Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Genuine question re: immigration, not trying to be goady!

117 replies

questionsICantAskInRL · 26/12/2023 14:29

This is a genuine question please don’t accuse me of trying to be goady or whatever the hell people say on mumsnet:

my question is countries like USA who literally took over the country from the natives therefore have no right being there, how can they talk about immigrants taking over their jobs, their country etc? Also the UK how can they talk about immigrants etc. when they invaded lots of countries with the British empire and took all the wealth and gems etc and killed thousands of people who opposed them then complain that the same countries try to come over to make their lives better.

thread title edited by MNHQ at OP's request.

OP posts:
Vinrouge4 · 26/12/2023 15:51

Yawn.

Tinselburn · 26/12/2023 15:50

I know right?! The hypocracy seems to be lost on most though.

dooneyousmugelf · 26/12/2023 15:48

Probs because all that was generations ago and nothing to do with them. Their logic is rooted in the here and now. Also, being thick goes some way to explain it.

YouTookMyUsername · 26/12/2023 15:46

Every country has the right to control immigration, even the US. Allowing everyone into your country reduces quality of life for everyone and can change the culture, which people don't like. YABU.

I don't even understand why you're comparing the UK to the USA when we haven't invaded any countries for 100+ years. Are we supposed to all self flagellate forever? See above.

What I do find completely baffling, is white Americans throughout history who have hated indigenous Americans and blacks people who they brought over. That is actually something that doesn't make sense and is indefensible.

Balloonhearts · 26/12/2023 15:45

Mixture of ignorance, stupidity and short memories.

Ponoka7 · 26/12/2023 15:43

I did find it interesting when the stabbings in Dublin happened and the garda commissioner, Drew Harris said that being born in the UK and NI doesn't give you more of a right to housing etc and and decried patriotism/ moderate nationalism. I think that we then become the only country to not work in the best interests of it's citizens (I know that's the case under a Tory government). We should be concerned with population numbers. We shouldn't have unrestricted immigration. Liverpool is in crisis because of underfunding and placing asylum seekers here has escalated that. If we don't have a national sense of belonging etc then our young men will find it somewhere and there's many groups waiting to fill the gap. There's lots of problematic opinions in the US. I don't like the creeping in of acceptance of religious extremism and how it's ignored.

Westfacing · 26/12/2023 15:43

I'm reminded of when in New York some years ago - as we were waiting to cross at a busy junction a 'red neck' type with his young son referred to a miscreant driver who was jumping the lights as a 'fucking immigrant invader', based on the driver's darker skin!

The irony.

questionsICantAskInRL · 26/12/2023 15:42

@lljkk thats very insightful (sorry if I keep using this word, I’m still hungover and can’t think straight). Thank you for that. It’s made me want to research my own family tree

OP posts:
questionsICantAskInRL · 26/12/2023 15:40

Thank you all for your insights. It’s a very interesting topic. No I’m not new to mumsnet lol! Been here for a while but created a new and fitting username as I will be asking lots of different questions which I can’t in RL. Nothing controversial, just genuine questions I want to discuss. That’s really interesting about British history. I’ll confess being British myself I don’t know much apart from obvious Roman Empire/Viking etc. I need to research more and find out my family tree

OP posts:
Jk8 · 26/12/2023 15:39

Because countries change + The ones who 'invaded other countrys' were not also funding the public health system/welfare payments/caring for the elderly ect. It was a very small group of in-it-for-themselves who could afford to sail around the world stealing shit like land & valuables like gold - should I have to pay for it ? Not a chance. Does it often get thrown around like we were all there ? Absolutely!

verdantverdure · 26/12/2023 15:36

questionsICantAskInRL · 26/12/2023 15:02

apologies if I’m wrong but if “everyone does go back to where they came from” like lots of racists say then all the people living in Australia and American etc. who are descendants of English, Welsh, Irish, Scottish etc. who are living there what will happen then?! And how would they all fit back in the UK?

Edited

Most of the population of the U.K. does not have a majority British ancestry, so most of us would be leaving.

lljkk · 26/12/2023 15:35

One thing I only realised belatedly is how Europeans constantly conquered and subjugated neighbouring populations for centuries before they went out & colonised the world. There were between-kingdom wars that happened in Africa in the same way... India? China? Mediterranean, Afghanistan? Seems same everywhere. Aztecs, Maya & Incas did same to people who came before them.

mollyfolk · 26/12/2023 15:33

As tale as old as time - being suspicious and hateful of newcomers.

Shocked that anyone can be anti immigrant here in Ireland too. There are literally millions of Irish everywhere in the world and we were treated like the lowest of the low . In fact there is still a level of anti Irish sentiment in the UK / yet you still get this hateful eejits giving out about people coming here.

lljkk · 26/12/2023 15:32

People are tribal & competitive about protecting what they have, in short.

Some of the most "anti-immigrant" people are immigrants themselves, or are kids of immigrants. "It was ok to let my parents in, but now there are too many foreigners."

I've heard this attitude from the Hindi lady running corner shop about Albanians, and you see it in national politics from people like Suella Braverman about "irregular" immigration.

