And my bra is too tight!!
And my chin has 2 pound of lard wobbling about under it when I talk!
And my tummy looks like I'm pregnant!!
But the worst thing of all is my back, it is covered in fat! My upper back fat rolls onto my lower back fat.
OMG. I look horrendous.
I feel horrendous.
Meanwhile my legs, bum, hips and arms remain completely unchanged, no extra ounce of fat anywhere on these areas.
I look like I've put a fatsuit onto my central body, like a fatsuit bodywarmer jacket, leaving my arms and legs as normal.
It's aging too....I look years older with all this extra weight.
Oh help.
How have I gained soooo much weight in only 1 month? I'm sure this isn't normal??
Why does it all go onto my back, boobs and tummy?
Why can't I eat the things other people eat??
Why have I put on 18 pounds in 1 month rather than just a few pounds?
I hate my body right now!!!
I'm 45, 5ft 7, and right now I weigh 15 stone.
1 month ago I weighed 13 stone 10.

OP posts:
ChanelNo19EDT · 27/12/2023 17:05

I disagree that the problem is not exercising enough, you cannot out run a bad diet, and a lot of foods we think of as being normal staples are very high in calories but don't satiate us. I'm always walking as I don't drive. It's what I eat that matters.

I think people who recommend intuitive eating underestimate how greatly hunger can vary from person to person.

ChanelNo19EDT · 27/12/2023 16:58

Same @DewHopper same. I maintain at 1400 and start to put back on weight if I go up to 1500. I am in my 50s but I get it. I'm not railing against it. I was aiming for 800s today, just had 90 grams of tuna, two eggs, 70 grams of peas with a bit of soy sauce. I'm not hungry but I ate 3 walnuts! Now that's 800. Day 1 was easy. Did a standing abs workout too. I know it'svaleays easy the first day, and I'm not planning to do 800 every day.

I night listen to that book recommended upthread, I've been avoiding refined foods as much as I can all year but I might get a few shocks. Like is soya yogurt ultra processed.

Piglet89 · 27/12/2023 16:55

@Mumsanetta has it. I have the audiobook of “Why we eat too much” and it’s a game changer. Completely fascinating stuff, too.

I do appreciate there is HEAPS of conflicting health and diet advice out there, though, which makes it even harder to know what to do. Add the quirks of each individual’s physiology and it’s actually tricky to throw out hard and fast rules - although Mumsnet loves to do that (“eat less, move more” anyone?)

I am no Rosie Huntingdon-Whitely and have gained a stone in the last couple of years, through depression and stress. However, I have now basically knocked booze on the head. I do not eat until I feel very hungry. I skip breakfast most days. I try to eat slowly and mindfully. And I lift twice a week with a PT (forced to do this to strengthen the pelvis and spine and increase flex in my hips, to stop my weak lower back going out). I may also be in peri too as my periods are all over the place ATM, having previously been regular.

AzureBlue99 · 27/12/2023 16:21

I have just come back from a funeral of a neighbour. 40 year old beautiful woman. Life is short. Either embrace the way your body works or do something about it. The words you use to describe your body are so sad and angry. It works, appreciate it. Seriously life really is too short. We all worry about shite, yet our ability to do something about it could be gone in a heartbeat.

Ilovemycatalot · 27/12/2023 16:17

I was always overweight 5ft 3 11 stone then went into a deep depression in may and lost all the weight and am now 9stone.
I wouldn’t wish my depression on anyone but isn’t it strange how the body works I mean I virtually lost my appetite over night and it’s not returned. I tried everything before and could never loose it.

NettleTea · 27/12/2023 16:09

Luckylottowinnertobe · 27/12/2023 15:36

I walk everyday and l am 55 years old , size 10 and never been on a diet. I eat what l like. People don't exercise enough, esp if weather not good. No one in my family is overweight we are all active. Make exercise fun. Sedentary lifestyle is making the nation obese.

thats because thats how your body reacts though. I always thought that. I got to age 38 before everything changed drastically. I was still as active fit as before. more so perhaps as I took my baby out daily and cycled with her on a bike when old enough. Didnt stop the weird sudden massive weight gain.
same happened with my mother - she gained 5 stone when pregnant with me and went from being a size 12 (she's 5ft 10) to a size 22. has been dieting ever since.

TheFrendo · 27/12/2023 16:09

@MyBlueDiary

Have you misunderstood the word 'part' in that wikipedia article?

Parts are not grams. You need to scale by molecular weight.

DewHopper · 27/12/2023 16:06

Humbugss · 27/12/2023 13:45

My first thought is I wonder if you’re eating enough as our bodies can cling onto weight even more if we aren’t. Women are supposed to have 2000 cals a day and you’re only having 1200 - 1500.

I’m also wondering if you have a medical condition? My friend discovers she has issues that make her retain weight - think it’s her thyroid.

Sorry but if I ate 2000 calories a day I would be the size of a house.

FaiIureToLunch · 27/12/2023 16:03

OP, all the weight going to your stomach and torso would indicate some sort of insulin/blood sugar related issue, you need to specifically manage your carbs and sugar intake. I was in your shoes and have lost 12” off my waist in about 8 months. I have PCOS and it all goes on my waist. x

zendeveloper · 27/12/2023 16:00

MyBlueDiary · 27/12/2023 15:53

It's 3-4g water for every 1g glycogen (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glycogen) plus the 400g figure is an average based on a 70kg person whereas OP is closer to 95kg. (Plus of course not all water stored in the body is bound to glycogen.) It's really unsafe to assume that 18lb on the scales is 18lb fat and start multiplying up to work out an amount of excess calories.

Glycogen is stored in the muscle tissue though, and this has not changed during the last month.
Having said that, there are many other ways water weight is carried, hydration of glycogen is just a part of it. Eating more salt than usual (this might not be immediately obvious - but all the sausage, cheese, even desserts are quite salty!), drinking alcohol and being sedentary can easily lead to +2-3kg water retention.

baileybrosbuildingandloan · 27/12/2023 15:58

electriclight · 27/12/2023 11:22

Well I have just put your height, age and weight into an app that calculates your maintenance calories, and chose 'no exercise at all' and it said you could eat 2143 calories per day without gaining weight.

I have always found it to very accurate and have successfully lost a lot of weight using it over the past year.

And 18lb of fat is 63000 extra calories.

So either you are underestimating your calories or you have a serious underlying medical issue and need to see your GP.

Do you weigh everything, count calories in everything including fruit and drinks?

I am not unsympathetic by the way. I've been overweight and know exactly how you feel. I also find it difficult to lose.

Could you say which App it is please? 😊

MyBlueDiary · 27/12/2023 15:53

TheFrendo · 27/12/2023 15:41

@MyBlueDiary

As I understand the science here, excess calories are mostly stored as fat. Only a few 100g stored can be as glycogen, with which comes 2x water. So, 400g glycogen => 800g water = 1200g total or ~2.5lb, but that is a total, not a gain.

It's 3-4g water for every 1g glycogen (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glycogen) plus the 400g figure is an average based on a 70kg person whereas OP is closer to 95kg. (Plus of course not all water stored in the body is bound to glycogen.) It's really unsafe to assume that 18lb on the scales is 18lb fat and start multiplying up to work out an amount of excess calories.

Glycogen - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glycogen

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 27/12/2023 15:48

If I'd started eating Xmas treats a month before I'd have put on the same, it's a slippery slope. I've had a few meals out and absolutely scoffed myself silly the last 3 days and I've put on 3 lbs. Back on track from tomorrow .

fetchacloth · 27/12/2023 15:43

I also could have written your post OP.
It's SO frustrating and sadly when you hit the menopause it gets even worse 😞
Unfortunately it's genetics - every single member of my family is the same, on both sides, so no hope really.
I just grin and bear it and try and keep myself fit. It's getting harder though.🙄

TheFrendo · 27/12/2023 15:41

@MyBlueDiary

As I understand the science here, excess calories are mostly stored as fat. Only a few 100g stored can be as glycogen, with which comes 2x water. So, 400g glycogen => 800g water = 1200g total or ~2.5lb, but that is a total, not a gain.

Luckylottowinnertobe · 27/12/2023 15:36

I walk everyday and l am 55 years old , size 10 and never been on a diet. I eat what l like. People don't exercise enough, esp if weather not good. No one in my family is overweight we are all active. Make exercise fun. Sedentary lifestyle is making the nation obese.

