Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why can't you just dispose of evidence in the bin

362 replies

someladdersandsnakes · 26/12/2023 13:30

I'm reading a thriller and the character done a murder and has destroyed her clothes by burning them. I feel like that would draw attention though. It wasn't the sort of crime that would be discovered immediately and the character wouldn't be suspected immediately either so I would have thought just putting them in the bin would be a good option really but nobody ever does that. Why not? Like surely once the rubbish van has come, and everything from the bins has been combined and smooshed down, there's no way any evidence would be recovered? Who's gonna dig through all that?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
saltinesandcoffeecups · 26/12/2023 17:11

Drive the body to a shitty part of town leave the car/keys and head home. Car will be stolen in no time and if found will have been part of another crime which gives reasonable doubt as long as all other evidence is gone.

That of course depends on the method of murder… this works best with stabbing or gunshot. Leave weapons in the car with the body and keys. Weapon will be stolen and probably used in other crimes which again will muddy the waters.

Cover story is that victim has been acting strange lately you were both going out and got in a fight, and got out of the car. You were worried about stress and suspected drug use or drinking but no evidence that you’d been able to find.

mangochops · 26/12/2023 17:10

Topofthemountain · 26/12/2023 17:06

That did happen, but obviously there is then excess soil, a forensic botanist was able to prove where the dump soil came from and how long it had been there.

It was Jayden Parkinson (I watched a TV documentary about it)

https://www.oxfordmail.co.uk/news/11295633.update-court-hears-jayden-buried-grave-ex-boyfriends-uncle/

Edited

Yeah- plus I don't know if they have CCTV in those places either. That's interesting. The forensics available nowadays are so advanced that it's actually very hard to get away with it which is a good thing obv.

Needhelp101 · 26/12/2023 17:09

frantically taking notes for my next book

I do remember a very sad case in Australia where police dug through a massive rubbish tip in search of a murder victim's body. Imagine that, digging through stinking rubbish in summer heat to find the rotting body of a poor murdered girl. Whatever they were paid, it was NOT enough.

SockQueen · 26/12/2023 17:09

SardineJam · 26/12/2023 15:49

Slightly off topic...I use a moon cup and have heavy periods, I often wonder if anyone was monitoring the sewerage/water ways and identified a larger amount of blood (yes I know it will thin out when mixed with loads of water), if that would ever raise suspicion

I often wonder if I got murdered, whether the police would be thrown off the scent by finding traces of blood around the sink where I rinse mine out. Poor DH might get accused!

FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 26/12/2023 17:07

Rubbish doesn’t necessarily go straight to landfill though. Where I live it’s compressed by bin hopper and taken to a local storage shed. There it is further compressed and piled up by the manitou. An arctic will come and collect when bay is full. Which can be a few weeks.

Topofthemountain · 26/12/2023 17:06

mangochops · 26/12/2023 17:01

The best way to dispose of a body is to dig up an existing grave and put it in there. That's what I'd do anyway

That did happen, but obviously there is then excess soil, a forensic botanist was able to prove where the dump soil came from and how long it had been there.

It was Jayden Parkinson (I watched a TV documentary about it)

https://www.oxfordmail.co.uk/news/11295633.update-court-hears-jayden-buried-grave-ex-boyfriends-uncle/

MereDintofPandiculation · 26/12/2023 17:03

RoseAndRose · 26/12/2023 13:46

I can never work out why, when there is a bit of time to achieve the task, they're not got rid of in more normal ways.

So perhaps one guilty item in a bag to a charity bin. Another washed and dropped off at a charity shop (again with other stuff, so obviously you need to plan your murder for when you need to declutter). Something in one of those kerbside collection bag. Something else could be cut up, and the tatters and thrown away in several different ways eg put in with some food packaging waste and then divided into being dumped in a random public litter bin, put in your own landfill bin, put in (you dreadful person you) other people's bins ideally from out of your own area that have different collections (and perhaps go to a different tip or part of tip)

Or perhaps just left behind on public transport, or after a public event

If everything is found in one place and there is evidence linking you to that place, that’s weak evidence that you were involved.

if things are found in 3-4 places and CCTV or other evidence links you to each, that’s much stronger evidence of you involvement

mangochops · 26/12/2023 17:01

The best way to dispose of a body is to dig up an existing grave and put it in there. That's what I'd do anyway

ActDottie · 26/12/2023 16:58

I watched a murder investigation on TV recently about a young lady who was murdered. They found footage of the suspect disposing of her clothes in a bin and a skip. They were able to trace the bin and skip contents and sifted through the rubbish at the recycling centre and were able to retrieve the clothing as evidence complete with forensics. So they do search through rubbish.

