Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this isn’t normal 3 yo behaviour?

166 replies

Threestepsbackwwards · 26/12/2023 11:44

Consistent with shoving other kids out of the way, trying to kick for no reason, etc.

It’s been going on since about 16 months for context.

OP posts:
Threestepsbackwwards · 28/12/2023 08:56

They weren’t too close. They were a kid climbing a climbing frame in a completely ordinary and appropriate way. He wasn’t overcrowded or distressed.

I do obviously follow him round and physically prevent him attacking. But it isn’t always possible especially in play areas designed for kids.

DH and I just don’t talk about it.

OP posts:
Yalta · 28/12/2023 08:49

From my point of view I’m picking ds up and being told he’s been unkind, he’s done this, he’s done that. Eventually, I sent a very nice email (I will actually anonymise it and post it on here if you want me to) expressing concern that the situation was unpleasant for everyone - other children, DS and staff, and where did we go from here

There is a lot of removing him from situations and telling offs but no giving him words or showing other behaviours. Telling him to say excuse me or don’t come too close when someone is getting close on s climbing frame.

I know you are saying to be kind with hands and feet but what does that even mean to a 3 year old

If it means don’t kick then say don’t kick
Say exactly what you want to see or don’t want to see

Has he any friends at nursery

wudubelieveit · 28/12/2023 08:39

wudubelieveit · 27/12/2023 19:15

You haven’t said much about what aspects of parenting your husband is involved in?to be very stereotypical your boy is moving from the mummy nurturing stage as it were to being more outward looking and a typical male figure is involved in teaching boundaries, the limits of rough play ,managing own strength etc….I’m wondering what his relationship is like with his dad and how his play /behaviour is when he’s with his dad? @Threestepsbackwwards if you have grown up experiencing male violence I think it’s really important your OH steps up for this issue as seeing what a “good “ father teaches about anger and aggression will be really important…however we do tend to marry people through whom we work through our own childhood issues, for good and for bad, so just to flag up as these dynamics may be surfacing somehow!

Edited

@Threestepsbackwwards i'm re-posting my post as it always seems from what you are writing that you are alone in this ...you are not, your husband is fully part of this too! with your last few updates i really think you are replaying aspects of your own childhood so please get your OH involved and some extra support for yourself.

matthewstirling · 28/12/2023 08:18

Just a few things that may or may not be helpful.

  • SEND covers several different areas. One of those areas is Social Emotional and Mental Health (SEMH) there is always a reason for 'difficult behaviour' and nursery could (should?) be monitoring this with you in case there are SEMH issues that need addressing (they will have evidence that can be passed on to school for example so that he isn't starting from square one when he starts school). Telling you it's not a SEND issue as if SEND only covers physical or 'academic' development is not helpful to anyone including you but mostly your child. *all difficult behaviour is for a reason, the reason may not present itself until he is much older or ever but it's always for a reason. It's never because the child is spiteful or mean. There will be a reason that he is behaving in this way- it might be as simple as getting a reaction or it might be more complex and due to development, neurodiversity or trauma. It might not even be his trauma, it might be trauma that you or his Dad have suffered that has effected your own parenting/view of childhood (I am absolutely not parent blaming here, but your own issues -it you have any- will absolutely effect your child). The fact that all behaviour has a reason will not make it any easier for you to deal with but may give you a different lense through which to view the behaviour. catch him being good every tiny thing that he does in areas he finds tricky that is positive (eg saying hello to the baby, not reacting when another child enters the playground etc), make a massive fuss of your child. Be hyper vigilant for tiny good things that he does in relation to other children. Even if these things are totally normal things and use language of praise with him. 'Wow, well done DS, it was really kind of you to pick the baby's hat up because he'd have a cold head without it, you're a super big brother. I'm so pleased to have you to help me.' Etc go over the top but reframe your view of him and go mad on praise. *make sure he knows the rules everytime. When you arrive at the playground, stop at the gate and go through the rules in a positive way 'right DS, today I'm going to be looking for you letting other children play on the climbing frame while you're on it and being able to play your game when another child is near you, if you can't do that, I'm afraid I'll have to take you out of the playground for five minutes but if you can do that, you can have a sticker/high five/treat. When in the playground, go mad praising him, even if the other child is miles from him. If he does kick somebody etc take him out, explain what he's done wrong then give him another chance. You'll need to be totally on him and playing with him etc for this, talking him through eg. 'Oh look, there's a little girl who's come to join us, we need to be really kind and let her on the climbing frame too. Why don't you ask her name?' Etc. You may need to only go to the playground when you can leave the little one with somebody else and give DS your full attention for a while or when somebody else can watch the little one. *he is only little and is still learning, he'll still be learning when he's 5,6,7 etc. don't think 'what if he's still doing this when he's 6, concentrate on helping him now and for now.

