Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this isn’t normal 3 yo behaviour?

166 replies

Threestepsbackwwards · 26/12/2023 11:44

Consistent with shoving other kids out of the way, trying to kick for no reason, etc.

It’s been going on since about 16 months for context.

OP posts:
PaperDoIIs · 27/12/2023 19:07

Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 18:17

Why did you try to hurt that child? Probably wouldn’t answer.

A better way to ask is what happened. I work with kids and if they think they're in trouble/they did the wrong thing they either become belligerent or shut down. What happened helps to get them to open up more and also get things from their perspective. It might be a skewed perspective sometimes,but it can explain why.

Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 19:04

@Escaperoom I am not trying to be churlish or rude.

I don’t really want advice because most of it has already been tried. Sometimes we seem to be making progress but then there will be an incident that makes me feel that we aren’t making any progress at all. We had a good run, it seemed anyway, but then back to square one. As you can imagine I feel disheartened and upset.

(the baby has been sleeping very badly and as a result so am I - of course - which is also getting me down.)

Involving GPs, HVs and the like for what appears to be a very sweet, well behaved little boy would get me labelled neurotic at best. I’ve explicitly asked nursery if they believe he has additional needs and they’ve clearly indicated no.

@RoseGoldEagle has clearly described DS without meeting him. That sort of behaviour is him to a T. It isn’t every time we go somewhere. For example the weekend before Christmas there were two birthday parties: loud and chaotic and he was fine, no altercations or aggression. Then we’re at a playground and it’s all fine and child comes behind him and he kicks and I’m lost.

He most probably is testing boundaries and I know I have a very visceral reaction as I grew up with violence. DHs upbringing was more normal so he’s probably more pragmatic.

OP posts:
Escaperoom · 27/12/2023 18:49

I think it is fair to note that the OP didn't actually ask for help or advice. What she asked was if this was normal behaviour for a 3 year old. In my (not particularly vast) experience the answer to that would be no, not usually, not the way she is describing it. What should she do about it? Well she seems to be ruling out all the free sources of help available and can't afford the paid kind, but as I said above she didn't actually ask for help, so maybe we should all butt out and stop offering what isn't wanted. When he gets to school (assuming she isn't planning to home school) next year if this kind of thing is still going on then if his school is anything like the one my DGD attends they will be on to it straight away. There is still hope that he might grow out of it in the meantime however.

Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 18:42

Thank you so much @RoseGoldEagle

OP posts:
RoseGoldEagle · 27/12/2023 18:41

I had similar concerns about my DS at 3, including the sometimes hurting other children with no provocation or indication he was stressed or upset before hand. I remember going to a playground when there was one other little girl there, who was minding her own business and playing, and he just chased her wherever she went and tried to stop her playing on whatever equipment it was, physically pushing her or trying to restrain her. (Obviously we intervened to stop and warned him we’d take him home if he continued, which we then did). It was just such a different experience to his elder sister, who would play with anyone and would never have hit a child at the age of 3.

He’s 4 nearly 5 now, and the change in him since starting school is enormous. It’s like he’s grown up a year and a half in 3 months. He’s still a bit cautious of people he doesn’t know, but will either say hi or ignore them, he no longer randomly hits or shoves them (I think it was an anxiety thing before). He’s got some lovely little friendships in reception and is thriving. Of course I don’t know the situation with your DS, but just wanted to share as I think 3 is still within the realms of this behaviour being ‘normal’, (but I agree it’s very stressful, I was very worried for ages), and doesn’t indicate he’s going to be like this forever.

Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 18:36

@Octonaut4Life i really think he knows this. Sometimes if I have those sorts of conversations with him he will say sorry to me but obviously I’m not the one he needs to say it too.

I think there’s an element of seeing what he can get away with but he is aggressive. I can’t really put any other spin on it.

