Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To people who believe in ghosts..

358 replies

AnxiousAnniee · 26/12/2023 10:40

I used to believe in ghosts when I was a child but as an adult I don’t. I find that there’s too many things that don’t make sense to me and just aren’t logical. When you actually start thinking about it and what it means to be a ghost, I think it just seems silly. I get that everyone has a different opinion though so I’m really genuinely interested to hear what people believe about the following questions…

  • if ghosts exist and look like the person who has died, how do they walk around and move things without muscles or a brain? How do people hear ghosts giggle and speak if they Dont have a brain or a voice box? If they are just a see through sprit how can they really do this? You can’t move, think, or talk without a brain. And they don’t have a brain or muscles because they are spirits.
  • similarly with moving things around or opening cupboards. First of all why would they do this? Why would a ghost turn a tap on??? For what reason? Secondly if they are so light and see through and can walk through things, how can they pick things up instead of just moving through them?
  • if a ghost is a spirit and someone’s soul, then how come they are always wearing clothes when people claim to have seen them? Clothes don’t die and clothes don’t have souls, so clothes don’t have an afterlife and shouldn’t come back as clothes ghosts. They should all be naked.
  • how come people only ever see ghosts of loved ones and scary Victorian children or soldiers and things? How come no one ever sees a caveman ghost or a chav ghost in trackies? (Again, they shouldn’t really be wearing anything anyway)
  • if ghosts are souls then that means everyone will turn into a ghost when they die. Which means we are currently SWAMPED with ghosts. They’re everywhere. We’re constantly walking through them everywhere we go because that many people have died in the world, we are bombarded with them
  • what about baby ghosts? Babies can’t walk so does that mean that there’s loads of ghost babies just lay on the floor all around us?

I’m not taking the piss here, these are genuine questions that I have asked myself when I believed. And the more I think about it the more I just don’t believe it. However, I’m aware that people still do, so I’d love to hear what you think the answers are to these questions and what you think ghosts actually are, and their purpose?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Watchkeys · 04/01/2024 17:20

@WhatsTheUseOfWorrying

Sorry you're so confused. I don't need you to understand and can't be bothered to try to understand your posts any more!

Happy new year.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 03/01/2024 21:55

Watchkeys · 03/01/2024 21:09

@WhatsTheUseOfWorrying

You could say whether this was accurate or not?

It looked like you were saying that your personal opinion on the truth is less cruel and frightening than other options (such as the speaker's opinion on the truth, or disregarding the truth because empathy has nothing to do with truth

Your statement doesn’t make any sense. It doesn’t show empathy of any sort to say that some experience was or might have been a visitation of the paranormal.

I think you’re confusing the offence that you seem to feel when people disagree with you with empathy for emotional reaction to unsettling experiences. But I can’t be at all sure because what you’re saying is so muddled.

Watchkeys · 03/01/2024 21:09

@WhatsTheUseOfWorrying

You could say whether this was accurate or not?

It looked like you were saying that your personal opinion on the truth is less cruel and frightening than other options (such as the speaker's opinion on the truth, or disregarding the truth because empathy has nothing to do with truth

StillStuckInTheShed · 03/01/2024 21:03

It's always going to be a controversial argument... for me it's as simple as before science and technology was advanced enough to prove the existence of oxygen we had no idea it was a thing. Let alone something so important it kept us alive.

The universe is a marvelous and never ending thing and no doubt there's WAY more to it than what we can physically see or test right now. Who's to say our technolgies aren't yet advanced enough to find 'super natural' evidence?

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 03/01/2024 21:02

I don’t see what else I can do other than ask you to re-read the post I was responding to and my post, both in full.

anotherghoststory · 03/01/2024 20:43

CurlewKate · 31/12/2023 16:46

And just to repeat. I don't think people are usually lying or deluded. I think they are mistaken. Or misinterpreting. Or misinformed.

Well i know what i saw, initially seen by my young daughter, i posted about it earlier in the thread, so i wont repeat.

It doesn't really matter what people believe, it wont change the world.

