Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so angry at how FAT my back and boobs are

293 replies

FatBack2023 · 27/12/2023 11:09

I'm raging.
I absolutely HATE my body shape.
I HATE how FAT my back gets when I gain weight.
And my neck.
And my chin.
And my abdomen.
And my BOOBS!! OMG. I'm carrying around 2 great pendulous gargantuan breasts that get more huge with every extra pound of weight I gain.
And I absolutely HATE how easily I gain weight. I put weight on thunderously fast compared to other people.
Why is this?
I basically have to sub exist on 1,200 cals a day to maintain my weight. If I go over this, my weight rapidly increases but it increases in an accelerated way. I put so much weight on so fast, it's completely disproportionate to the extra calories I eat. If I eat 2,000 cals a day for a few weeks, I gain 1 stone in weight. And my back, neck, chin, breasts and tummy BALLOON.
At the end of November, after maintaining my weight with 1,200 cals all year, the Christmas festivities began and I thought, I'm going to let myself go over 1,200 cals for the next month, and eat & drink Christmas things. So I've indulged. But I've carried on tracking (I use nutracheck) and I have stayed below 2,000 cals most days for the past month, but there have been days when I've gone up to 2,400. But interestingly, looking back at my tracking over the past month, on those days where I've gone above 2,000 cals a day, I've naturally eaten a lot less the following day without consciously thinking about it, back down to 1,500 or 1,200 for a day.
Anyway, over the past month, yes I've had mince pies. Yes I've had cake. Yes I've had trifle. Yes I've had biscuits. Wine. Roast dinners. I confess, I have indulged. But not all the time. And not everyday. I've also had home made vegetable soups and salads. And some days I've barely eaten anything. Some days I've had 1 meal only and tracked 800 cals for the whole day. I haven't just eaten Christmas foods all day every day. But yes I have had those foods over the past month. And still tracked every single thing.
And I have gained 18 POUNDS in weight in 1 month!!!!
And it's all gone on my back and boobs and chin and tummy.
I can literally grab handfuls of fat on my UPPER BACK!!
And my bra is too tight!!
And my chin has 2 pound of lard wobbling about under it when I talk!
And my tummy looks like I'm pregnant!!
But the worst thing of all is my back, it is covered in fat! My upper back fat rolls onto my lower back fat.
OMG. I look horrendous.
I feel horrendous.
Meanwhile my legs, bum, hips and arms remain completely unchanged, no extra ounce of fat anywhere on these areas.
I look like I've put a fatsuit onto my central body, like a fatsuit bodywarmer jacket, leaving my arms and legs as normal.
It's aging too....I look years older with all this extra weight.
Oh help.
How have I gained soooo much weight in only 1 month? I'm sure this isn't normal??
Why does it all go onto my back, boobs and tummy?
Why can't I eat the things other people eat??
Why have I put on 18 pounds in 1 month rather than just a few pounds?
I hate my body right now!!!
I'm 45, 5ft 7, and right now I weigh 15 stone.
1 month ago I weighed 13 stone 10.

OP posts:
Lentilweaver · 29/12/2023 14:35

I think you need to see another doctor, if you can. There must be a medical reason.

Calliopespa · 29/12/2023 14:30

ChanelNo19EDT · 29/12/2023 13:52

Well, I didn't read her responses as nasty, I read it as frustration that she wasn't being believed. Lots of people telling her that she must be defying the laws of science.
I have more sympathy as I know from experience that body was surviving on 1200 cals per day, not losing a gram. For 6 weeks I kept going with it and lost nothing. Breaking the laws of science apparently. I only lost weight when I increased calories. Maybe the laws are a bit more complicated than calories in /calories out. Maybe hormones matter.

Yes I read OP that way too. She has reached out from a real low for solidarity and instead been told she’s a self-deceiving glutton. Ever heard of hitting someone when they’re down?
And there really can be other things like hormones at play. I have friends who have struggled and struggled. Some people imagine they are blessed with an unnatural gift of insight and discipline in that they can cut calories or lift weights. The truth is most people who want/ need to can, but it doesn’t always work quite like that… so they get bogged down.

