Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Genuine question re: immigration, not trying to be goady!

117 replies

questionsICantAskInRL · 26/12/2023 14:29

This is a genuine question please don’t accuse me of trying to be goady or whatever the hell people say on mumsnet:

my question is countries like USA who literally took over the country from the natives therefore have no right being there, how can they talk about immigrants taking over their jobs, their country etc? Also the UK how can they talk about immigrants etc. when they invaded lots of countries with the British empire and took all the wealth and gems etc and killed thousands of people who opposed them then complain that the same countries try to come over to make their lives better.

thread title edited by MNHQ at OP's request.

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 26/12/2023 17:40

Southpoint · 26/12/2023 17:23

Really depends on the type of immigrants. It is very naive to assume that every person is going to add to the country. If you get a bunch of criminals and terrorists that would have a negative impact on the country. Basically, you need to vet who is coming to the country.

That's the logic Tory immigration policy is based on.

Bring in qualified immigrants to do the well paid jobs and leave all the zero hours contract, low paid no pension type ones for British people.

verdantverdure · 26/12/2023 17:37

Livelovebehappy · 26/12/2023 17:14

None of what you state happened in my name. So why should I, and the current generations, be held to account for something that happened in a different place, different time hundreds of years ago? Fed of people saying we should apologise and feel guilty for something that was done many many generations ago.

To be fair most U.K. immigration is linked to wars we have been involved in a lot more recently than that.

And we're all participating in the fossil fuel caused climate emergency that is causing the exodus from Africa and will cause an exodus from the Pacific and other islands as sea levels continue to rise.

flowerchild2000 · 26/12/2023 17:33

Very much agreed, I live in the US and most of my friends and some of my ancestors are indigenous. It's really horrible what has been done and is still being done to them. I used to work with activists to try and help at least protect the little land and resources they have left but the government is too greedy, it's futile. For this reason and many more I'm "going back to where I came from" ironically and saving to buy a house in my home country. Even though I've never even been there. Many places our ancestors immigrated from are dealing with population decline, especially in more rural areas, that also happen to be incredible in terms of history, architecture, culture, etc. I think a lot more people will be doing this as the US is falling apart and has destroyed the environment. It didn't take them long either! It's such a deplorable tragedy.

Abitofalark · 26/12/2023 17:26

I agree with RubySundayy about click bait or useless thread titles. Also it is goady to start going on about the British Empire or the USA.

Southpoint · 26/12/2023 17:23

Really depends on the type of immigrants. It is very naive to assume that every person is going to add to the country. If you get a bunch of criminals and terrorists that would have a negative impact on the country. Basically, you need to vet who is coming to the country.

Livelovebehappy · 26/12/2023 17:14

None of what you state happened in my name. So why should I, and the current generations, be held to account for something that happened in a different place, different time hundreds of years ago? Fed of people saying we should apologise and feel guilty for something that was done many many generations ago.

Vegetus · 26/12/2023 17:14

Hate to break this to you but in the entire history of humanity one band or tribe has displaced another band or tribe. How far do you want to go back until everyone is where they should be in your eyes?

YouTookMyUsername · 26/12/2023 17:11

therealcookiemonster · 26/12/2023 17:04

anyone of the opinion that colonialism is distant history - maybe look up the bengal famine (specifically Churchill's role in redirecting aid heading for the region) and how aboriginal and indigenous canadian children were taken from their parents forcibly to 'civilise' them

colonisers even killed koalas by the hundreds of thousands as they were seen as pests (they arent).

Who is saying it's distant history though. It's modern history. It may have been tragic but it doesn't mean borders should all be open, that is a terrible idea.

Also, if the famine was in 1943, anyone involved would be over 100 years old (and that's assuming they were as young as 20).

I think my parents are old, in their 60s. They were born in the 1950s.

RaspberriesUpside · 26/12/2023 17:06

blacksax · 26/12/2023 15:12

Two things, firstly the OP not appearing to know the usual terminology: "whatever the hell people say on mumsnet" being a fairly hefty clue, and secondly, first post with this username. So either new poster, or - possibly more likely now you come to think of it - deliberately namechanged in order to start controversial (some might say goady) thread on Boxing Day of all days.

Oh and in case the OP is reading this - it ain't just the USA and the UK, not by a long, long way. History is full of it, the world over.

I change my username every couple of days. I love being as private as I can. Don’t assume people are new users or have sinister motives.

therealcookiemonster · 26/12/2023 17:04

anyone of the opinion that colonialism is distant history - maybe look up the bengal famine (specifically Churchill's role in redirecting aid heading for the region) and how aboriginal and indigenous canadian children were taken from their parents forcibly to 'civilise' them

colonisers even killed koalas by the hundreds of thousands as they were seen as pests (they arent).

43ontherocksporfavor · 26/12/2023 17:01

*Irish

43ontherocksporfavor · 26/12/2023 16:56

@Whygobald lots of Orish immigrants in U.K. which is justified as they were left so impoverished by the English. All immigrants from British Empire ruled countries are welcome in my mind. You reap what you sow.

IncompleteSenten · 26/12/2023 16:51

Fiery30 · 26/12/2023 16:44

It is not hundreds of years ago though. India was independent just about 75 years ago. Many African countries got freedom so much later. It is not an ancestral problem. Also while you personally may not be responsible, it is entrenched in your country's history and cannot simply be erased because it is not current.

Indeed it's not.
My husband's father and some other relatives were part of the Mau Mau freedom army

Fiery30 · 26/12/2023 16:44

KylieJennersMakeUpSponge · 26/12/2023 15:11

Because we are not responsible for the behaviour of our ancestors, nor should we base policies of what happened hundreds or thousands of years ago.