Watchkeys · 03/01/2024 20:39

Perhaps you could explain more clearly? It looked like you were saying that your personal opinion on the truth is less cruel and frightening than other options (such as the speaker's opinion on the truth, or disregarding the truth because empathy has nothing to do with truth)

Do please correct me... I'm sure you'll be happy to. You seem to know everything with such certainty @WhatsTheUseOfWorrying

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 03/01/2024 18:59

Watchkeys · 03/01/2024 18:57

why would it be a problem to tell them that the experience wasn’t paranormal

Because 'telling the facts as you believe them to be' isn't reassuring. Basic understanding of what they feel is empathic, so if they feel it was paranormal, 'No, it wasn't' is just a bit shitty.

Why have you selectively quoted from my post? You’ve misrepresented what I said and the point at issue.

Watchkeys · 03/01/2024 18:57

why would it be a problem to tell them that the experience wasn’t paranormal

Because 'telling the facts as you believe them to be' isn't reassuring. Basic understanding of what they feel is empathic, so if they feel it was paranormal, 'No, it wasn't' is just a bit shitty.

GrandParade · 02/01/2024 09:36

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 02/01/2024 01:22

If a person is shaken by an experience (I assume you mean a strange one, not a car accident, burglary etc) why would it be a problem to tell them that the experience wasn’t paranormal? Seems to me it would be cruel and frightening to tell someone they’d seen a dead person rather than to tell them (the truth) that it was a natural and harmless experience wrongly understood.

There’s nothing compassionate about a belief in ghosts and the rest of the ‘paranormal’, still less about arguing for that belief.

I’ve noticed this a number of times on here. A poster comes on and describes an experience that they say was terrifying — a heavy weight pinning them to the bed, a hideous creature in their room, a sense of malevolence emanating from it. Someone says, perfectly civilly, ‘Those are classic sleep paralysis symptoms’. There’s almost always, not necessarily from the OP, a resistance from some people, to having a non-supernatural solution offered. Sometimes from the OP, despite claiming to have been terrified by their inexplicable experience.

And I don’t just mean on ‘woo’ threads where the point of the thread is sharing stories.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 02/01/2024 01:22

GreenAppleCrumble · 01/01/2024 17:48

Jeez! I literally said at the time ‘I know you don’t mean it like this but…’ What’s with the over-sensitivity? Not being believed is a very upsetting thing; can you not see how adopting a blanket ‘I know better than you’ is potentially (at best) condescending or (at worst) an offensive stance to take when engaging with people who’ve been shaken by an experience? You don’t always know best. I think you have massively over-reacted, especially since I immediately apologised. It was churlish of you to fling that back. Anyway, we will have to agree to disagree then.

If a person is shaken by an experience (I assume you mean a strange one, not a car accident, burglary etc) why would it be a problem to tell them that the experience wasn’t paranormal? Seems to me it would be cruel and frightening to tell someone they’d seen a dead person rather than to tell them (the truth) that it was a natural and harmless experience wrongly understood.

There’s nothing compassionate about a belief in ghosts and the rest of the ‘paranormal’, still less about arguing for that belief.

GreenAppleCrumble · 01/01/2024 17:48

CurlewKate · 01/01/2024 17:04

@GreenAppleCrumble "I apologise if I offended you." You didn't "offend" me. You were just surprisingly rude for what I thought was an interesting discussion. But if, as you say "the truth is that the very stance of the ardent disbeliever can be quite offensive in itself to the person seeking to be believed"
then the sort of discussion I would choose to have is completely impossible. Particularly as believers seem to have no compunction at all about being rude to non believers.

Jeez! I literally said at the time ‘I know you don’t mean it like this but…’ What’s with the over-sensitivity? Not being believed is a very upsetting thing; can you not see how adopting a blanket ‘I know better than you’ is potentially (at best) condescending or (at worst) an offensive stance to take when engaging with people who’ve been shaken by an experience? You don’t always know best. I think you have massively over-reacted, especially since I immediately apologised. It was churlish of you to fling that back. Anyway, we will have to agree to disagree then.

CurlewKate · 01/01/2024 17:04

@GreenAppleCrumble "I apologise if I offended you." You didn't "offend" me. You were just surprisingly rude for what I thought was an interesting discussion. But if, as you say "the truth is that the very stance of the ardent disbeliever can be quite offensive in itself to the person seeking to be believed"
then the sort of discussion I would choose to have is completely impossible. Particularly as believers seem to have no compunction at all about being rude to non believers.

