Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think children suffer the most from divorce

109 replies

Mirabelle2 · 26/12/2023 18:56

I am really unhappy in my marriage, My husband became very lazy once our children arrived and I have just grown more and more resentful. His priorities were up the wall and felt as though I was doing everything on my own anyway. A few weeks ago I asked him to leave, which he did, he is still having regular contact with the DC (more so than before). We have told the children that he is looking after his parents house whilst they are away for 2 months as I cant tell them unless I know it is final, the thing is, I think I am happier on my own. I just feel so so guilty for the kids like I am ruining them by making this decision. I keep trying to force myself for these feelings to come back and I really do want them to but I just dont think they will. He still tries to be intimate with me on occasion but I find it exhausting and like I dont want to see him in case he initiates anything?

What is happening to me? I always thought I would love this man forever :(

OP posts:
Ishbel38 · 26/12/2023 20:23

Before you have children make a commitment to giving them a stable home. That’s a 20 year minimal commitment. Your children, always, should come before yourself, needs, desires -these change all the time. If you can’t both commit to being there for your children, dont have them. You don’t deserve them and they certainly don’t deserve you! In this case - sit down with your partner and talk . Put the children first and create the best solution for them. Not for you or him. You and he dont count in this. You’ve made your mistakes. The children you created come first. Always!

Greymustard · 26/12/2023 19:52

I was a child of divorce.

Thank fuck. My dad was a useless dick. Even if there isn't abuse, I think there are often better outcomes than two parents sticking it out when desperately unhappy.

telestrations · 26/12/2023 19:50

You say he's being a more active parent since you've separated so the situation for the kids has already been improved by him leaving though this could temporary or ruse to get things back to where they were.

If you are seriously considering rekindling the relationship he needs to understand that it's as much on him if not far more then you, what is required of a father and a husband, and it's a long road.

It doesn't start with you forcing yourself to be intimate with a man you don't like, it ends with you wanting to be intimate with a man that you like and like that, again.

PurpleBugz · 26/12/2023 19:46

My parents never got divorced. I learnt to put up with shit from lazy men because that is what I was raised with. Bad parenting can happen within a marriage or out of it

JANetChick · 26/12/2023 19:42

Not the same situation but ….As a teen, I used to fantasise about my dad leaving my unpleasant mother and meeting a lovely middle-aged divorcee. Sometimes, it would be a specific woman such as a friend’s lovely aunt! Children do pick up on dismal marriages, whatever the reason for the dismal-ness.

Also, don’t leave it until the youngest has just gone off to uni because it will be obvious that you were just biding your time. That happened to a uni friend of mine in our first year (October 1990). She found out at Christmas that her unhappy mum had met another man about four years prior and was waiting to be with him (the man’s ex-wife told my friend when they bumped into each other on a night out and when my friend asked her mum about it, she admitted it). Guilt all round. I recall the tearful ‘phone call from my friend like it was last week.

Also, many couples who are together “for the children” are really together for financial reasons. Obviously, finance impacts the children too and is an important factor so it’s understandable. But let’s be honest, these people are not being entirely altruistic.

Isis1981uk · 26/12/2023 19:41

Hoglet70 · 26/12/2023 19:06

I honestly don't feel my DS was affected at all by my divorce. He was 3 when me and his Dad split up for good and now he has a fabulous Step Dad and a fabulous Step Mum. He is 18 and really well adjusted. It's not always negative. A happy single Mum is healthier than two miserable parents who are together for the sake of the kids.

This! My two were 3 & 7 when I separated from their dad - they didn't see him much before as he did shift work, and he had no involvement in their lives on a practical level, so when he moved out nothing really changed for them! They never got upset or cried, or even asked why or when was daddy coming back, they honestly didn't seem that affected! They now have an amazing stepdad who has been more of a dad (emotionally, financially, in every way) to them in the last 5 years than their actual dad!

RatatouillePie · 26/12/2023 19:40

Mirabelle2 · 26/12/2023 19:23

We never argue in front of the kids, He just doesnt help me around the house and works late, plays sport 3 nights per week and goes to every social even possible. He is constantly saying I dont show him affection and I dont, I feel like I cant walk past him without him wanting a kiss/cuddle etc its exhausting.

He treats you like his mother not his wife so it would be quite difficult to feel affectionate towards him!

I have the same. Zero desire to be affectionate with my DH as its me that does almost everything. He prioritises his dogs and phone. I cook, clean, work 38 hours a week term time, food shop, laundry, child care etc...

Just be honest with him. Tell him it's near impossible to show affection when he treats you like his mum not his equal. Well done for asking him to move out!

Grilly · 26/12/2023 19:38

Think practically about what your life would be like if you divorced (likely to involve lower living standards and in time, stepparents and other children) and think about what would make you happier in your current marriage (maybe dropping a night of sport for a date night, no sex for three months whilst you have counselling, paying for a cleaner, a childfree holiday).

Personally from what you’ve said I think you’d risk regretting not trying harder in your marriage.

Circe7 · 26/12/2023 19:34

I think the issue with this debate is that leaving a bad marriage is framed as a choice unless there is abuse. In reality it is very hard to fake a good relationship over multiple years. There are obviously marriages which appear to be on the rocks but which might be saved with a lot of work or where there are issues and compromises to be made but overall things are tolerable. But if you’ve got to the point where you have no feelings for the other person or actively dislike them and have tried and can’t work through that I don’t think it’s as easy as just staying and having enough self-control not to show hostility to each other in front of the children.

