Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To people who believe in ghosts..

358 replies

AnxiousAnniee · 26/12/2023 10:40

I used to believe in ghosts when I was a child but as an adult I don’t. I find that there’s too many things that don’t make sense to me and just aren’t logical. When you actually start thinking about it and what it means to be a ghost, I think it just seems silly. I get that everyone has a different opinion though so I’m really genuinely interested to hear what people believe about the following questions…

  • if ghosts exist and look like the person who has died, how do they walk around and move things without muscles or a brain? How do people hear ghosts giggle and speak if they Dont have a brain or a voice box? If they are just a see through sprit how can they really do this? You can’t move, think, or talk without a brain. And they don’t have a brain or muscles because they are spirits.
  • similarly with moving things around or opening cupboards. First of all why would they do this? Why would a ghost turn a tap on??? For what reason? Secondly if they are so light and see through and can walk through things, how can they pick things up instead of just moving through them?
  • if a ghost is a spirit and someone’s soul, then how come they are always wearing clothes when people claim to have seen them? Clothes don’t die and clothes don’t have souls, so clothes don’t have an afterlife and shouldn’t come back as clothes ghosts. They should all be naked.
  • how come people only ever see ghosts of loved ones and scary Victorian children or soldiers and things? How come no one ever sees a caveman ghost or a chav ghost in trackies? (Again, they shouldn’t really be wearing anything anyway)
  • if ghosts are souls then that means everyone will turn into a ghost when they die. Which means we are currently SWAMPED with ghosts. They’re everywhere. We’re constantly walking through them everywhere we go because that many people have died in the world, we are bombarded with them
  • what about baby ghosts? Babies can’t walk so does that mean that there’s loads of ghost babies just lay on the floor all around us?

I’m not taking the piss here, these are genuine questions that I have asked myself when I believed. And the more I think about it the more I just don’t believe it. However, I’m aware that people still do, so I’d love to hear what you think the answers are to these questions and what you think ghosts actually are, and their purpose?

OP posts:
GreenAppleCrumble · 31/12/2023 14:26

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 31/12/2023 13:55

It’s not simply imagining - as in honest mistakes about - sights, sounds, smells, temperatures - though there’s plenty of that goes on - it’s imagining reasons for the sights and sounds.

As for the Rome story, I have no idea what the background or temperament of the witnesses was, beyond what I’m told in the book. Nor anything about others in the story or not in the story. (The husband doesn’t feature much IIRC, or the daughters.)

But if you want a best guess on the facts we’re given, what happened to Andrew when babysitting was a prank. Just like the Enfield Poltergeist.

Before you say “but a prank was ruled out”, we can’t know that. At least not on the basis of the book.

Thank you for engaging with this. I’m finding it really interesting 🤔

Yes, a prank can’t be ruled out if someone is lying. I thought it was weird what happened right at the end - after the now adult babysitter revisited the apartment. If people aren’t lying it’s harder to reconcile all these events 🤷‍♀️

I get what you’re saying about the reasons for sights/sounds etc. But I’m fairly happy for there to be no explanation settled on, with the door left open for it to be something ‘woo’, I guess! For example, if you go into your kitchen and every cupboard is wide open despite no-one having been in there, you might say - it’s the wind maybe? Or a prank?! But there are often ways of more or less ruling those things out, especially if the same thing happens repeatedly and for different witnesses. My reaction might not be to go ‘it’s definitely the ghost of Great Aunt Hilda’ but I would defintely be kicking round done paranormal ideas! Just because it would be so, so weird - not like a trick of the light or a waking dream.

I’m of the opinion that each case should be taken on it’s own merits, but also that the overwhelming wealth of testimony out there, much of it from regular, clear-minded people, can’t all be lies/misunderstandings.

CurlewKate · 31/12/2023 14:19

@GrandParade ". I love that there is MR James fan fic."

I am ashamed and somewhat embarrassed to admit that it wasn't MR James fanfic- it was a significantly lower brow and less worthy fandom. I just stole the story....

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 31/12/2023 13:55

It’s not simply imagining - as in honest mistakes about - sights, sounds, smells, temperatures - though there’s plenty of that goes on - it’s imagining reasons for the sights and sounds.

As for the Rome story, I have no idea what the background or temperament of the witnesses was, beyond what I’m told in the book. Nor anything about others in the story or not in the story. (The husband doesn’t feature much IIRC, or the daughters.)

But if you want a best guess on the facts we’re given, what happened to Andrew when babysitting was a prank. Just like the Enfield Poltergeist.

Before you say “but a prank was ruled out”, we can’t know that. At least not on the basis of the book.

GrandParade · 31/12/2023 13:47

CurlewKate · 31/12/2023 13:39

@GrandParade That's interesting-for some reason when I was very young I got it into my head as Mrs James and have never properly got it out!

I'm a member of a fan fic writing group and once rewrote Whistle And I'll Come To You as a gay love story for the characters. Maybe truer than I thought!

That’s funny! 🤣 I think he was Montagu(e?) Something James. A reactionary old sod, but a brilliant ghost story writer. He’s buried in Eton — I was visiting a friend when there was a big restoration of his headstone. I love that there is MR James fan fic.

GreenAppleCrumble · 31/12/2023 13:43

@CurlewKate

But I really don't see any difference between him retelling a story someone has told him, and someone telling a story they have imagined. It's fun, but I don't see how it moves anything forward...

Really? But there is a difference, surely? I mean, one is fiction and one is (or purports to be…) non-fiction. I mean, if you assume everyone is lying, then yes, the latter becomes fiction too!

I guess I’m more gullible than you then! I tend to believe people unless there’s a particular reason to disbelieve them or there’s going to be material/financial harm if I’m mistaken.

It’s easy to dismiss the phenomena (even those with multiple witnesses) if you assume people are liars, yes.

The other point that @WhatsTheUseOfWorrying raises is the imagination- the suggestion that people are subconsciously creating these phenomena. Again, it’s harder with multiple witnesses but it’s a point sceptics regularly raise. I just don’t buy it though as an explanation for the thousands upon thought of weird experiences people have documented. As I’ve said before on these threads - I don’t think I’ve ever imagined something that wasn’t there. I’ve had those weird moments when you think you’ve heard a doorbell waking you up from a dream or you think you see a figure but it’s a trick of the light. But those are really easily solved or dismissed. I find it literally impossible to conceive of a situation where I would imagine something so vividly that it would deeply affect me. I’m sure it can happen in the odd case where there’s a chemical explanation- but again, I believe people when they say that they’re otherwise healthy and clear-headed!

Just out of interest, if you don’t dismiss the key players as liars, how do you explain the Rome apartment story?

CurlewKate · 31/12/2023 13:39

@GrandParade That's interesting-for some reason when I was very young I got it into my head as Mrs James and have never properly got it out!

I'm a member of a fan fic writing group and once rewrote Whistle And I'll Come To You as a gay love story for the characters. Maybe truer than I thought!

watermelonsugar56 · 31/12/2023 13:31

I’m scared the white scary ghost people you see sometimes tv.

Sometimes when lying in my bed, I feel someone gently stroking my hair like my grandma used to. It gives a sort of ASMR feeling and is extremely comforting. I’d like to think that’s something. ❤️

FancyJapflack · 31/12/2023 13:29

It’s all so illogical isn’t it.

The only thing that makes an ounce of sense to me is the theory that reality/time is in multiple layers. If time isn’t linear and/or there multiple universes all existing at once then maybe there are thin areas sometimes/somewheres where things collide.

i could sort of get on board with that idea.

GrandParade · 31/12/2023 13:25

CurlewKate · 31/12/2023 11:13

@GreenAppleCrumble "And M.R. James was openly writing fiction, no?"

Yes he/she( I can never remember which) was. The point is that there is nothing to indicate, except his say-so, that Robins isn't too. Well, not yet, anyway.

MR James (a he, very much, and one who lived in a very all-male world, medievalist scholar, fellow of King’s, Cambridge, Provost of Eton, never married, notoriously dismissive of women, often assumed by biographers to be a closeted gay man, used to read his stories aloud to all-male gatherings of his friends) is interesting because his ghost stories are readable in terms of exploring his own demons. Lots of the horrifying or frightening manifestations of ghosts in his stories suggest the sexual or feminine (like the spectre of bedclothes in ‘Whistle and I’ll Come to you, my Lad’), or his survivor’s guilt for outliving his younger friends and students during and after WW1.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 31/12/2023 12:26

CurlewKate · 31/12/2023 12:21

@WhatsTheUseOfWorrying Yes-it's not abridged.

Thanks. Just curious. I’ve never listened to an audiobook. But I’ve always assumed they would say if they’re abridged.

CurlewKate · 31/12/2023 12:21

@WhatsTheUseOfWorrying Yes-it's not abridged.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 31/12/2023 12:12

CurlewKate · 31/12/2023 12:08

@WhatsTheUseOfWorrying I'm listening to Robins as an audio book- he tells a story brilliantly and scarily! But I really don't see any difference between him retelling a story someone has told him, and someone telling a story they have imagined. It's fun, but I don't see how it moves anything forward...

Yes, I agree.

Out of interest, is the audiobook word-for-word the printed work?

CurlewKate · 31/12/2023 12:08

@WhatsTheUseOfWorrying I'm listening to Robins as an audio book- he tells a story brilliantly and scarily! But I really don't see any difference between him retelling a story someone has told him, and someone telling a story they have imagined. It's fun, but I don't see how it moves anything forward...

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 31/12/2023 11:20

CurlewKate · 31/12/2023 11:13

@GreenAppleCrumble "And M.R. James was openly writing fiction, no?"

Yes he/she( I can never remember which) was. The point is that there is nothing to indicate, except his say-so, that Robins isn't too. Well, not yet, anyway.

I think I see what GreenApple meant: MR James consciously imagined his stories. I’m perfectly happy to think that Danny Robins faithfully recorded other people’s.

The key, I think, is in the word ‘imagined’. Conscious imagination v unconscious imagination.

Anyway, it’s good that you are enjoying the book. I didn’t dislike it; but I can’t say I thought it was either particularly well-written or insightful.

CurlewKate · 31/12/2023 11:13

@GreenAppleCrumble "And M.R. James was openly writing fiction, no?"

Yes he/she( I can never remember which) was. The point is that there is nothing to indicate, except his say-so, that Robins isn't too. Well, not yet, anyway.

ballytravlr · 31/12/2023 10:49

Anything experienced as true by any individual is actually true because it has actually happened.

GreenAppleCrumble · 30/12/2023 19:30

CurlewKate · 30/12/2023 18:47

@GreenAppleCrumble I'm enjoying Danny Robins book very much. He's a fantastic teller of stories-and I actually decided to stop listening to one for a bit while I was on my own. But so far I don't understand how it's different to, say, MR James......

He is really good, isn’t he? I know you did that research into his background and there were some things that made you feel that he’s got a really vested interest in the paranormal, as it were. But I think he’s in earnest and tries to be even-handed. He’s definitely not a paid-up believer. And M.R. James was openly writing fiction, no?

GreenAppleCrumble · 30/12/2023 19:28

PickledRaspberry · 30/12/2023 18:39

I don't know if I believe or not. I really wouldn't believe at all because so many things don't seem to add up but I've actually seen one. If only I had seen it then I'd just put it down to my own Imagination but it was also seen by a friend.

I’d really love to know more about this but will understand if you don’t want to share!

CurlewKate · 30/12/2023 18:47

@GreenAppleCrumble I'm enjoying Danny Robins book very much. He's a fantastic teller of stories-and I actually decided to stop listening to one for a bit while I was on my own. But so far I don't understand how it's different to, say, MR James......

PickledRaspberry · 30/12/2023 18:39

I don't know if I believe or not. I really wouldn't believe at all because so many things don't seem to add up but I've actually seen one. If only I had seen it then I'd just put it down to my own Imagination but it was also seen by a friend.

GreenAppleCrumble · 30/12/2023 13:27

*The difficulty with this is that people say more than “I believe in…”.

They say “this castle is haunted”, “I can tell your future, for £50”, “I can contact your dead loved one”, “I can tell your past because I’m psychic”, “I knew your mum was ill because I’m telepathic”, “my house was ransacked by a poltergeist”, “the ouija board put me in touch with a Victorian murderer”, and so on. And, of course, “ghosts are real”.*

Mmmm. It’s about judgement, isn’t it? It depends who is claiming what. If your position is ‘I will openly reject any information that seems to contradict the universe as I know it’, then great! It’s probably not going to do you any harm. But if I would rather take each new piece of evidence (yes, I’m calling people’s testimonies ‘evidence’ 😱) as an individual case for consideration, then that’s my look-out, I guess. I’m pretty confident in my judgment and am happy to take that stance.

I’m confident enough, for example, that I’m not going to part with £50 if someone can claim to contact my departed cat. But I’m also happy to go ‘Wow that’s weird’ if the contents of someone’s kitchen are thoroughly rearranged when the flat’s empty. I’m not going to stake anything on the existence of a ghost, but I’m intrigued.

I’m not at all bothered about you ‘judging’ me! I don’t know who you are. I’m just bringing my perspective to the table and arguing for more open-mindedness than some people are willing to give.

Watchkeys · 30/12/2023 13:00

CurlewKate · 30/12/2023 12:39

@Watchkeys You really aren't prepared to have any sort of discussion, are you. Fair enough.

What's the point of this post?

The truth is that nobody, including science/scientists, knows anything about the paranormal with 100% confidence.

Discuss all you like, it won't make any difference to anything, including the science/scientists. We simply don't know. Anybody who thinks they know, either way, is stating probability/likelihood as fact, which is their prerogative. On that basis, it's a fact that nobody has ever won the lottery, from my perspective. But I can take other perspectives into account, too. You could try it, it's nice!

CurlewKate · 30/12/2023 12:39

@Watchkeys You really aren't prepared to have any sort of discussion, are you. Fair enough.

JazzyJogger · 30/12/2023 12:34

I had a poltergeist in my old house . The next occupant had an identical experience to me , I didn't know her or met her . It was an ex neighbor who never knew of my experience told me what was happening to the new occupant. It was identical to what I experienced. They got a medium in to send it on its way .

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 30/12/2023 12:18

Watchkeys · 30/12/2023 11:23

We all rely on our senses to a large degree. If you saw something inexplicable in the cold light of day I’m willing to bet you’d have a good old think about it. So when people tell me that the inexplicable thing happened to them, I do the same - have a think about it. It’s fine that you don’t- but it doesn’t give you the right to look down on those who stop to consider the paranormal

I think this is it, really. It's the judgement. Most people understand that it's fine to believe whatever you want, but that stepping into the realms of judging those who don't agree with you, is a different matter.

There's a lot of people who didn't believe in the paranormal until something happened to them that they couldn't explain. There's a lot of people who think there might be things going on that humans don't know about. There's a lot of people who think we know everything, so nothing can exist that we don't know about. Nobody has any right to tell anybody else where they should be, according to their own opinion.

Scientists acknowledge that science doesn't know everything, so basing your argument on what science proves doesn't logically follow.

The difficulty with this is that people say more than “I believe in…”.

They say “this castle is haunted”, “I can tell your future, for £50”, “I can contact your dead loved one”, “I can tell your past because I’m psychic”, “I knew your mum was ill because I’m telepathic”, “my house was ransacked by a poltergeist”, “the ouija board put me in touch with a Victorian murderer”, and so on. And, of course, “ghosts are real”.

Once someone makes a material claim it’s testable. If it fails the test, the claim is in doubt. If it fails repeatedly it’s discounted.

If you want to say you have faith, knock yourself out. If you want to say that the paranormal reveals the past or influences or predicts the world, don’t be surprised if others ask for proof and, with no proof, that others tell you you’re, at a minimum, mistaken. If you feel that’s ‘judging’ you there’s nothing I can do about that.

I think we’ve reached that point where you basically repeat “I don’t care what anyone says, I believe in claims of the paranormal and no amount of investigation or thought will change my mind”.