Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Took the shine off my Christmas present

364 replies

notdoing · 27/12/2023 09:24

We had and family round for Christmas and Boxing Day and after hosting, finally got round to showing off my gift from DP.

Obviously I was really pleased as it was something I've wanted for a while, not cheap so I hadn't just bought it myself already, and I made that clear. As I'm showing them what I got, my very close friend gets out her phone, searches for the gift and buys herself the exact same thing. It's something you'd wear so I did comment but she made out like it was fine, we won't wear them at the same time etc and I didn't want to ruin the mood.

I just feel like it's not the done thing though and it really took the shine off it for me. I don't know if I'm being unreasonable or not but just honestly felt a bit gutted 😞

OP posts:
IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 27/12/2023 14:48

GustyFinknottle · 27/12/2023 14:45

It's evidenced on the thread that different people would have different responses to this, and unless you think that you're the final arbiter of who is right and who is wrong, you will understand my point.

Well, yes, the people on this thread who say the OP is making a fuss about nothing are the same people who shove their plates into the centre of the table the minute they've finished eating, or say they'll bring wine for Christmas lunch and then just bring one bottle, drink it and ask for more, or who roll in at 2am and play music loudly when there are relatives sleeping upstairs and neighbours who'll be disturbed. Barbarians: not acceptable in polite society. They do what they want without thinking of anyone else. They show no respect for others. Just like the OP's 'friend' who has done something almost perfectly designed to spoil her pleasure in a thoughtfully-chosen gift.

What a ridiculous post and ridiculous assumptions.

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 27/12/2023 14:46

whatwasIgoingtosay · 27/12/2023 14:12

Sometimes I think half of Mumsnet lives in a parallel universe where social standards and customs are completely different to the rest of us. Of course adults 'show off' Christmas gifts. If I had any guests coming in the days after Christmas, I'd be saying, 'Look at the lovely scarf DH bought for me! Isn't it nice?' That seems like very normal behaviour to me and I bet it happens in millions of homes across the UK without people recoiling in horror at the 'unreasonableness'. I think your friend's action was crass and I would be put out in your position.

If I had any guests coming in the days after Christmas, I'd be saying, 'Look at the lovely scarf DH bought for me! Isn't it nice?' That seems like very normal behaviour to me and I bet it happens in millions of homes across the UK without people recoiling in horror at the 'unreasonableness'

I don't think anyone "recoiled in horror at the unreasonableness" of this. Over egging one's point to make a point rarely works.

Several posters thought it was odd behaviour for anyone over the age of 10 (and I'm one of them). I certainly would not say that to guests or friends. It's a bit crass and fishing for compliments. (And the viewer might think it's awful - LV Everfull I'm looking at you)

GustyFinknottle · 27/12/2023 14:45

It's evidenced on the thread that different people would have different responses to this, and unless you think that you're the final arbiter of who is right and who is wrong, you will understand my point.

Well, yes, the people on this thread who say the OP is making a fuss about nothing are the same people who shove their plates into the centre of the table the minute they've finished eating, or say they'll bring wine for Christmas lunch and then just bring one bottle, drink it and ask for more, or who roll in at 2am and play music loudly when there are relatives sleeping upstairs and neighbours who'll be disturbed. Barbarians: not acceptable in polite society. They do what they want without thinking of anyone else. They show no respect for others. Just like the OP's 'friend' who has done something almost perfectly designed to spoil her pleasure in a thoughtfully-chosen gift.

TitaniasAss · 27/12/2023 14:44

McMuffins · 27/12/2023 14:08

Was she copying her though or just happened to like the same item?

I think you have a bit of a playground mentality tbh. I haven’t cared about anyone ‘copying’ me since year 9.

If two grown adults both like something why shouldn’t they both be allowed to enjoy it?

You're missing the point entirely, but OK.

CharlieUniformNovemberTangoYankee · 27/12/2023 14:36

"What is the gift?"
Sorry, I don't want to say. She uses MN occasionally and as pps have said, it's not worth falling out about. I do think she'd make a big thing about me having shared this on here even though it's completely anonymous.

Do you seriously think your friend wouldn't recognise herself here, just because you haven't revealed the mystery gift?

Fullofxmascbeer · 27/12/2023 14:35

I’m team op.

It would have been slightly better if she’d have asked if you minded, but even then you’d have felt pressurised to agree.

InsomniacA · 27/12/2023 14:34

EffortlesslyInelegant · 27/12/2023 13:39

Not sure why everyone is so puzzled about what the gift was Grin

It was an LV tote. Obvs. Grin

I just thinking LV Neverfull or a scarf in vivid Burberry check. Or a Pandora bracelet. But something in this category, I'm certain.