ChanelNo19EDT · 29/12/2023 13:52

Well, I didn't read her responses as nasty, I read it as frustration that she wasn't being believed. Lots of people telling her that she must be defying the laws of science.
I have more sympathy as I know from experience that body was surviving on 1200 cals per day, not losing a gram. For 6 weeks I kept going with it and lost nothing. Breaking the laws of science apparently. I only lost weight when I increased calories. Maybe the laws are a bit more complicated than calories in /calories out. Maybe hormones matter.

saffy2 · 29/12/2023 13:36

Why are you all still attempting to help her? Her responses are patronising and nasty.

Lalalanding · 29/12/2023 13:12

Almost certainly you are insulin resistant but also you have metabolic issues linked to that too.

HIIT training is not suitable for weight loss in post menopausal women as we are so impacted by the high cortisol it produces through stressing the body. Weights are far more beneficial at this age.

electriclight · 29/12/2023 12:40

OP even with pcos and menopause it is not possible to maintain 14 stone at 5' 7" on 1200 calories every single day even if completely sedentary, which you are not. But I see now that you are cross with anyone who suggests some element of autonomy over this and want very much for there to be a reason that is beyond your control. I regret posting my experience but hope you get to the bottom of it.

Gardeningtime · 29/12/2023 12:29

ChanelNo19EDT · 29/12/2023 12:21

@Gardeningtime think you might need to brush up here. Unless you skim read my post in your haste to dismiss my experience as myth. But I wasn't questioning why I had put on 10 kilos, I was questioning why I couldn't lose weight when I reduced calorie intake.

I have managed to lose weight this last year, focusing on real foods, eating as though I were already maintaining, weighing regularly to assess the results/loss.

Baffled as to what part of my experience you're dismissing as myth.

@FatBack2023 I would go to a gp, I was talking to a gp this time last year about going on hrt as unfortunately, low oestrogen exacerbates insensitivity to insulin. Instead of just calories in calories out im also thinking about insulin down glucagon up and eating in this way like I don't want to get diabetes in the future has really levelled things out over time. I'm rarely hungry (but I could still lose about 4 kilos)
Getting hormones sorted has left me feeling a lot better.

Apologies, and you are right, I missed the nuance, I was referring it to the op who is now thinking that’s why she is gaining weight and just pointing out you need to eat or drink the cals even when insulin resistance.

shes adamant she doesn’t, so only a doc can help her as she is gaining weight on fresh air and defying all laws of nature. She is literally the only human being in existence ever to actually gain weight without actually eating rhe food. On 1200 cals a day, she’s even maintaining at nearly 14 stone.

saffy2 · 29/12/2023 12:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

FatBack2023 · 29/12/2023 12:21

saffy2 · 29/12/2023 12:10

So you’re not teetotal. teetotal don’t drink any alcohol.

And it is over the past month of festivities where you have consumed alcohol where you have put on a literally stupid amount of weight. Im absolutely amazed that you haven’t made that correlation. Alcohol is very very very high in calories, especially wine.

Over the past month that I am referring to where I have consumed things outside of my normal dietary intake, I have drunk 3 glasses of dry white wine measured by me at home in a measuring jug as as 125ml servings per glass.
1 glass of 125mls on Christmas eve.
1 glass of 125mls on Christmas day.
1 glass of 125mls on Boxing day.
At approx 95 cals per glass, rounding it up to 100, that's 300 calories in total of alcohol.
Would you agree?
And if you agree, do you continue to feel amazed by that?

OP posts:
ChanelNo19EDT · 29/12/2023 12:21

Ps my doctor didn't roast me. Definitely make an appointment xx

ChanelNo19EDT · 29/12/2023 12:21

@Gardeningtime think you might need to brush up here. Unless you skim read my post in your haste to dismiss my experience as myth. But I wasn't questioning why I had put on 10 kilos, I was questioning why I couldn't lose weight when I reduced calorie intake.

