Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hope that it doesn’t have to be like this?!

286 replies

Switchingoff · 26/12/2023 18:04

I will probably be flamed for this as a non parent but it’s a genuine q.

Spent Christmas with 4 kids on DP’s side, ages ranging from 9mo to 2.5 (and their parents).

It was absolute non stop them clinging to or crying for there mummys, not listening when told they couldn’t do something dangerous etc (obviously mostly applies to the older ones), being super picky about food, who fed them, where they sat etc, waking up multiple times a night, parents getting pissy if anyone dared to so much as breathe too loudly when kids were napping / had gone to bed etc. Everything (Christmas meal, present opening etc) had to be timed around their completely different nap and meal times. Every possible source of light that might come under doors had to be removed. Parents had to stay with them once asleep or they would cry when they woke (several times a night) - largely applied to two of the under 2s. Or in another case spend an hour putting to sleep.

It was frustrating, exhausting and somewhat ridiculous tbh.

im sure when we were kids we had to go with the flow a bit more and would often just fall asleep in a room full of people and be put to bed when adults went up?

currently TTC but tbh this is putting me off! Does it have to be like this or can you parent differently?! Since when did EVERYTHING revolve round the kids and since when were they so unresilient?!

OP posts:
SelectiveParticipation · 26/12/2023 19:31

and this contact napping, going to bed with the kid or putting them to bed etc is normal for them not just a Christmas / change of location thing

This is actually a thing I didn’t think I would do, and we really tried not to, but they wouldn’t go to sleep otherwise. You just do what works for your child. But, I teach 1-3 year olds and I can definitely say that many parents now pander to their children like never before. Letting them make decisions they are not old enough to decide. Letting them interrupt instead of teaching them to wait just a while etc. They want the best for their children and are very loving parents, but there are different ways to do things of course.

Arabellla · 26/12/2023 19:31

TinyTom · 26/12/2023 19:29

You are being incredibly disingenuous and seem to be massively back pedalling as you are being flamed on here. Your post was not just 'asking a question', it wouldn't be 20 lines long if it was. You used goady and inflammatory language which DRIPPED with judgment of the parents, no wonder people are riled - you were rude first. At least your trying to minimise what you first wrote shows you regret going in so hard to start with 🤷🏻‍♀️

No she wasn’t goady or inflammatory. She asked a question as she is TTC.

Calm down.

meganorks · 26/12/2023 19:31

I was a much better parent before I had kids too. Come back in 5 years and tell us all how its done (or cringe at your own comments)

YABU. Some people definitely take things to the extremes (my SIL was a right PITA when it came to being completely inflexible about nap/meal times etc) but all kids are different and behave differently when they are out of their own routines and home. And these are really young children you are talking about.

My first went to bed nicely at home, but rarely if somewhere else. She has only ever fallen asleep on a sofa etc when it turned out she was sick. My youngest was an absolute nightmare to get to sleep until at least 3 and I rarely stayed anywhere because I knew I wouldn't be able to get her to bed.

Hayliebells · 26/12/2023 19:30

Annon1234 · 26/12/2023 19:28

No it doesn’t have to be like this, maybe I was lucky but my child, fell asleep where she when she was tired. Whenever she wanted, within reason, didn’t hold anyone to her nap and food time. She absolutely did go with the flow. Could take her anywhere to any family gathering and she just slotted in absolutely fine

You were just lucky. It's not because you were better at babies. The OP isn't going to be able to plan to have a baby that is a good sleeper.

TinyTom · 26/12/2023 19:29

Switchingoff · 26/12/2023 19:18

With meals it was so parents who contact nap could be there for example.

so 4 different mealtimes / meals 3 times a day for the kids, plus the adult meals.

