Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why can't you just dispose of evidence in the bin

362 replies

someladdersandsnakes · 26/12/2023 13:30

I'm reading a thriller and the character done a murder and has destroyed her clothes by burning them. I feel like that would draw attention though. It wasn't the sort of crime that would be discovered immediately and the character wouldn't be suspected immediately either so I would have thought just putting them in the bin would be a good option really but nobody ever does that. Why not? Like surely once the rubbish van has come, and everything from the bins has been combined and smooshed down, there's no way any evidence would be recovered? Who's gonna dig through all that?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
anothernamechangeagainsndagain · 26/12/2023 18:35

Out in hasn't been collected for 6 weeks, hope none of my neighbours were relying on municipal rubbish collection to dispose of evidence. I'm really hoping they collected it Saturday as per the email I got

Curlygirl06 · 26/12/2023 18:32

Framilode · 26/12/2023 15:53

My brother was the QC for the prosecution many years ago where a woman had stabbed another woman because she was in love with her husband. Though the police strongly suspected the woman they could not find the murder weapon.
The police (in disguise) took over the bin collection for the area and went through the rubbish. The murder weapon was found in a neighbour's bin.

@Framilode if this is the one I'm thinking of (Wiltshire?) she was my ex husband's teacher. They lived the next town over but previously she'd lived just up the road.

Igotagoodcard · 26/12/2023 18:21

Topofthemountain · 26/12/2023 17:06

That did happen, but obviously there is then excess soil, a forensic botanist was able to prove where the dump soil came from and how long it had been there.

It was Jayden Parkinson (I watched a TV documentary about it)

https://www.oxfordmail.co.uk/news/11295633.update-court-hears-jayden-buried-grave-ex-boyfriends-uncle/

Edited

Also, with things like this where there would basically be no good explanation for being in a graveyard digging up a grave, you would have to be so sure no one would see you.

raindropsonatinroof · 26/12/2023 18:20

ChihuahuasREvil · 26/12/2023 18:17

Wouldn’t you just soak it in cold salt water to get the blood out? I’ve never understood all this disposing of bloody clothing, why not just clean it? No blood to find if you’ve got it all out.

Cleaning doesn't always remove all blood traces at all temps. Just googled and found this study:

It was determined that while a sufficient amount of DNA for the forensic genetic profiling can be obtained from cotton and nylon fabrics washed at 40 and 60 °C, a sufficient amount could not be obtained from the ones washed at 90 °C. And that shows even if bloodstained fabrics are washed at 60 °C, the fabrics still can be considered as physical evidence of the crime and can be associated with the scene, perpetrator and victim triangle.

drowninginsick · 26/12/2023 18:20

uclpp · 26/12/2023 13:54

If I’d done the crime, I’d get the bloodied clothes, put them in a Tesco bag for life and mix in some shit (dog shit from the street or a dog shit bin, not your own dog) to make it look like someone had a messy problem. Then I’d drive my fragrant bag and ditch it in a public bin miles away.

don’t cross me Grin

This is exaclty my plan!

ArtG · 26/12/2023 18:19

It seems to me that disappearing the corpse and other items is fraught with peril. Better off being brazen. Either : kitchen knife incident, sever the femoral artery and get as bloody as you like “stopping” the bleed. Or steal a car, run them over, torch the car.

Cerealkiller4U · 26/12/2023 18:19

VisionsOfSplendour · 26/12/2023 17:51

What do you mean by the working title?

Are you talking about Corrie McKeague (apologies if that's not the correct spelling)

That’s the one. They’ve never known if that’s what happened. That’s what I mean. That’s just what they’re working with.

zaazaazoo · 26/12/2023 18:18

user1477391263 · 26/12/2023 15:18

I‘d hack up the body with the hacksaw we use for cutting up the Xmas tree, put it in a bunch of small separate freezer bags, put them in the freezer, then dispose of them one by one in the bin.

(Can’t believe I just wrote that)

You really would not want evidence in your freezer for that length of time

ChihuahuasREvil · 26/12/2023 18:17

Wouldn’t you just soak it in cold salt water to get the blood out? I’ve never understood all this disposing of bloody clothing, why not just clean it? No blood to find if you’ve got it all out.

