Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so angry at how FAT my back and boobs are

293 replies

FatBack2023 · 27/12/2023 11:09

I'm raging.
I absolutely HATE my body shape.
I HATE how FAT my back gets when I gain weight.
And my neck.
And my chin.
And my abdomen.
And my BOOBS!! OMG. I'm carrying around 2 great pendulous gargantuan breasts that get more huge with every extra pound of weight I gain.
And I absolutely HATE how easily I gain weight. I put weight on thunderously fast compared to other people.
Why is this?
I basically have to sub exist on 1,200 cals a day to maintain my weight. If I go over this, my weight rapidly increases but it increases in an accelerated way. I put so much weight on so fast, it's completely disproportionate to the extra calories I eat. If I eat 2,000 cals a day for a few weeks, I gain 1 stone in weight. And my back, neck, chin, breasts and tummy BALLOON.
At the end of November, after maintaining my weight with 1,200 cals all year, the Christmas festivities began and I thought, I'm going to let myself go over 1,200 cals for the next month, and eat & drink Christmas things. So I've indulged. But I've carried on tracking (I use nutracheck) and I have stayed below 2,000 cals most days for the past month, but there have been days when I've gone up to 2,400. But interestingly, looking back at my tracking over the past month, on those days where I've gone above 2,000 cals a day, I've naturally eaten a lot less the following day without consciously thinking about it, back down to 1,500 or 1,200 for a day.
Anyway, over the past month, yes I've had mince pies. Yes I've had cake. Yes I've had trifle. Yes I've had biscuits. Wine. Roast dinners. I confess, I have indulged. But not all the time. And not everyday. I've also had home made vegetable soups and salads. And some days I've barely eaten anything. Some days I've had 1 meal only and tracked 800 cals for the whole day. I haven't just eaten Christmas foods all day every day. But yes I have had those foods over the past month. And still tracked every single thing.
And I have gained 18 POUNDS in weight in 1 month!!!!
And it's all gone on my back and boobs and chin and tummy.
I can literally grab handfuls of fat on my UPPER BACK!!
And my bra is too tight!!
And my chin has 2 pound of lard wobbling about under it when I talk!
And my tummy looks like I'm pregnant!!
But the worst thing of all is my back, it is covered in fat! My upper back fat rolls onto my lower back fat.
OMG. I look horrendous.
I feel horrendous.
Meanwhile my legs, bum, hips and arms remain completely unchanged, no extra ounce of fat anywhere on these areas.
I look like I've put a fatsuit onto my central body, like a fatsuit bodywarmer jacket, leaving my arms and legs as normal.
It's aging too....I look years older with all this extra weight.
Oh help.
How have I gained soooo much weight in only 1 month? I'm sure this isn't normal??
Why does it all go onto my back, boobs and tummy?
Why can't I eat the things other people eat??
Why have I put on 18 pounds in 1 month rather than just a few pounds?
I hate my body right now!!!
I'm 45, 5ft 7, and right now I weigh 15 stone.
1 month ago I weighed 13 stone 10.

OP posts:
Mirabai · 28/12/2023 15:19

High protein diets are not good for you long term though - in animal studies - increased protein leads to kidney hypertrophy.

CharlotteBog · 28/12/2023 15:18

Over 24hrs since OP posted asking for advice, yet hasn't been back.

ChookChooks · 28/12/2023 13:48

I've worked out from meticulous tracking that I need to eat 4,000 calories less than maintenance to lose 1lb of weight.

But I only need to eat 1,800 calories 'extra' to gain 1lb.

The 3,500 loss/gain is just an average and is not true for everyone!

My trick to maintain is low carb, high protein. It's the only way I can ensure I'm satisfied and don't gain weight.

It's so annoying!

Scorchio84 · 28/12/2023 12:53

ChanelNo19EDT · 28/12/2023 11:47

Let us know if it's worth the money in yr opinion. I feel I can do it on my own if I decide to. But determination can vary from week to week.

I will! I've never signed for anything like this before so hopefully it'll help me make some change, I'll report back in two weeks.. good luck 💪

ChanelNo19EDT · 28/12/2023 12:07

electriclight · 27/12/2023 18:14

How can eating less make you put on more weight?

You don't see fat people in famines.

We are not in famine. We are in a time of abundance primarily an abundance of high carb/high sugar foods.

To say famine adaptation has been debunked leaves out the second half of the story, the inevitable follow up period.

Nobody thinks that starving yourself makes you fat, but we have to be aware that before bodies starve, they ADAPT to survive on fewer calories. And then when the inevitable end of restriction ends what was once your maintaining weight number of calories is now a number that will lead to weight gain.

