Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if you’re a parent with kids on loud devices in public what’s your reasoning?

338 replies

AMuser · 26/12/2023 16:28

…just can not quite fathom it?

This afternoon in a beautiful 5 star hotel. A quiet lounge room with various family groups and so on. Suddenly aware of the awful referred noise of a kid watching his phone on full volume. He was aged about 8 or 9 and sitting with his parents - quite some way away from me (to show how loud it was).

Waited awhile to see if it would stop. It didn’t. So went over asked politely could they please put the child’s phone on silent. Seemingly decent woman immediately goes on the attack “why should he”. Well you’re in a public place and it’s rude. “Who says” was her response. I mean, if you don’t realise that what hope is there.

I’ve got 4 older kids who did have iPads etc at a certain point. But always with headphones or on silent. Newsflash they will still stare at it regardless

Rather lovely young Dad seated much closer to them came over and thanked me. Said he’d wanted to say something as it was so grating but his wife had asked him not to.

So if you do this - what is your reasoning? Why is this ok?

YABU - my child (or indeed my own) need to listen to tik tok / you tube / Cocomelon etc trumps anyone else in a public place that might not want to hear our devices.

YANBU - and we must rise up in the most unBritish fashion to challenge this insanity & establish order once more and let people know they need to get headphones or go home to blast their phones in public

OP posts:
Qwerty556 · 27/12/2023 19:04

comingintomyown · 27/12/2023 18:24

On a train I recently turned around and asked a young lad with his mum if by any chance he had some headphones with him in a super quiet calm voice. The mum then loudly says “I’m so sorry xxxx that that adult was so rude to you and you had to go through that “
YANBU public noise from any device except the sound of it ringing is totally out of order

If the Germans ever fancy a 3rd go at us, all they need to do is wait until this generation is 20.

Can you image these kids running up the beaches on DDay? They'd all turn up with a note from their mum saying they can't go as they've lost their inhaler.

AMuser · 27/12/2023 18:57

In summary tho we are at 98% so pretty much in agreement!

But it’s the silent sufferers we need to join in and as a PP way up thread says - with a massive smile and lots of eye contact - make sure we address each and every intrusive incident. With of course the proviso that there may be some cases of neurodiversity that require extra consideration if there really is no tolerance to headphones or no volume!

And of course to adults who are much bigger offenders on their own (and responsible for the children they are sitting with )

OP posts:
AMuser · 27/12/2023 18:50

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 27/12/2023 09:50

Parents do this because they're trying to stop their children from (god forbid apparently) making any noises and spoiling the ambience for those around them (with cat bum faces that believe children should be seen and not heard).

So they're damned if they do, and they're damned if they don't.

Maybe concern yourself with your own life rather than judging parents trying to do their best and then going to the lengths to make a post about it, patting yourself on the back.

Christ. Utterly ridiculous.

I was very much concerning myself with my own life thanks. 😀The day in my life in a lovely hotel that I’d saved all year to stay in. With the general chatter of kids of all ages & family all around me - all of which is lovely and very very different to a the tinny, piercing noises from the phone of a child of good age - I’d say 7 or 8 - and no discernible (and I’m fairly sure she’d have told me if he had) additional needs - not a teeny toddler. Who had two parents right beside him who seemed to think that he has the right to impose that sound all across the room, rather than maybe, what, chat to him.

So no it’s not damned if you do or damned if you don’t. That’s a daft arguement. If he hasn’t had his phone at worst he’d have been a little bit … bored. In my view those parents were not doing “their best”. That’s the mum standing rocking her inconsolable 18 month old with ear ache 6 hours into a 7 hour flight to whom I will always give an understanding smile not a pissed off face. That’s the parent with an overwrought toddler having a melt down in a shoe shop before we’ve alll been there.

I had 3 under 5, once of whom is ND - and I largely parented them alone. Was always aware of where we were, what level of noise they were making and certainly any time they had screens they were on silent or they had headphones. The words “other people are having their meals / on the train and don’t want to listen to X” were said often. Really not rocket science.

