Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if you’re a parent with kids on loud devices in public what’s your reasoning?

338 replies

AMuser · 26/12/2023 16:28

…just can not quite fathom it?

This afternoon in a beautiful 5 star hotel. A quiet lounge room with various family groups and so on. Suddenly aware of the awful referred noise of a kid watching his phone on full volume. He was aged about 8 or 9 and sitting with his parents - quite some way away from me (to show how loud it was).

Waited awhile to see if it would stop. It didn’t. So went over asked politely could they please put the child’s phone on silent. Seemingly decent woman immediately goes on the attack “why should he”. Well you’re in a public place and it’s rude. “Who says” was her response. I mean, if you don’t realise that what hope is there.

I’ve got 4 older kids who did have iPads etc at a certain point. But always with headphones or on silent. Newsflash they will still stare at it regardless

Rather lovely young Dad seated much closer to them came over and thanked me. Said he’d wanted to say something as it was so grating but his wife had asked him not to.

So if you do this - what is your reasoning? Why is this ok?

YABU - my child (or indeed my own) need to listen to tik tok / you tube / Cocomelon etc trumps anyone else in a public place that might not want to hear our devices.

YANBU - and we must rise up in the most unBritish fashion to challenge this insanity & establish order once more and let people know they need to get headphones or go home to blast their phones in public

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ChrisPackhamsYellowFleece · 30/12/2023 19:54

@HolyFuckingNight But what about social conventions about what's acceptable and what isn't? Why is it up to restaurant staff to enforce basic manners? If your kids won't headphones, they either behave politely without electronic distraction or you don't take them to a restaurant. This should be really basic stuff, but according to this thread it isn't.

HolyFuckingNight · 30/12/2023 13:10

@InAMess2023 Because if the place like the cafe allows it, as it’s not illegal, they get to decide what they class as acceptable for their business. The company/owners get to decide and as customers we get to vote with our feet. You don’t get to decide. There’s lots of things I may not like, I don’t get to control others. I can campaign and petition for things I’d like to happen/not happen but until it changes I have to accept that that is just how things are.

InAMess2023 · 30/12/2023 12:52

@HolyFuckingNight can you please tell me why, in spaces designed for adults, eg cafes, nice restaurants etc. that anyone should have to put up with tinny, squeaking, beeping noises, etc. let alone someone like me who would find these sounds actually physically painful? Just because it's 'allowed' doesn't make it acceptable. I'm very glad to see that your views appear to be in the minority here

HolyFuckingNight · 30/12/2023 12:49

Just because something is 'allowed' aka not specifically banned, doesn't mean that it should just be accepted. It's not illegal to talk very loudly all the way through a film at the cinema but I'm damn sure most people wouldn't put up with it.

But cinemas would have an issue with that, at least our local one does. I’ve seen them remove a group of teens for making noise when the film is on. You’re also told to turn off phones in cinemas I use (cineworld), there are adverts about it before the film. I’m not talking about it being illegal, it’s whether the place you are in allows it.

If it’s in a place that allows it to be on quietly, like a cafe where people chat, it is allowed and therefore fine. If they stop allowing it, then it’s not fine. That’s just how it is.

LaurieStrode · 29/12/2023 01:22

Agree, @XenoBitch

That rhetoric shocked me. The poor DH.

XenoBitch · 28/12/2023 22:56

BitOfChocolate · 28/12/2023 04:41

Absolutely right. Not getting into a debate about what 'quietly' means. It's either on silent, through headphones or OFF

Like my husband with his jazz music.

Me : "Turn that fucking row off will you?"

He "I'll turn it down"

Me: " No, that doesn't work for me. Quieter is not less annoying"

He: " But surely you can hardly hear it now"

Me : " But I can still hear it. Just turn it off please."

He loves it so he cannot understand that it puts all my nerves on jangle.
I hate it. It's unmusical It is not music. It is just a disjointed unwanted noise.

He says he finds it relaxing

How!!? Why!?

It's a cacophony of disjointed sounds to me. How anyone can listen to jazz music and actually enjoy it is a mystery.

So my point is that jus because you turn it down doesn't make it less annoying. It can actually make it a lot more annoying. because it's still bloody there despite your plea for it to stop.

Likewise electronic gadgets in public places.