Icantbedoingwithit · 27/12/2023 14:34

Such a huge mountain out of a molehill. I get a nice present for Christmas and I show everyone. My friend is well impressed and says Ohhhhh I’d love one of those, it’s fab! Impulsively whips out her phone and orders one. Big deal! How it takes away from the shininess of the present is actually beyond me. Who cares? I honestly don’t get it. It’s an OBJECT readily for sale on the internet, not exclusive, not hard to get, I could buy one now in 2 mins. Ridiculous overreaction. You got something, she liked it, she bought one. In the grand scheme of things it’s pitifully trivial.

InsomniacA · 27/12/2023 14:30

notdoing · 27/12/2023 09:52

Maybe it's not that deep then but now do I need to check if she's wearing hers before we go anywhere? Or do you often see people wearing identical coats/shoes/bags?

I wish I had your problems instead of mine. I am rather embarrassed for you.

Duvetdayforme · 27/12/2023 14:28

Yeah, friend was slightly odd, but it doesn't sound spiteful otherwise OP would have said she had form for nastiness.

OP you do sound very very sensitive. I am glad to read that you do not intend to fall out with your friend over this. Some posters are never happy until the OP has LTB or gone NC.

Isitthathardtobekind · 27/12/2023 14:24

cynan · 27/12/2023 09:39

What adult "shows off" their Christmas gift? I find that unreasonable. Are you put out that your friend could afford the item without it having to be a Christmas treat?

Why can’t she show something she’s been given that she’s really pleased with? Some people need to lighten up a bit.

Sallyh87 · 27/12/2023 14:20

I think that is a really odd thing to do! Like she was making a point that your gift wasn’t special and just some you could pick up any time, which obviously it is but still a weird thing to do.

Give her the benefit of the doubt, she just liked it and wasn’t thinking. She got some Christmas money and splurged.

Also, I assume it’s a nice handbag 😜

ifIwerenotanandroid · 27/12/2023 14:13

notdoing · 27/12/2023 14:01

@Scirocco it's not that I'm bothered about having the same thing necessarily, it's the way the whole situation came about.

Some posters have hit the nail on the head I think, it was more that even though the other people in the room were a bit Confused and said so, she continued without any concern as to how she made me feel. I still have no idea why she did it and just feel a bit crap about the whole thing tbh.

Was she ver' ver' drunk at the time?😂

Maybe she woke up the next day & with a groan remembered doing it & realised what a tit she'd been (& has maybe blown her January paycheck on this thing which she now can't wear because she promised not to clash with you wearing yours).

We can only hope.

whatwasIgoingtosay · 27/12/2023 14:12

cynan · 27/12/2023 09:39

What adult "shows off" their Christmas gift? I find that unreasonable. Are you put out that your friend could afford the item without it having to be a Christmas treat?

Sometimes I think half of Mumsnet lives in a parallel universe where social standards and customs are completely different to the rest of us. Of course adults 'show off' Christmas gifts. If I had any guests coming in the days after Christmas, I'd be saying, 'Look at the lovely scarf DH bought for me! Isn't it nice?' That seems like very normal behaviour to me and I bet it happens in millions of homes across the UK without people recoiling in horror at the 'unreasonableness'. I think your friend's action was crass and I would be put out in your position.

McMuffins · 27/12/2023 14:08

TitaniasAss · 27/12/2023 10:21

Well it's kind of obvious which MNetters happily copy their friends' purchases, which is kind bizarre behaviour for adults. 😁

OP, it's not a huge deal I suppose, but it just wasn't very nice of her. If a friend of mine has something new and lovely, I'll compliment them on it but I wouldn't dream of reaching for my phone to buy the identical item, because I'm not 13.

Was she copying her though or just happened to like the same item?

I think you have a bit of a playground mentality tbh. I haven’t cared about anyone ‘copying’ me since year 9.

If two grown adults both like something why shouldn’t they both be allowed to enjoy it?

DwightShrutesgirlfriend · 27/12/2023 14:04

I wouldn't be at all fussed if a friend owned the same item as me, but I think the fact that she ordered it at that particular moment was really crass on her part and I totally get where you're coming from @notdoing.

notdoing · 27/12/2023 14:01

@Scirocco it's not that I'm bothered about having the same thing necessarily, it's the way the whole situation came about.

Some posters have hit the nail on the head I think, it was more that even though the other people in the room were a bit Confused and said so, she continued without any concern as to how she made me feel. I still have no idea why she did it and just feel a bit crap about the whole thing tbh.