RoseAndRose · 26/12/2023 18:17

zaazaazoo · 26/12/2023 18:06

But now you've created multiple opportunities for individual pieces to be discovered. Once discovered each could link to you. Donated with other stuff of YOURS. Put in a kerbside collection with YOUR stuff. This is a terrible idea

Well it was your stuff - the OP said " the character done a murder and has destroyed her clothes by burning them" which I took to mean the contaminated clothes of the murderer herself, not the victim. And that there would be a few days before discovery

So being with your stuff is a really good place. Having a declutter and giving a way a bag of stuff from sundry members of your household is less suspicious than getting rid of just the clothes someone might remember you wearing that day. And the warehousing/distribution systems - especially of the kerbside cowboy collectors - would be hard to follow.

And if you can get DH to drop it off - because it's just a routine declutter after all, and with some of his manky old stuff too - so much the better.

zaazaazoo · 26/12/2023 18:17

@Dotjones Of course burning clothes draws attention. Some people have a habit of regularly lighting bonfires in their gardens, presumably this is so that nobody notices anything unusual when the time comes to burn evidence.

You think people who have regular bonfires do so in preparation for the day they want to burn evidence and not attract attention? Wtf do you live? 😂

Cerealkiller4U · 26/12/2023 18:16

oakleaffy · 26/12/2023 18:13

Dogs {even dogs with 'poor' noses like sighthounds} have superb senses of smell - many times dogs have found remains. ''Found by a Dog walker'' is so common.

Elaine O' Hara's bones were found in a remote forest by a little dog who came back from undergrowth with small bones assumed initially to be animal bones by the owner.

I think only when a more identifiable bone was brought out by the dog did the owner and the landowner investigate further.

A forensic teacher I follow says that 40% of dead bodies are found by dog walkers

Cerealkiller4U · 26/12/2023 18:16

user1477391263 · 26/12/2023 15:18

I‘d hack up the body with the hacksaw we use for cutting up the Xmas tree, put it in a bunch of small separate freezer bags, put them in the freezer, then dispose of them one by one in the bin.

(Can’t believe I just wrote that)

Someone tried something similar to that and got caught

oakleaffy · 26/12/2023 18:13

MereDintofPandiculation · 26/12/2023 18:05

I'd bury clothes etc in a hole in the middle of nowhere! And they'd be found within 3 days by a dog walker.

Dogs {even dogs with 'poor' noses like sighthounds} have superb senses of smell - many times dogs have found remains. ''Found by a Dog walker'' is so common.

Elaine O' Hara's bones were found in a remote forest by a little dog who came back from undergrowth with small bones assumed initially to be animal bones by the owner.

I think only when a more identifiable bone was brought out by the dog did the owner and the landowner investigate further.

megletthesecond · 26/12/2023 18:12

Police search landfill. The BBC series 'The Met' showed how they piece a murder investigation together with CCTV, number plate recognition etc.

MikeRafone · 26/12/2023 18:09

uclpp · 26/12/2023 13:54

If I’d done the crime, I’d get the bloodied clothes, put them in a Tesco bag for life and mix in some shit (dog shit from the street or a dog shit bin, not your own dog) to make it look like someone had a messy problem. Then I’d drive my fragrant bag and ditch it in a public bin miles away.

don’t cross me Grin

cctv and mobile phone pings would establish the location, Dan would still be on the clothing - how would you explain your movements? how would you explain the dna of the murdered person in a bag in a bin at a location you visited?

cakeorwine · 26/12/2023 18:09

coldcallerbaiter · 26/12/2023 17:37

Put in a plastic lidded container and cover in bleach and water to the top. Dispose of it in a bin within a bag. Even if it leaks out or is found, the dna will be destroyed.

Have you been watching Breaking Bad?

Jesse dissolves his bathtub (and a body) | Breaking Bad Season 1 | CLIP

Jesse Pinkman is Tv's most lovable loser and that moment with the acid is LEGENDARY🔥 Buy or rent the movie NOW ➤ https://www.amazon.com/Breaking-Bad-Season...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wJcfhwYJ5uc

zaazaazoo · 26/12/2023 18:06

RoseAndRose · 26/12/2023 13:46

I can never work out why, when there is a bit of time to achieve the task, they're not got rid of in more normal ways.