Burning clothes removes 99.9% of forensic evidence too so is the “safest” way to get away with it.

SmudgeButt · 26/12/2023 16:57

Oh more body disposal tips.....Anyone remember Hamish MacBeth? There was an episode where someone went missing and then they realised he'd fallen into the lobster enclosure. There's a similar sort of discussion in a Dorothy L Sayers book too. Think it was "Have His Carcase".

DyslexicPoster · 26/12/2023 16:57

NotDoingOk · 26/12/2023 14:57

I wouldn't want to put them in my own bin.

Ultimately I suppose I would want to make my movements look as routine as possible...

So I might wash some things in my usual wash loads, and then dispose of them in public bins where I might feasibly stop anyway. Fill up with petrol and clear out some "rubbish" from the car into the bin next to the pumps. Then there are more bins next to the entrance of the Supermarkets. And a clothing drop bin there too.

But there's CCTV everywhere, so if there was any reason to suspect you, they would work it out quickly.

Yes public bins, but cctv. Still safer than burning. I'd take it to the tip as I go quite often anyway. Unless it's a big profile murder I honestly struggle to belive the police would be fast or effective enough to find the evidence in a tip. They need to be quick and find traces of blood in things like your car or house or your dna on the body. Finding dna in your house isn't enough in reality. It has to be beyound reasonable doubt. They didn't take any clothes or do any examination when my friend was raped. You assume they follow a standard procedure or use tools and methods known to them but in reality that's not always the case. It took months to ask for the phone then lost it. I think even if your reasonably dense you'd have a good chance of not getting caught and zero if your smart depending maybe on pot luck of the force who investigated it. I'm still shocked at how ineffective the police was.

You presume they will seek justice by all means available.

Oblomov23 · 26/12/2023 16:56

Interesting. You can't get away with anything these days. The man who rented the wood chipper does sound, very sensible, but even he got caught.

Hettanett · 26/12/2023 16:56

I heard of a man who went to Liverpool police 30 years after the war saying he couldn't live with himself. He'd been on leave from his merchant ship during the Blitz and had gone with a sex worker to a bomb damaged building and strangled her there. He told them where it was, and it turned out the area had been bombed again and cleared after the war and redeveloped. The police said they couldn't charge him and sent him away.

GrandParade · 26/12/2023 16:56

SmudgeButt · 26/12/2023 16:25

Ok so to explain away the blood - if I take decongestants I get a bloody nose. And I'm talking about the real gusher types. So that would explain the bloody clothes/shoes in the bin.

And the body - I'm thinking Sweeney Todd. Not quite what to suggest if someone was vegan....

The alternative is to have a turkey farm. I know you've all just finished off your big birds but they do have a bit of a rep for eating almost anything. I went to an agricultural college for a couple of years and someone mentioned what happened when his grandfather had a fatal heart attack in the field where the turkeys were kept..... fyi - pigs aren't much better - ask that serial killer that was caught near Vancouver...

But the blood won’t be your blood if it’s tested..?

Another thing PD James killers seem to do, or to consider, quite often, is doing to actual murder naked, so you can do a quick wash afterwards before getting into clean clothes.

It is, of course possible that the less body-confident might be put off murder entirely by the idea of having to perform it unclad.

raindropsonatinroof · 26/12/2023 16:55

Ha! This is something I have thought about too but I've seen crime and discovery shows whereby someone threw the murder weapon in the bin and it was found a few days after the murder. I always thought "how fcking stupid" to not get rid of it properly (the stupidity annoyed me almost more than the crime lol).

Murder victims are usually found fairly quickly (unless the person has gone missing) therefore, there isn't enough time for the bin men to collect.

tescocreditcard · 26/12/2023 16:51

RoseAndRose · 26/12/2023 16:36

I suppose best method might also hinge on why you need to dispose of your murder outfit. Is it because it is bloodied? Or because you fear other contamination if forensically examined (transferred hair, fibres, pollen, distinctive dust, mud/earth in treads of shoes)? Or simply because if seen, you want to be able to demonstrate you have no clothing of that type in your house?

Could you break your washing machine (and post about the breakage copiously on MN) and take clothes to a launderette where you can start off a load yourself, and then staff do the rest so you pick up a bag of clean, folded stuff? Maybe 3 loads (in different machines) over the course of a week/10 days? Wash your "guilty" stuff with your DP's, but the rest of your stuff and your DC's separately.