I have managed to lose weight this last year, focusing on real foods, eating as though I were already maintaining, weighing regularly to assess the results/loss.

Baffled as to what part of my experience you're dismissing as myth.

@FatBack2023 I would go to a gp, I was talking to a gp this time last year about going on hrt as unfortunately, low oestrogen exacerbates insensitivity to insulin. Instead of just calories in calories out im also thinking about insulin down glucagon up and eating in this way like I don't want to get diabetes in the future has really levelled things out over time. I'm rarely hungry (but I could still lose about 4 kilos)
Getting hormones sorted has left me feeling a lot better.

Calliopespa · 29/12/2023 12:20

FatBack2023 · 29/12/2023 12:03

Thanks.
Yes, I did discuss about hormones with GP. She explained that they don’t test LH or FSH anymore for menopause, and go by symptoms and symptomatic treatment instead. I think what she was trying to say was that a woman could have hormone levels within range but have menopause symptoms and so they would want to treat the symptoms and not be deterred by the person having normal range hormones. And vice versa - they wouldn't treat someone with no symptoms but whose blood hormone levels were out of range. This was my understanding and made sense to me so I didn't push any further. I had tiredness, but no other symptoms.
Although now I'm wondering if the tiredness and weight gain are in fact menopause symptoms. But now I'm also wondering about PCOS and insulin resistance. Or a combination of all 3 maybe!

Yes it could well be a combination of all three. Good luck with getting to the bottom of it and I hope you feel better in 2024. No idea what has wound saffy up so tight…

saffy2 · 29/12/2023 12:10

FatBack2023 · 29/12/2023 12:05

Yes, I've had wine over the past month.
But outside of this, I don't ever drink wine or alcohol. I am ralking about what i consume normally. I am teetotal outside of the past month of Christmas festivities.

So you’re not teetotal. teetotal don’t drink any alcohol.

And it is over the past month of festivities where you have consumed alcohol where you have put on a literally stupid amount of weight. Im absolutely amazed that you haven’t made that correlation. Alcohol is very very very high in calories, especially wine.

FatBack2023 · 29/12/2023 12:05

saffy2 · 29/12/2023 12:03

You’re a tee total? Really? Your opening post says that you’ve had wine…since November.
its not patronising to read your posts where you mention drinking alcohol, and then mention calculating food calories and then ask have you definitely included drinks in your calories.

i also think you’re being very very rude and patronising yourself actually, people are reading what you have written and trying to help. If you have written the wrong things that’s not on us. It also very patronising to assume that every single person in the world who don’t understand calories and what constitutes calories is an idiot and stupid. That’s really nasty.

youre very rude. Why would you even post when you seemingly only want to be nasty to people who are trying to help you.

what do you actually want people to say…yes you have gained 18lbs in a month by eating only 1200 calories a day and doing vast amounts of movement and you’re just that fat and there’s nothing that can help you 🙄🤷🏽‍♀️

you don’t seem like a very nice person, and you don’t seem like you actually want help. In which case, don’t post.

Yes, I've had wine over the past month.
But outside of this, I don't ever drink wine or alcohol. I am ralking about what i consume normally. I am teetotal outside of the past month of Christmas festivities.

OP posts:
FatBack2023 · 29/12/2023 12:03

Calliopespa · 29/12/2023 11:37

Yes it can OP. I actually wondered about pcos.

I think ( no expert) that is also linked to hormone levels? I’m surprised they refused to test them when your periods stopped at your age. It’s normal for peri but quite early for stopping. I think you should try again as some form of HRT may be of real assistance from the sound of it.

