Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Joint birthday and Christmas presents

160 replies

AppleChunkPunk · 26/12/2023 19:44

My DD turns 1 tomorrow and I've specifically said since she was born "No joint presents!" Get her a small gift for 1 and put £5 in her account, or whatever people can afford, but do 2 things, they are separate special days.

2 family members - one from my side 1 from DP - have gone against our wishes and said she is only 1, she won't remember, it was an expensive gift so she will like it etc.

AIBU for being angry they chose to go against what we asked? I said to both family members if her birthday was July you would have bought 2 gifts, but I still got "she won't know she is only 1".

I'm not ungrateful for the gifts, they are lovely and DD probably won't know, but as parents we know, I'm upset they couldn't even put £1 in her card as a gift, or buy an actual birthday and actual Xmas present.

Am I being silly?

OP posts:
AppleChunkPunk · 26/12/2023 21:17

I should also add, now I've read all the comments, they have chosen to only see her on 1 of the days - her birthday OR Christmas, so it's actually not even just gifts, it's time spent too.

I wouldn't have batted an eye lid if everyone said "no presents at all this year" we would have bought her gifts from us and been thankful her family visited, but they didn't

OP posts:
usererror99 · 26/12/2023 21:17

It's the dictating of how you want it which is coming across as a bit rude and entitled personally. Being born on Xmas Eve / Xmas Day / Boxing Day - well that's sort of bad planning on the parents part unless there was a medical emergency. I wouldn't like to then be told how I'm to spend my money by them. I have a limited budget for gifts and one larger more expensive item is surely better than 2 cheaper ones just to fulfil your requirements. (FWIW I have twins and whilst they are young I don't have a problem with joint presents for them)

14Q · 26/12/2023 21:15

She is one so she doesn't care. I think you are being silly. Be grateful for the presents and let people do what they want. We have a lot of Xmas time birthdays (4 very close and one on the 12th 🤦🏻‍♀️) in our house and it's never been an issue. I've just done a joint pressie for my Mum. My kids who have birthdays a few days away from Xmas don't care either. Birthdays with friends didn't matter as they would have a party or pub trip a week or two before their actual birthdays. They sometimes buy joint Xmas birthday presents for each other so it clearly doesn't bother them.

I used to make their birthdays as special as I could but it was useful to have the option to combine their Xmas and birthday presents so they could buy something bigger.

I think fussing about this type of thing and trying to control what other people do is boring. I think you should relax and not worry about it. You don't need to be indignant about this especially on behalf of a one year old.

caringcarer · 26/12/2023 21:13

I've got 2 summer born DC and 1 mid December. When he was small he got gifts on his birthday and others at Xmas but as he got a bit older the toys he wanted like garden toys his siblings had didn't work as well in December so we asked him if he'd rather celebrate his birthday in the summer on his half birthday and he said yes. We've done that ever since. On his real birthday we just have a family tea.

UsingChangeofName · 26/12/2023 21:13

At this age it doesn't matter, as your baby won't have a clue.

Also, you can only ever say "We'd really rather you do X" (about presents). You can't 'demand' anything.

Nor is it true that this doesn't happen for any children who have birthdays at this time of the year. All my 3 dc (now adults, but with birthdays spread throughout the year) have had a more expensive present for either birthday or Christmas at various times on the understanding this is their joint birthday / Christmas present as it is more ££ than we would normally spend on them.

I do understand you wanting to keep the separate days, but you can't 'demand' how others choose to do that.
I do think (once they get older) saying to everyone "Don't get dc1 a birthday present in December, we are going to celebrate her birthday officially at the end of January when it doesn't get taken over by Christmas. If anyone wants a wishlist for a birthday present we'll try and pull something together in early January".

KeyWorker · 26/12/2023 21:12

I think if it’s an older (?12+) maybe, child then it may be ok if it’s an expensive item such as Playstation, designer coat etc if they are fully onboard and understand the concept of how expensive that item is, then it may be ok but certainly for little ones then think it’s important to have a definite separation of birthday and Christmas.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 26/12/2023 21:05

YANBU. I'm 2 weeks after Christmas and people still do this. I've stopped getting people presents in the past and told them their birthday present was joint with their Christmas present who cares if their birthday is in August?!

AppleChunkPunk · 26/12/2023 21:03

Thank you so much for all the responses, I really appreciate them all.

She is an only child however, that may not be the case forever if we are fortunate to have another baby in the near future and I'd like to know all kids will be treated fairly.

I'm definately not asking for more presents! Maybe I wasn't clear on that. If someone only had £5 say to spend, I'd rather 2 presents, 1 for her birthday and 1 for Christmas. I'm definately not grabby! We both work full time and are financially comfortable, we provide more than enough for her and she will always want for nothing, I suppose I was almost expecting her close family to respect both occasions as separate events, not rolled into 1 through lazyness and the poor excuse of "it was expensive". Maybe if she doesnt know what day of the week it is she will also not know how much people spent and will be less worried about 1 expensive present and enjoy 2 gifts knowing they were given on 2 separate days.

My little sister is 19th Dec and she had 2 separate events, and she was always very happy, but looking at some December baby responses where it was treated as the same day almost I'm feeling alot less unreasonable to ask for 2 separate events. I'm sorry you all felt a bit cheated out of your birthdays, I'll try my best not to let that happy to my baby!