4 different nap schedules, bath and bedtimes

barely any slots in the day available!

one parent got annoyed we started some presents while they were doing an hour long bedtime. But the next kid was half an hour off bedtime and has a parent stay with them once they go to bed. Another had just come back from the other side of the family and needed dinner. Etc etc

Once again, jeez, I’m not having a go. I’m asking if it’s ALWAYS (or nearly) like this

and this contact napping, going to bed with the kid or putting them to bed etc is normal for them not just a Christmas / change of location thing

I also have a chronic illness so have less energy than most which is another reason why I’m asking whether it’s realistic to hope! Thanks to the few of you who have given constructive and helpful responses. The rest of you, no need to be so rude 🙄

You are being incredibly disingenuous and seem to be massively back pedalling as you are being flamed on here. Your post was not just 'asking a question', it wouldn't be 20 lines long if it was. You used goady and inflammatory language which DRIPPED with judgment of the parents, no wonder people are riled - you were rude first. At least your trying to minimise what you first wrote shows you regret going in so hard to start with 🤷🏻‍♀️

Lifeasiknowitisout · 26/12/2023 19:28

Switchingoff · 26/12/2023 19:18

With meals it was so parents who contact nap could be there for example.

so 4 different mealtimes / meals 3 times a day for the kids, plus the adult meals.

4 different nap schedules, bath and bedtimes

barely any slots in the day available!

one parent got annoyed we started some presents while they were doing an hour long bedtime. But the next kid was half an hour off bedtime and has a parent stay with them once they go to bed. Another had just come back from the other side of the family and needed dinner. Etc etc

Once again, jeez, I’m not having a go. I’m asking if it’s ALWAYS (or nearly) like this

and this contact napping, going to bed with the kid or putting them to bed etc is normal for them not just a Christmas / change of location thing

I also have a chronic illness so have less energy than most which is another reason why I’m asking whether it’s realistic to hope! Thanks to the few of you who have given constructive and helpful responses. The rest of you, no need to be so rude 🙄

It’s not always.

But it’s not always down to parents. It’s down to a ton of different factors.

and parents, like non parents, can be dickish sometimes especially when tired and pushed to their limits.

Honestly, with a chronic condition you may need plenty of support and it will be difficult. Not that you can’t do it. But you may find you or your partner give in more because your limits can’t be stretched as far. Or maybe you baby will be really easy.

My dd didn’t sleep. But had one tantrum in her entire toddlerhood. Decided herself she was going on a potty at 18 month old and was dry at night 2 months later. She spoke early, always loved school, did well at school, didn’t have a nightmare teens and is now a really independent adult. I thought I was a fab parent. I had ds and he showed me that, actually, it was mainly down to DDs personality.

My brothers child slept through from 2 weeks. They were convinced they had magical parent powers. They decided to ttc because their first was so easy. By the time their first was 2 they had a really difficult toddler and a really difficult baby who didn’t fall in line with magical sleep technique. Both kids constantly fall out and are now 14 and 15. They never stop.

You just can’t predict it. And what works for one child worked for that child. Doesn’t work for everyone’s.

Annon1234 · 26/12/2023 19:28

No it doesn’t have to be like this, maybe I was lucky but my child, fell asleep where she when she was tired. Whenever she wanted, within reason, didn’t hold anyone to her nap and food time. She absolutely did go with the flow. Could take her anywhere to any family gathering and she just slotted in absolutely fine

Hayliebells · 26/12/2023 19:28

With the contact napping thing, it very much depends on the child. You can't train every baby/toddler to fall asleep on their own, some will do that, some won't. Proponents of baby gurus like Gina Ford think you can train a baby to do that by leaving them to cry it out, but we now know more about child development and how that can be harmful, so most people don't choose to do that sort of thing anymore. If you have a chronic health condition, do you have a plan incase you have a baby that won't sleep or nap very easily, or for very long? Do you have access to a lot of support? You can't guarantee you won't get a poor sleeper by any means that you have any control over. It's just luck if you get a good one.

Pookerrod · 26/12/2023 19:23

Don’t let this out you off, you are not seeing normal life. Large family gatherings are often overwhelming for babies and very small children. Lots of noise, attention, people they don’t know. It makes them over tired and clingy. This in turn stresses out the parents who just desperately want them to go to sleep so they can relax.

I doubt every day life in their homes is like this.