Parents have managed their children for preceding millenia without gadgets to keep them quiet. We went out as a family 50 years ago. We varied in age from 3 to 16. It was not even a thing then, to expect that a small child would kick
up a fuss.

We just behaved courteously. Normally. And the kids did too. They followed the lead of their parents. But apparently nowadays ,following the lead of your parents is going to make you an entitled jobless loser.

TBH, that sounds like a clash in musical tastes to me. If someone posted in AIBU that her DH was telling her that listening to Jazz was offensive to his ears and he was talking to her like you are to your DH, the overwhelming replies would be to LTB.

FestiveFruitloop · 28/12/2023 14:35

What I don't get is that many games have an option to turn off the music and sfx, but so many kids (and adults) never do. I get that it's part of the experience, but surely it wouldn't kill people to mute them when playing in public out of courtesy?

AMuser · 28/12/2023 10:51

Qwerty556 · 28/12/2023 01:12

I'm sure there are a tiny percentage of children whose needs are so severe that they need some level of sound and cannot wear headphones. However the vast majority of times kids have volume on in public it's because they have a useless parent who is either so selfish they don't care about others or is so stupid they have no idea how rude they are being.

Exactly this!!!

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 28/12/2023 07:22

fitzwilliamdarcy · 27/12/2023 11:40

2. Life is more busy. Houses cost two salaries. The cost of living is high. People have to work more. Most families have two working parents. So when they go to a place like a coffee shop they want to relax for a few minutes and spend time together, not parent their kids.

Then they need to go to an appropriate venue where them choosing not to parent doesn’t impact other people. They can’t just go to a coffee shop (a place which can actually be dangerous for young kids because hot drinks are carried) and then say “this is my me-time, I don’t want to parent right now and that’s ok!”

It’s not ok.

Anyone else remember Planet Kids in Bristol? If anywhere was an appropriate venue, this was.

BitOfChocolate · 28/12/2023 04:41

Absolutely right. Not getting into a debate about what 'quietly' means. It's either on silent, through headphones or OFF

Like my husband with his jazz music.

Me : "Turn that fucking row off will you?"

He "I'll turn it down"

Me: " No, that doesn't work for me. Quieter is not less annoying"

He: " But surely you can hardly hear it now"

Me : " But I can still hear it. Just turn it off please."

He loves it so he cannot understand that it puts all my nerves on jangle.
I hate it. It's unmusical It is not music. It is just a disjointed unwanted noise.

He says he finds it relaxing

How!!? Why!?

It's a cacophony of disjointed sounds to me. How anyone can listen to jazz music and actually enjoy it is a mystery.

So my point is that jus because you turn it down doesn't make it less annoying. It can actually make it a lot more annoying. because it's still bloody there despite your plea for it to stop.

Likewise electronic gadgets in public places.

Parents have managed their children for preceding millenia without gadgets to keep them quiet. We went out as a family 50 years ago. We varied in age from 3 to 16. It was not even a thing then, to expect that a small child would kick
up a fuss.

We just behaved courteously. Normally. And the kids did too. They followed the lead of their parents. But apparently nowadays ,following the lead of your parents is going to make you an entitled jobless loser.

mantyzer · 28/12/2023 03:30

I think there will be a backlash. I think in 20 years time we will have a significant cohort of parents who think devices should be avoided at all costs except for school work. Because this swing is what tends to happen in fashions.
And MN will be full of young mums arguing devices for young children is child abuse and their parents never talked to them, just handed them a device. Again I see this kind of exaggeration on MN currently with past parenting fashions.

BitOfChocolate · 28/12/2023 03:29

I’ve voted YANBU because of it being loud but I do think YABU about expecting it to be on silent.

But even if it's on quiet it's bleepy and annoying. Some have sensitive hearing.
My hearing is shit, by the way, but I can hear a bleepy computer game 10 seats away on the bus. It makes me ragey, Just shut the fucking fuck up, is what I think. But of course I don't say it.

BitOfChocolate · 28/12/2023 03:14

I do believe societal norms are changing and devices will become the normal

That will never happen. Devices are not normal

BitOfChocolate · 28/12/2023 03:07

*I think arguing that anyone who ever allows their children access to a screen in a discreet and non-disruptive way is a bad parent (which is what your post implies) is quite a stretch

Nobody but nobody has said that. If it works for you and yours then you have to do it. It makes you a good parent in fact.