I am NOT anti-immigration but this is such a weak argument

It is not hundreds of years ago though. India was independent just about 75 years ago. Many African countries got freedom so much later. It is not an ancestral problem. Also while you personally may not be responsible, it is entrenched in your country's history and cannot simply be erased because it is not current.

SmudgeButt · 26/12/2023 16:38

As an immigrant I am frequently amazed at witnessing good, intelligent people going off on a rant about "bloody foreigners coming and taking our jobs" etc.

When I remind them I'm not a British citizen the response is always "well I'm not talking about you! You're ok!!"

And the reason for that is I'm white and English is my first language!

But yes - none of us have the right to be racist and have a blanket condemnation of foreigners. I do understand the need to control some movement so that resources aren't stretched too thin so know that there has to be some rules about who can come and live in the UK. But if there was a massive catastrophe, another Nazi style holocaust brewing would any of us really want to stop truly desperate people from entering the UK?? Wouldn't we all want to be helping with the Kindertransport or Underground Railroad??

phoenixrosehere · 26/12/2023 16:38

FreshWinterMorning · 26/12/2023 16:26

Yep this. ^ Some people act like the UK is the only country to have some people who don't like incomers. Some other countries are far worse, and far more people in those countries are against incomers than the UK is. The UK is NOT a racist country, no matter how some people try to make out it is. (Not aimed at the OP by the way.)

I think most have said it is not as racist as other countries. Many countries have issues with race in some way, just depends on how covert/overt it is and the who towards.

verdantverdure · 26/12/2023 16:34

As IF the U.K. controls its borders!!!!Grin

That went out the window when Brexit happened.

ReallyAgainReally · 26/12/2023 16:34

Nice thread!

verdantverdure · 26/12/2023 16:33

questionsICantAskInRL · 26/12/2023 15:40

Thank you all for your insights. It’s a very interesting topic. No I’m not new to mumsnet lol! Been here for a while but created a new and fitting username as I will be asking lots of different questions which I can’t in RL. Nothing controversial, just genuine questions I want to discuss. That’s really interesting about British history. I’ll confess being British myself I don’t know much apart from obvious Roman Empire/Viking etc. I need to research more and find out my family tree

We're all descended from immigrants. It's just a case of how many generations.

IncompleteSenten · 26/12/2023 16:32

I would imagine it's because the people doing the complaining are not the people who did the conquering and they either don't know the history or are of the opinion that they didn't do the conquering, enslaving and murdering so it's irrelevant to their position on immigration.

FreshWinterMorning · 26/12/2023 16:26

eardefender · 26/12/2023 15:51

Op you are talking about every country on Earth. Countries must control their borders for the sake of their resources and security. If they don’t do this they are not a country, every country in the world has an obligation and a duty to control their borders and conserve their resources. When they fail to do this it causes suffering. It would also be very foolish for countries to make rules based on the situation as it was in the 1600’s.

Yep this. ^ Some people act like the UK is the only country to have some people who don't like incomers. Some other countries are far worse, and far more people in those countries are against incomers than the UK is. The UK is NOT a racist country, no matter how some people try to make out it is. (Not aimed at the OP by the way.)

mineallmine · 26/12/2023 16:24

Ponoka7 · 26/12/2023 15:43

I did find it interesting when the stabbings in Dublin happened and the garda commissioner, Drew Harris said that being born in the UK and NI doesn't give you more of a right to housing etc and and decried patriotism/ moderate nationalism. I think that we then become the only country to not work in the best interests of it's citizens (I know that's the case under a Tory government). We should be concerned with population numbers. We shouldn't have unrestricted immigration. Liverpool is in crisis because of underfunding and placing asylum seekers here has escalated that. If we don't have a national sense of belonging etc then our young men will find it somewhere and there's many groups waiting to fill the gap. There's lots of problematic opinions in the US. I don't like the creeping in of acceptance of religious extremism and how it's ignored.

Drew Harris never mentioned the UK or NI. He's the garda commissioner, lives and works in Ireland, not the UK (although he's from NI.)

therealcookiemonster · 26/12/2023 16:17

questionsICantAskInRL · 26/12/2023 14:57

Thank you everyone! I was dreading this going the direction many threads do on mumsnet. My question originated as we have a relative from one of these countries and she was going on about how the “immigrants” are making the place bad. I had to bite my tongue and stop myself saying “we’ll the poor natives that were killed etc.” DH said I will sound stupid if I say that as it’s not as simple as clear cut as I’m making it.

why would you sound ignorant if you pointed out basic facts? what was done to the indigenous peoples of the Americas, many African nations, Australia and New Zealand is genocide. even to this day, they are treated as second class citizens in their own countries.

we sadly cannot change the past, but we can support them now to help preserve their cultures, languages and peoples.

CurlsnSunshinetime4tea · 26/12/2023 15:58

Current overpopulation and limited resources (water in the Middle East for example). Countries with schemes for social welfare somehow needs to be factored in to the argument.
movement prior to government benefits was less problematic.
you came with nothing and either established a service or died.

eardefender · 26/12/2023 15:51

Op you are talking about every country on Earth. Countries must control their borders for the sake of their resources and security. If they don’t do this they are not a country, every country in the world has an obligation and a duty to control their borders and conserve their resources. When they fail to do this it causes suffering. It would also be very foolish for countries to make rules based on the situation as it was in the 1600’s.

Swipe left for the next trending thread