Thanks.
Yes, I did discuss about hormones with GP. She explained that they don’t test LH or FSH anymore for menopause, and go by symptoms and symptomatic treatment instead. I think what she was trying to say was that a woman could have hormone levels within range but have menopause symptoms and so they would want to treat the symptoms and not be deterred by the person having normal range hormones. And vice versa - they wouldn't treat someone with no symptoms but whose blood hormone levels were out of range. This was my understanding and made sense to me so I didn't push any further. I had tiredness, but no other symptoms.
Although now I'm wondering if the tiredness and weight gain are in fact menopause symptoms. But now I'm also wondering about PCOS and insulin resistance. Or a combination of all 3 maybe!

OP posts:
saffy2 · 29/12/2023 12:03

FatBack2023 · 29/12/2023 11:54

Oh my goodness me.
Do you think I'm so stupid that I don't realise that drinks contain calories?
Do you think I'm going to say "Oops! Silly me! I haven't been adding all the wine and fruit juice and milk to nutracheck! How silly of me! Turns out I've been DRINKING an extra few thousand calories a week ha ha!"
What planet of idiotness do you live on?
Please, I beg, stop patronising me.
And please, I beg, stop assuming.
I drink only water.
I do not drink any alcohol whatsoever. I'm 100% teetotal.
I do not drink fruit juice.
I do not drink tea, coffee, squash, fizzy drinks, hot chocolate, etc. etc.
I drink water only.
Which is WHY I'm only referring to FOOD.

You’re a tee total? Really? Your opening post says that you’ve had wine…since November.
its not patronising to read your posts where you mention drinking alcohol, and then mention calculating food calories and then ask have you definitely included drinks in your calories.

i also think you’re being very very rude and patronising yourself actually, people are reading what you have written and trying to help. If you have written the wrong things that’s not on us. It also very patronising to assume that every single person in the world who don’t understand calories and what constitutes calories is an idiot and stupid. That’s really nasty.

youre very rude. Why would you even post when you seemingly only want to be nasty to people who are trying to help you.

what do you actually want people to say…yes you have gained 18lbs in a month by eating only 1200 calories a day and doing vast amounts of movement and you’re just that fat and there’s nothing that can help you 🙄🤷🏽‍♀️

you don’t seem like a very nice person, and you don’t seem like you actually want help. In which case, don’t post.

FatBack2023 · 29/12/2023 11:54

saffy2 · 29/12/2023 10:45

You only mention food every time you mention calorie tracking…
you could easily be adding 1000 calories with drinks and alcohol, it is very easy actually to miscalculate calories taken in. Especially when you are saying you’re only in taking such small amounts of calories, 800-1200 calories if 1 very very tiny meal. No coffee, no tea, no juice, no soft drinks, no alcohol, no snacks etc etc. that’s why people are suggesting you may be miscalculating. It is very easily done, even with an app. Especially if you are only calculating food.
i would also assume you had a serious medical
condition if you are only ever having 1200 or below at the activity level you describe. 1200 calories is a very very very small amount of food and drink for the day even at a sedentary lifestyle.

Oh my goodness me.
Do you think I'm so stupid that I don't realise that drinks contain calories?
Do you think I'm going to say "Oops! Silly me! I haven't been adding all the wine and fruit juice and milk to nutracheck! How silly of me! Turns out I've been DRINKING an extra few thousand calories a week ha ha!"
What planet of idiotness do you live on?
Please, I beg, stop patronising me.
And please, I beg, stop assuming.
I drink only water.
I do not drink any alcohol whatsoever. I'm 100% teetotal.
I do not drink fruit juice.
I do not drink tea, coffee, squash, fizzy drinks, hot chocolate, etc. etc.
I drink water only.
Which is WHY I'm only referring to FOOD.

OP posts:
Calliopespa · 29/12/2023 11:37

FatBack2023 · 29/12/2023 08:58

To answer questions....
I'm not sedentary. I am walking around all day long, every day, both in my job which requires movement and activity, and when I'm at home as I dont stop running round after my young kids and doing endless housework.
I go for a 40 minute brisk pace walk 5 x weekly.
I go for a 5 mile brisk pace walk twice weekly.