I'm the mother of a daughter with severe LD, I use a screen whenever I can, to keep my daughter occupied in waiting rooms and wherever we have to go..

But I would never, ever, in a million years think it was ok to have the SOUND on.
It's just so rude and disruptive. Nobody else wants to hear it and neither should they be forced to listen to it. As disabled as she is, non verbal and has no idea of where she is and why, she has become accepting that there are certain situations where it just happens that the cartoons on the phone or tablet don't have a soundtrack.

It's quite a hard road to get there, but I've had 40 years to finesse it.
I'm still looking after her. And trust me folks. If you want to get over the really hard bits, you have to be very firm.

It's really dead easy to set the rule that we don't do noisy stuff on the bus or the train. It might be hard for the first 10 years, but it will eventually bear fruit

Most folks here, I imagine, have pretty normal kids

So they'll be much easier to teach all this normal stuff to.

Except, apparently, and in my experience, they don't seem to teach
their kids anything beyond their "rights"

Along with rights, come a lot of responsibilities. You cannot have
one without the other,

You very lucky people, who have normal kids, do them a massive favour, and bring then up to be nice people. Some responses on mumsnet make me aware that not everyone is nice person.

"Noise of gadgets on trains doesn't bother me so neither should it bother anybody else" So that's it, for them.

BitOfChocolate · 28/12/2023 02:00

anyone of any age playing sound from an electronic device in a public place, needs to have the volume low so it doesn't disturb others

An electronic device is always audible to others in the room. No matter how low the sound is. It is piercing and the bleeps and jingles are perceptible and very annoying to others.

It can be 15 or 20 decibels, which is very low conversational noise ant not at all intrusive. But when it's an electronic device it is screechy and tinny and bleepy, and not in any way a normal background noise.

Honestly, you chaps (parents) who imagine that we would rather hear the tinny cacophony of multiple devices while we eat our dinner are sadly misguided.

What we would like to see, and we would happily put up with the fallout,
is parents actively teaching their chldren how to behave in a restaurant.
I love seeing kids in eating places. I have to drag up my experiences in the European continent. Kids are there from 8pm till 11pm sometimes.

They are a joy. They have loads of fun and play together. They create loads of fun and it's joyful to watch. They do not need electronic devices.

In the UK, kids are always screeching ad crying and shouting NO!
I travel widely, and i don't see this anywhere else.

What is it with British people, who seem utterly incapable of teaching their children anything at all.

LaurieStrode · 28/12/2023 01:38

Qwerty556 · 28/12/2023 01:12

I'm sure there are a tiny percentage of children whose needs are so severe that they need some level of sound and cannot wear headphones. However the vast majority of times kids have volume on in public it's because they have a useless parent who is either so selfish they don't care about others or is so stupid they have no idea how rude they are being.

This x1000.

We traveled frequently by plane, rail and auto as kids and portable screens didn't exist then.

Guess what? We amused ourselves by viewing the scenery or conversation with our parents. Imagine that!!

We were quiet, composed, well-behaved and capable of being calm and competent from a young age because we had parents who talked with us, taught us manners, fostered curiosity plus situational awareness, taught us how to actually be resourceful and content with our own thoughts, and to manage boredom.

They didn't try to squelch us into little zombies incapable of coping without a steady stream of passive entertainment.

JamSandle · 28/12/2023 01:37

It's incredibly rude and antisocial and encourages children to grow into adults who have no awareness of the thoughts and feelings of others.

XenoBitch · 28/12/2023 01:19

fitzwilliamdarcy · 27/12/2023 22:03

MN doesn’t care about ND adults or adults with disabilities.

I’ve posted on many threads like this where parents have accused everyone of not caring about disability and wanting to confine parents to their homes. I’ve pointed out that my ND means that I have to stay inside as I can’t reliably use public spaces due to the endemic of parenting with screens.

It’s always been crickets. They don’t care.

Same.
My DP is autistic, and struggles with sounds such as screeching kids and IPads.
When I say struggle, I don't mean he does not like it and can laugh it off. He goes in to full meltdown, and his meltdowns are shouting and lashing out.

Screens and the associated sounds are just plain antisocial.

