Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's wrong to make a child wet themself?

95 replies

WoIsMe · 26/12/2023 16:22

A friend's partner was driving on the motorway when their 7yo daughter needed the loo. I don't know how close the nearest service station was or why they couldn't pull over on to the hard shoulder for a wild wee, but the partner told the girl to wee in her car seat, i.e. to deliberately wet herself. My friend found out about it today and is very upset about the incident. I can understand a child having an accident in the car, although maybe not so much at age 7, but it seems very strange to me. So, AIBU to think it's wrong to make a child wet themself in the car?

OP posts:
Wateroverwine · 27/12/2023 01:54

There are services available for this. So horrible to do that to a child.
I agree about not stopping on the hard shoulder though

melj1213 · 27/12/2023 01:20

I don't know how close the nearest service station was or why they couldn't pull over on to the hard shoulder ... but the partner told the girl to wee in her car seat, i.e. to deliberately wet herself.

YABVU - the first sentence is where your AIBU should have stopped because you are knowingly judging a situation, that is 100% contextual, based on zero context which you cannot do fairly as all the relevant information is missing.

YA also VVVVU to suggest stopping on the hard shoulder is in any way, shape or form and acceptable option for anything other than a life or death emergency, which a child needing a wee is not.

There is also a massive difference between:

"Dad, I need a wee!"
<Said just after passing last service station for many miles in heavy motorway traffic>
"We won't get to <destination> for 2hrs and the next services aren't for another 20mins, can you hold it that long?"
"No, I'm desperate!"
"I'm sorry sweetie but there's nowhere safe to stop so you'll have to try and hold it until the services and I'll try and get us there as fast as we can. If you have an accident before we get there then don't worry, I know you're trying your best to hold it but it is a long way so if you can't hold it then it's ok. We can stop and get cleaned up if necessary but we'll try and get there as quick as we can"
Child then wets themselves, driver stops at the next opportunity to get child out of wet clothes/seat and clean up as much as possible asap

Vs

"Dad I need a wee!"
<Said just as sign appears to say the turn off to the next services is in ½ a mile on a journey where there is no time constraints to prevent a toilet stop>
"Well you'll have to hold it because I'm not stopping till we get to <destination>"
"I'm not desperate but I can't wait that long!"
"Well you'll have to try!"
20 mins later, after passing multiple services/rest stops
"Dad, I'm really desperate for a wee now, I can't hold it any more"
"I told you, I'm not stopping until we get to <destination> so you'll just have to hold it for another hour or wee in your seat, either way I'm not stopping!"
Child then wets themselves and is forced to sit in wet clothes/seat for the next hour despite multiple opportunities for the driver to stop and let them get cleaned up

The former situation is perfectly understandable - the driver is in a situation where they cannot stop immediately, they have acknowledged that they know there is a risk of the child having an accident in the car but has reassured the child that they know it's a possibility and they're not going to get mad at them whilst trying to get them to hold on as long as possible so they can find somewhere safe to get off the road. They have also made it clear that they will stop at the next services regardless so that the child can either use the toilet or get cleaned up for the rest of the journey.

The latter situation is totally unacceptable as the driver has multiple opportunities to stop but chooses not to and humiliates the child for no reason other than they don't want to stop the car.

From your OP we cannot ascertain which of these situations you are describing and therefore YABU to ask people to judge the situation out of all context.

Georgeandzippyzoo · 27/12/2023 00:55

When my niece was younger, around 5yrs old, we were on the motorway in a similar situation. Next services were about 15miles away and we had to say that it was OK if she wet herself , we even managed to get a towel under her but she was hysterical. It wasn't a great option but it was the only we had in that situation, we did hope for a junction but none at that point. .
She actually held on until we pulled into the services and had a wee on the grass where we stopped the car, she wasnt getting to the loo in time.

Sugarfree23 · 27/12/2023 00:43

iLovee · 26/12/2023 22:12

I'm not a driver, but why is it so dangerous to stop on the hard shoulder?

1 in 10 motorway accidents involve cars on hardshoulder.

It's not unknown for other drivers to see the lights of a vehicle, become disoriented, laps in concentration, pull over thinking its a slow lane and drive straight into the rear of stationary vehicles. They realise too late the vehicle is stopped, then hit the stationary vehicle.

We have no idea why the driver didn't stop at the services, or pull off at a junction. The answer is probably a combination of factors, little warning, and too far to services.

But we can assume he had some reason, as nobody would want their car stinking of pee, even if they were hoping the carseat would take the brunt of it.

iLovee · 26/12/2023 23:52

KylieJennersMakeUpSponge · 26/12/2023 23:13

A car breaking down as well as an accident - if you watch CCTV videos of motorway crashes, car crash into the sides of the motorway and a child having a wee would be dead in a heartbeat. Also, fast HGVs flying past as you are stood on the hard shoulder is a risk

Aw thanks so much! Makes sense ♥️

porridgeisbae · 26/12/2023 23:51

It is poor planning on any responsible adults' part(s) probably, isn't it? Someone's given the child drinks at the wrong time/too many drinks, rather than planned what the child has around the upcoming journey.

Otherwise, this would happen more often. But people manage to usually make sure it doesn't.

