Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Joint birthday and Christmas presents

160 replies

AppleChunkPunk · 26/12/2023 19:44

My DD turns 1 tomorrow and I've specifically said since she was born "No joint presents!" Get her a small gift for 1 and put £5 in her account, or whatever people can afford, but do 2 things, they are separate special days.

2 family members - one from my side 1 from DP - have gone against our wishes and said she is only 1, she won't remember, it was an expensive gift so she will like it etc.

AIBU for being angry they chose to go against what we asked? I said to both family members if her birthday was July you would have bought 2 gifts, but I still got "she won't know she is only 1".

I'm not ungrateful for the gifts, they are lovely and DD probably won't know, but as parents we know, I'm upset they couldn't even put £1 in her card as a gift, or buy an actual birthday and actual Xmas present.

Am I being silly?

OP posts:
Kendodd · 27/12/2023 18:17

CleverLilViper · 27/12/2023 14:39

Well, you don't sound grabby at all...

If someone handed a present back to me with that attitude-the kid would never get a gift from me ever again and I'd make a point of it.

Thing is, the parents entitled, grabby and rude attitude is not the kids fault. Hopefully any children will have a better view of the world and understand that a gift is exactly that, a gift, and not something to be demanded of people.

FixItUpChappie · 27/12/2023 18:03

If anyone gave a joint birthday and Christmas present, I would ask them where the Christmas gift was. If it was wrapped in Christmas paper, I would ask where the birthday gift was. Then I would hand the present back with a no thanks.

Then you would be exceedingly rude and entitled.

ScroogeMcDuckling · 27/12/2023 18:02

I’m a Capricorn too.

I did better with a joint present, because people inevitably spent more on one gift, than two. As I got older you could see the “clutching of pearls” or “wringing their hands” telling me how expensive the one gift was 🤣🤣

it is nice to get to gifts, but I’d really rather have something beautiful or practical which I love rather than two bits of old tat, so I have a birthday gift and a Christmas gift, which may/will be donated to the charity shop.

Perhaps I’m just selfish.

Alwaystired23 · 27/12/2023 18:00

My sons birthday is tomorrow. I obviously buy him separate presents, birthday wrapping paper, etc. However I don't think you can really dictate to someone giving a gift to give 2 separate presents. Surly, what they give is up to the giver? Just make sure you treat them as separate events.

x2boys · 27/12/2023 17:47

AuntyMabelandPippin · 27/12/2023 17:43

People who are saying it's ridiculous, obviously have birthdays at different times of the year.

It's one of the most annoying thing about a birthday close to Christmas, everyone thinks they can lump it together, but they're totally different events.

Don't let them do this, my parents didn't, thank goodness, so I was ok.

As I said up, thread my son was 17 yesterday so I get it ,but I'm not rude and neither is he

LolaSmiles · 27/12/2023 17:47

People who are saying it's ridiculous, obviously have birthdays at different times of the year.
Not necessarily, just have the sense to realise that one more expensive gift for a 1 year old baby is likely to be a common sense decision by the gift givers so being annoyed about it is a bit over the top.

It's not like they've tried to pass off a selection box and a £5 note as birthday and Christmas combined, which most people would probably say is cheeky and unfair.

AuntyMabelandPippin · 27/12/2023 17:43

People who are saying it's ridiculous, obviously have birthdays at different times of the year.

It's one of the most annoying thing about a birthday close to Christmas, everyone thinks they can lump it together, but they're totally different events.

Don't let them do this, my parents didn't, thank goodness, so I was ok.

x2boys · 27/12/2023 17:40

WesselCups · 27/12/2023 16:45

@BalletBob Gratitude? For allowing treating one child more favourably than the other?
I don't think so!

With that attitude of might find that none if your kids get any presents from anyone else other than you ,be careful what you wish for...

x2boys · 27/12/2023 17:35

peakygold · 27/12/2023 15:20

DS's birthday is just before Christmas and his GF made the mistake of a 'joint' gift last year. He soon kicked her into touch. We have never done that, and I even keep one room completely free of all Christmas embellishments so we can actually celebrate his birthday. No Christmas wrap on his birthday gifts etc. I have always been absolutely adamant with family and friends that his birthday is as special as DD's in July.

