Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this isn’t normal 3 yo behaviour?

166 replies

Threestepsbackwwards · 26/12/2023 11:44

Consistent with shoving other kids out of the way, trying to kick for no reason, etc.

It’s been going on since about 16 months for context.

OP posts:
BusMumsHoliday · 27/12/2023 14:23

I have a 3 year old DS who has displayed challenging behaviour and is on the ASD pathway. He doesn't have very noticeable delays and I'm not sure nursery would have raised it with us, if we hadn't opened the discussion. I absolutely agree with @BertieBotts that some borderline cases can slip under the radar - kids who struggle socially without being a million miles from expected levels, some of whom don't meet criteria for a diagnosis of any kind, and some who will.

Kindly, you need to separate your emotions about the situation from the actions you can take. You need to talk to nursery about your concerns without getting upset or angry. That won't help him or you. And I do think you should approach your HV.

You seem to both want help and to dismiss all the obvious sources of help, which seems strange. Are you depressed about other areas of your life? Do you have much support in parenting?

My son's behaviour has improved immensely with supports in place and as he's matured a bit towards 4. There's no reason why your son will always be like this. It might take him longer than other kids, or he might need adjustments or teaching in different ways. But you can do those things with help.

Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 13:47

No - he goes mad when you remove him but it’s anger.

He has started to be better with ds2. He used to be very mean and pinched, tried to crush him etc, but is better now. Still needs watching but I don’t think that’s unusual.

Nursery … very, very hard to say. I had a lot of poor reports at one point but I will admit I got upset about it and I’m worried he’s still behaving badly but they are concerned I’ll withdraw him if they report badly of him, so hard to know.

OP posts:
PaperDoIIs · 27/12/2023 13:43

Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 13:36

Hard to say. I thought I had given examples - the climbing frame being one. But here are some that spring to mind.

Once I took him to a playground and one other child was there. He immediately seemed to take a dislike to him shouting ‘get down boy.’ I told him very firmly if he did that again we’d go. Some girls then came to the gate and he ran up like an aggressive dog shouting at them to get away. Removed him.

Another example - standing on a piece of playground equipment and another kid climbing up, he stamped on the kids fingers.

Walking through a corridor once and a toddler coming the other direction, barged into her on purpose.

It is these sort of random little acts of spite - so hard to deal with.

Does he have the same behaviours at nursery? What about with his younger brother?

Does he say anything after? Can he explain why? Does he show consideration and empathy for others outside these incidents?

Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 13:36

Hard to say. I thought I had given examples - the climbing frame being one. But here are some that spring to mind.

Once I took him to a playground and one other child was there. He immediately seemed to take a dislike to him shouting ‘get down boy.’ I told him very firmly if he did that again we’d go. Some girls then came to the gate and he ran up like an aggressive dog shouting at them to get away. Removed him.

Another example - standing on a piece of playground equipment and another kid climbing up, he stamped on the kids fingers.

Walking through a corridor once and a toddler coming the other direction, barged into her on purpose.

It is these sort of random little acts of spite - so hard to deal with.

OP posts:
PaperDoIIs · 27/12/2023 13:31

Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 12:05

Honestly it has made me question everything I thought I knew about parenting. I assumed a child brought up in love would be fine. He isn’t fine.

I hate to say it but I think that he’s just not a very pleasant person. He’s aggressive, violent and evil. I regret having him.

Can you give some concrete examples of incidents and situations where this happens? Also I asked before, how often does this happen? It's hard to advise without a full picture.

Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 12:17

So you remove him after sort of reasonable chance, like if you do that again we go home, then you go home, then it happens again, and again, and again. But it doesn’t always happen. Sometimes all is fine. Busy places do seem to be a trigger. But obviously I don’t always know it somewhere is going to be busy or not.

It’s hard not to succumb to depression. I blame myself, I feel isolated and alone, I hate parenting him. I resent him because he makes me so unhappy. Then I get terrible guilt for these feelings.

OP posts:
inapickle2300 · 27/12/2023 12:11

What consequences do you give him? Eg time out, naughty step, removal of toy.
After he kicked out on the climbing frame, did you let him stay? Or did you go home?

Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 12:05

Honestly it has made me question everything I thought I knew about parenting. I assumed a child brought up in love would be fine. He isn’t fine.

I hate to say it but I think that he’s just not a very pleasant person. He’s aggressive, violent and evil. I regret having him.

OP posts:
Mynewnameis · 27/12/2023 11:55

I'm not sure ADHD causes violence either.
Can you access any service like family gateway in your area?

Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 11:49

Does ADHD come with a propensity for violence though? Genuinely meant as I didn’t think this was the case. Hard not to feel depressed about it.