Not sure if any of that is helpful, it just sometimes makes things better to reframe how we think about our kids and see them in a different light.

Aliciainwunderland · 28/12/2023 08:00

OP. You are not a bad mother. Your child isn’t a bad kid. Talk to your partner, talk to a gp. Talk to a therapist. You need help, love and support. Wishing you the best

Aliciainwunderland · 28/12/2023 08:00

OP. You are not a bad mother. Your child isn’t a bad kid. Talk to your partner, talk to a gp. Talk to a therapist. You need help, love and support. Wishing you the best

Wanderpeg · 28/12/2023 07:53

I’m worried for your son.

His behaviour as you’ve described is still completely within the realms of normal for his age, not all children develop at the same pace and there are always outliers. There may or may not be a developmental issue, you should be talking to your HV about this…but you’ve worryingly said you don’t want to.

Your posts are strange, bordering on mentally unhinged. Your mental state is going to affect your children, you need to go see a GP and repeat some of the things you’ve written here (about killing yourself if you had just had him, that you’ve predicted his future already and decided he will be a bad person, that you believe a toddler is evil)

Three years old is still so young, he may seem more grown up if he is your oldest but you will look back and see how small he truly was at this age.

Before you ruin yours and your childrens lives you NEED to get outside help.

Puffling235 · 28/12/2023 07:42

Threestepsbackwwards · 28/12/2023 04:10

He isn’t learning though, is he? That’s the point.

For nearly two years now he has been told no, we use kind hands and feet. Teeth are not for biting. If you cannot use kind hands we shall have to leave.

He has learned precisely nothing in that time (apparently.)

So he’s three now. Let’s say in another two years we’re still here and he’s five. Is he still just a baby then?

How about at seven, nine, eleven?

I will genuinely try to do my best. It isn’t helpful for me to post here or to talk about it any more.

Where something is repeated like this, children need actively preventing not telling. They are impulsive. I suspect this, and possibly your own reactions to his behaviour, are the adjustments that need to be made to parenting.

Puffling235 · 28/12/2023 07:37

Threestepsbackwwards · 28/12/2023 03:15

So from a post that was very helpful this

the fire and ramp them up rather than down. It can often take a long time to calm them down, and by the time they have calmed down they have absolutely no idea what you are talking about when you try to discuss it with them. They either shut down and refuse to give an answer, give a silly answer, or literally don't seem to remember/understand is probably the most helpful.

We had another incident tonight which I’m upset about. Poured cold water on the baby’s face. Baby obviously hysterical and no sort of warning or provocation.

I am alone in this and it’s so isolating. Nursery, HV and GP just aren’t going to be any help. I did flag my concerns re aggression at the two year check and it didn’t even get acknowledged. The HV will likely just give me the standard sort of advice that does not work. The GP will ask what nursery think and when I say nursery think all is fine then that ends there.

I have been lying awake thinking about it. I just wish I hadn’t had him. I know that’s just awful but it’s the honest truth, as unfortunately I see where he’s going and where we’re all going.

Look I don't know about the rest of it but this sounds like very normal 3yo behaviour. Framing it as aggressive or cruel is going to be very unhelpful. Is your upbringing skewing your responses here?

It sounds like he needs very close supervision whenever around other children, and blocking whenever the physicality comes up. Ie before it happens. He needs close spotting. Recruit your husband (or others) to help where possible. If other children are close by, expect that it is going to happen. Don't stand by passively until it's too late. Don't punish, prevent. If you miss something, and it happens, remain calm, and end the situation where appropriate (eg leave park). Tell him why. Start again.