Qwerty556 · 28/12/2023 01:12

I'm sure there are a tiny percentage of children whose needs are so severe that they need some level of sound and cannot wear headphones. However the vast majority of times kids have volume on in public it's because they have a useless parent who is either so selfish they don't care about others or is so stupid they have no idea how rude they are being.

DdraigGoch · 27/12/2023 22:44

Benibidibici · 26/12/2023 18:49

Hardly comparable to an old person with failing hearing
Exactly. That’s something that they can’t help.

Well not always actually. I have parent A - has hearing aids and hears well with them in but honest to god fucking can't be arsed, so rudely has phone on speakerphone against their ear the whole time, uncle B who refuses to have a hearing appointment and clearly needs hearing aids, also using speakerphone against ear. Contrast with other parent, C. Sought timely hearing appointment, listened to drs advice & uses bluetooth hearing aids for phone calls. A & B are perfectly capable of using these but basically don't want to be bothered & aren't considering others needs. Its just as bad as putting peppa pig on loud on the ipad for a toddler.

Sounds like Mrs Richards from Fawlty Towers.

Mistressofpemberly · 27/12/2023 22:42

Yanbu. Literally every day I have to tolerate adults who do it on trains. It is bizarre. And rude.
if adults think it’s ok then there is no hope for the kids.

Cubic · 27/12/2023 22:35

bjjgirl · 27/12/2023 22:24

The thing is it's just the complete lack of consideration for others-
I have SN and literally can not keep a conversation going if there's iPad or phone game noises going off near by.

It is not something people should have to endure in a relaxing environment- McDonald's / arcade / soft play- no issue.

Adult spaces - no.

Allow others to exist - just as much as if I felt more comfortable walking around naked - I would not expect it to be accepted in public, nor would aggression etc. it's not just kids though- people face timing on loud speaker also bad

You may have sn but the fact that you are able to argue on social media and hold a conversation that can be interrupted by distraction puts you in a different league to those I'm guessing @Pinkdressinggownbelt referred to. You would not be classed as severe.

Some people (I'm including some adults) have severe needs such that they cannot wear or tolerate headphones. They may use repetitive noise or sounds and movements, flaps, walk up and down, grunt, use echolelia, squeeze or any number of things which generally annoys the public. These people cannot help it, which is why many public places including theatres have have a policy around noise relating to disability. These people may enjoy being in public places and have as much right as anyone else to be there. It may he easier for them (and others) to have a screen with a familiar programme/ credits/ youtube video to stop the other behaviour. Watching a device maybe unsociable but it is more "normal" than some other behaviour...

bjjgirl · 27/12/2023 22:24

Pinkdressinggownbelt · 27/12/2023 19:29

Why all these angry people on MN lol. Potty mouth… 😒
anyway , as I already said above some families with kids with severe learning disabilities who do not tolerate headphones and need music/videos from their tablets are left with no choice. It’s not lazy parenting 🙄 and it is a preferable noise to the other “noises” and behaviours being prevented by the use of tablet/phone believe me. And no we are not going to hide away for anyone else’s convenience. As I said before we don’t go to quiet zones, spas or libraries etc but yes family restaurants, public transport we have to

The thing is it's just the complete lack of consideration for others-
I have SN and literally can not keep a conversation going if there's iPad or phone game noises going off near by.

It is not something people should have to endure in a relaxing environment- McDonald's / arcade / soft play- no issue.

Adult spaces - no.

Allow others to exist - just as much as if I felt more comfortable walking around naked - I would not expect it to be accepted in public, nor would aggression etc. it's not just kids though- people face timing on loud speaker also bad

BrainInAJar · 27/12/2023 22:14

I was sitting next to a teenager waiting for a train last year. No-one else around us. She plays some horrid rap music on loudspeaker. I blasted some 1980s disco remix and smiled at her. She got the message.

Yes, up the revolution!

fitzwilliamdarcy · 27/12/2023 22:03

TigerRag · 27/12/2023 19:38

And again, what about people like me who can't deal with loud noise?

No one on here has ever answered this. It's like we don't matter?

MN doesn’t care about ND adults or adults with disabilities.

I’ve posted on many threads like this where parents have accused everyone of not caring about disability and wanting to confine parents to their homes. I’ve pointed out that my ND means that I have to stay inside as I can’t reliably use public spaces due to the endemic of parenting with screens.

It’s always been crickets. They don’t care.