Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Took the shine off my Christmas present

364 replies

notdoing · 27/12/2023 09:24

We had and family round for Christmas and Boxing Day and after hosting, finally got round to showing off my gift from DP.

Obviously I was really pleased as it was something I've wanted for a while, not cheap so I hadn't just bought it myself already, and I made that clear. As I'm showing them what I got, my very close friend gets out her phone, searches for the gift and buys herself the exact same thing. It's something you'd wear so I did comment but she made out like it was fine, we won't wear them at the same time etc and I didn't want to ruin the mood.

I just feel like it's not the done thing though and it really took the shine off it for me. I don't know if I'm being unreasonable or not but just honestly felt a bit gutted 😞

OP posts:
BlazingWorld · 27/12/2023 10:50

notdoing · 27/12/2023 09:52

Maybe it's not that deep then but now do I need to check if she's wearing hers before we go anywhere? Or do you often see people wearing identical coats/shoes/bags?

I can honestly say I wouldn’t notice at all if someone had the same shoes or bag as someone else. And if someone had the same coat I would possibly notice, if it was distinctive, but not have any thoughts about it. I’ve actually bought friends things that I already own in the past, because I like them, so I assume/ hope they like them too. Although I am now reminded of Friends “we’ll be bracelet buddies!” Grin

Shinealight9 · 27/12/2023 10:50

notdoing · 27/12/2023 09:52

Maybe it's not that deep then but now do I need to check if she's wearing hers before we go anywhere? Or do you often see people wearing identical coats/shoes/bags?

It was definitely rude but I wouldn't fall out over it unless this type of behaviour became perpetual. Friendship shouldn't be about causing hurt.

Kaleidoscopeofbutterflies · 27/12/2023 10:50

I'm with you OP .. would annoy me.. actually it would upset me and take the pleasure out of it.
I think it was mean and cruel.
And why not show gifts off.. to your Mum etc.. some very negative people on here.

Rachie1973 · 27/12/2023 10:47

notdoing · 27/12/2023 10:15

"What is the gift?"

Sorry, I don't want to say. She uses MN occasionally and as pps have said, it's not worth falling out about. I do think she'd make a big thing about me having shared this on here even though it's completely anonymous.

I suppose I need to consider why that is, just like I'm wondering why she ordered herself the same thing there and then, despite others in the room being a bit taken aback and saying as much at the time.

The fact is, it's not something either of us would just buy every day, it was special enough that I went and got it to show them and they wanted to see. She also apparently agreed it would be odd if we wore it at the same time.

I think that ship has sailed to be honest. If she sees this thread it’s quite obvious

GustyFinknottle · 27/12/2023 10:47

As I'm showing them what I got, my very close friend gets out her phone, searches for the gift and buys herself the exact same thing.

YNBU, OP — that's really, really bad manners and I can't understand why so many PP don't see it. It's a crass, shitty thing to do. You had been given something that felt very special to you and she has nicked your delight. Poor you. You need friends with better manners and social skills.

I've occasionally coveted something that a friend has bought or been given but I would never just go and buy a duplicate unless it's something like a piece of equipment — a kitchen appliance, say. And even then I'd say 'I'm going to buy one of those for myself, as you've recommended it so highly' and see what they say. But if it's something like a wonderful new coat or a designer top or jewellery or some delicious boots, then I'd wait a bit to give the friend the pleasure of showing them off and then talk to them about it. 'I love your boots so much, you look so good in them. I don't want to alienate you by being a copycat. Would it upset you if I bought a pair very like them?' That's the way to do it.

You can get your back on her by saying 'Ah, look, you're wearing my copycat boots/ coat/ necklace' loudly for everyone to hear every time she turns up wearing the item.

Stompythedinosaur · 27/12/2023 10:46

I couldn't get upset about this. Surely you aren't expecting to be the only person allowed to own this item? That would be crazy!