That would wash blood/residue in to someone else's machines/drains, and even though investigators would know you'd been there, so would scores of other people.

Then you would have clean enough clothing to recycle, and I think those kerbside "charity" bags would be the best way, ie the ones that aren't from a real charity but some sort of accumulator who makes a v vague claim about a proportion of proceeds going to charity) as they get taken to centres and redistributed (rags, bulk by weight/type overseas, some of the better stuff for resale). But you can never be sure when one of those bags will turn up. (I would say leave it outside someone else's house, but you might get picked up by someone's home CCTV).

OTOH, perhaps you can get too screwed up by fear of CCTV. If you suspect a long interval between act and it being noticed at all, then how easy is it going to be to trawl all the possible CCTV around you for several weeks. Especially if you go to visit someone you see frequently, who lives in an area with no ANPR and little CCTV outside their town centre?

The launderette scenario is genius. I'm gonna use this when I next murder someone.

ErrolTheRednosedDragon · 26/12/2023 16:50

Yes but your mobile phone would lead the police straight to that hole.

Only if you'd been stupid enough to take it with you.

tescocreditcard · 26/12/2023 16:48

Notfeelinghunkydory · 26/12/2023 14:08

I'd bury clothes etc in a hole in the middle of nowhere!

Yes but your mobile phone would lead the police straight to that hole.

BCBird · 26/12/2023 16:46

Never given any thought of jow to dispose of incriminating evidence. 🙄🤣

Topofthemountain · 26/12/2023 16:45

If you have carried out a murder that has involved a lot of blood then you will not be thinking rationally afterwards. Hence not carefully discarding of things.

I watch some of the forensic shows on CBS reality, the things they can discover, even years later, is amazing. One man almost got away with it, he poisoned his wife with a very short lasting poison, so by the time she died from the effects all trace was gone. It was only solved because a nurse (colleague of the deceased) had taken some blood and hid it in a fridge (previous suspicions) and when it was discovered and tested, traces were found.

SydneyCarton · 26/12/2023 16:45

Dobkin, not Dobson.

SydneyCarton · 26/12/2023 16:44

@LoobyDop There was a carnival house of horrors attraction in the US in the 1970s that was found to have a real mummified corpse among its props. It had been bought in the 1920s from a funeral parlour who had embalmed it and kept it as no one claimed the body, and was bought and sold several times over the years until no one remembered that it was real 😯

@cakeorwine A man called Harry Dobson murdered his wife in 1941 and hid her body in the ruins of a bombed church so that if she was found it would be thought that she was a bomb victim. But when she was eventually found it was clear from the post mortem that she’d been strangled and hadn’t died from blast injuries.

ErrolTheRednosedDragon · 26/12/2023 16:43

"Tales of the Unexpected" Lamb to the Slaughter

That is the ideal murder weapon and means of disposal, for sure.

The various posts suggesting distributing parts of the body and/or clothing etc over an area and/or time seems to me like more chances for something to be discovered.

RoseAndRose · 26/12/2023 16:36

I suppose best method might also hinge on why you need to dispose of your murder outfit. Is it because it is bloodied? Or because you fear other contamination if forensically examined (transferred hair, fibres, pollen, distinctive dust, mud/earth in treads of shoes)? Or simply because if seen, you want to be able to demonstrate you have no clothing of that type in your house?

Could you break your washing machine (and post about the breakage copiously on MN) and take clothes to a launderette where you can start off a load yourself, and then staff do the rest so you pick up a bag of clean, folded stuff? Maybe 3 loads (in different machines) over the course of a week/10 days? Wash your "guilty" stuff with your DP's, but the rest of your stuff and your DC's separately.

That would wash blood/residue in to someone else's machines/drains, and even though investigators would know you'd been there, so would scores of other people.

Then you would have clean enough clothing to recycle, and I think those kerbside "charity" bags would be the best way, ie the ones that aren't from a real charity but some sort of accumulator who makes a v vague claim about a proportion of proceeds going to charity) as they get taken to centres and redistributed (rags, bulk by weight/type overseas, some of the better stuff for resale). But you can never be sure when one of those bags will turn up. (I would say leave it outside someone else's house, but you might get picked up by someone's home CCTV).

OTOH, perhaps you can get too screwed up by fear of CCTV. If you suspect a long interval between act and it being noticed at all, then how easy is it going to be to trawl all the possible CCTV around you for several weeks. Especially if you go to visit someone you see frequently, who lives in an area with no ANPR and little CCTV outside their town centre?

MyDogsPaws · 26/12/2023 16:34

Note to self.. plan any future murders for bin day 🤔