GreenAppleCrumble · 01/01/2024 12:47

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 01/01/2024 12:37

OK, at the risk of repetition there really aren’t any ghosts caught on camera, if by ‘ghosts’ you mean something not phoney or unconvincing.

You might as well say there are lots of photos of fairies or the Loch Ness Monster.

That’s why I put ‘ghosts’ in inverted commas 😐

The point is, anything can be made to look like a ghost on camera. How would you tell?

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 01/01/2024 12:37

GreenAppleCrumble · 01/01/2024 12:29

The cause of fleeting experiences would these days likely be on camera. Someone upthread said that hospitals have lots of ghosts. But not one caught on a video or phone camera? Really?

There are thousands of ‘ghosts’ caught on camera! Have a Google! I think we’ve already been here upthread - video evidence means nothing at all to anyone these days.

As far as your thermometer analogy goes - yes, you are relying on the thermometer first and foremost. But a fallible human reads it. Using their eyes. The same eyes you won’t believe in other scenarios! Yes, of course - you’re right that you can double, triple check, so your eyes are not the only eyes being believed. But you can’t do that with a fleeting experience, can you? It’s just not comparable! You can’t say ‘OMG I just saw a figure, clear as day, standing by the door but now it’s gone - can you check for me?’

I think the scientific method actually hampers some people in this way; not everything can be measured under lab conditions.

OK, at the risk of repetition there really aren’t any ghosts caught on camera, if by ‘ghosts’ you mean something not phoney or unconvincing.

You might as well say there are lots of photos of fairies or the Loch Ness Monster.

decionsdecisions62 · 01/01/2024 12:36

Why don't you both beg to differ and go on your merry new year ways and let others take up the discussion?

GreenAppleCrumble · 01/01/2024 12:29

The cause of fleeting experiences would these days likely be on camera. Someone upthread said that hospitals have lots of ghosts. But not one caught on a video or phone camera? Really?

There are thousands of ‘ghosts’ caught on camera! Have a Google! I think we’ve already been here upthread - video evidence means nothing at all to anyone these days.

As far as your thermometer analogy goes - yes, you are relying on the thermometer first and foremost. But a fallible human reads it. Using their eyes. The same eyes you won’t believe in other scenarios! Yes, of course - you’re right that you can double, triple check, so your eyes are not the only eyes being believed. But you can’t do that with a fleeting experience, can you? It’s just not comparable! You can’t say ‘OMG I just saw a figure, clear as day, standing by the door but now it’s gone - can you check for me?’

I think the scientific method actually hampers some people in this way; not everything can be measured under lab conditions.

GreenAppleCrumble · 01/01/2024 12:22

CurlewKate · 01/01/2024 12:15

@GreenAppleCrumble "I know you don’t mean it to sound smug and condescending- but it does come across like that when you suggest that a cursory look around would clear up most of these standout, life-changing experiences!"

I wasn't suggesting that. I only mentioned my Green Man because it was a real experience I had. Sometimes the explanation is obvious-sometimes it isn't and needs deeper investigation. I my case a cursory look round solved it-but it was a long time-a least a year before anyone thought to do it. And, actually, it was a pretty stand out, life changing experience for 4 year old me-it made me the sceptic I am today!

Incidentally-I have worked really hard at being polite and respectful on here. I think calling me smug and condescending is incredibly, outrageously unfair.

I apologise if I’ve offended you. In my defence, I wasn’t calling you smug and condescending- but I was pointing out that that position (i.e. Now, look, if you’ll just try I’m sure there’s an obvious enough explanation) is by its very nature rather condescending; it’s suggesting to the person who’s tearing their hair out over something really troubling that they’re just the equivalent of a small child with a vivid imagination…

Again, not wanting to offend you, but the truth is that the very stance of the ardent disbeliever can be quite offensive in itself to the person seeking to be believed (not talking about me here).

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 01/01/2024 12:18

But you’re not trusting your senses. You’re trusting the thermometer. If the result is unexpected, repeat it. Use a different thermometer. Ask someone else to read the thermometer(s). If the result is still unexpected, and all other variables are excludable, that’s the result.

The cause of fleeting experiences would these days likely be on camera. Someone upthread said that hospitals have lots of ghosts. But not one caught on a video or phone camera? Really?

No recording of a ‘real’ poltergeist’s activity?

It’s quite difficult for something in public not to be recorded these days, and often enough in private places. I never saw a ghost on You’ve Been Framed.

CurlewKate · 01/01/2024 12:15

@GreenAppleCrumble "I know you don’t mean it to sound smug and condescending- but it does come across like that when you suggest that a cursory look around would clear up most of these standout, life-changing experiences!"

I wasn't suggesting that. I only mentioned my Green Man because it was a real experience I had. Sometimes the explanation is obvious-sometimes it isn't and needs deeper investigation. I my case a cursory look round solved it-but it was a long time-a least a year before anyone thought to do it. And, actually, it was a pretty stand out, life changing experience for 4 year old me-it made me the sceptic I am today!

Incidentally-I have worked really hard at being polite and respectful on here. I think calling me smug and condescending is incredibly, outrageously unfair.

GreenAppleCrumble · 01/01/2024 12:05

@WhatsTheUseOfWorrying

But every one of your examples involves the human senses. You look at the speedometer- it says 30 mph. You take that as fact. Someone else looks at her porch at sees a man standing there. She believes her eyes too, just like you did.

I think I’ve asked before - where do you draw the line? How many people have to verify what it says in your speedometer? How many people have to look at the thermometer? In reality, probably only one. More complex medical cases will require more investigation, more data. I get that all that. You can have your charts and test results etc etc.

But a fleeting experience can’t be subject to these tests - it just can’t! But it’s not wildly unreasonable to trust the same senses that allowed you to read the thermometer when they tell you something you weren’t expecting.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 01/01/2024 11:50

GreenAppleCrumble · 01/01/2024 11:32

If there is no good evidence of improbable things (people’s subjective experiences are not good evidence) then I think they should be considered bogus until firmly proven.

I can see what you mean here. But subjective experience is our only experience. Ever. No one experiences the world in any other way. At some point we have to trust our own senses.

There we differ.

If I want to know how fast I’m driving I look at the speedometer. If I’m doing 35 in a 30 zone I can’t defend a fine on the basis that I felt I was doing 30 if the camera or radar gun says otherwise.

If I want to know my temperature I use a thermometer. I may be a little hot or alarmingly hot.

If I want to know how good my vision is, my optician can run tests.

If I have pain and a doctor wants to see my innards they take an X-ray (and use other technology). It might be bad, it might be benign, whatever I’ve convinced myself.

If I think a room has gone suddenly cold, a figure has walked though a wall, voices are being heard or objects are moving of their own accord, etc, there are a range of instruments independent of our senses that could record these effects, the environment they’re happening in, speed of effect, duration, and so on. And we can analyse these recordings and compare them.

Plus we need explanations of mechanism, i.e. satisfactory, coherent theory.

The fact that someone - better, a number of different people - needs to see or hear the results or has to do the reading and thinking has got nothing to do with the techniques of investigation and explanation.

GreenAppleCrumble · 01/01/2024 11:32

If there is no good evidence of improbable things (people’s subjective experiences are not good evidence) then I think they should be considered bogus until firmly proven.

I can see what you mean here. But subjective experience is our only experience. Ever. No one experiences the world in any other way. At some point we have to trust our own senses.

GreenAppleCrumble · 01/01/2024 11:29

@CurlewKate

This covers the vast majority of events. Proper investigation leads to rational explanations.

I’ll have to pick you up on this bit… You objected to my use of the word ‘investigate’ when referring to Danny Robins- but you’ve applied it here to the act of your mother taking a quick look at a wall! By contrast, Robins flew to Rome, made repeated applications to access the apartment belonging to the Catholic Church etc.

I think it’s a bit unfair to suggest that people don’t properly investigate their experiences. Obviously some won’t. But those people who are deeply troubled and baffled really, really do. I know you don’t mean it to sound smug and condescending- but it does come across like that when you suggest that a cursory look around would clear up most of these standout, life-changing experiences!

Swipe left for the next trending thread