OP posts:
TheaBrandt · 27/12/2023 18:41

Dear god who would be a teacher dealing with the progeny of twats like this.

greengreengrass25 · 27/12/2023 18:28

comingintomyown · 27/12/2023 18:24

On a train I recently turned around and asked a young lad with his mum if by any chance he had some headphones with him in a super quiet calm voice. The mum then loudly says “I’m so sorry xxxx that that adult was so rude to you and you had to go through that “
YANBU public noise from any device except the sound of it ringing is totally out of order

It's unbelievable and not teaching him to be resilient

The world doesn't revolve around him

Clingfilm · 27/12/2023 18:25

High five OP, I have done the same in the past and will continue to do so in future. My polite British awkwardness seems to be cancelled out by inconsiderate behaviour so I have no issues confronting people, be that loud kids' tablets or that perennial favourite, someone taking up a seat with their bag.

comingintomyown · 27/12/2023 18:24

On a train I recently turned around and asked a young lad with his mum if by any chance he had some headphones with him in a super quiet calm voice. The mum then loudly says “I’m so sorry xxxx that that adult was so rude to you and you had to go through that “
YANBU public noise from any device except the sound of it ringing is totally out of order

TodayForTomorrow · 27/12/2023 18:23

It's not ok at all.

I have a 3yo and 6yo with ants in their pants and eating out with them has always made me very paranoid about judgement from other people.

I've overcompensated really but I have a specific back pack full of colouring books, nicer-than-usual pens and pencils, magic painting, dot to dots, sticker books etc. I keep it topped up with new stuff to keep it novel.

As an absolute last resort I've got a few kids puzzle apps on my phone that don't require any sound. If all else failed, I'd rather give them that than have them disturb people, but I've rarely had to use them.

They both actually sit well now and aren't phased by it. The last time we went was really easy.

Qwerty556 · 27/12/2023 18:15

Pinkdressinggownbelt · 27/12/2023 08:29

i mean, you could put your hearing aids on….

I wear hearing aids.

Just so you know, hearing aids amplify harsh electronic noises much more than speech. Clear speech in background noise is the holy grail of hearing aids and no manufacturer has cracked it.

A tablet near me playing beeps and music causes severe problems for me hearing speech.

So:
a) your sarcasm about turning on hearing aids is a bit of a shitty thing to say.

b) what about my needs? I suppose I don't matter.

I don't inflict my deafness on other people, so I object to other people claiming a right inflict their special needs upon me. Especially as their actions significantly impact on my ability to interact with my friends and relatives.

Cubic · 27/12/2023 18:02

I think what is classed as acceptable behaviour will change and evolve with technology and what is classed as normal.

I do think it is unreasonable and have voted that way.

My eldest child was raised in a way that this would not be acceptable at all and he doesn't even have his mobile atthe table.

My youngest has used an ipad with an app on for his communication. He presses a button and it verbalises for him, there is no way in the world I would ever mute this or turn it down. It would be the equivalent of gagging him (taking away his voice). Due to his level of understanding and because of this it means his non communication ipad (the other ipad is only used for communication, one app and nothing else) we struggle to keep the volume down on any other device - he doesn't understand the difference. This doesn't mean we don't try and we have enforced headphones in some situations (planes) but this doesn't always transfer to other situations.

I will not even try in some situations if there are others using devices as he wouldn't understand why he should and others don't.

I do believe societal norms are changing and devices will become the normal.

FestiveFruitloop · 27/12/2023 18:01

ThoughtYouKnew · 27/12/2023 13:41

Having it on loud is unreasonable but having it on quietly wouldn’t bother me at all. To me, if it’s on quietly, it’s no different to everyone around me having conversations and all the other background noise in life.

Unless it’s not allowed where you are, you just have to deal with it. Cafes, pubs, hotels etc seem to allow people to do it as long as it’s quiet so unless that changes, it’s ok.

People have different definitions of 'quietly' though.
And, in response to a pp, some parents do do this because they can't be arsed to interact with their kids.

MimiGC · 27/12/2023 17:06

Eventually, yes. He was drunk and fairly belligerent, so I think they were a bit afraid of him. Plus, they were absolutely run off their feet, so barely had time to deal with his nonsense. It was 3 o'clock in the morning, by the way !

greengreengrass25 · 27/12/2023 16:40

MimiGC · 27/12/2023 15:52

Parents, please teach your children not to play their devices out loud in public. Otherwise they might grow into the oafish young man who was playing loud music on his phone in A&E. After having waited 12 hours to be admitted, my nerves were in shreds anyway. The waiting room was full of the sick and elderly. I don't know what was wrong with him or why he was there and I don't care. He was an ignorant pig , who could not have cared less about anyone else.

