Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why can't you just dispose of evidence in the bin

362 replies

someladdersandsnakes · 26/12/2023 13:30

I'm reading a thriller and the character done a murder and has destroyed her clothes by burning them. I feel like that would draw attention though. It wasn't the sort of crime that would be discovered immediately and the character wouldn't be suspected immediately either so I would have thought just putting them in the bin would be a good option really but nobody ever does that. Why not? Like surely once the rubbish van has come, and everything from the bins has been combined and smooshed down, there's no way any evidence would be recovered? Who's gonna dig through all that?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
MadWifeInTheAttic · 29/12/2023 15:49

Strangers on a Train was an excellent Hitchcock film. The actor Robert Walker who played the murderer who went through with it was oddly charismatic, but died tragically soon afterwards in real life. An unusual and disturbing film for myriad reasons- highly recommended.

I'm reading Death in Holy Orders by chance... not PD James's best, but not as bad as Death Comes To Pemberley. She had odd views about child abuse, didn't she?

dayswithaY · 29/12/2023 15:22

I love this thread, so educational! I always thought water destroyed all evidence over time, so the sea would be my choice for disposal. But there is an argument for saying nothing, doing nothing, just carrying on and hoping no one notices.

Google Leigh Anne Sabine.

laceydoily · 29/12/2023 12:22

@howdoesyourgardengrowinmay I might read it now in full- sounds intriguing!

Topofthemountain · 29/12/2023 12:16

BigBoysDontCry · 29/12/2023 09:54

The suburban issue isn't cctv, it's Ring type doorbells and car cameras which are everywhere and the police can ask to see. My neighbour has a motion sensor camera at his front door etc.

It is extremely difficult to get away with killing someone nowadays. Not that I'm making plans.... 😁

A slight crossover I think with the "any issues with having a ring doorbell" thread.

howdoesyourgardengrowinmay · 29/12/2023 11:21

laceydoily · 29/12/2023 07:03

You could do- BUT the UK has more CCTV cameras than anywhere in the world, so that along with number plate recognition for cars means if you were spotted at those same locations (and had a motive so the police knew to watch you) it would look very suspicious if it was found and you just coincidentally happened to be in all those locations at some point. I imagine that the closer your connection to the person, the harder it is to get away with it.
Wasn't there a book called strangers on a train about two people who got chatting on a train and agreed to each murder the other person's victim?- to me, that seems a good idea as there would be no obvious connection between them (presuming no texts messages etc) and the victims were strangers to them so the police wouldn't have a clue who to suspect. Not sure how the book ended but if you had no connection whatsoever to the victim I imagine it would be much harder to investigate

If I remember correctly, strangers on a train ended with one of them bottling out of the arrangement, resulting in an unhappy ending 😁

scaredofff · 29/12/2023 11:10

Police officers and detectives dig through the rubbish dump all the time, it's part of their job.

And when they find the evidence in bins my first thought is always 'how stupid' at the fact they've left it too easy to find

Whereas when something really really serious happens and they're looking for a body - the last place they look is a bin!! Like my friend who went missing and was later found in an inquiry to have been taken to landfill in the back of a bin lorry and never seen from again. I guess it's just luck if you use it the day bins are due to be collected

ArtG · 29/12/2023 10:54

I imagine at some point a consensus will be reached on this thread and in a year or two we can expect a Netflix series on « The Mumsnet Murders » where means and methods are identical but victims are geographically dispersed and with wildly different motives and opportunities.

AppleChristsBirthdayMacchiato · 29/12/2023 10:12

educatingrati · 26/12/2023 21:14

That's both genius and a bit unnerving you've thought it through! 😂

I was reading a book by a female mortician and former crematorium worker, and apparently in Britain it's illegal for crematorium workers to open the coffin. In the US, they open the coffin and check everything before it goes into the oven as standard.

This is apparently a problem for British crematorium workers as they can't check the corpse for a pacemaker scar, and pacemakers explode in ovens.

But convenient if you're a funeral director wanting to dispose of an extra body.