In the USA, our genocide of indigenous people is very remote in time and for me it was abstract, not personal to me until I did family history & could see the Puritans, pioneers and slave owners in my own family tree; most people don't know that part of their own history. I read all about boring Puritans in New England, in textbooks, when I was a kid. I knew they had 'Indian Wars' that G.Washington fought in, but I didn't understand what that meant. I didn't know the Puritans enslaved indigenous people then shipped them to Carribean (swap with African slaves). I didn't understand that it was my people who helped clear Indiana or the North Dakota prairies of indigenous people. I didn't know those cold-hearted pioneers were "my people" and even if I did know, I might have decided they were dead people I never met and wasn't responsible for, nothing to do with me.

Meet the immigrants who voted for Brexit

In economically depressed towns like Luton, concerns over jobs and wages cut across ethnic lines.

https://www.politico.eu/article/immigrants-who-voted-for-brexit-luton-migration/

verdantverdure · 26/12/2023 15:28

questionsICantAskInRL · 26/12/2023 14:29

This is a genuine question please don’t accuse me of trying to be goady or whatever the hell people say on mumsnet:

my question is countries like USA who literally took over the country from the natives therefore have no right being there, how can they talk about immigrants taking over their jobs, their country etc? Also the UK how can they talk about immigrants etc. when they invaded lots of countries with the British empire and took all the wealth and gems etc and killed thousands of people who opposed them then complain that the same countries try to come over to make their lives better.

thread title edited by MNHQ at OP's request.

I think it's why some people get their knickers in a twist about immigration, and some even use words like "invasion".

Because they know what their ancestors did to the real indigenous populations of these countries.

FreshWinterMorning · 26/12/2023 15:20

Because that's just the way it's always been - in every country - on every continent. People invading and then acting like they own the land. (And treating people like crap who try and move there too.)

As Crocodile Dundee said... ".........see those rocks? Been standing there for 600 million years. Still be there when you and I are gone. So arguing over who owns them is like two fleas arguing over who owns the dog they live on."

DojaPhat · 26/12/2023 15:19

You're right of course but apparently no-one is responsible for 'what their ancestors' did so it's therefore just a useless discussion. And also something something about other countries invaded other countries too so something something the empire wasn't that bad.

randomstress · 26/12/2023 15:19

It is not particularly rational to state that the foreign policy of a country in one century has to dictate that of the current or future time.

All countries change through time and their policies internally and externally will change as well.

Tinkerbyebye · 26/12/2023 15:18

questionsICantAskInRL · 26/12/2023 15:02

apologies if I’m wrong but if “everyone does go back to where they came from” like lots of racists say then all the people living in Australia and American etc. who are descendants of English, Welsh, Irish, Scottish etc. who are living there what will happen then?! And how would they all fit back in the UK?

Edited

Because the English would have to go back to Norway and other Scandinavian countries via the Viking invasions, as well as Italy following the Romans, France following 1066 and the rest. So there would be plenty of room, everyone would just love round countries

KylieJennersMakeUpSponge · 26/12/2023 15:18

zaazaazoo · 26/12/2023 15:15

@KylieJennersMakeUpSponge it's not about blame, it's about the illogical hypocrisy of migrants and descendants of migrants condemning current and future migrants as bad, the route of all problems, negative to a country etc.

Oh yes I agree on that point - it’s often the same Americans who proudly declare “I’m Irish” (or whatever they perceive to be a ‘white’ heritage). They do this because their great great great grandparents emigrated from Ireland. They’ve never been to Ireland or have any relatives living in Ireland. But frankly the answer is <drum roll please> racism! ‘White’ immigration from ‘cool’ European countries is endearing. ‘Black’ immigration is a threat

Whygobald · 26/12/2023 15:15

zaazaazoo · 26/12/2023 15:09

This is not the other side of the coin. It is the same side of the same coin

I see a difference between invaders/colonisers and asylum seekers/refugees, even economic ones. Neither can reasonably block further immigration, agreed.

zaazaazoo · 26/12/2023 15:15

@KylieJennersMakeUpSponge it's not about blame, it's about the illogical hypocrisy of migrants and descendants of migrants condemning current and future migrants as bad, the route of all problems, negative to a country etc.

KylieJennersMakeUpSponge · 26/12/2023 15:14

Also owning land is not an inherent quality. Since the beginning of our time humans have been digging a stick into the ground and saying ‘mine’. Land was often acquired through aggressive and murderous means and I don’t think this should be a basis for which land belongs to which set of people thousands of years later.

ilovesooty · 26/12/2023 15:14

blacksax · 26/12/2023 15:12

Two things, firstly the OP not appearing to know the usual terminology: "whatever the hell people say on mumsnet" being a fairly hefty clue, and secondly, first post with this username. So either new poster, or - possibly more likely now you come to think of it - deliberately namechanged in order to start controversial (some might say goady) thread on Boxing Day of all days.

Oh and in case the OP is reading this - it ain't just the USA and the UK, not by a long, long way. History is full of it, the world over.

If you think that report it instead of being snide.

blacksax · 26/12/2023 15:12

TinselTitts · 26/12/2023 14:57

Where has the OP stated they're new to Mumsnet?

Two things, firstly the OP not appearing to know the usual terminology: "whatever the hell people say on mumsnet" being a fairly hefty clue, and secondly, first post with this username. So either new poster, or - possibly more likely now you come to think of it - deliberately namechanged in order to start controversial (some might say goady) thread on Boxing Day of all days.

Oh and in case the OP is reading this - it ain't just the USA and the UK, not by a long, long way. History is full of it, the world over.