This second chapter hasn't been studied. How do people react to more food after a "famine"? To what degree has the body adapted? Does it affect our lizard brain? Are we getting signals to lay down fat in case there's another "famine"?

I'm definitely not saying don't bother or don't try, but it requires research as well as willpower. In jan/Feb of last year I was losing NOTHING on 1200 per day so I upped my cals gradually to 1400 per day, still avoiding high carb or sugar foods. I upped cals with nuts. I did not put on wright to my relief.

After a year of research I know that my body only needs 1400 worth of good food per day.

So my plan is to do 800 maybe every second day. Or every third day after initial burst of efforts.

Just a friendly word of warning to people who believe that their body won't adapt to fewer and fewer calories with every passing diet and every passing decade. Maybe it's partly age, but the body is smart.

I was looking in to reverse dieting and zig zag dieting last Jan/Feb after my 1200 per day diet did not work!! My body was like, well, you chose well, eggs, tuna, tomatoes, chickpeas, nuts so thanks, but as body not hungry, body won't be letting go of fat stores thanks and goodbye".

I've lost 7 kilos since I upped cals to 1400 last February. I am hoping to lose a few more still, fingers crossed, to get to my goal. Not there yet.

It ain't easy but I'm practicing maintaining. The middle path. Stop the pendulum always heading with great momentumvtowards impressive liss or shockingly quick gain.

CornishGem1975 · 28/12/2023 11:55

mapleriver · 27/12/2023 20:54

Have you tried fasting? I do 18/6 and can't physically manage the amount of calories in that time frame to put on weight. 6-8 of it is already done while you sleep.

I do fasting from time to time and I could easily consume the amount of calories I need to put on weight which is about 1700-1800. That's one pizza and a glass of wine!

So I have to still 'diet' when fasting.

ChanelNo19EDT · 28/12/2023 11:47

Scorchio84 · 27/12/2023 20:50

I've just signed up for a two week trial with a diet app called "Noom" fingers crossed it'll give me a kick in the arse to drop a stone & a half before the end of Feb, think it's €109 for the time they estimate it should take me to reach my target, but I'll see how the trial goes before I commit

Let us know if it's worth the money in yr opinion. I feel I can do it on my own if I decide to. But determination can vary from week to week.

ChanelNo19EDT · 28/12/2023 11:45

Well after an 800 cal day yesterday, I lost .3 of a kilo! I'm pleased with that. I will have a normal day today (1400, my maintaing amount) and do another 800 cal day tomorrow so I don't metabolically adapt to 800 cals per day.

Muscles feel a bit tight after my 16 minute standing abs routine ystrdy, but I'll do it again.

mapleriver · 27/12/2023 20:54

Have you tried fasting? I do 18/6 and can't physically manage the amount of calories in that time frame to put on weight. 6-8 of it is already done while you sleep.

Scorchio84 · 27/12/2023 20:50

I've just signed up for a two week trial with a diet app called "Noom" fingers crossed it'll give me a kick in the arse to drop a stone & a half before the end of Feb, think it's €109 for the time they estimate it should take me to reach my target, but I'll see how the trial goes before I commit

ShittyGlitter · 27/12/2023 20:30

Wow some of the diet advice here is a bit worrying.

@FatBack2023 your weight gain sounds quite rapid for someone who is generally calorie conscious. Have you considered if there might be an underlying problem? Your description sounds like cushings disease

Humbugss · 27/12/2023 20:22

DewHopper · 27/12/2023 16:06

Sorry but if I ate 2000 calories a day I would be the size of a house.

Fair enough and thanks for sharing. Just proves it’s not a one size fits all and all about knowing your own body

Gardeningtime · 27/12/2023 18:56

RedToothBrush · 27/12/2023 18:31

Because of the effects on hormones and whether it produces a starvation reaction where you store more food.

Some foods act on your body in different ways and are easier / harder to process (take calories from) but affect how full you feel.

Starvation mode has been debunked. You eat less that you expend you lose weight.

CornishGem1975 · 27/12/2023 18:38

Eating less might make you put on MORE weight rather than lose it.

If I eat 1200 calories a day I will consistently lose 1-2lbs a week. I do not gain weight.

If I go up to 1800 calories I will slowly gain weight.

RedToothBrush · 27/12/2023 18:32

The weight gain is when you get access to more food, not when you are restricting.

It's to do with efficient food processing rather than amount of food.

RedToothBrush · 27/12/2023 18:31

electriclight · 27/12/2023 18:14

How can eating less make you put on more weight?

You don't see fat people in famines.

Because of the effects on hormones and whether it produces a starvation reaction where you store more food.