Maxus · 29/12/2023 10:02

someladdersandsnakes · 26/12/2023 13:30

I'm reading a thriller and the character done a murder and has destroyed her clothes by burning them. I feel like that would draw attention though. It wasn't the sort of crime that would be discovered immediately and the character wouldn't be suspected immediately either so I would have thought just putting them in the bin would be a good option really but nobody ever does that. Why not? Like surely once the rubbish van has come, and everything from the bins has been combined and smooshed down, there's no way any evidence would be recovered? Who's gonna dig through all that?

Police officers and detectives dig through the rubbish dump all the time, it's part of their job.

laceydoily · 29/12/2023 09:59

The suburban issue isn't cctv, it's Ring type doorbells and car cameras which are everywhere and the police can ask to see. My neighbour has a motion sensor camera at his front door etc.

Yep- plus shops/businesses and residential homes all have cctv now too. My H has a business on a suburban road and he has CCTV because he has expensive equipment in it. The police popped round last year and asked to see his footage as there was a punch up on that road late at night and they wanted it as evidence. Every business in that road (its a mix of houses and businesses) has CCTV.

MadeOfAllWork · 29/12/2023 09:58

1975wasthebest · 29/12/2023 09:15

I don’t know about all the CCTV cameras that are supposedly all around us. I can’t see any in my suburban part of the big city I live in, but I know there’s plenty in the city centre.

I saw an episode of 24 Hours a police custody where they convicted a man based on the evidence of a Ring doorbell.
They could place him walking past and then hear him talking to the girl he then attacked.

BigBoysDontCry · 29/12/2023 09:54

1975wasthebest · 29/12/2023 09:15

I don’t know about all the CCTV cameras that are supposedly all around us. I can’t see any in my suburban part of the big city I live in, but I know there’s plenty in the city centre.

The suburban issue isn't cctv, it's Ring type doorbells and car cameras which are everywhere and the police can ask to see. My neighbour has a motion sensor camera at his front door etc.

It is extremely difficult to get away with killing someone nowadays. Not that I'm making plans.... 😁

laceydoily · 29/12/2023 09:31

1975wasthebest · 29/12/2023 09:24

Wasn't there a book called strangers on a train about two people who got chatting on a train and agreed to each murder the other person's victim?- to me, that seems a good idea as there would be no obvious connection between them (presuming no texts messages etc) and the victims were strangers to them so the police wouldn't have a clue who to suspect. Not sure how the book ended but if you had no connection whatsoever to the victim I imagine it would be much harder to investigate

One of the characters becomes obsessive about the other and that's when things unravel. It's a rookie error getting someone involved in a murder, in any way.

Ah! right- thought it seemed a bit too easy lol

AppleChristsBirthdayMacchiato · 29/12/2023 09:26

Don't ask how I know but I have been reliably informed that the best way to dispose of a body is to feed it to pigs. I always thought it would be fun to have a murdered caught out via not realising the victim had a pacemaker.

I live in a massive block of flats with a huge communal bin store in the basement, and the building only has CCTV in the lobby, not in the hallways, lifts, or the bin store. I wonder why more murder writers don't use that as a mode of disposal for evidence.

1975wasthebest · 29/12/2023 09:24

Wasn't there a book called strangers on a train about two people who got chatting on a train and agreed to each murder the other person's victim?- to me, that seems a good idea as there would be no obvious connection between them (presuming no texts messages etc) and the victims were strangers to them so the police wouldn't have a clue who to suspect. Not sure how the book ended but if you had no connection whatsoever to the victim I imagine it would be much harder to investigate

One of the characters becomes obsessive about the other and that's when things unravel. It's a rookie error getting someone involved in a murder, in any way.

AppleChristsBirthdayMacchiato · 29/12/2023 09:22

MereDintofPandiculation · 28/12/2023 11:39

Nah. Bodily fluids would be toxic wate, to be taken to the only recycling site who can deal with it, on the far side of the city, and charged for, with a charging mechanism geared to hospital volumes,

Leave out in one of those charity bag collections? I saw/read a whodunnit in which the offending garment was sent to charity. The murderer was identified.

There was an episode of Law and Order once where the murderer donated the cashmere sweater he was wearing at the time of the murder to charity, and when the detectives turned up at the charity, the woman running the charity shop was actually wearing the sweater herself.

1975wasthebest · 29/12/2023 09:15

I don’t know about all the CCTV cameras that are supposedly all around us. I can’t see any in my suburban part of the big city I live in, but I know there’s plenty in the city centre.

guinnessguzzler · 29/12/2023 09:05

Yes, it was Suzanne Pilley who was murdered in Edinburgh and they never found her body but good police work secured a conviction for the horrible man who did it. Among other things they timed the drive up to the forests where her dumped her body to prove it was achievable in the time. I think about her quite often, it was so very sad. RIP.

Edited to correct spelling of Suzanne's surname.

RoseAndRose · 29/12/2023 08:54

CelestiaNoctis · 29/12/2023 02:38

I always think why couldn't you put it in a public bin like in the park or on a random street. How could they track that? Unless someone saw you doing it but you could do it with lots of little bags in different bins, I'm thinking in like a city type area.

If you're in a city, you are very likely going to be on CCTV, and even if they don't catch the very moment something goes in to a bin, they'll see the amount you are carrying reduce.

So yes, using a public bin (especially if you are not close to your home - say in a different London borough that might be only a few streets away but will have completely separate waste management contracts) is good. But you need an obvious, conspicuous reason to be putting stuff in a bin - or be carrying "guilty" items in a way that means it doesn't show that you're carrying less. Trawling round several bins is really unlikely to be part of anyone's routine behaviour

It's the "out of character" bit that will raise the most red flags.

So if you want to jettison something by leaving it in a gym changing room, join the gym months ahead of time and actually go regularly

PUGMEISTER21 · 29/12/2023 08:43

What was this program called please?

ThinWomansBrain · 29/12/2023 07:10

Bit off topic, but assuming if your reading this you enjoy thrillers; I read Louise Doughty's A Bird in Winter over the break - can thoroughly recommend.

laceydoily · 29/12/2023 07:03

CelestiaNoctis · 29/12/2023 02:38

I always think why couldn't you put it in a public bin like in the park or on a random street. How could they track that? Unless someone saw you doing it but you could do it with lots of little bags in different bins, I'm thinking in like a city type area.

You could do- BUT the UK has more CCTV cameras than anywhere in the world, so that along with number plate recognition for cars means if you were spotted at those same locations (and had a motive so the police knew to watch you) it would look very suspicious if it was found and you just coincidentally happened to be in all those locations at some point. I imagine that the closer your connection to the person, the harder it is to get away with it.
Wasn't there a book called strangers on a train about two people who got chatting on a train and agreed to each murder the other person's victim?- to me, that seems a good idea as there would be no obvious connection between them (presuming no texts messages etc) and the victims were strangers to them so the police wouldn't have a clue who to suspect. Not sure how the book ended but if you had no connection whatsoever to the victim I imagine it would be much harder to investigate

CelestiaNoctis · 29/12/2023 02:38

I always think why couldn't you put it in a public bin like in the park or on a random street. How could they track that? Unless someone saw you doing it but you could do it with lots of little bags in different bins, I'm thinking in like a city type area.

GrandParade · 28/12/2023 20:37

BigBoysDontCry · 28/12/2023 16:38

But definitely don't Google about how to obtain your poison or anything to do with destroying evidence etc.

You would clearly be researching a crime novel, like Harriet Vane in Strong Poison, who goes around London buying arsenic (and unfortunately is tried for the murder by poison of her ghastly lover, and only saved from execution by Peter Wimsey having fallen for her as she stood in the dock.)

Wakemeup17 · 28/12/2023 20:11

oakleaffy · 26/12/2023 13:59

@someladdersandsnakes look up Elaine o Hara. Ireland.

That could have been the perfect crime

Thank Goodness her killer was caught by a few chance coincidences.

Her killer Is thankfully Jailed.

A taxi driver in Dublin told me that story once! Bloody hell.