OP posts:
AmaryllisNightAndDay · 27/12/2023 18:34

I’m not going to be engaging with HVs etc though so it might be frustrating if that’s the advice

That's up to you, you're the mum. Are you OK going via the GP or nursery instead? Sometimes it's possible / easy to bypass the HV, sometimes it's very hard, it may depend where you live.

I don't know much if you're totally going it alone though because that's not the route I took.

Octonaut4Life · 27/12/2023 18:34

If you ask a child of his age why they did something they can't really answer. But you can say to them things like "how would you feel if someone did that to you?" And encourage them to see it from the other child's point of view, and talk about it that way. Is he able to understand that if he hurts someone it makes them feel sad or angry, and can he understand that's not nice and it wouldn't be okay for someone to do it to him?

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 27/12/2023 18:26

Plus and harsh as this may sound, ADHD isn’t curable. If he has it (which I don’t think he has) then there’s not much we can do. It vindicates me to a point I suppose but that’s little comfort.

ADHD and ASC might not be curable - they are not illnesses! - but the right parenting strategies, the right adaptaions, the right education, and often in the case of ADHD the right medication, can make a huge difference to how a child grows up.

If your DC has ADHD or ASC there will be a huge amount you can do. It will be a lot of work but massively worthwhile.

Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 18:25

Thanks. I do appreciate that. I’m not going to be engaging with HVs etc though so it might be frustrating if that’s the advice [smile ]

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 27/12/2023 18:24

Aah sorry I can see I've missed bits and you've posted in between my longer posts which I sort of typed and then ran because DS2 wanted me to do lego with him.

I'll catch up (I've got that cuppa now!) and let's see if we can help you feel more positive/like there are steps forward. Because there ARE. I fully fully totally 100% believe this, I have been in that "Aaaaaargh" frustration point, I have half wondered if I should just give DS1 to his aunty and let him live with her. He is 15 now and a lovely boy, totally calm, not a bully at all. It took a lot of work (and some just waiting for him to grow up) but we got there. Understanding really really really helps. It feels hopeless when you're seeing it just as malice and I promise you that it is not. Or at least, not pure malice for no reason. It will make sense to him somehow and once you've got that, you're able to help him.

DS2 is now in the frustrating arsehole stage so I haven't forgotten what it's like. We will get there.

Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 18:23

He doesn’t care. Well, he does, but doesn’t seem to get that we left because of his behaviour. Then we get stuck in a negative sort of cycle where he’s upset etc. I’m worried about tomorrow as heavy rain and wind is forecast but nowhere to take him he won’t attack.

OP posts:
Infusedwithfigandhoney · 27/12/2023 18:20

I would warn him before you get to the park etc
Then if he does it immediately home.
Then discuss why.

At the moment he goes to the park, kicks, gets a warning,plays again,then does it again , then goes home.
Zero tolerance.
If he does it several times then stop the park telling him why.
I don't think stopping nursery helps, he will learn how to behave from others.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 27/12/2023 18:20

The problem is, he isn’t upset or angry. It’s fine, he’s happy, enjoying himself. Then kicks someone in the face. It isn’t a loss of control when frustrated - I could understand that.

Hm yes, I can see why you're worried. I don't remember development stages exactly but I do think three years is old for that. I would say this is health visitor/GP territory because they can refer on if necessary. They may well suggest a parenting group as a next step anyway. I got pointed at a parenting group while we waited for referrals to CAMHS.

Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 18:17

Why did you try to hurt that child? Probably wouldn’t answer.

OP posts:
Hercisback · 27/12/2023 18:13

What does he say if you ask him why?

Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 18:11

The problem is, he isn’t upset or angry. It’s fine, he’s happy, enjoying himself. Then kicks someone in the face. It isn’t a loss of control when frustrated - I could understand that.

OP posts:
AmaryllisNightAndDay · 27/12/2023 18:09

Well, if you are very upset or angry and you are a young child, you do want to hurt someone but you don't really understand that you could really damage or injure them, or realises that they will carry on being hurt long after you have stopped feeling angry. Or maybe you don't quite understand that other people really do hurt as much as you do. Or you do kind of know these things but you're still too little to control yourself in the moment,

That kind of thing can lead to spitelful behaviour. Empathy and patience can develop late in some children. It doesn't mean that they will never develop, but they may take longer, and some children may need help to grow them fully.

Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 17:58

I’m afraid I don’t really … could you explain?

OP posts:
AmaryllisNightAndDay · 27/12/2023 17:56

But while I could deal with some stuff spite is probably so hard, the hardest of the lot. I’ve read about angry kids and frustrated kids but mean kids?

I remember "spite" was actually on one of the diagnostic checklists for my DC - not for a specific condition (as far as I know) but more a broad sign that something wasn't right and needed to be investigated. It is painful as a parent but young children sometimes don't have the skills or understanding to not be spiteful (if you see what I mean).

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 27/12/2023 17:47

Start with a toddler/preschool parenting group - Triple P, Positive Parenting, or whatever your local area has to offer. Your health visitor or GP should be able to refer you to one.

I don’t really want to go down the HV route.

Well, health visitors are exactly the people who know this stuff. Not saying they're all perfect - there used to be one in my area that all the new mums warned each to avoid! - but this is part of their skill-set.

A good way to find out if it is your parenting really is to try a parenting group. None of us can tell you if your DS's behaviour is "normal". And normal or not, you are worried about it, and the things you've tried so far haven't solved the problem. A parenting group is just the next thing to try. The group will recommend strategies that work for most children and give you the theory behind them, and you will be able to do them and explore what does and doesn't work, and discuss and compare notes with the other parents and the group leader. It will either fix most of the problems, or give you a head start if you do need to discuss your child with professionals.

I did say (very nicely) that I didn’t feel it was helpful to just keep telling me he’d hurt other children without any sort of further discussion about what they wanted and that if he was unhappy and making other children unhappy it might be best to consider withdrawing him. After that it’s all gone silent.

That's because withdrawing him from nursery is (probably) the wrong thing to do. It's not about the money. Withdrawing him at this stage will not help him to learn how to deal with other children, and it will not help anyone to identify whether he has an underlying problem interacting with other children or not. It will only mask the problem.

He does have friends and children he likes but maybe his ‘default’ when it’s an unknown entity is aggression rather than shyness (which is probably more socially acceptable.)

Been there done that. Turned out to be ASC for us, but we didn't find out til DC was a couple of years older. All your reasons for "not sure" I would have given for my own DC at age 3 (and older) as well. You often don't get really clear signs until later.

Wishing you the best OP. It's worrying having a child who's aggressive. Don't give up though flowers

Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 17:16

Oh and eats and sleeps well too

OP posts:
Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 17:16

It’s hard diagnosing at a young age but there really aren’t many / any signs of SEN.

Dyspraxia for example - motor skills are very good and always have been. Can use playground equipment designed for much older children with little or no help. Really good with fine motor skills too.

ADHD - I’ve taken him to theatre performances, church services, things that require a certain amount of sitting and listening and he’s fine. He doesn’t (yet) watch films or show much interest in jigsaws for instance. But that’s not hugely significant.

ASD - this can be a contentious one as am well aware that one person with ASD is one person, however

Makes eye contact
Responds to name
laughs and smiles
has been able to follow basic instructions for a long time
Good verbal skills
Gets involved in imaginative play
Has friends (it surprises me too but he does have friends)

So - not sure.

OP posts:
Zombiemum1946 · 27/12/2023 17:10

I had this with my son. He was quite hyper and at times frustrated. We've since discovered he's dyspraxsic and the behaviour was a part of it. Tasks involving fine motor skills (drawing, painting, building models) were triggers. This became very clear when he was trying to learn to draw letters and numbers. He also had balance and coordination problems. The frustration for him was overwhelming. There was lots going on at home as well. It settled down eventually. I just wish we'd known a lot earlier and that the nursery and school had been able to provide the correct support.