MyBlueDiary · 27/12/2023 15:33

TheFrendo · 27/12/2023 15:28

Just looking at numbers...

18 pounds is 8172g. This weight gain is stored almost completely as fat. Each gram of fat is 9 calories.

That is 73,000 calories.

Averaged over 30 days, that is 2450 calories stored per day.

I think something must be wrong with your numbers.

If OP has spent the last month eating a ton of carbs after a period of restriction, she may well also be carrying an extra 5-6lb water weight.

Anothenamechange · 27/12/2023 15:31

Haven't read all the comments so it may have been recommended already but I would strongly recommend you get your thyroid levels checked out. Won't bore you with the details but I've had mine removed, so have done a lot of reading around the subject and some doctors opine that peri/menopausal women should be taking thyroid replacement drugs on low dose as standard to counteract the fact that the levels drop naturally.
It's easy to be unaware of how much our hormone levels affect us.

I really sympathize with you, especially if you really enjoy food. I will
also second the strength training to control weight-muscle burns calories much more efficiently. And you feel great after a session!

MyBlueDiary · 27/12/2023 15:30

OP, I'm a similar age to you and like you can gain a large amount while feeling I'm only deviating slightly from normal. The things that I find hard are perimenopause and how differently I need to eat from the rest of my family to avoid gaining (Dh is 6'5", DS similar, both sporty so it's not surprising but it's hard to have to eat such a restricted diet and STILL being the fat one when surrounded by people eating vast quantities of whatever they want).

I would recommend the following-

  • get a full blood count and thyroid test done at your GP
  • for me, simple carbs make me gain a huge amount. There are good science-based reasons for this (I'd recommend reading Giles Yeo) so ignore anyone who tells you that all calories are equal
  • ditto alcohol sadly
  • On the plus side, protein, veg and healthy fats like olive oil are great and less likely to lead to over-eating because they fill you up and don't fuck up your blood sugar
  • Cut out the UPF
  • Would you consider stopping counting cals and switching to a different way of eating instead-veg, protein, healthy fat, some fruit and wholegrains but not too much (base your meals around the veg rather than eg a bowl of pasta). Think about what's nourishing rather than what's low cal. That can help you break out of the diet/binge mindset.
  • weights, yoga, walking

But I'm afraid fundamentally it's about accepting reality- that you can gain a large amount in a short time and if you don't want to do that, you need to change how you eat. That's why it's frustrating when people pop up on threads like this to say X or Y is not possible, or that they know better than you what you have eaten. Figures like 3500 cals/lb are only ever averages and, as a perimenopausal woman with a history of calorie restriction, you are not average. For me, just accepting that some other people can eat a lot more than me without gaining weight was a turning point.

NettleTea · 27/12/2023 15:30

to all those who disbelieve all the sudden weigh gain and inability to lose weight - it can be down to medical issues, not always obvious ones. After I had my daughter, and the stress of my ex husband had gone, I suddenly jumped in weight a huge amount. I mean huge - 3 stone in 3 months. I went from someone who was always a size 8-10 to a size 14-16. second pregnancy bumped things up again, and throw in perimenopause and off we go. Turned out I had primary lymphodema as well - the doctor ran every test known to man after the first weight gain and all was good. Even now all is apparently 'good' but like OP, weight on my belly, back/ boobs/chin and arms/legs all seem fine. I went to weight watchers at one point and managed to get down to 9.5 stone which I maintained for about 6 months, but once I hit 10 stone 'BOOM' massive rapid wright gain. I went back to weight watchers but the things I had done previously didnt work - I weighed and tracked religiously for A YEAR and at the end of the year I had lost 3lbs. I tried Keto. I tried food replacements. I tried Dax Moy, I tried Noom, and recently I tried another one, which was after a long long time of just ignoring things. This time, as with the other more recent I lost almost a stone, and then plateaued. I cannot get below 12 stone, wheras I know I need to be a couple of stone below that. I dont drink. I dont snack, I dont eat crisps or cakes. Most food is prepared from fresh ingredients and I use very little sugar or processed ingredients

I do know menopause is over now and that played havoc. I know that fat deposits in lymphodema are not the same as fat deposits in most peoples skin. I know that lymphodema is an inflammatory condition and Ive developed / have a whole bunch of inflammatory connective tissue issues, and at times when Ive been very stressed, everything flares up and my weight jumps rapidly - much more rapidly than just calories in. Most studies on weight are not done on women - we are far far too complex with our hormones. And even where we lay down fat is different, not only from men, but at different points in our lives.