He sounds very precious ,you can treat him like a prince on his birthday
But you can't expect others too

Fairyliz · 27/12/2023 17:33

My birthday is January and I often got joint presents as a child; it still rankles me and I’m nearly 64.
I don’t get joint presents now; just all the rubbish people got at Christmas which they regift me.

AuntMarch · 27/12/2023 17:16

WesselCups · 26/12/2023 20:41

One of my kids birthday is on 21st December.
If anyone gave a joint birthday and Christmas present, I would ask them where the Christmas gift was. If it was wrapped in Christmas paper, I would ask where the birthday gift was.
Then I would hand the present back with a no thanks.
They soon got the message. Either a present for both occasions or none at all.
I refused to allow a joint present because if the birthday had been at any other time of the year, they would have got a present for both occasions.
My birthday is in mid December and my mum took the same stance of a gift for both of none at all.

I don't necessarily buy for both anyway so you'd save me a few quid!

ZebraD · 27/12/2023 17:09

Kokeshi123 · 27/12/2023 08:09

People should give a separate Xmas and b-day gift but... I really don't think there is a way to say to people "You need to give extra gifts" that doesn't look and sound really grabby.

I'd just accept what they gave for her, and try to find other ways to make it up for her a bit as she gets older.

Would you say extra gifts for anyone else’s birthday not around Christmas! This kind of attitude is so annoying and frustrating! It’s not about extra it about SEPARATE CELEBRATION!

WesselCups · 27/12/2023 16:45

@BalletBob Gratitude? For allowing treating one child more favourably than the other?
I don't think so!

JenniferJupiterVenusandMars · 27/12/2023 16:41

As my 3 siblings and I were all born within a couple of days of Christmas, I had a childhood of joint presents, the disappointment in the lack of consideration and imagination has remained with me all my life 🤷🏼‍♀️

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 27/12/2023 16:41

Both dd1 and youngest dsis have birthdays very close to Christmas. When they were little we always kept gifts separate, but as they’ve got older they’ve had some large joint birthday and Christmas gifts, this has been discussed and agreed on as the gifts were more than would normally be spent on one occasion.

but honestly at 1 it doesn’t really matter and so close to Christmas I’m normally just pleased people remember and make any effort at all.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 27/12/2023 16:29

peakygold · 27/12/2023 15:20

DS's birthday is just before Christmas and his GF made the mistake of a 'joint' gift last year. He soon kicked her into touch. We have never done that, and I even keep one room completely free of all Christmas embellishments so we can actually celebrate his birthday. No Christmas wrap on his birthday gifts etc. I have always been absolutely adamant with family and friends that his birthday is as special as DD's in July.

I’d be so disappointed if I had raised my child to be this ungrateful and rude to his girlfriend. I have bought my DH joint birthday and Christmas gifts (his birthday is December) and he was nothing but grateful for the thought I’d put into his gift - a tablet, phone, high-ticket experience…

BalletBob · 27/12/2023 16:06

peakygold · 27/12/2023 15:20

DS's birthday is just before Christmas and his GF made the mistake of a 'joint' gift last year. He soon kicked her into touch. We have never done that, and I even keep one room completely free of all Christmas embellishments so we can actually celebrate his birthday. No Christmas wrap on his birthday gifts etc. I have always been absolutely adamant with family and friends that his birthday is as special as DD's in July.

He sounds a bit of a muppet if he's ended an otherwise happy relationship over some minor ego trip about being special 😐 I hope he returned the gift and she was able to get her money back.

BalletBob · 27/12/2023 16:03

WesselCups · 27/12/2023 11:04

@BalletBob and @x2boys There is nothing wrong with wanting my kids to be treated the same.
Why should one be only worthy of one gift when the others get two just because their birthday falls near Christmas and the others don't.
No, they get treated the same as far as I'm concerned.
So you either buy them a separate present for each occasion or don't bother buying at all.