OP posts:
IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 27/12/2023 14:01

I just feel like it's not the done thing though and it really took the shine off it for me. I don't know if I'm being unreasonable or not but just honestly felt a bit gutted

You asked. My answer is, I think you are being unreasonable. Your friend's behaviour is a bit odd but your reaction is OTT.

And yes it does matter what the gift was. I don't own this dress (yet) but I've had my eye on It. It can be bought quickly online but it's such a distinctive dress made in limited quantities that if I did own it, and a friend immediately bought it, I'd be a bit miffed. It would spoil it for me as the dress is almost unique.

Dress I wouldn't want my friend to own if I owned it

On the other hand, as there are so many of these it wouldn't make the slightest difference if a friend owned it.

Bag I wouldn't care if my friend owned even if I had it

Dusk Dress in Doomed Voyage print, sorbet & port

Dusk Dress in Doomed Voyage print, sorbet & portS

The Dusk dress is our show-stopping dress. A romantic, whimsical, loose, oversized, solid silk dress full of gathers. The dress has large billowing sleeves, pockets and  button cuffs and a gathered skirt.  The doomed voyage print is a toile de jouy pri...

https://klements.co.uk/collections/dresses/products/dusk-dress-in-doomed-voyage-print-sorbet-port?variant=42760402043038

Watchkeys · 27/12/2023 13:59

@GustyFinknottle

I'm not disputing that some things are regarded as good manners and some aren't, or that some things are more likely than others to cause offence. That's not what I was saying. I was saying that the grey areas aren't yours or mine to define, at the expense of someone else's right/wrongness.

Who is the authority? Where are the rules? Why would Fred know better than Tim? Why would OP know better than her friend?

It's evidenced on the thread that different people would have different responses to this, and unless you think that you're the final arbiter of who is right and who is wrong, you will understand my point.

Scirocco · 27/12/2023 13:58

@notdoing I don't think it's ever something I've cared that much about. There have been times friends and I have coincidentally worn the same thing and we've just laughed and carried on with our days. I wouldn't think anything of it, and I wouldn't be bothered by other people having the same thing as each other. If it bothers you, though, you could always just contact her in advance and tell her you're wearing/using yours for a particular event. Then she can decide what to do about hers.

Zombiemum1946 · 27/12/2023 13:58

Whilst it's a compliment in one way, it's also a bit rude to just whip out the phone and buy it in front of everyone. Just enjoy the gift and try ignore what your friend did. I doubt she meant to upset.

nutster · 27/12/2023 13:55

Given your BF presumably knows you are a sensitive soul prone take offence, I am surprised she took the risk tbh.

nutster · 27/12/2023 13:53

notdoing · 27/12/2023 13:49

"It's not nutster who is getting cross."

4 posts in a row, edited at that, getting heated about what "bloody relevant" when I've explained my stance on that.

Hmm, ok then.

edited for a typo! 😂

GustyFinknottle · 27/12/2023 13:51

Personally I think it was quite insensitive of her to buy your present for herself, especially to do it right there and then. But sensitivity is a feeling, and it's different for everybody. You are allowed to feel as sensitive about her action(s) as you like; your feelings are a manifestation of who you are, and nobody can tell you you're right or wrong.

No, some things are likely to cause upset and offence and some things aren't, and an action like the 'friend's is highly likely yo be understood as undermining the OP and stealing her joy. You might think it's okay for, say, you to sit down for Christmas dinner naked and that I am being 'sensitive' when I tell you you need to put clothes on — but some things are okay and some things aren't, and sitting naked at a dining table when everyone else is clothed is not okay. Boundaries and manners go hand in hand. Manners are about showing respect. The OP's friend showed no respect for good manners or the OP's feelings. OP, I think when you're ready you do need to have a think about your friend's attitude to you and whether she really does value and respect you. Because her behaviour certainly didn't indicate that.

NonPlayerCharacter · 27/12/2023 13:49

vivainsomnia · 27/12/2023 13:01

I just feel like it's not the done thing though and it really took the shine off it for me
OP says it herself. Her main issue was that it took the shine off her. If that's not referring to attention, what is meant by this statement?

Of course she wanted attention. Contrary to sanctimonious MN teaching, humans like and need attention from time to time and it's not a crime or a bad thing. There's nothing wrong with showing a few loved ones a nice Christmas gift from your husband for a couple of minutes of "aw how nice". Maybe you like being ignored all the time and never having a few moments of focus but if so, you're unusual to say the least.

Swipe left for the next trending thread