Im afraid I have no answer. But just wanted to say, its not nearly as simple as some people are saying.

TheFrendo · 27/12/2023 15:28

Just looking at numbers...

18 pounds is 8172g. This weight gain is stored almost completely as fat. Each gram of fat is 9 calories.

That is 73,000 calories.

Averaged over 30 days, that is 2450 calories stored per day.

I think something must be wrong with your numbers.

Crikeyalmighty · 27/12/2023 15:25

I've found that if I eat 1200 calories a day ( and I'm still 3 and a half stone overweight after losing 2st 4) I actually don't lose weight. If I have several days a week where I eat 1600 and then go back to 1200 I lose weight- slowly but maybe 1 and a half lbs a week.eating a bit more several days a week but still at 'normal' levels seems to kick start my metabolism - and I'm 62

Calliopespa · 27/12/2023 15:25

I’m sorry you are feeling so down about your appearance OP. You are more than your looks ( a cliche, but it’s true) and you aren’t the the first person, and you won’t be the last, to have over-indulged over Christmas.

I suspect your are fighting against all sorts of background issues including peri. I do think it is worth seeing a gp and checking there aren’t other background issues too. However, beyond that, weight loss is just a tedious slog and I don’t think there is an easy way round that. There will no doubt be loads of January weight loss posts which may give you some support.

The only helpful thing I can think of suggesting that wont already be obvious or previously said is that , while your focus has been on over-consumption, I do wonder what types of food of you have been having? It is possible to over eat and still be malnourished in the sense of not consuming enough fibre and other useful things. If you have been indulging in treats then limiting calories the next day this is a possibility. There isn’t much nutrition in a Christmas mince pie! As a gentle start in the right direction, and a kind to yourself mindset, could you take a few weeks of forgetting ( within reason!) about calorie counting etc and focus instead on making sure everything you eat is truly nourishing. You won’t necessarily lose weight ( and you can even put weight on with too much healthy food) but generally speaking some avocado on brown toast or smoked salmon on rye with a twist of lemon or even a baked potato with spicy beans will nourish and satisfy you much better than the same amount of calories in a sugary mince pie. Lots of fibre will clean out your digestive tract. I quite enjoy slow cooked oats with a couple of chopped prunes and chopped almonds ( with the merest sprinkle of brown sugar if you must, but at least you are getting lots of nutrients with it). Also lots of water to make sure you are hydrated and flush out any water retention issues. Would it be worth a few weeks of eating to nourish and correct dietary imbalances before embarking on a more punishing weight loss regime? That way you know your body is well placed to resist nutritional cravings etc and you may just feel a lot better psychologically knowing you have at least been giving your body what it needs, rather than overindulging in things that aren’t good for it.
But please don’t hate yourself too much. Weight is an issue for so many in our society and there really are greater character failings .

ChanelNo19EDT · 27/12/2023 15:22

Wow, it has taken me all year to get from 70.5 kilos to 63! I had got down to 61.6 and relaxed a bit and was a bit pee'd off to have put on 1.4 kilos from (as I see it) just being less careful. I was still avoiding sugar, most refined/ high GI carbs. All I did was stop tracking everything, but the intention was to keep going but to just lose the 'obsessive' tracking, but as soon as I stop, the weight creeps back on. Reading about a 7 kilo weight gain like @Switcher describes puts it in to perspective. I'm still trying to get to my goal of 59 kilos and then maintain. That was so easy for me in my forties.
Good luck to everybody staring down the barrel of a big challenge.

lljkk · 27/12/2023 15:19

18*3500/30 = 2100 excess calories per day.
OP says she's only consuming 2000/day on her big eating days, and gains unless she only has 1200 kcal/day.

<shrug>. Maybe OP should sign up to have her special genetics tested, since it seems like her body holds solution to world hunger, so much less food required to sustain her body than other human beings need.