Some foods act on your body in different ways and are easier / harder to process (take calories from) but affect how full you feel.

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/12/2023 18:21

electriclight · 27/12/2023 18:14

How can eating less make you put on more weight?

You don't see fat people in famines.

Depends what you mean by "less". If it's highly calorific then you don't need vast quantities to gain weight from it.

electriclight · 27/12/2023 18:14

How can eating less make you put on more weight?

You don't see fat people in famines.

RedToothBrush · 27/12/2023 18:12

41quid · 27/12/2023 14:20

A question for the medically trained:

Is 18 pounds, 63,000 calories for everyone or just for some?

I ask because I've known sick folks being assailed with all manner of cakes and calorific meals continue to lose weight and know two twins who, while spending a week away together attending a family funeral ate identically, the childless one stayed the same weight and the other (mother of three) put on half a stone.

Do those who respond to calories most strongly need to record their food intake more carefully (gluten, fat, protein ...) and reflect on food combinations and their impact to avoid sabotaging themselves?

The biggest impact on my figure has been adopting the 16:8 diet and eating whatever I feel like. No blood sugar fluctuations or excessive hunger pangs that characterised other diets. Two stone down over 18 months, with no anxiety.

Have you read 'why we eat (too much) by Andrew Jenkinson.

It challenges the idea that calories in = pounds on, because the research demonstrates that there is a discrepancy between the increase in calories human eat and the amount of weight they SHOULD have point on for those additional calories.

Once you understand that, it starts to raise big questions about the diet and food industry generally.

There are a number of writers who are saying similar things in recent years and the science does seem to be backing up the point.

Eating less might make you put on MORE weight rather than lose it.

Crikeyalmighty · 27/12/2023 18:02

@slaybell I went to the US in October and ate around 2500 calories a day for 10 days and drank a few wines every night - I was suprised that I actually only put 3 to 4 pounds on as it felt like I had eaten a lot as normally eat around 1600 - 18lbs isa lot !

slaybell · 27/12/2023 17:31

@41quid That was my point.

OP was talking about fat. I was pointing out how difficult it would be to gain that amount of fat in such a short space of time with her calorie intake - so likely something else.

41quid · 27/12/2023 17:25

slaybell · 27/12/2023 17:14

I'd be surprised at 18 pounds in a month. That is a LOT of weight to gain in a short amount of time.

It doesn't make sense from what you've said it takes on average 3000 excess calories to gain 1lb of fat so if that is all fat gain you'd have had to have 1800 extra calories a day!

I'll guess that's it is not all fat gain and it'll soon drop off once you go back to eating normally.

An allergic reaction - exacerbated by my GP recommending something that made it worse - resulted in me adding more than a stone of water in ten days. We should not assume that all excess weight is fat.

slaybell · 27/12/2023 17:14

quisensoucie · 27/12/2023 11:19

At the end of November, after maintaining my weight... the Christmas festivities began and I thought, I'm going to let myself go over 1,200 cals for the next month, and eat & drink Christmas things. So I've indulged... I have stayed below 2,000 cals most days for the past month, but there have been days when I've gone up to 2,400. Anyway, over the past month, yes I've had mince pies. Yes I've had cake. Yes I've had trifle. Yes I've had biscuits. Wine. Roast dinners. I confess, I have indulged.
The fact that you started all this a month before Christmas would not have helped
I am unsure why you are surprised; do you exercise?

I'd be surprised at 18 pounds in a month. That is a LOT of weight to gain in a short amount of time.

It doesn't make sense from what you've said it takes on average 3000 excess calories to gain 1lb of fat so if that is all fat gain you'd have had to have 1800 extra calories a day!

I'll guess that's it is not all fat gain and it'll soon drop off once you go back to eating normally.

Calliopespa · 27/12/2023 17:10

ChanelNo19EDT · 27/12/2023 17:05

I disagree that the problem is not exercising enough, you cannot out run a bad diet, and a lot of foods we think of as being normal staples are very high in calories but don't satiate us. I'm always walking as I don't drive. It's what I eat that matters.

I think people who recommend intuitive eating underestimate how greatly hunger can vary from person to person.

I think in fact people over-estimate how much lots of things can vary from person to person, and actually even from one period of the same person’s life to another period of their life. Body chemistry is complicated. There are hormones and metabolic factors, differences in body shape and fat storage patterns, underlying conditions… and on it goes. Being lucky shouldn’t give people licence to be judgmental.

MorganKitten · 27/12/2023 17:06

Have you asked your GP about Orlistat? It’s worked wonders for me, I had diet control, worked out 4/5 times a week and this is the on
y thing that’s kickstarted the weight loss