Summerbay23 · 26/12/2023 23:28

the hard shoulder is absolutely not a place for a wee. If you can’t hold on to the next services then you would either need to pull off at junction and wild wee/find facilities or sadly wet yourself, it is never ok to use hard shoulder for wee (unless maybe absolutely stationary traffic jam for over an hour).

KylieJennersMakeUpSponge · 26/12/2023 23:13

iLovee · 26/12/2023 22:17

Oooh thanks! Is that incase someone veers into the hard shoulder or is it just because being stationary on a motorway is a bad idea?

Aw man I feel so dumb 😂

A car breaking down as well as an accident - if you watch CCTV videos of motorway crashes, car crash into the sides of the motorway and a child having a wee would be dead in a heartbeat. Also, fast HGVs flying past as you are stood on the hard shoulder is a risk

KylieJennersMakeUpSponge · 26/12/2023 23:10

Im not sure about some on this thread but on my planet service stations don’t just pop up at random when you need a wee. Sometimes you can wait 50 miles for one.

KylieJennersMakeUpSponge · 26/12/2023 23:09

I would 100% rather have a child wet themselves than stop on the hard shoulder!! FFS that’s for emergencies it’s not a toilet. Even in an emergency you get people off the hard shoulder and leave the car unless you have an actual death wish.

Universalsnail · 26/12/2023 23:03

It's unreasonable to think he should have pulled onto the hard shoulder that is do dangerous, however it's not acceptable to force a child to wee themselves, if he couldn't see a services to stop at he should have come off at the next junction and found a safe place to pull over for a wild wee.

Tacotortoise · 26/12/2023 22:31

Sceptre86 · 26/12/2023 22:15

I'd be angry too. My dd is 7 and she would have tried to hold on for as long as possible. The driver should have stopped at the nearest service station rather than humiliate a 7 year old child.

Yes they should but it may not have been a option. My ds would only announce he needed the loo when he was already fit to burst. If this little girl did likewise then there may not have been much option.

porridgeisbae · 26/12/2023 22:29

Apparently it's on non-motorway roads we would do it in an 'emergency,' not motorways.

iLovee · 26/12/2023 22:17

Saschka · 26/12/2023 22:14

Risk of being hit by other cars, essentially.

Oooh thanks! Is that incase someone veers into the hard shoulder or is it just because being stationary on a motorway is a bad idea?

Aw man I feel so dumb 😂

Sceptre86 · 26/12/2023 22:15

I'd be angry too. My dd is 7 and she would have tried to hold on for as long as possible. The driver should have stopped at the nearest service station rather than humiliate a 7 year old child.

Saschka · 26/12/2023 22:14

iLovee · 26/12/2023 22:12

I'm not a driver, but why is it so dangerous to stop on the hard shoulder?

Risk of being hit by other cars, essentially.

iLovee · 26/12/2023 22:12

I'm not a driver, but why is it so dangerous to stop on the hard shoulder?

Dwappy · 26/12/2023 21:54

porridgeisbae · 26/12/2023 21:35

I don't have kids but I don't know anyone who wouldn't do the stop by the side of the road thing in a wee 'emergency.'

If it's a motorway it's illegal. A wee does not count as an emergency even if you call it a wee emergency.
In the same way my friend got bollocked by the police for stopping due to a vomiting passenger emergency.

Allfur · 26/12/2023 21:51

It's a horrible thing to do

musicforthesoul · 26/12/2023 21:48

You can't possibly judge this unless you know the full context. If he just couldn't be arsed to stop he's in the wrong but there's plenty of other scenarios where he was reasonable.

Hard shoulder is dangerous so that's a no go, depending on which motorway it may not even exist.

Services can be a long way away depending on route, there's a section I drive where there is about 1 hour drive time between the services! Getting off at a random junction to find a spot for a wild wee could take ages if you don't know the area.

Perfectly possible there wasn't anywhere safe to stop in the relevant timeframe.

Sirzy · 26/12/2023 21:40

porridgeisbae · 26/12/2023 21:35

I don't have kids but I don't know anyone who wouldn't do the stop by the side of the road thing in a wee 'emergency.'

I would stop at the side of a normal road if I could safely do so. I would never stop on the hard shoulder of the motorway for a wee stop. It’s dangerous and it’s illegal.

but too many drivers seem to think stopping with your hazard lights on somehow keeps you safe!

porridgeisbae · 26/12/2023 21:35

I don't have kids but I don't know anyone who wouldn't do the stop by the side of the road thing in a wee 'emergency.'

malmi · 26/12/2023 21:24

porridgeisbae · 26/12/2023 20:54

We would always have stopped by the side of the road if we couldn't wait. I never knew of anyone who had deliberate car-peeing instead as an option for them or any passenger. Imagine trying to get it out afterwards.

Risk your kids' lives cos you can't be arsed cleaning the car seat

VisionsOfSplendour · 26/12/2023 21:24

porridgeisbae · 26/12/2023 20:54

We would always have stopped by the side of the road if we couldn't wait. I never knew of anyone who had deliberate car-peeing instead as an option for them or any passenger. Imagine trying to get it out afterwards.

Even on a motorway? That's extremely dangerous, did you really put your children in that situation?

NotARealWookiie · 26/12/2023 21:15

This isn’t really something we can answer without context.