The other issue is that it takes two to try to make things work. I might have been able to stay with my ex and had at least a civil relationship with him but I would have had to do all the housework and childcare for the remainder of our marriage with zero complaint whilst holding down my career (and forgiving his affair and a load of other stuff) and having sex I didn’t want. In reality I couldn’t have tolerated that long term without showing resentment and I think it would have been an awful example to my boys.

I agree divorce often has a negative affect on children but once you’re in a really bad relationship I don’t think it’s always realistic or desirable to stay together for the children.

LittleGreenDragons · 26/12/2023 19:31

Can I honestly force intimacy if I dont feel it?
No. Many many women push their feelings and emotions to one side just so a man can fuck a hole. Why would you do that? You will end up hating yourself so don't even think this could be a possibility.

Not all children suffer when their parents split up, some positively bloom and flourish. Children are not stupid and can sense the mood in the house no matter how much you try to hide it. If you are not happy then your children are already aware of this. Don't prolong your (and their) unhappiness by staying as you are, either leave or have marriage counselling.

NameChangeAgain23 · 26/12/2023 19:28

My children were affected by my separation from their Dad, without a doubt. Neither can really remember us being together but they still get sad and wish we lived together so they didn’t have to split their time.

However, what they do get is the true, proper Version of me. Not the down trodden, miserable cow bag is become! They don’t have to listen to constant arguments and they don’t have a hostile home environment!

Covid was peaceful… it would have been hell on earth if I was still with their Dad. They are mostly happy and week adjusted. They have new step parents who add lots to their life and a little brother they wouldn’t otherwise have…

Hibye23289 · 26/12/2023 19:28

I was worried about this but I have not let the children be involved in any mess they are older age too so more aware but I have just been determined to give them a good childhood. Anti ds help me stop crying and I have been ok around them, my kids actually like the social side of going to see their dad at the weekend etc and my daughter says thats why she dont want us back together haha.

qpalbfy · 26/12/2023 19:26

Thing is you might not be arguing but you won't be demonstrating a healthy and happy marriage for your children, you want them to look up at you and know what they want from life when they grow up, not grow up thinking they have to settle or not know what a loving relationship looks like.

Mirabelle2 · 26/12/2023 19:25

I just want to do the right thing so much.

OP posts:
CaineRaine · 26/12/2023 19:24

It is devastating as an adult to realise your parents only stayed together because you were still a child. Don’t settle for less for yourself than you’d want for own children OP.

baileybrosbuildingandloan · 26/12/2023 19:24

I made ALL the effort to ensure mine did not. They grew up pretty well adjusted and have all gone on to form excellent relationships.

Their father made Disney Dad style effort as he wallowed in OWs money.

I never recovered financially.

So it doesn't have to be that way.

MintJulia · 26/12/2023 19:23

My parents stayed together despite not liking each other. It made our childhoods a misery in the process.

Don't let your dcs think you've sacrificed your happiness for them, it's too much to lay on them. Kids aren't stupid.

Mirabelle2 · 26/12/2023 19:23

We never argue in front of the kids, He just doesnt help me around the house and works late, plays sport 3 nights per week and goes to every social even possible. He is constantly saying I dont show him affection and I dont, I feel like I cant walk past him without him wanting a kiss/cuddle etc its exhausting.

OP posts:
minipie · 26/12/2023 19:23

What has his reaction been? Do you think he realises he’s been shit and wants to change? Do you think your feelings might change- not quickly but after say 6 months to a year of consistent effort from him?

How old are your DC?

I don’t believe in staying for the sake of the children but I do believe in trying hard to fix a marriage (if DC) before splitting. But only if both sides are trying hard.

Mirabelle2 · 26/12/2023 19:21

I keep thinking my feelings might come back, once I tell the kids I will never go back so I need to be 100%.

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 26/12/2023 19:20

What's worse for the children, having two miserable, unhappy parents together or having happy, relaxed parents apart?
Personally, I believe that no one who is "staying together for the sake of the children" is actually doing their children any favours.

I agree. I would even say parents who are getting on that badly should split up for the sake of the children.

I was not happy growing up as the child of parents who really ought to have called it a day. It’s also no fun watching them grow old unhappy with one another, and even worse when parents suggest their children should be grateful to them for it.

qpalbfy · 26/12/2023 19:20

Children suffer most when a relationship isn't working whatever the outcome. It can't be helped, it's life. Whether it's divorce or a tense marriage, children feel it, so better to do what is in your interests (within reason of course) and at least then it models healthy behaviours for your children growing up, daughters especially, so they don't grow up thinking they have to martyr themselves.

TomatoSandwiches · 26/12/2023 19:19

Would you be happy to encourage your son or daughter to force themselves to have sex with someone they have fallen out of love with, someone they resent because of their own poor behavioir?

I couldn't imagine wanting that for my child, I would rather anything but that for my child.

flowerchild2000 · 26/12/2023 19:18

Keeping children in an unhappy home is emotional abuse and neglect.

Thepeopleversuswork · 26/12/2023 19:18

Divorce is never easy for children but that doesn’t mean it isn’t the best available outcome.

I can’t say if your marriage is worth saving or not. But I can say unequivocally that you will be better alone than with a man who has checked out of family life. Whether that’s the case or not is up to him.

FWIW I don’t think divorce in itself is what harms children. It’s the bickering, arguing, head game playing and displacement that goes along with it which is the problem. It’s perfectly possible for two people to separate with dignity, compassion and putting the children as a priority.