OP posts:
Thepossibility · 26/12/2023 17:03

My nephew was like this at that age. At that point I'd had my own kids and had been around a lot of kids so could see it was more than normal.
He has ADHD.

Namechange4234 · 26/12/2023 16:50

Threestepsbackwwards · 26/12/2023 14:53

I don’t think he’s a psychopath Smile I just don’t know what is going on with him really. I’m not looking for advice really @AlohaRose . I’m just trying to get a grasp on what’s normal. I feel it’s probably been going on too long to say it is normal and maybe it’s parenting but again hard to say as strategies you would use on a toddler aren’t the same as a 3 yo. And yet you also need to be consistent. Hard to know very hard.

It's not parenting

Unless DS sees you calmly kicking people in the face

See the GP

UnbeatenMum · 26/12/2023 16:30

I don't think it's that usual but also don't think it's necessarily poor parenting, it sounds like you're doing what most parents do in that situation. If you think he's doing it calmly it could be poor impulse control which could just be because he's 3 but could be something to keep an eye on. Or maybe he's had a bad experience in a play area with other children and wants to keep them away. Dropping toys next to a (your?) newborn could be normal sibling jealousy.

TornIntoPieces · 26/12/2023 16:07

BertieBotts · 26/12/2023 11:54

"not normal" does not always mean "poor parenting", it could mean:

Sensory difficulties
Underlying painful health condition
Socio-emotional developmental delay
Speech and communication delay (incl hearing issues)
Poor frustration tolerance
Extra strong emotions (needing more emotional regulation skills than usual)
Underlying stress for child
Poor role models
Reactive nervous system
Poor impulse control
Struggles with flexibility
Poor problem solving skills

Some of these would benefit from a health and developmental check up whereas some can be improved with the right kind of parental support.

I like this post, generally sums up what I'd say with the addition of difficult home environment.

I have seen children behave like this, usually without firm boundaries and overly gentle parenting. My toddler herself, as most do, tried this but firm tellings and seeing through what I've said seemed to help. I'm generally all for gentle parenting but there needs to be clear boundaries and you need to be unwavering bar any major circumstances such as illness /big day out/etc etc.

Toddlers/children will attempt to push boundaries , that is normal and shows that in most cases they feel secure enough to do so. It's what you do after that helps. Not always though. See reasons above. Starting young helps a lot more though, set the tone early.

BertieBotts · 26/12/2023 15:59

OK so you say that you thought perhaps speech was an issue before, but it didn't get better. Has his speech improved? You say no concerns with speech, but he didn't tell the boy to get down off the climbing frame, or invite him to play, or talk to him at all - he went straight to kicking?

I don't think that nursery saying there are no special needs means that it's definitely just the way he is or parenting. It's like you're seeing this as a black and white issue but it is not. The problem is that at three there is such a range in development and behaviour.

So you will have children who are fine at nursery, and respond well to basically any reasonable discipline technique and are naturally eager to please and will adopt prosocial behaviours by coping other children and adult role models, listening to messages given by teachers, parents, books, TV etc.

Then a little bit further down the scale, you'll have children who are a bit more challenging, maybe not in all settings, they will respond to discipline and they get there with the good behaviour, it just takes a bit of time and consistency.

Then a little bit further down the scale, you'll have children who have more persistent behavioural problems, they don't naturally pick up the social behaviours, they don't necessarily have any SEN or disorders, but they do need a bit more targeted behaviour management specifically to teach them the correct behaviours or work on the skills they are struggling with or just scaffold them a bit until their development catches up. We can't all be good at everything, and while some children will be really social but struggle with maths for example, there will be children who struggle with social skills, or emotions, or impulse control. Not to the level of it being anything diagnosable. Just needing a little bit of extra support with learning that.

Then you'll have the kids that do have some kind of SEN but it's so borderline it's hard to detect, their behaviour/milestones aren't significantly off track but they just seem to be that bit more difficult a lot of the time. IME, nurseries and schools typically don't alert to these cases because it requires a more skilled, experienced eye.

The cases of SEN that are so clear that nurseries pick up on them are quite far at the severe end of the scale IME. These children stand out quite clearly from other children their age. I think this is probably why those "borderline" cases don't alert nurseries, because they are looking for a presentation like this, whereas they may miss a more subtle one.

For example, I live in another European country where there are regular developmental check ups. Nursery never picked up on my middle child needing speech support but his paediatrician did. In the UK unfortunately you don't get this automatic yearly check up so it's up to you to ask your health visitor if you have any concerns about your child. Honestly, I probably wouldn't have thought to. In fact, my eldest child's speech was similar and when we lived in the UK I did not get him looked at because I did not realise that his speech would be concerning.