OP posts:
chillidoritto · 26/12/2023 21:03

YANBU. Well maybe a bit this year, but def wise to set your stall out for future years. As others have said, not fair on her to get one present when summer born siblings get 2!

DappledThings · 26/12/2023 21:00

When DD is older if she starts getting joint presents and it seems like she's getting less overall than DS I might feel we should get her some extra bits to make up for it.

I still think it's really rude to demand anyone else does it a particular way.

WesselCups · 26/12/2023 21:00

Mariposistaa · 26/12/2023 20:59

Life is not all about presents. Especially not at Christmas. Time spent with family and friends is so much more important

Behave.

SiennaMillar · 26/12/2023 21:00

Just do the same for them, regardless of when their bday is. If they only want to celebrate Xmas but not birthday of your child, do the same to them.

Mariposistaa · 26/12/2023 20:59

WesselCups · 26/12/2023 20:44

Is it?
So as a child, you would have been happy with one present while your siblings got two?
If your birthday was in July, would you have been happy with the present giver telling you that the present was for Christmas too, then on Christmas Day, you have no present while your siblings have one?
Don't talk wet.

Life is not all about presents. Especially not at Christmas. Time spent with family and friends is so much more important

Coconutter24 · 26/12/2023 20:58

My birthday is Christmas Day, I’ve always had separate birthday and Christmas presents, never received a birthday gift in Christmas wrapping paper which might seem silly but I’ve always been grateful people have took the time to think about each occasion. I wouldn’t dream though of telling anyone how they should gift anything so yes YABU for being angry and yes you are being silly

ProudparentofaMuffin · 26/12/2023 20:57

I had a joint Christmas and birthday CARD from a 'friend' one year...

tpmumtobe · 26/12/2023 20:56

YANBU and you're right to be clear about it from the start. DS has a bday in early Dec (so not even that close!) and the number of Christmas themed gifts he got for his bday when he was younger riled me no end. Now he's older we are actively debating moving his bday celebrations to his half bday to make a clearer distinction. In your case I would seriously consider doing that now while she's young enough to not notice the change.

TrixieFatell · 26/12/2023 20:56

I have a child with a Christmas birthday (not the actual day but very close). From day one we have insisted that if people want to buy Christmas and birthday gifts then they are separate. Might sound grabby but I don't care. Their birthday and Christmas are two different occasions. Their grandad bought a joint present the first year, and I thanked them for it and asked if they were happy for me to buy them one gift for their Christmas and birthday (they have a summer birthday). They weren't oddly enough. It's lazy and shows a lack of thought.

You'll get loads on here saying that you should be grateful etc but you are doing this for your child. Before my Dec baby was born all I got told was how miserable Dec birthdays are with one gift, Christmas wrapping used on their birthday etc. I was determined my child would have a birthday they loved and they have.

rwalker · 26/12/2023 20:51

My mum bought a joint present for my cousin on her first birthday spent far no than she would on 2 presents
her and my aunt’s relationship which wasn’t great never really recovered

my mum did forewarn that she would only do it for 1st birthday as cousin would not have a clue
tbf when aunty asked about presents for me and my sister in the early years she told them not to bother as we had no idea what it was all about wait till we could unwrap and appreciate gifts

I’m struggling to see how joint present would affect your DC 1st birthday
I do agree with separate presents when there older and understand

mumsytoon · 26/12/2023 20:49

Don't be ungrateful. It was an expensive gift.

WesselCups · 26/12/2023 20:44

Mariposistaa · 26/12/2023 20:35

Grab grab grab grab grab

Is it?
So as a child, you would have been happy with one present while your siblings got two?
If your birthday was in July, would you have been happy with the present giver telling you that the present was for Christmas too, then on Christmas Day, you have no present while your siblings have one?
Don't talk wet.

Mumof1andacat · 26/12/2023 20:42

I'm a 27th December baby and presents should not be joint just because the birthday is close to Christmas and should also not be wrapped in Christmas paper. It is lazy and thought less.

WesselCups · 26/12/2023 20:41

One of my kids birthday is on 21st December.
If anyone gave a joint birthday and Christmas present, I would ask them where the Christmas gift was. If it was wrapped in Christmas paper, I would ask where the birthday gift was.
Then I would hand the present back with a no thanks.
They soon got the message. Either a present for both occasions or none at all.
I refused to allow a joint present because if the birthday had been at any other time of the year, they would have got a present for both occasions.
My birthday is in mid December and my mum took the same stance of a gift for both of none at all.

ComtesseDeSpair · 26/12/2023 20:41

I think their reasoning that it’s her first birthday and she won’t give a shit is completely fair. She won’t. It’s a busy time of year for most people, not wanting to do two separate presents and cards and fusses for a baby who has no idea that it’s either birthday or Christmas just to appease a pair of overly precious parents is understandable. If they’re still doing it in three years time when she does realise, then’s the time to ask that they either recognise both separately or neither at all (and be prepared to accept without fuss that some people will opt for the latter.)

Hardbackwriter · 26/12/2023 20:38

I think your intention is good but there is just no way to say 'you need to buy my child more presents - I am unhappy that you didn't buy her more presents' that doesn't sound absolutely awful and ungrateful.

Mariposistaa · 26/12/2023 20:35

Grab grab grab grab grab