Southlondoner88 · 26/12/2023 19:22

@Switchingoff are your dp’s family very middle class, sensitive types? I grew up working class, different country and this s* would not have been tolerated in my culture. Not saying this is right but just an observation. Most mumsnetters are quite middle class and are into the gentle parenting thing so you will be getting skewed answers here. Maybe your friends and family are more relaxed so prob why you’re confused, I certainly was when I moved to middle class part of london to be a nanny. It was a shock but I see the positives and negatives to both cultures now.

newtimesagain · 26/12/2023 19:22

All the money in the world would not get me to have a child.
Ive seen enough with my sisters and read enough on MN it gets worse as their teens.
Its true you have no life when you are a parent.
I dont hush and hum when i see a baby i think thank god its not mine.

My sister is in her 40s with a 2 year old plus teens no thank you.
My other sister is in the middle of the teen years with both daughters omg its hell.
Im free and its staying that way.
And they all no do not ask me to baby sit im very blunt you had them you look after them.
I wont even date a man that has children. (i dont date for record love single life)
Going back under my rock now.

Arabellla · 26/12/2023 19:20

Thepeopleversuswork · 26/12/2023 19:11

The thing is OP that people vastly overstate the degree of control they have over their offspring. I don’t think you’re being unreasonable finding this tedious but you are being judgemental in implying that parents can control it.

As a pre-parent it’s very easy to say: “I will be a chilled parent” and “I won’t organise my life in such a way that it disrupts other adults lives just because I have a kid”. But actually your child may or may not go along with this.

So the parent who insists on having the room their child is sleeping in completely silent or dark may be being controlling but much more likely they are just sleep deprived and exhausted and desperately want a bit of downtime.

Yes it’s fucking annoying to be around but the onus is on you to choose not to put yourself in the middle of the situation. A parent of a toddler is basically trying to survive one of the most intense and demanding situations in their life. Your comfort levels are nowhere near being their priority.

They they should stay home instead of inflicting silence and darkness on other people. Not sure why you think OP should care about their comfort if they don’t care about hers.

margotrose · 26/12/2023 19:20

I’m asking if it’s ALWAYS (or nearly) like this

When you have four small children from different households in different routines then yes, it will be like this. Young children are exhausting and take up practically all of your time and energy.

That's why I don't have any Grin

TeaGinandFags · 26/12/2023 19:19

charliecoopershair · 26/12/2023 18:05

🤣🤣🤣

This.

Buckle up, OP. You're about to have a bumpy ride. Welcome to motherhood.

Switchingoff · 26/12/2023 19:18

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 26/12/2023 19:11

I do have to add, when mine were little, I wouldn’t make everything silent and dark in order for them to sleep. But equally you do expect some “give” in the usual adult order of things to accommodate small children - such as reasonable meal times, a bit of shh late at night etc

With meals it was so parents who contact nap could be there for example.

so 4 different mealtimes / meals 3 times a day for the kids, plus the adult meals.

4 different nap schedules, bath and bedtimes

barely any slots in the day available!

one parent got annoyed we started some presents while they were doing an hour long bedtime. But the next kid was half an hour off bedtime and has a parent stay with them once they go to bed. Another had just come back from the other side of the family and needed dinner. Etc etc

Once again, jeez, I’m not having a go. I’m asking if it’s ALWAYS (or nearly) like this

and this contact napping, going to bed with the kid or putting them to bed etc is normal for them not just a Christmas / change of location thing

I also have a chronic illness so have less energy than most which is another reason why I’m asking whether it’s realistic to hope! Thanks to the few of you who have given constructive and helpful responses. The rest of you, no need to be so rude 🙄

OP posts:
margotrose · 26/12/2023 19:17

Since when did EVERYTHING revolve round the kids

They're babies and toddlers. Of course everything is going to revolve around them!

Strictlymad · 26/12/2023 19:14

They are all babies basically, 1 baby easy to work round but yes 4 together is going to seem like the whole world revolves around babies, which it does! As long as you don’t have quads op you will be fine

Thepeopleversuswork · 26/12/2023 19:11

The thing is OP that people vastly overstate the degree of control they have over their offspring. I don’t think you’re being unreasonable finding this tedious but you are being judgemental in implying that parents can control it.

As a pre-parent it’s very easy to say: “I will be a chilled parent” and “I won’t organise my life in such a way that it disrupts other adults lives just because I have a kid”. But actually your child may or may not go along with this.