Which is all to say - I don't think that you necessarily need to be thinking that your DS has SEN to look for support or try a more focused behaviour coaching type approach. I can also understand if you're wary of your child being labelled, but to me it does make sense to rule out really easy things like a speech delay, hearing issue, stomach pain, glue ear etc.

Threestepsbackwwards · 26/12/2023 14:56

And yes meeting all milestones fine which is why I don’t think SEN (nursery agree.)

OP posts:
Threestepsbackwwards · 26/12/2023 14:53

I don’t think he’s a psychopath Smile I just don’t know what is going on with him really. I’m not looking for advice really @AlohaRose . I’m just trying to get a grasp on what’s normal. I feel it’s probably been going on too long to say it is normal and maybe it’s parenting but again hard to say as strategies you would use on a toddler aren’t the same as a 3 yo. And yet you also need to be consistent. Hard to know very hard.

OP posts:
ChihuahuaMummy · 26/12/2023 14:31

Hi OP

Has he hit his developmental milestones at an appropriate age? The reason I ask is my daughter was very similar when younger and turned out she had global developmental delay and then when older she was diagnosed with a learning disability.

Does the aggression always happen when people are coming too close to him?

AlohaRose · 26/12/2023 14:30

I think if you were looking for advice, you’re not giving people a great deal of information to go on. You say there is a younger sibling, does the onset of this behaviour coincide with the arrival of that younger sibling? Is he acting out because he is desperate for attention, even if negative? You keep talking about “I”, do you have a partner? Is your younger child from the same partner? If you are a lone parent, does your child see his other parent, could there be issues there?

your default seems to be too blame either the child or poor parenting without any reference to other potential contributors, but at the same time, not be willing to take up any of the suggested advice and referrals from people here. What are you hoping for from the thread?

Iwrotethelyricstoaxlf · 26/12/2023 14:26

You say this has been going on for 18 months.

does that coincide with the arrival of your younger child?

could be plain and simple that he feels that any attention is good, and it doesn’t matter if he gets that by being good or being naughty.

Raverquaver · 26/12/2023 14:23

I know it's tempting to think, he must be some kind of psychopath or there's something sinister about his behaviour but genuinely at 3, and particularly with some boys, a lot of it seems to be experimenting to see what the reaction to his actions will be, or a compulsion that he can't stop. If I could tell you how much difference 6 months have made, it has been genuinely life changing. Fingers crossed for you amigo.

Namechange4234 · 26/12/2023 14:20

Threestepsbackwwards · 26/12/2023 14:17

That’s reassuring @Raverquaver - thank you.

Unfortunately I don’t have the money for private therapy. anyway. He isn’t angry. He’s generally quite calm as he does it.

He calmly kicks another child in the face?

I'd visit the GP with him

Threestepsbackwwards · 26/12/2023 14:17

That’s reassuring @Raverquaver - thank you.

Unfortunately I don’t have the money for private therapy. anyway. He isn’t angry. He’s generally quite calm as he does it.

OP posts:
Namechange4234 · 26/12/2023 14:07

Threestepsbackwwards · 26/12/2023 13:56

He’s at nursery. No need to speak to SENCO as fairly sure it isn’t special needs (they agree) so it’s either parenting or just - him. Which is very hard, either way it’s hard.

Take him to a private child therapist to work out why he has such anger issues ?

I dont think it's normal for a 3 year old to deliberately try to hurt another child who has done nothing to them ..... unless that 3 year old has issues

I don't think you have taught him to deliberately hurt others

Raverquaver · 26/12/2023 14:05

Hi OP, little message of hope for you. This was my 3 year old. Whenever I picked him up from his nursery (which he only attended for a few hours a day), I'd be told he'd bitten, kicked, hit etc etc another child. Same with toddler groups i took him to. We were beside ourselves and ended up withdrawing him for his own and other children's benefit. Questioned how we had gone so wrong in our parenting. Many people suggested autism, but this just didnt compute with how he was 1 to 1. Fast forward 6 months and he is an entirely different child. He is at pre school now and his teacher tells us he is her favourite student, very kind to other children, never reacts if somebody takes something off him etc. We nearly fell off our chairs during parents evening!! I read around a lot on this and basically he struggled to self regulate (so basically in his head he'd be thinking I want this person to stay away from me and couldn't stop himself physically acting on it). Once he'd matured enough to stop himself from doing these things, the behaviour miraculously got better overnight. I hope your child is the same.