Exhausting? yes - necessary, yes.

FacingTheWall · 28/12/2023 04:19

Find your local Family Hub and see what parenting courses they’re running. The incredible years programme would be good for you, even if only to explore what typical development is like, and to see if you think ds’s behaviour is different.

From my experience of hundreds of small children, I think you’ll see a huge difference once he starts school.

Threestepsbackwwards · 28/12/2023 04:10

He isn’t learning though, is he? That’s the point.

For nearly two years now he has been told no, we use kind hands and feet. Teeth are not for biting. If you cannot use kind hands we shall have to leave.

He has learned precisely nothing in that time (apparently.)

So he’s three now. Let’s say in another two years we’re still here and he’s five. Is he still just a baby then?

How about at seven, nine, eleven?

I will genuinely try to do my best. It isn’t helpful for me to post here or to talk about it any more.

OP posts:
Threestepsbackwwards · 28/12/2023 04:06

And, I think I shall probably delete my MN account as I think I come here desperate for answers but there are no answers.

I do think I’ve made many mistakes and there are quite a few things I wish I could do again. I will try to make an appointment with the GP to try to rule out any physical health conditions that may be either the cause of some of the aggressive behaviour towards others or may be exacerbating it. But other than that it’s really just hoping he grows out of it or - and this is awful - that one day he’ll pick on the wrong kid.

OP posts:
Josette77 · 28/12/2023 04:05

I'm going to suggest therapy for yourself most importantly.

Nothing you have said seems all that horrible for a just turned 3 yo. He has been on this planet for 3 years and is still learning.

Your reaction to him is extreme and I wonder if it's more about your childhood than him. Lots of kids hit and act out at that age.

Why are you deciding he's a bad person who is out to hurt people? He is still very much a baby..

Threestepsbackwwards · 28/12/2023 03:56

He isn’t a baby. He hasn’t been a baby for some time now.

Any sort of removal from the situation makes him more angry and it takes a long time to settle him then.

I don’t want to label him as evil, that was a post I shouldn’t have made. However, he does have a personality, as everyone does, some children are shy and timid, some are exuberant and outgoing. Mine … he has his good points but fundamentally he is aggressive and cruel.

If I only had him, no other children, I think I would probably end my life. I have been thinking about this tonight. I couldn’t bring myself to harm a child much less my own. But the years ahead won’t bring much joy. It’s just all going to be a fight, trying to prevent him harming himself and others. But since I have another child in need of protection I can’t do that. What a mess

OP posts:
Josette77 · 28/12/2023 03:49

I have a child with complex special needs who was very violent as a child to me, not other kids. We still struggle sometimes.

There are many different parenting strategies that experts can suggest but at his age you stay consistent, remove him immediately no second chances, and at home he can have a 3 minute time out in his room.

Do not try and lable his emotional state as evil or cruel. He's still a baby. He's learning.

You need to stay calm when these things happen and just swiftly consequences. Be matter of fact.

Afterwards you discuss what happened.

Discussing this with parenting experts or reading books is a good thing. Also, 123 magic was a great book.

Threestepsbackwwards · 28/12/2023 03:15

So from a post that was very helpful this

the fire and ramp them up rather than down. It can often take a long time to calm them down, and by the time they have calmed down they have absolutely no idea what you are talking about when you try to discuss it with them. They either shut down and refuse to give an answer, give a silly answer, or literally don't seem to remember/understand is probably the most helpful.

We had another incident tonight which I’m upset about. Poured cold water on the baby’s face. Baby obviously hysterical and no sort of warning or provocation.

I am alone in this and it’s so isolating. Nursery, HV and GP just aren’t going to be any help. I did flag my concerns re aggression at the two year check and it didn’t even get acknowledged. The HV will likely just give me the standard sort of advice that does not work. The GP will ask what nursery think and when I say nursery think all is fine then that ends there.

I have been lying awake thinking about it. I just wish I hadn’t had him. I know that’s just awful but it’s the honest truth, as unfortunately I see where he’s going and where we’re all going.