Other than that, I don't do any other type of exercise. But I rarely sit down.
I stopped my period a year ago. Have had no menopause symptoms. I just didn't have a period one month and it never returned.
No diagnosed health conditions.
Had blood tests 2 months ago for feeling tired a lot of the time, all normal including thyroid and glucose. GP refused to test hormone levels.
Interestingly, 13 years ago I saw a Gynaecologist for infertility after 18 months of trying to conceive who told me he was certain I had PCOS and arranged for a surgical procedure to investigate this, I got a date for the procedure but then out of the blue I suddenly conceived and was pregnant by the date of my procedure. So it was cancelled, I went on to have 2 children and I've never re-explored this. So it's interesting that people have mentioned PCOS but how does this make you gain excessive amounts of weight?

Yes it can OP. I actually wondered about pcos.

I think ( no expert) that is also linked to hormone levels? I’m surprised they refused to test them when your periods stopped at your age. It’s normal for peri but quite early for stopping. I think you should try again as some form of HRT may be of real assistance from the sound of it.

Gardeningtime · 29/12/2023 11:26

ChanelNo19EDT · 29/12/2023 11:15

I agree with the comment about insulin resistance. Nearly a year ago I was crying with frustration that my usual restriction to 1200 cals per day diet that I pulled out of the bag every so often was this time having zero effect. Started a few threads about it! and I was told I was underestimating my intake. Like it's extremely hard. I wasn't. I approach it very scientifically and often double check and often round up to avoid an overall underestimation.

I had become insulin insensitive (if not insulin resistant) so I decided to slow down and focus on reducing carbs (only white ones, although, I still go very easy on brown rice and brown bread too). No sugar. Eating in a window. Think about gut biome. I'm doing it all!. I read up on ''reverse dieting'' too and I upped calories by about 50 per day every couple of days until I got to 1400 but making sure everything was real food. Like a can of tuna in olive oil or three eggs with pitted black olives and cucumber and cherry tomatoes. You will be full for hours.

After crying to myself about how I could NOT lose weight, I kept going, I felt like, well at the end of the year I will know for certain what really happens to my body if I eat 1400 of cals per day. Some days I went over, but mostly I didn't even quite reach 1400. And I do feel like I know. I feel like my body will sit at a BMI of 26 on a year long diet of 1400 healthy food per day. So clearly, depressingly, I need less than this.

I have lost weight as the year passed. I've lost 7 kilos this year, so not a quick loss.

So, ignore people telling you that you're accidentally miscalculating the calories in what you eat. I logged every gram, every morcel and I wasn't losing weight. I have been too stringent in my logging in younger years. When I say my body adjusted to 1200 cals it really had.

This is such a myth as you’ve missed the key point, which is insulin resistance causes weight gain as excess blood sugar is stored as fat. The key word here is excess. You need to consume the excess in the first place.

i don’t know why folks keep posting like they are some medical miracle who gain weight without eating the food. It is simply not true. Yes many things make it easier to gain weight, or lead to weight gain, but the fundamental underlying fact is you need to be eating the food in the first place.

ChanelNo19EDT · 29/12/2023 11:20

ps, yes, when you do the maths, you would have needed to be eating nearly full time to have gained this much!

ChanelNo19EDT · 29/12/2023 11:15

I agree with the comment about insulin resistance. Nearly a year ago I was crying with frustration that my usual restriction to 1200 cals per day diet that I pulled out of the bag every so often was this time having zero effect. Started a few threads about it! and I was told I was underestimating my intake. Like it's extremely hard. I wasn't. I approach it very scientifically and often double check and often round up to avoid an overall underestimation.

I had become insulin insensitive (if not insulin resistant) so I decided to slow down and focus on reducing carbs (only white ones, although, I still go very easy on brown rice and brown bread too). No sugar. Eating in a window. Think about gut biome. I'm doing it all!. I read up on ''reverse dieting'' too and I upped calories by about 50 per day every couple of days until I got to 1400 but making sure everything was real food. Like a can of tuna in olive oil or three eggs with pitted black olives and cucumber and cherry tomatoes. You will be full for hours.