TitaniasAss · 27/12/2023 10:45

Calabou · 27/12/2023 10:32

Is it? A coworker asked where I got my trousers (we're both tall and like certain styles) and I sent her the link to the exact item. I didn't sit with a face on when she wore them to work, I thought it was nice someone else thought my clothes looked good and that she now has somewhere else to find clothes that won't be far too short on her.
It's odd to assume that anyone who asks where a friend got something and buys it is "13". The OP, if she isn't a remote worker, may well come across various colleagues and clients/customers wearing the exact same item.

The situation is completely different and I think that's quite obvious. Perhaps my post wasn't very clear.

I've also sent links to friends for clothes they've liked, but buying the same pair of box standard trousers is, in my view, very different from immediately whipping your phone out at Christmas and ordering something that a friend received as a special gift. I wouldn't do that to a friend as I think it's unkind (and childish) behaviour. You do not, and that's fine.

Luckynumbereight · 27/12/2023 10:44

I perfectly understand how you feel, OP. I would have been miffed as well.

Your title says it all and is perfectly correct - she DID try to take the shine off your gift and 100% succeeded.

I’d be careful around this one.

Ulysees · 27/12/2023 10:43

If she's usually ok I would just let it go . But I'm the sort who would have said something at the time and my friends wouldn't do that. They're grown ups.

JaneAustensHeroine · 27/12/2023 10:42

Unless it was a personally commissioned piece of clothing, jewellery or art I really wouldn’t be bothered by this. As previous posters have said, items are mass produced and therefore unless it has been designed especially for you I would find it ok.

It is a little gauche to order it in front of you but clearly she thinks you have the kind of friendship where you can be that open and transparent. And it is probably better than finding out at a later date when she wears it in front of you. Perhaps in that situation I might have asked you if you would mind me ordering one for myself as I like it so much.

I think her actions show you have a comfortable friendship and that is something to be valued.

rainbowstardrops · 27/12/2023 10:42

I'm wondering if it's a distinctive looking coat and that would look a bit odd if OP and her friend rocked up to a bar both wearing one.
If it's a designer bag that's just neutral and doesn't stand out then it's not so bad.
Still bloody weird to whip your phone out and order one right in front of people though!
I wonder if she's jealous that she didn't get a beautiful, lovely gift? What is she usually like?

ALunchbox · 27/12/2023 10:39

Is the item supposed to be unique / one of X exemplars? If so, I see why you would feel annoyed. If it isn't, I couldn't get worked up about it. Everyone wears the same variations of shoes/trousers/dresses/tops. I mean, how often are you stopped in your tracks blown away by how original one person's attire is?

nutster · 27/12/2023 10:39

obviously a very very close best friend to be spending christmas day together

is this completely out of character?

or in line with past behaviour?

oakleaffy · 27/12/2023 10:38

notdoing · 27/12/2023 10:08

"You’ve still not told anyone what this “not cheap”, mystery item is but have managed to share the fact you have more of a disposable income than said friend. It’s not that deep"

No, not the case at all. I was giving context in that, it's not a cheap pair of gloves or whatever that you'd just pick up without a second thought.

And then I had to clarify that this wasn't a difference in financial circumstances issue because I hadn't made it clear enough and pps were understandably focusing on that.

It's a nice enough thing for everyone I was showing to be saying "oh it's lovely" and passing around to look at. Hence, it felt a bit special, until suddenly it wasn't.

My friend has the same type of dog as me, and we both bought the same dog coat.. [Friday Fox Newmarket wool]...and people in street or on walks stop and ask where it came from..and I tell them!

It doesn't really matter, @notdoing
'Imitation is the greatest form of flattery'
If clothing, it makes a huge difference as to WHOM is wearing it.

Ditto jewellery and bags.

guineverehadgreeneyes · 27/12/2023 10:38

I'd have found it a bit off that she ordered it there and then in front of you and everyone else.

Whatever the item is, she could have waited until she got home. Or she could have waited a few days and then said, she really liked your gift and would you mind if she ordered one, too, knowing that you'd probably say no, you would not mind.

But to whip out her phone after your mum had asked to have a look at your gift and order one for herself, there and then, is thoughtless and rude.

I would try not to let it spoil my enjoyment of a nice gift but it would certainly colour my view of her, in the future.

KezzaMucklowe · 27/12/2023 10:37

It really wouldn't bother me but obviously from this thread I can see that it would bother quite a few people do I don't think yabu.
Unless it's a bag in which case no one would even notice that anyway.
Op, I know you don't want to say what the item is incase your friend is on here but I'm sure she will be able to figure out it is her from this regardless.

FestiveHackathon · 27/12/2023 10:36

Was it something distinctive like this cape?

https://www.wolfandbadger.com/uk/the-silver-feather-cape/

Whothatbe · 27/12/2023 10:36

On the one hand it's very annoying and petty. Don't copy me, some things are nicer because you just have it. You sourced it and loved it. Then someone else shows up in it , it's annoying.
On the other hand , in a months time you won't care.
But yes- very annoying.

TiptoeThroughTheToadstools · 27/12/2023 10:36

It seems to me, its less about having the same thing and more about the fact she bought it while you were showing yours off. It is a bit thoughtless by your friend, and clearly your DM thought the same. I think if you can try to let it go, she probably doesn't realise that she's upset you as she seemed more focused on you both not wearing it at the same time, rather than taking the shine off your Christmas present. You speak about your friend as if she is a lovely person so I'm sure you agree that it wasn't an intentional shitty thing, just didn't think.

notdoing · 27/12/2023 10:35

"Does this friend have a partner/DH?"

Yes she does and he treats her well.

For all those saying there will be lots of people also with the same item, yes there will, but none of my friends or family already had it and I've only seen one other person wearing it whilst out and about!

OP posts:
betterangels · 27/12/2023 10:35

cynan · 27/12/2023 09:39

What adult "shows off" their Christmas gift? I find that unreasonable. Are you put out that your friend could afford the item without it having to be a Christmas treat?

I mean, this is what it sounds like to me too. Just enjoy your gift.

ZeldaFighter · 27/12/2023 10:34

I think that's really rude and inappropriate, possibly with some very unpleasant psychological motivations underneath. If someone was showing me their new puppy / Lego/ bracelet, I would not get my phone out and get myself one in front of them!!! How rude and disrespectful! YANBU

How you go forwards is up to you. Only 1 friend got me thoughtful gifts this year but I will not fall out, just not put so much time and effort in next year for them. How you proceed depends on your current relationship.

BetterWithPockets · 27/12/2023 10:33

Haven’t read all the posts here, OP, but some, and all your updates — and I’d be miffed too. As another poster has said, not worth falling out over but it’s a bit weird of your friend.
Also, to the posters complaining the OP hasn’t revealed what the item is — she doesn’t have to! I hate this MN thing where people demand information…

Calabou · 27/12/2023 10:32

TitaniasAss · 27/12/2023 10:21

Well it's kind of obvious which MNetters happily copy their friends' purchases, which is kind bizarre behaviour for adults. 😁

OP, it's not a huge deal I suppose, but it just wasn't very nice of her. If a friend of mine has something new and lovely, I'll compliment them on it but I wouldn't dream of reaching for my phone to buy the identical item, because I'm not 13.

Is it? A coworker asked where I got my trousers (we're both tall and like certain styles) and I sent her the link to the exact item. I didn't sit with a face on when she wore them to work, I thought it was nice someone else thought my clothes looked good and that she now has somewhere else to find clothes that won't be far too short on her.
It's odd to assume that anyone who asks where a friend got something and buys it is "13". The OP, if she isn't a remote worker, may well come across various colleagues and clients/customers wearing the exact same item.

Lindjam · 27/12/2023 10:32

Handbag probably. In which case it’s extremely unlikely there won’t be other people with the same bag when you are out and about with it. Plus, nobody will even notice.

Whilst I agree it was a little odd for friend to order it immediately, I would write that off as enthusiasm and I definitely wouldn’t be cross with her.

Life is too short to get uptight about 💩 like this OP. Let it go and enjoy your gift.