That's so awful

Did the staff not tell him to be quiet

FourLeggedBuckers · 27/12/2023 16:22

No, @Thepeopleversuswork, that’s your inference, not my implication. Parenting children doesn’t mean never allowing them screens. It means setting appropriate limits on their use, including supervising their use and ensuring they aren’t a nuisance to other people in public places. That includes enforcing subtitles / silent mode in public if the kid won’t wear headphones or hasn’t got them to hand. It’s your inference that parenting your child means not allowing them to use a screen in a public space at any point.

Thepeopleversuswork · 27/12/2023 16:10

@FourLeggedBuckers

Needing a break is not an excuse to let your kid do whatever it wants - whether that’s running around in an unsafe place or listening to a tablet out loud in a cafe. It’s also not an excuse never to teach a child how to behave appropriately in a restaurant without a screen, if it’s capable of doing so. That’s setting your kid up to fail as an adult.

I absolutely agree that kids should be taught that they can't demand a screen every time they're in a restaurant. I'm pretty hardline about this with my own DD.

But you say in your post that if people don't want to parent their children "they shouldn't have had them", which, in the context of this thread, clearly implies that anyone who allows their child to watch a screen in a public setting is not up to the job of parenting. Which in my view is a wild over-reaction.

There's two separate questions being explored here which need to be kept separate: whether its acceptable to allow children to consume content in public spaces with the sound up (in my view the answer is always a hard no) and whether it's acceptable to allow children to consume content in public spaces with headphones in.

I think arguing that anyone who ever allows their children access to a screen in a discreet and non-disruptive way is a bad parent (which is what your post implies) is quite a stretch.

MimiGC · 27/12/2023 15:52

Parents, please teach your children not to play their devices out loud in public. Otherwise they might grow into the oafish young man who was playing loud music on his phone in A&E. After having waited 12 hours to be admitted, my nerves were in shreds anyway. The waiting room was full of the sick and elderly. I don't know what was wrong with him or why he was there and I don't care. He was an ignorant pig , who could not have cared less about anyone else.

FourLeggedBuckers · 27/12/2023 15:29

Thepeopleversuswork · 27/12/2023 13:52

If parents don’t want to parent their kids, they shouldn’t have had them. That is the worst excuse on the thread. Having kids is a privilege, not a right, and fobbing them off with a tablet because you don’t want to parent your own kids is really appalling.

Parents don't have to be "parenting" 24/7/365. "Parenting" (and I dislike the verb intensely precisely because it lends itself to this helicopter tendency) doesn't require you to have 100% constant oversight of your little darlings. You don't have to be hovering around them at every second, constantly engaged in conversation and jumping to anticipate their every whim: that's bad for all concerned.

Everyone is entitled to downtime, to time in another room and to have an adult conversation from time to time as long as their kids are supervised and happy.

I wouldn't judge anyone having a nice Sunday lunch or a coffee who quietly gave their kid an iPad for half an hour so they could talk to their spouse uninterrupted. I would judge someone hard who did so and didn't give their kid headphones with which to do this.

Nothing wrong with adults occasionally and appropriately wanting adult time. There's everything wrong with imposing your kid's irritating content on others because you wish to do so.

If a parent needs downtime for themselves, they need to pick an appropriate venue for that. You can’t just opt out of parenting your own kid in a public place. That’s what a child-proofed space in your home is for, or another appropriate area - not a cafe or restaurant.

There is a hell of a lot of projection in your post - I didn’t suggest kids should be hovered over 24 hours a day, because that’s daft. I also didn’t suggest that a parent occasionally using a screen appropriately (on silent or with headphones), while supervising the child, isn’t doing fine.

Needing a break is not an excuse to let your kid do whatever it wants - whether that’s running around in an unsafe place or listening to a tablet out loud in a cafe. It’s also not an excuse never to teach a child how to behave appropriately in a restaurant without a screen, if it’s capable of doing so. That’s setting your kid up to fail as an adult.

salsmum · 27/12/2023 15:06

Same on buses adults having loud phone conversations or kids/teens with full volume up just WHY??? 🤬

Thepeopleversuswork · 27/12/2023 13:52

If parents don’t want to parent their kids, they shouldn’t have had them. That is the worst excuse on the thread. Having kids is a privilege, not a right, and fobbing them off with a tablet because you don’t want to parent your own kids is really appalling.