There are ways and means of dealing with things. Being unnecessarily rude and combative is going to achieve nothing, apart from ruining your children's relationships with wider family and friends. You can express a preference but making demands around gift giving is out of order. You aren't the Queen of Sheba. If people want to spend a bit extra and get a bigger, combined present there's nothing wrong with that and you should respond with grace and gratitude.

MargaretThursday · 27/12/2023 15:27

I sort of agree with you, but It otoh my dc have all had joint birthday and Christmas presents when they've had something expensive they want. None of their birthdays are anywhere near Christmas.
So if it is something more expensive and They don't do it every time then I think it's fair enough.
What I would be not wanting is the spending about the same and calling it joint. So spending £12 instead of £10 and saying it worst of both.

CleverLilViper · 27/12/2023 15:23

peakygold · 27/12/2023 15:20

DS's birthday is just before Christmas and his GF made the mistake of a 'joint' gift last year. He soon kicked her into touch. We have never done that, and I even keep one room completely free of all Christmas embellishments so we can actually celebrate his birthday. No Christmas wrap on his birthday gifts etc. I have always been absolutely adamant with family and friends that his birthday is as special as DD's in July.

So, hang on, your son who is old enough to have a GF who dared to buy him a joint present-was so ungrateful for that present he "kicked her into touch."

He sounds pleasant and I hope she kicks him to the curb.

CleverLilViper · 27/12/2023 15:21

I think some people on this thread need a reality check and to rein in their entitlement.

  1. No one, bar the parents, is obligated to buy a single present for any children at all so if they do-you ought to do the gracious thing and be grateful for whatever they do get.

  2. You can make a request like this of people, but you cannot demand or dictate that they follow it. How other people choose to gift is their choice and not your remit to demand.

  3. Acting rude and crass like @WesselCups is a guaranteed way to disillusion anyone who was considering being kind and giving a gift into never bothering again and thus, a great way of cutting your nose off to spite your kid's face. Which is fine-if you never want your children to receive any gifts at all and great for any friends and relatives bank accounts!

Christmas is a busy, expensive time of year for most people. If people choose to do joint gifts, it's probably not because they don't care or want to be thoughtless. It's that there's a lot on people's plates at that time of year and they're trying to juggle everything at once.

Teach your children to be grateful for what they do receive. Try and host a party for your child at a different time for their birthday to celebrate.

I was always taught to be grateful for whatever I did receive. People don't have to give gifts-and believe it or not, other people's lives and worlds don't revolve around your kids. Honestly-if I went out of my way to purchase a present for a friend or a relative's child, and they acted like this about it-I'd never buy anything for them again.

peakygold · 27/12/2023 15:20

DS's birthday is just before Christmas and his GF made the mistake of a 'joint' gift last year. He soon kicked her into touch. We have never done that, and I even keep one room completely free of all Christmas embellishments so we can actually celebrate his birthday. No Christmas wrap on his birthday gifts etc. I have always been absolutely adamant with family and friends that his birthday is as special as DD's in July.

CleverLilViper · 27/12/2023 15:11

WesselCups · 27/12/2023 14:44

@CleverLilViper That is absolutely fine, as long as you don't buy presents for my other kids either.
My kids will always be treated equally, regardless of when their birthdays are.

You mean people can save money on not buying your kids presents at all? Score!

WesselCups · 27/12/2023 14:44

@CleverLilViper That is absolutely fine, as long as you don't buy presents for my other kids either.
My kids will always be treated equally, regardless of when their birthdays are.

CleverLilViper · 27/12/2023 14:39

WesselCups · 26/12/2023 20:41

One of my kids birthday is on 21st December.
If anyone gave a joint birthday and Christmas present, I would ask them where the Christmas gift was. If it was wrapped in Christmas paper, I would ask where the birthday gift was.
Then I would hand the present back with a no thanks.
They soon got the message. Either a present for both occasions or none at all.
I refused to allow a joint present because if the birthday had been at any other time of the year, they would have got a present for both occasions.
My birthday is in mid December and my mum took the same stance of a gift for both of none at all.

Well, you don't sound grabby at all...

If someone handed a present back to me with that attitude-the kid would never get a gift from me ever again and I'd make a point of it.