OP posts:
Vettrianofan · 27/12/2023 21:39

Threestepsbackwwards · 26/12/2023 12:02

Have looked into parenting classes but mostly seems to be sponsored/expensive stuff, hard knowing what’s genuine. Plus I don’t think I’m doing anything drastically different. Not perfect but is anyone? So don’t know really.

Check out Solihull Parenting Approach. These classes can be done online.

BertieBotts · 27/12/2023 21:05

Don't worry, that's OK. Smile Get some sleep. I bet it will not be like this next Christmas, if you can get the right info behind you (which a lot of the standard parenting advice is not).

Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 20:54

@BertieBotts i am probably too tired to give that post full justice but a genuine and heartfelt thank you.

OP posts:
gooddayruby · 27/12/2023 20:33

Children don't develop full impulse control under around 4 so I wouldn't worry that they'll be a violent person.

BertieBotts · 27/12/2023 20:03

Okay :) And apologies for there being some "speak to HV" in there but if you're working out as you type, which I def do as well - then maybe it's a useful thinking point anyway.

Speaking to a HV or GP does not mean that you are looking for a diagnosis or being neurotic, though. To me the reason to do this would be to say "I'm struggling with some difficult behaviour in my child, and I'm looking to rule out underlying causes such as recurrent ear infection, speech delay, hearing problems, and anything else I might not have thought of as I am not a medical professional".

They probably will ask how he is at nursery, which is why communication with nursery is a good idea. I would go to nursery first. (take notes/ask for a written report) Find out any patterns. What specific problems are they having. What doesn't work. What does work well. Any areas (social, impulse control, behaviour, what do they think?) where he's out of step with his peers. Take this info to HV and see what she suggests as next steps. I don't think this will have your card marked as an anxious mother, I think this will come across as diligent and organised. If they say no, everything is normal, he will grow out of it, then ask when would she expect you to see an improvement, and what should you do if there is no improvement? Explain that you are concerned about this behaviour persisting into school, and that you do not want your son to become a playground bully. That's your concern, isn't it? So you can just be honest about it. That won't come across as neurotic.

You also said you wanted a parenting course, they can refer you to one for free (and it will be a decent one) or I also linked to one much earlier in the thread, and someone posted the link to Incredible Years, which is another (similar) evidence based approach.

Forget diagnoses for a moment because I think this is causing you to get stuck in a loop of "but he doesn't have that and anyway if he does have that I can't do anything" (Someone else answered the "can't do anything" v well above). You said that you are wondering if this is temporary. It seems to me that he is a little bit stuck in a stage most children leave behind earlier, which might mean that he won't move out of this easily without help. I don't mean to paint a bleak picture but I do think that if you get stuck in an unhelpful cycle there is a potential (NOT guaranteed!!) outcome where he continues to act out, you and other adults - nursery, school, etc - and other kids, kick back, or dislike him and he ends up with this negative self-image and combative automatic defensive response. That's the worst case scenario and where you don't want to go because it takes even more work to unpick that. So how to change the story? Look at what all the challenging behaviour experts say. Not the normal parenting "experts" (many of whom are anything but) but the ones who go into schools and work directly with the worst behaved children who don't respond to anything else. (Ross Greene, Becky Bailey, Stuart Shanker, Alan Kazdin, Thomas Phelan, Mona Delahooke, various Occupational Therapists or behaviourists, for example).

And they basically all say variations of the same thing:

If you're repeatedly doing the same thing and it's not working, it's probably not the case that the child is refusing to meet your behaviour expectation, it's probably that they can't - there's a gap there between their ability and what you're asking them to do.

Most of them BTW say that if there's a diagnosis it's not necessarily relevant - a diagnosis will get you access to any therapies and medications (maybe) and an EHCP at school etc and it might give you info about what might be realistic in a child of that age with that condition, but it doesn't change anything about what you actually do. The process is the same, diagnosed condition, undiagnosed, no condition at all.

They all say that harsher/stricter punishment isn't the answer and generally makes the situation worse. I know you have not suggested this.

Then they tend to split off into what they do recommend, with a lot of similarities.

All of them emphasise building connection is important. Positive regard for the child is important. Catching them being good, and recognising this (with praise, rewards, attention or even just noticing) is important.

Many of them recommend getting really specific about the exact behaviour that you're expecting to see. This helps in a couple of ways - it means that you can see if it's really realistic. For example if you're currently at "unprovoked physical violence" and you want to get to "plays nicely/neutrally ignores other children" that's quite a large gap. You would not expect your younger child to potty train tomorrow, I expect. You know that there is a long way to go in terms of verbal communication, recognising their body sensations, bladder development, being able to physically reach the toilet and take on and off clothing. Difficult behaviour is basically social skills and this is the same. Breaking this down into more manageable steps, and working out what the required underlying skills are can be extremely helpful.

Some provide info about what is likely going on behind the behaviour. For example, both Mona Delahooke and Stuart Shanker, and a lot of OTs talk about the concept of stress-response behaviour. This one has been huge for me. I could see it happening with DS1 but had no language to explain it to anybody else. Now I understand what is happening.

Some differentiators for misbehaviour vs stress behaviour are that misbehaviour is able to be changed through normal discipline techniques, punishment, reasoning, etc. It's behaviour that is thought through and decided upon and has a sort of logic to it (even if it's childish logic or results in something antisocial) the child can reflect on what they were thinking at the time and why. You can interrupt it and the child might be defensive but ultimately will respond to discipline in an appropriate way.

Whereas stress behaviour tends to be extremely sudden and seem to come "out of nowhere". It can often be violent. If they are talking, their voice will be harsh and high pitched. They may even laugh. Their body will be tense, if you put a hand on them to try to move them, block them or just try to connect with them/calm them down you can feel this. Their face may have a strong expression, even seeming "evil" or "manic". Discipline attempts tend to be like adding fuel to the fire and ramp them up rather than down. It can often take a long time to calm them down, and by the time they have calmed down they have absolutely no idea what you are talking about when you try to discuss it with them. They either shut down and refuse to give an answer, give a silly answer, or literally don't seem to remember/understand. Discipline has no effect on it and it will continue to happen, often with a pattern of the general surroundings of the trigger, even if the trigger itself is somewhat of a mystery. It can be difficult to see the overarching pattern, which is why conferring with other settings/adults can help.

The explanation for why it is so sudden and out of the blue is that what you're seeing with stress behaviour is the culmination of dozens of individual, tiny, invisible stresses which are all feeding into a sort of "Buckaroo" effect on the child, where this one thing happens and it sets off a sort of explosion of all of the other things. You know like when you are having a bad day and your DH makes a stupid joke and you snap at him, whereas another day you would just roll your eyes and ignore it? It's basically like a very extreme version of that.

Threestepsbackwwards · 27/12/2023 19:16

No that’s OK @BertieBotts . I’m not really ‘wanting’ anyone to tell me anything. I tend to work out things as I type.

@PaperDoIIs thank you. He doesn’t tend to give details (does any 3 year old) so if you ask how he got the scratch on his face he might say Thomas, but no details as to whether Thomas was acting in self defence or not!

OP posts:
wudubelieveit · 27/12/2023 19:15

You haven’t said much about what aspects of parenting your husband is involved in?to be very stereotypical your boy is moving from the mummy nurturing stage as it were to being more outward looking and a typical male figure is involved in teaching boundaries, the limits of rough play ,managing own strength etc….I’m wondering what his relationship is like with his dad and how his play /behaviour is when he’s with his dad? @Threestepsbackwwards if you have grown up experiencing male violence I think it’s really important your OH steps up for this issue as seeing what a “good “ father teaches about anger and aggression will be really important…however we do tend to marry people through whom we work through our own childhood issues, for good and for bad, so just to flag up as these dynamics may be surfacing somehow!

BertieBotts · 27/12/2023 19:14

And no I have not written paragraphs saying just "go to the HV" Grin

BertieBotts · 27/12/2023 19:13

I've written quite a bit in another window because I didn't want to lose it through refreshing the thread. I'm getting the sense though that you actually want people to tell you that your DS will grow out of this without you doing anything different and everything will be fine. If that is what you want, then I will take my unhelpful rambling somewhere else. If you would like to hear someone else's experience/what I've found out over the last 12+ years then I would be happy to share it.