After crying to myself about how I could NOT lose weight, I kept going, I felt like, well at the end of the year I will know for certain what really happens to my body if I eat 1400 of cals per day. Some days I went over, but mostly I didn't even quite reach 1400. And I do feel like I know. I feel like my body will sit at a BMI of 26 on a year long diet of 1400 healthy food per day. So clearly, depressingly, I need less than this.

I have lost weight as the year passed. I've lost 7 kilos this year, so not a quick loss.

So, ignore people telling you that you're accidentally miscalculating the calories in what you eat. I logged every gram, every morcel and I wasn't losing weight. I have been too stringent in my logging in younger years. When I say my body adjusted to 1200 cals it really had.

scaredofff · 29/12/2023 10:56

Do you keep a diary of what you drink? Alcohol/juice/tea/coffee and water?
Do you have a diary you can share with us?

TBH I'd be more worried than angry if I were in your situation. I'd be at that gp as soon as they had an app for full check up if you are as sure as you say about your calorie intake

saffy2 · 29/12/2023 10:45

FatBack2023 · 29/12/2023 08:11

Thanks everyone.
Sorry I haven't replied sooner, been busy hosting relatives staying with us.
Some of these replies say I'm miscalculating my intake, but I'm not. I use nutracheck which is brilliant at calculations. I find it quite patronising to suggest I'm calculating calories wrong. It's not hard to weigh and measure food then enter it in to nutracheck.
Also, I have literally gained 18 pounds in 1 month.
Based on the maths of having to eat 3,500 extra calories to gain an extra 1 pound in weight, I haven't eaten 3,500 (cals) x 18 (pounds) which totals 63,000 additional calories on top of my normal intake over the past month, which is the why I'm so angry and confused.
63,000 calories ÷ 30 days = 2,100 calories every day in addition to my normal calories.
So 3,300 cals DAILY for a month??? No way have I eaten this! I've tracked and calculated it all!

You only mention food every time you mention calorie tracking…
you could easily be adding 1000 calories with drinks and alcohol, it is very easy actually to miscalculate calories taken in. Especially when you are saying you’re only in taking such small amounts of calories, 800-1200 calories if 1 very very tiny meal. No coffee, no tea, no juice, no soft drinks, no alcohol, no snacks etc etc. that’s why people are suggesting you may be miscalculating. It is very easily done, even with an app. Especially if you are only calculating food.
i would also assume you had a serious medical
condition if you are only ever having 1200 or below at the activity level you describe. 1200 calories is a very very very small amount of food and drink for the day even at a sedentary lifestyle.

chewsandwhine · 29/12/2023 10:32

Meant to add, op.
As well as counting the calories, perhaps up the protein as it fills you up more and helps you reduce your intake of carbs.

Add the HIIT and you become fat burning machine.

FatBack2023 · 29/12/2023 10:28

Gardeningtime · 29/12/2023 09:30

If the doctor has ruled out any issues, I’m sorry you’re underestimating your total intake. No matter how much you feel that’s wrong. And pcos doesn’t add that much, it makes you more prone to gain weight, but you still need to put the calories in

i lnow you don’t want to accept it, but the sad fact is you’re eating way more than 1200 a day normally to maintain at nearly 14 stone. Likely close to double that, and now with the extra in the last month you’ve gained this weight.

unfortunately you will continue to be over weight until you address this. I personally would start with a month of calorie counted meals ie a pot of readymade porridge rather than toast where the spread can be double , and a ready meal for lunch and dinner, calories are controlled and counted for you. See how you get on.

you can also post a standard day for you, when, you’re eating normally. But you need to include any cheat days, where for example you may drink at the weekend and eat crisps or nuts.

No, I'm not underestimating.
I'm not estimating full stop.
I'm measuring and weighing every single thing I eat and drink and inputting it in to an excellent calculation app.
Not sure how much more I can say this.

OP posts: