Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To people who believe in ghosts..

358 replies

AnxiousAnniee · 26/12/2023 10:40

I used to believe in ghosts when I was a child but as an adult I don’t. I find that there’s too many things that don’t make sense to me and just aren’t logical. When you actually start thinking about it and what it means to be a ghost, I think it just seems silly. I get that everyone has a different opinion though so I’m really genuinely interested to hear what people believe about the following questions…

  • if ghosts exist and look like the person who has died, how do they walk around and move things without muscles or a brain? How do people hear ghosts giggle and speak if they Dont have a brain or a voice box? If they are just a see through sprit how can they really do this? You can’t move, think, or talk without a brain. And they don’t have a brain or muscles because they are spirits.
  • similarly with moving things around or opening cupboards. First of all why would they do this? Why would a ghost turn a tap on??? For what reason? Secondly if they are so light and see through and can walk through things, how can they pick things up instead of just moving through them?
  • if a ghost is a spirit and someone’s soul, then how come they are always wearing clothes when people claim to have seen them? Clothes don’t die and clothes don’t have souls, so clothes don’t have an afterlife and shouldn’t come back as clothes ghosts. They should all be naked.
  • how come people only ever see ghosts of loved ones and scary Victorian children or soldiers and things? How come no one ever sees a caveman ghost or a chav ghost in trackies? (Again, they shouldn’t really be wearing anything anyway)
  • if ghosts are souls then that means everyone will turn into a ghost when they die. Which means we are currently SWAMPED with ghosts. They’re everywhere. We’re constantly walking through them everywhere we go because that many people have died in the world, we are bombarded with them
  • what about baby ghosts? Babies can’t walk so does that mean that there’s loads of ghost babies just lay on the floor all around us?

I’m not taking the piss here, these are genuine questions that I have asked myself when I believed. And the more I think about it the more I just don’t believe it. However, I’m aware that people still do, so I’d love to hear what you think the answers are to these questions and what you think ghosts actually are, and their purpose?

OP posts:
Watchkeys · 28/12/2023 20:42

Actually the Brian Cox thing will be irrelevant, because we're talking about the paranormal, which is external to science anyway. He's saying that science proves ghosts don't exist. I'm saying (and I'm not alone in doing so) that science doesn't know everything. Cox's argument is that we can't prove that ghosts exist using science, and I agree with him.

Watchkeys · 28/12/2023 20:38

@CurlewKate

Yes- several things. They have all turned out to be entirely explicable

Well then how are you assigning them to the 'inexplicable' category?! Honestly, it's not worth bothering arguing with someone who thinks that 'something inexplicable' is something they have an explanation for. It was a straightforward enough question.

Has Brian Cox got evidence that ghosts don't exist, then? I'd love to see it.

GreenAppleCrumble · 28/12/2023 20:10

CurlewKate · 28/12/2023 19:56

@GreenAppleCrumble Oh, ok. Because you were giving the impression that only the existing scientific laws were acceptable."

When I said it would be incredibly exciting, I don't actually think that will happen. To quote a famous authority (for fellow oldies!) "Ye canna change the laws of physics!"

And that’s fair enough. But it might not mean ‘changing the laws of physics’ so much as discovering new ones? As I said, I’m not a scientist, but I do hear discussions sometimes about new ideas - and I’m fairly sure there are huge avenues for investigation that could throw up very challenging ideas?

No one is asking you to discount gravity, for example, but there are some interesting questions about the nature of time that are not necessarily dead ends.

CurlewKate · 28/12/2023 19:56

@GreenAppleCrumble Oh, ok. Because you were giving the impression that only the existing scientific laws were acceptable."

When I said it would be incredibly exciting, I don't actually think that will happen. To quote a famous authority (for fellow oldies!) "Ye canna change the laws of physics!"

GreenAppleCrumble · 28/12/2023 19:54

@WhatsTheUseOfWorrying
Really happy for you to engage with the points I made (primarily to @CurlewKate) but perhaps you could be as polite and respectful as she manages to be?

GreenAppleCrumble · 28/12/2023 19:52

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 28/12/2023 19:43

That’s not sneering. That’s straightforward comment.

TBH, these ghost threads always end up with the para-faithful playing the put-upon victims, no matter how they themselves post. 🤷‍♀️

Perhaps you weren’t aware that you were being sarcastic and condescending? If you think that’s ‘straightforward comment’ you really don’t understand language!

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 28/12/2023 19:43

That’s not sneering. That’s straightforward comment.

TBH, these ghost threads always end up with the para-faithful playing the put-upon victims, no matter how they themselves post. 🤷‍♀️

GreenAppleCrumble · 28/12/2023 19:24

Yes, sorry, it was @WhatsTheUseOfWorrying who was sneering:

It’s tricky stuff this science and rationalism: takes a bit of effort to grasp probability, think through problems and face the realities of the world. So much easier just to believe in ghosts and psychic powers.

My apologies, @CurlewKate

GreenAppleCrumble · 28/12/2023 19:19

CurlewKate · 28/12/2023 18:54

@GreenAppleCrumble "What if the explanation, should we ever uncover it, blows all your existing assumptions out of the water? What then?"

That would be incredibly exciting.

Oh, ok. Because you were giving the impression that only the existing scientific laws were acceptable.

Perhaps you haven’t sneered - sorry. That might have been someone else.

CurlewKate · 28/12/2023 19:00

And I am pretty sure I haven't sneered at anyone.

CurlewKate · 28/12/2023 19:00

@Watchkeys
"So, has anything you couldn't explain ever happened in your life? And, what 'laws of science' would ghosts defy?"

Yes- several things. They have all turned out to be entirely explicable.

According to Brian Cox, the 2nd law of
Thermodynamics. I've got an article he wrote about it saved somewhere. I'll find it for you later.

CurlewKate · 28/12/2023 18:54

@GreenAppleCrumble "What if the explanation, should we ever uncover it, blows all your existing assumptions out of the water? What then?"

That would be incredibly exciting.

Watchkeys · 28/12/2023 18:15

@CurlewKate

What I don't accept is "we don't know so so we need to make up something that defies the laws of science to explain whatever it is." rather than just waiting for more data

So, has anything you couldn't explain ever happened in your life? And, what 'laws of science' would ghosts defy? Surely if they actually, factually disproved the laws of science, that would be scientific proof that they don't exist, wouldn't it?

GreenAppleCrumble · 28/12/2023 18:15

@CurlewKate

I am perfectly happy to accept "we don't know." What I don't accept is "we don't know so so we need to make up something that defies the laws of science to explain whatever it is." rather than just waiting for more data. Cf "orbs", spontaneous human combustion, yetis, the Bermuda Triangle....

I think the reason some people are having trouble with your point of view is that, on the surface, you’re willing to reserve judgment and go with ‘we don’t know’ but on the other hand, you’re saying there must be a logical explanation for every single ‘weird’ occurrence- and that the explanation must come from a range of sources that you already know and approve of.

What if the explanation, should we ever uncover it, blows all your existing assumptions out of the water? What then?

You sneer at people ‘making stuff up’ but people are only using terms like ‘ghostly’ and ‘apparition’ as shorthand for things they can’t explain; no one has proposed a detailed hypothesis about the Rules of Ghosthood. They’re just saying ‘this happened.’

You’re happy to say ‘you hallucinated’ because that’s a real, documented phenomenon- but that’s not to say there isn’t another explanation that hasn’t yet been proven and documented.

In short, it seems as if you’re happy for things not to be understood yet, but with a caveat that when/if they are understood, they correlate with already existing ideas. Now, I’m not a scientist, but isn’t this not how science works? Aren’t there already discoveries at quantum level that fly in the face of conventional physics?

decionsdecisions62 · 28/12/2023 17:59

@CurlewKate ok well that explains how patients are able to then recount what doctors discussed in different rooms post event. So once again not explained by science. Try again!

GreenAppleCrumble · 28/12/2023 17:57

Grimpo · 28/12/2023 14:30

You're absolutely right, OP. What often strikes me about people's tales of ghost encounters is how utterly trivial the things are that it is claimed ghosts say and do. I can't help thinking that if I came back after death, I would want to see people I love, not spend my time making weird noises at strangers or whatever.

It’s this type of question that makes me realise how utterly pointless it is for us to try to understand every experience. If there were ‘ghosts’ or other dimensions or whatever- do you imagine them just as the BBC ‘Ghosts’ characters?! Just invisible humans living it up in after-life? Why would you be able to rationalise their appearance or apparent behaviour? They would, almost by definition, be beyond our human understanding!

CurlewKate · 28/12/2023 16:43

@Watchkeys "The human ego's inability to accept 'We don't know', on the basis of nothing at all, and unwittingly, is mind blowing."

I am perfectly happy to accept "we don't know." What I don't accept is "we don't know so so we need to make up something that defies the laws of science to explain whatever it is." rather than just waiting for more data. Cf "orbs", spontaneous human combustion, yetis, the Bermuda Triangle....

CurlewKate · 28/12/2023 16:35

@decionsdecisions62 "@CurlewKate ok near death experience- explain that."

Lack of oxygen to the brain.

Watchkeys · 28/12/2023 15:14

@decionsdecisions62

I'm not fired up, I'm laughing! I agree about philosophy :)

decionsdecisions62 · 28/12/2023 15:06

@Watchkeys try and relax love you are getting all fired up!

I personally think philosophy holds the key for more answers than science. Isn't it great we all have opinions and are free to express them?

Watchkeys · 28/12/2023 14:58

decionsdecisions62 · 28/12/2023 14:22

@GrandParade you make sweeping assumptions. I'm a senior lecturer in a scientific field. I still acknowledge the massive limitations of science trying to provide answers to this. What do you do?

This really made me laugh. It'll make no difference that you're a professional. These people know better than you about science, because they KNOW the truth and it is A FACT. It would be interesting to hear what their fields of specialism are within science, but I don't think they're going to tell us...

That's what we're arguing against here. A lack of understanding about the limitations of science, and a blind faith in the power of humans to know everything. The human ego's inability to accept 'We don't know', on the basis of nothing at all, and unwittingly, is mind blowing. I wonder if the same people thing that nothing at all existed, until science started to find proof for things? Did dinosaurs exist before we had proof, for example? Did oxygen only start to exist once we had scientific proof, and, if so, how the hell did we create proof without being able to breathe?

decionsdecisions62 · 28/12/2023 14:46

@CatsinCastles cue the posters ready to say 'you didn't' It's funny how for every other experience in life we would call it gaslighting but for this we don't have any problem dismissing someone's experience. Perhaps it's fear in them?

LynetteScavo · 28/12/2023 14:43

I can't help thinking that if I came back after death, I would want to see people I love, not spend my time making weird noises at strangers or whatever.

That's assuming ghosts have control over what they do, and who experiences them.

If ghosts are just repeats of what has already happened in the same place it happened they can't go travelling around to have out with people they lived with.

I've heard unexplainable footsteps, on more than one occasion. How could that nose have been created? There must be a logical explanation, and I do think one day we'll understand.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 28/12/2023 14:31

GrandParade · 28/12/2023 14:20

Another one with a total ignorance of the basic principles of science who thinks scientists are harsh ing her ‘woo’ mellow.

And harshing the comfort of wanting to believe in ‘real’ magic.

It’s tricky stuff this science and rationalism: takes a bit of effort to grasp probability, think through problems and face the realities of the world. So much easier just to believe in ghosts and psychic powers.

Grimpo · 28/12/2023 14:30

You're absolutely right, OP. What often strikes me about people's tales of ghost encounters is how utterly trivial the things are that it is claimed ghosts say and do. I can't help thinking that if I came back after death, I would want to see people I love, not spend my time making weird noises at strangers or whatever.