Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister in law

28 replies

Kaxford · 27/12/2023 01:09

My sister in law hasn’t been shy about giving me her opinion on what I should be doing since I had my twins back in March. I smiled and listened because I thought she was well intentioned even though her advice was unsolicited. A few weeks ago we moved to be closer to my husbands family as I have no family in this country. She made the effort to call to the house every day, unannounced and I was happy to have her even if it wasn’t always convenient. She started calling the boys by nicknames I didn’t like and I let it slide until one day after a particularly rough night with the boys and told her to please not shorten their names as I didn’t like it. I felt bad afterwards. Then she would arrive while the boys were napping and deliberately make enough noise to wake the dead so they would wake and she’d rush over the pick them up. She arrived one lunchtime as I had just out the boys in the highchairs and picked one of them up after me asking her not too as I was literally about to feed them. So she settled for singing and messing with them so they are literally nothing 🤦‍♀️ then the straw that broke the camels back was when she said to me one of the boys wanted to taste the tea I had made her, I told her no he doesn’t, he gives me enough trouble without being full of caffeine. I literally turned my back on her to pick up one of their cups and when I turned round again she had her mug up to his mouth tilling it so he couldn’t drink the tea. And that was it I lost the plot. I grabbed the mug from her and told her I’d literally just asked her not to give him tea. I went on to pull her up on the fact she’d fed the boys something without asking when had been minding them the week before, leaving the lunch I’d left with them untouched telling me they didn’t want it so she gave them something else. She got shirty telling me it doesn’t do them any harm she’s a mother she knows what she’s doing. I told her that she may well be a mother but I’m THEIR mother and she needed to respect what I’m telling her. She went on to tell me that she knew more about babies than I did and which point I told her if she couldn’t do what I was asking then she could leave. She’s not spoken to me since. Was I out of line? How would the rest of you handled the situation? Sorry this was an essay 🙈

OP posts:
mayorofcasterbridge · 27/12/2023 01:25

Good for you! Stick to your guns with the silly bitch!

TheSilent1 · 27/12/2023 01:21

YANBU at all. I wish I had the guts you had to tell people when they've stepped out of line and crossed my boundaries. I have spent 18yrs suffering with in-laws over stepping their place with my children. I think if you have the ability to stand up for your own boundaries then do it. My DC have all been giving things not age appropriate (chocolate, tea, ice cream etc.) and against my wishes by female in-laws and I could never stand up to them about it so if you can then do. These are your children and people need to remember you gave birth to them so what you feel is right for them should be respected. I don't understand it because my family never do/say/give anything without first asking me and their father so why do in-laws always feel they have the right to. Wish you luck and stay strong 🥰

Chichimcgee · 27/12/2023 01:13

I don’t think you were out of line at all! What a horrible woman she is. It’s up to your partner to set her straight and I’d just ignore her ignoring you