So the parent who insists on having the room their child is sleeping in completely silent or dark may be being controlling but much more likely they are just sleep deprived and exhausted and desperately want a bit of downtime.

Yes it’s fucking annoying to be around but the onus is on you to choose not to put yourself in the middle of the situation. A parent of a toddler is basically trying to survive one of the most intense and demanding situations in their life. Your comfort levels are nowhere near being their priority.

Simonjt · 26/12/2023 19:11

I once made our son a pikachu pancake at about 3am when he was four, we were on holiday and he said if I made him one he’d be able to sleep. He’d had a crap night sleep every night of the holiday, if he had suggested I skin myself alive to help him sleep I would have happily done it.

Our two year old is going through a shit sleep phase, on the rare occasion she falls asleep in her bed without one of us laid in it, we have to silently army crawl out of her room in the hopes she doesn’t notice. If she notices you’re in a world of pain as then she’ll only sleep if she is laid on you.

Children have never been resilient by the way, it has just been traditional to ignore the needs of children as its more convenient for the adults.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 26/12/2023 19:11

I do have to add, when mine were little, I wouldn’t make everything silent and dark in order for them to sleep. But equally you do expect some “give” in the usual adult order of things to accommodate small children - such as reasonable meal times, a bit of shh late at night etc

Switchingoff · 26/12/2023 19:10

GreySantaRabbit · 26/12/2023 19:09

Aw, Bless your heart @Switchingoff

don't fall into the "my child will..." trap.

Because your child won't 😁😂

When did I ever say this?!

OP posts:
GreySantaRabbit · 26/12/2023 19:09

Aw, Bless your heart @Switchingoff

don't fall into the "my child will..." trap.

Because your child won't 😁😂

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 26/12/2023 19:08

I have a 2 year old. She's a bit out of routine. But not a single member of the family expects her to be able to sit through a 3 course meal at the table. No one expects her to skip a nap, because Christmas. Naps are important at this age because it stops them being utter monsters due to being exhausted. They can't go all day, it's physically impossible for them. No one expects a 2 year old to eat a full dinner. She did, however, eat some elements of it and request "more gravy".

If she was 4 or 5 then the expectations would be different. 4 kids under 3, I presume with at least 2 different sets of parents if not more, will have different needs and routines. And the parents will always want them to be as close as possible to normal to prevent being up ALL NIGHT following a crazy day.

Everyone thinks they can do it differently. But the reality is, when you have small children, life revolves around them because it has to.

Lifeasiknowitisout · 26/12/2023 19:08

Switchingoff · 26/12/2023 18:59

God, such abuse.
as stated it was a genuine question.

to clear a few things up:
it wasn’t judgmental and I wasn’t saying mine would be any better. Hence the q about whether it HAS to be like this ie can I hope it might be better?!
I have friends who aren’t like this with their kids and wondered if it was the exception or the rule.
and yes I am one of the oldest of my generation in my large family so I do remember what it was like when we were KIDS! I didn’t say when we were all toddlers but yes I was still a child when others were toddlers.
AND none of these kids understand Christmas btw.

They don’t need to understand Christmas to be swept up in the excitement and notice things at different.

You remember your relatives as toddlers through the lenses of a child. I don’t particularly remember my cousin being a pain in the arse at Christmas. But everyone who was an adult does and this was in the 90s. I am sure they have a better recollection that I do.

Of course it can be better. You may get an easy baby or because the kids are older by the time you have one, yours may not be impacted as much

I was very much ‘let them sleep on the sofa and put them upstairs when they are asleep when we had big christmass. But that’s as the easiest way to get mine to sleep. Both mine preferred noise to sleep.

But that doesn’t mean they were good sleepers or stayed asleep even when they were at home. Hence tired stressed tetchy parents.

The point is no one brings their kids up think ‘how can I make sure we are the biggest pains in the arse’ they are likely just trying to get through Christmas and relax.

and for what it’s worth, I know plenty of adults who whose parents were laid back and the kids fitted around them. It doesn’t guarantee great outcomes.

Kwasi · 26/12/2023 19:07

HettyMeg · 26/12/2023 19:00

This reminds me of before I had kids and said I would never allow screen time or any processed food 🤣

😂😂😂
True story!