Parents don't have to be "parenting" 24/7/365. "Parenting" (and I dislike the verb intensely precisely because it lends itself to this helicopter tendency) doesn't require you to have 100% constant oversight of your little darlings. You don't have to be hovering around them at every second, constantly engaged in conversation and jumping to anticipate their every whim: that's bad for all concerned.

Everyone is entitled to downtime, to time in another room and to have an adult conversation from time to time as long as their kids are supervised and happy.

I wouldn't judge anyone having a nice Sunday lunch or a coffee who quietly gave their kid an iPad for half an hour so they could talk to their spouse uninterrupted. I would judge someone hard who did so and didn't give their kid headphones with which to do this.

Nothing wrong with adults occasionally and appropriately wanting adult time. There's everything wrong with imposing your kid's irritating content on others because you wish to do so.

ThoughtYouKnew · 27/12/2023 13:41

Having it on loud is unreasonable but having it on quietly wouldn’t bother me at all. To me, if it’s on quietly, it’s no different to everyone around me having conversations and all the other background noise in life.

Unless it’s not allowed where you are, you just have to deal with it. Cafes, pubs, hotels etc seem to allow people to do it as long as it’s quiet so unless that changes, it’s ok.

TheaBrandt · 27/12/2023 13:15

No one should be listening to anything out loud without headphones in public in an enclosed space end of. I suspect in a few years this will be properly enforced and universally accepted as anti social behaviour and there will be notices etc. like banning smoking inside. It’s obviously fucking annoying to all other service users whoever is doing it and there is absolutely zero excuse or justification especially as headphones are now so cheap and easily available.

We were in a restaurant in France and an elderly French couple at the next table both had eyes glued to their blaring iPad throughout the whole meal. Even our teens were horrified.

FestiveFruitloop · 27/12/2023 12:59

If parents don’t want to parent their kids, they shouldn’t have had them. That is the worst excuse on the thread. Having kids is a privilege, not a right, and fobbing them off with a tablet because you don’t want to parent your own kids is really appalling.

Exactly this.

rookiemere · 27/12/2023 12:52

If it's not noisy then I haven't got an issue, but anyone of any age playing sound from an electronic device in a public place, needs to have the volume low so it doesn't disturb others.

We were on holiday in the summer in Jersey. Harassed woman gets on bus with DD in a pushchair. She gives an iPad to the DD to watch something. Shouldn't have been an issue except the volume was so loud I could hear all the words and I was right at the back - with not amazing hearing- and they were right at the front. Someone said something to her - wasn't nasty as they were both locals - and she did this whole "Well whatever I need to do to keep her entertained, better than annoying the bus with her screaming ". No awareness that the volume was far too high.

It is generally middle aged people that are the worst offenders. On recent train trip I was subjected to episodes of a loud and sweary tv show from a couple a few rows up, they looked too scary for me to confront them and the ticket collector didn't say a word to them about it.

Thepeopleversuswork · 27/12/2023 12:42

Lottapianos · 27/12/2023 12:24

'So when they go to a place like a coffee shop they want to relax for a few minutes and spend time together, not parent their kids.'

Most honest answer I've seen. Parents allow their kids to watch screens with no headphones / run around the place / scream their heads off in public because THEY JUST CAN'T BE ARSED with actually parenting them and think it's fine for that to be everyone else's problem

But even this is sort of understandable. I can't blame a ragged parent with two toddlers for wanting an uninterrupted hour to drink a coffee/beer. Fair enough to give them an iPad for a bit.

But why in God's name would you do that without headphones?

Lottapianos · 27/12/2023 12:24

'So when they go to a place like a coffee shop they want to relax for a few minutes and spend time together, not parent their kids.'

Most honest answer I've seen. Parents allow their kids to watch screens with no headphones / run around the place / scream their heads off in public because THEY JUST CAN'T BE ARSED with actually parenting them and think it's fine for that to be everyone else's problem

Swipe left for the next trending thread