So perhaps one guilty item in a bag to a charity bin. Another washed and dropped off at a charity shop (again with other stuff, so obviously you need to plan your murder for when you need to declutter). Something in one of those kerbside collection bag. Something else could be cut up, and the tatters and thrown away in several different ways eg put in with some food packaging waste and then divided into being dumped in a random public litter bin, put in your own landfill bin, put in (you dreadful person you) other people's bins ideally from out of your own area that have different collections (and perhaps go to a different tip or part of tip)

Or perhaps just left behind on public transport, or after a public event

But now you've created multiple opportunities for individual pieces to be discovered. Once discovered each could link to you. Donated with other stuff of YOURS. Put in a kerbside collection with YOUR stuff. This is a terrible idea

MereDintofPandiculation · 26/12/2023 18:05

I'd bury clothes etc in a hole in the middle of nowhere! And they'd be found within 3 days by a dog walker.

oakleaffy · 26/12/2023 18:05

DC1888 · 26/12/2023 17:34

Just read about that case. Horrific. Poor Elaine. The shallow water exposing the bag ultimately unlocked the case.

Yes....So many coincidences.
Had that Fisherman and his friend not been looking into the reservoir, had the water level not dropped so low due to the dry summer, the metal parts of the bondage gear would not have glinted up from below.
They said they thought it was a Stag Party stuff initially, but one of them was bothered enough by the style of it that made it seem too sinister for a mere hen or stag party.

Elaine was thought to have committed suicide {this is what the horrible killer was banking on} as she was seen crying at her mother's grave by a witness previously.

It was a vile crime, and poor Elaine was so vulnerable.

It was a really disturbing crime.

Also ...Nokia phones!

An iPhone wouldn't still be working after months underwater.

The metadata was retrievable.

I hope Elaine is at Peace.

Igotagoodcard · 26/12/2023 18:04

Dotjones · 26/12/2023 15:14

If you want to get away with it you either need to destroy the evidence or hide it. The trouble with hiding it is that it has a habit of being found again. Especially when you're talking about a murder, the police don't just give up, if they think there might be evidence in the landfill they'll take a look.

If you've got bloodied clothes and they're in a bin there's a risk of leaving DNA evidence in the bin even after it's been emptied. That's why burning is so popular.

Of course burning clothes draws attention. Some people have a habit of regularly lighting bonfires in their gardens, presumably this is so that nobody notices anything unusual when the time comes to burn evidence.

Even if the police aren't actually looking for evidence of the murder you committed there's a risk that they'll check your bins whilst investigating an unrelated matter. A few years back my bin was searched because of a stabbing a couple of streets away, they went through all the bins in the area in case the knife had been abandoned in one. I didn't have anything to worry about on that occasion but Sod's law dictates that if you've put some bloodied clothes in one in anticipation of the bins being collected tomorrow, that'll be the day some tosser stabs someone at the end of your street.

This was my first though- if you put bloody clothes in your bin, even in a bag, there might be traces left after the bin is emptied.

So you would have to wash your wheely bin with bleach- which if your usual cleaning routine is anything like mine would be massively suspicious!

GnomeDePlume · 26/12/2023 18:04

If your victim is someone known to you then there's a good chance you will be interviewed. Anything which looks odd will call attention. Strong smell of bleach, odd cooking smells.

Try to clean up someone else's home then you will be backwards and forwards - CCTV, ring doorbells, dash cam footage.

There was a man who decided to see if he could get away with murder. He murdered a stranger. The only people about were some dogwalkers. He was caught:

  • the dog walkers noticed him because he didn't have a dog. The dog walkers didn't know each other but they did know each other's dogs
  • ANPR cameras in the area was used to pick out his car
  • he left behind forensic evidence at the crime scene
tescocreditcard · 26/12/2023 17:58

I read somewhere that organised crime syndicates have been known to have a contact in the under-taking business and dispose of bodies by adding them to other peoples coffins before they are cremated.

They also train people up to be "cutters". The cut the body up professionally like a butcher then scatter the parts, always in different police counties knowing the police don't like to share information with their counterparts in other areas.

RoseAndRose · 26/12/2023 17:57

VisionsOfSplendour · 26/12/2023 17:49

But what about the electronic trial of getting there? Switching your off would be suspicious unless you are in the habit of doing that, CCTV? ANPR cameras?

How far do you live from the middle of nowhere, how would you know where to go?

It's easier said than done nowadays

Drive to visit your Dear Old Mum who lives on the outskirts of a sleepy market town (with no ANPR). Leave your phone there, and put your smartwatch on charge (innocuous reason to take it off). From the tech it would look like you had stayed in the house.

Then you go out on foot, in her car or on her bike to your preferred disposal site (somewhere you know well from your childhood, and which isn't even close to places with CCTV)