Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed with SILs decision re new baby.

885 replies

ankara · 26/12/2023 09:02

Respecting that all parents are quite within their rights to determine interaction between others and their babies, I am very disappointed and a bit 🙄 at SILs decision to put up a big sign at baby's cradle saying no touching , no lifting, no kissing.
There are no medical reasons for this. Baby is three weeks old.
None of the family have been allowed to do the above unless baby has been handed to family to give a bottle or r change baby.
I understand; that this is their first and is of course most precious but we are all a bit Confused and also disappointed as we love babies and we're so looking forward to cuddles .
Brother just goes along with her.
Is this a new thing? My kids are nearly teens now and I've not seen this before .

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Yazzi · 27/12/2023 22:18

I don't think it's any coincidence that the rise of "my baby my rules" has totally coincided with the rise of "there's no more village/ community/ support" and it's sad that new parents don't realise that these things are linked. I have a sibling and their partner who were like this. As a consequence I had zero relationship with my now 4 year old niece, and so do my kids which was devastating (no holding/ touching/ kissing allowed until she was over 3 at which point it was too scary for her anyway).

I know people will say "oh that's their right" and sure, they exercised it, but now their child is incredibly shy and socially unconfident and inappropriate. Meanwhile the parents complain about being isolated etc.

I think when you're a new parent the protective instincts are so high- I have a number of very young kids so remember it well. But part of being a parent is learning to make judgment of when to rein in the paranoia so you don't infect your kids with it. Part of reining it in is making early efforts to build your children a community and network of trustworthy, loving adults around them. In modern parenting, that has been lost.

LumiB · 27/12/2023 22:14

5128gap · 27/12/2023 22:10

Putting up a sign is over dramatic and rude. If she doesn't want anyone touching the baby, she should just say so. I think its a shame for all concerned though when a mother is so controlling and treats her baby as her possession to share out at her whim (and it is that, rather than caution, as its apparantly fine for relatives to hold the child to feed and change it for her!) but it does seem to be a popular bit of power for some these days.

Or maybe she has told people and still don't listen...after all op might be one of those people since she is moaning about it.

Its her child she is allowed to decided what is right for her child not you or anyone else.

sunglassesonthetable · 27/12/2023 22:12

It's a child not a toy for you and your family to pass around and play with.

Yes because holding a newborn is treating it like a ' toy '.

5128gap · 27/12/2023 22:10

Putting up a sign is over dramatic and rude. If she doesn't want anyone touching the baby, she should just say so. I think its a shame for all concerned though when a mother is so controlling and treats her baby as her possession to share out at her whim (and it is that, rather than caution, as its apparantly fine for relatives to hold the child to feed and change it for her!) but it does seem to be a popular bit of power for some these days.

Toomuchfun · 27/12/2023 22:07

You sound entitled and I totally understand why sil has done this.
It's rsv and cold time. Kissing - coldsores can kill newborns.
Back off, stop judging and support a new mum. It's a child not a toy for you and your family to pass around and play with.

sunglassesonthetable · 27/12/2023 22:04

It’s quite amusing to see people declaring it so ridiculous and claiming it has zero medical basis while ignoring the fact that some people have been told when leaving UK hospitals to do it,

Has OP's SiL been told to do it?

LightDrizzle · 27/12/2023 22:01

So many people on Mumsnet who think the placenta and breast milk provide immunity to all viruses and bacteria out there 🫣

Honestly are these the people visiting newborns with colds? Because the baby can’t catch it because of its immunity superpower? Maybe all newborns need signs! 😂 The world is more full of fuckwits than we thought.

And we’ve had a NICU nurse asserting newborns benefit from exposure to pathogens, although she hasn’t returned with any links to published research or medical advice to back that up, unlike the medical advice other posters have linked to that states the opposite. I really hope this “NICU nurse” is like my friend’s SIL who “used to be a nurse” and is a self proclaimed expert on all matters medical, except she wasn’t a nurse, she was a ward auxiliary for few months in the early ‘90s and has no medical training.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 27/12/2023 22:00

It’s quite amusing to see people declaring it so ridiculous and claiming it has zero medical basis while ignoring the fact that some people have been told when leaving UK hospitals to do it, and Ireland has basically told all parents of young babies to cocoon them because of the danger of RSV and high numbers of covid.

Oh to be so arrogant.

EarlGreywithLemon · 27/12/2023 21:59

Several of my friends’ winter born babies ended up in hospital with RSV bronchiolitis. One of them was so ill that the family were told to say goodbye as he likely wasn’t going to make it. He recovered, but his mother and grandmother can’t talk about it to this day, 10 years later, without crying. His mother said it completely changed the way she parents, for the rest of her life. My 16 month old was in hospital in the High Dependency Unit this autumn with Rhinovirus bronchiolitis - yes, rhinovirus, so common cold. It was the most frightening experience of my entire life. Believe me, when you see your tiny child fighting for breath, completely terrified in a CPAP mask, and the medical team start talking to you about ventilation, you stop being so blasé about these things. He was also in hospital with an adenovirus at 5 weeks old, but that was thankfully more of a precaution. So - I’m with her.

Also, I really found the post about women making too much fuss during pregnancy and too many C Sections extremely distasteful. Pregnancy makes huge demands on the body and women shouldn’t have to just get on with it if they are struggling. Great for you if you felt well in your pregnancy, but many don’t.

As for C sections, I lost 2.9l of blood, had a third degree tear and lost the ability to use my bladder for a while after a vaginal birth. I will always fight tooth and nail for any woman’s right to have an ELCS for whatever reason - even if it’s just because she doesn’t fancy the risk of birth injuries!!

Magicunicornpower · 27/12/2023 21:55

Sign sounds rude and ridiculous to me. If she's so anxious and precious about it don't invite people around. Also, holding a newborn when offered doesn't seem to be a problem to me, but kissing them seems really unnecessary and more dangerous to the baby. I would probably mention that to visitors. She will freak out when the baby starts nursery

sunglassesonthetable · 27/12/2023 21:55

the public health advice is to essentially cocoon the child up to six months at this stage.

I thought it was to keep newborns away from people with colds or flu. Sensible enough advice that most people follow.

sunglassesonthetable · 27/12/2023 21:49

I think it says more about the baby's DM/DF than anything else. Most people are not so extreme tbh.

Only read it on MN.

CountessWindyBottom · 27/12/2023 21:49

OP, you're being completely and utterly unreasonable and then have added lots of nasty jibes about SIL as well. Looks to me like you were looking for a pile-on against your SIL to validate your own feelings.

Well done to her is what I say! Obviously an excellent mother so far with her child's health at the very forefront of her mind. There are multiple cases of extremely poorly infants in ICU across the country because of RSV and the public health advice is to essentially cocoon the child up to six months at this stage.

You need to cop yourself on.

Judijudi · 27/12/2023 21:46

Seems to be new thing and I don’t get it either

DisabledDemon · 27/12/2023 21:43

Quite. My husband ended up with life-long cold sores because of an over-enthusiastic auntie.

sunglassesonthetable · 27/12/2023 21:41

Agree with you OP I'd be disappointed

In my world people hold babies. As long as baby is happy. It's a pleasure and part of life.

SiL has every right to put up her sign 🙄 but I bet she doesn't for baby No2. PFB to the max.

Pennypop81 · 27/12/2023 21:39

I would be disappointed as well. Maybe she’s had trouble with someone not listening to her. It’s her baby and maybe she will be a little bit more relaxed the next time you see her.

TulipinUK · 27/12/2023 21:33

Completely bonkers! Want a baby who lives in a gold cage, fine but imv this is ridiculous.

Chunkychips23 · 27/12/2023 21:31

mayorofcasterbridge · 27/12/2023 18:35

I don't think it's "entitled" to want a cuddle with your new niece or nephew.

Surely most adults are sensible enough to not wake a baby, to not hold a baby if they're not well themselves, to wash their hands and not to kiss them?

You’d think that, but as it turns out, a lot of adults aren’t that sensible. We politely asked relatives to not kiss our baby and to wash hands - might as well have asked people to do a backflip! My vulnerable newborn caught a cold, which set him back massively.

You can want a cuddle, but you’re not entitled to one no.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 27/12/2023 21:23

Savedpassword · 27/12/2023 21:11

What were infant mortality rates 15-20 years ago?

5.4 per 1000 live births in 2003. Compared to 3.8 in 2022

Given most people on here are older than 15-20 the rates were even higher when we were all babies - 12.5 in 1980, 18 in 1970 and 23 in 1960.

As I said previously, my great granny lost 10 of her 15 children. Infant death was incredibly common. So not everyone turned out just fine.

Bookworm39 · 27/12/2023 21:17

Well we are still in the middle of a pandemic - only the emergency phase has been declared over, not the whole thing. Why on earth would you want a newborn exposed to covid? I have long covid 2 years after being pretty ill with my one brush with covid, and my completely healthy 16 year old had medical issues with it and and also long covid after. It's not just a cold, and I'm in better health than others I know - amazingly as I still feel awful.

I absolutely took the same stand for my sons nearly 20 years ago as I had Strep B during both pregnancies which can be awful for babies to get, so I had to have intravenous antibiotics during labour. Probably family thought I was odd, but I didn't give a stuff. I was protecting my children. I was quite happy for people to handle them both if they'd washed their hands and they were well. I didn't go and see a relative having chemo if I was ill as I wanted them healthy, why on earth wouldn't I want the same for my children when they were newborns? And they've hardly grown up with anxious parents, they've both done loads despite one having significant SEN and complex medical needs. Turns out his rare condition can have significant complications if they get viruses early - though I didn't know that at the time. Good job I made my rules and didn't have everyone putting him at risk because of their own selfish wants!

Strawberrylacess · 27/12/2023 21:14

My son was in hospital this year with RSV as a robust 2 year old.

He was in for 3 days on an oxygen mask.

Many of the very tiny babies ended up on ventilators.

It's no joke, shame on the people on here taking the piss.

Thistlewoman · 27/12/2023 21:11

Your SIL is right. Its not all about you and what you (or anyone else for that matter) wants. Just because YOU and any/all random relatives/friends see her baby as public property doesn't make it so. Baby isn't a pass-the-parcel, and Mum has every right to decide who gets to pick up/hold/cuddle/breathe on her baby.
YABU-suck it up, buttercup.

Savedpassword · 27/12/2023 21:11

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 27/12/2023 21:08

We were all handled as babies and turned out just fine

have you ever looked at historic infant mortality rates?

What were infant mortality rates 15-20 years ago?

Oldgardener · 27/12/2023 21:10

Well, someone asked the internet. This is what some people on the internet (me) think. Like some other people are saying, it is a bit weird to put a sign up and suggests significant anxiety which is likely to play itself out in other ways as the child grows and perhaps lead to other problems as these anxieties are transmitted to the child. A bit of nuance there for someone who thought I couldn’t manage that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread