Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed with SILs decision re new baby.

885 replies

ankara · 26/12/2023 09:02

Respecting that all parents are quite within their rights to determine interaction between others and their babies, I am very disappointed and a bit 🙄 at SILs decision to put up a big sign at baby's cradle saying no touching , no lifting, no kissing.
There are no medical reasons for this. Baby is three weeks old.
None of the family have been allowed to do the above unless baby has been handed to family to give a bottle or r change baby.
I understand; that this is their first and is of course most precious but we are all a bit Confused and also disappointed as we love babies and we're so looking forward to cuddles .
Brother just goes along with her.
Is this a new thing? My kids are nearly teens now and I've not seen this before .

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Liveafr · 28/12/2023 09:16

If people are so bothered about protecting a baby, breastfeeding is a better thing to focus efforts on than telling people they can't cuddle baby.

And breastfeeding is more likely to be successfully established if the mum is calm and relatively rested, rather than stressed, if she can hold her baby skin to skin most of the time, rather than having him passed around and coming back smelling other people's perfume, if she can put the baby to the breast on demand target than having MIL insisting on feeding him or auntie asking "are you feeding him AGAIN?", if she can focus on latching him calmly rather than having an audience, if she can put the baby to the breast at the first hunger cue, rather than when he is crying and difficult to latch, so thanks for pointing out why cuddling other people's baby when they are the weeks old is not in their best interest.

JayJayj · 28/12/2023 08:30

Reading your replies, I completely understand why she has the sign.
You don’t need to understand why, you don’t need to know her medical reasons.
Your brother was using the word “we” to show he his on his wife’s side and your mum pulling him up on it shows more reason why THEY have their boundaries.

No kissing babies should be obvious but apparently people do think it’s ok so need to be told before hand.

Breast feeding can be really difficult for some and if there is a lack of support it can make it so much harder. Not all areas have that support. She probably already feels awful and guilty about it and doesn’t need others opinion on it.

she could have postnatal depression/ anxiety and doing what she needs to do to help that is fine.

I was fit and healthy before my pregnancy and had to be signed off work from 6 months because I couldn’t walk any more due to round ligament pain and how swollen I was due to water retention. It happens. Every pregnancy is different and just because it’s not what you experienced doesn’t lesson what she has gone through.

LaDamaDeElche · 28/12/2023 08:24

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 27/12/2023 21:23

5.4 per 1000 live births in 2003. Compared to 3.8 in 2022

Given most people on here are older than 15-20 the rates were even higher when we were all babies - 12.5 in 1980, 18 in 1970 and 23 in 1960.

As I said previously, my great granny lost 10 of her 15 children. Infant death was incredibly common. So not everyone turned out just fine.

Edited

Infant mortality rates in Spain are 2.011 deaths per 1000 live births, where it’s culturally normal here for very small babies to be held by the wider family, so how does one explain that?

MojoDaysxx · 28/12/2023 08:19

Fair play to your SIL. She protects her baby and she reduces her own stress as well.

Justforxmas2023 · 28/12/2023 08:15

Hopingtobeaparent · 28/12/2023 08:01

Agreed! I respect the boundaries if some family members are just helping themselves Willy nilly like picking up a cat, however, babies need to be exposed to germs and microbes from others for their immune system!! That’s how it builds. Also good for relatives to bond too. Not a good start, but she’s the mother… and no, babies are more robust than people think, and yes, they need their head to be supported etc of course, but most people know and are capable of doing that. Think SiL has lots of first baby anxiety, (and maybe some underlying OCD too? Or PND?)

You’re right about needing to be exposed to bugs in order to develop immunity but this does NOT apply in the first few months of life. A newborn baby has an underdeveloped immune system and what manifests as a cold in an adult can be life threatening. A newborn baby is NOT robust.

RandomButtons · 28/12/2023 08:12

Benibidibici · 28/12/2023 07:32

New babies are just so precious and fragile and germs really are too big for them

Oh ffs its rubbish!! My baby was 6 weeks prem & weighed sod all and was delightedly passed round both our families.

If people are so bothered about protecting a baby, breastfeeding is a better thing to focus efforts on than telling people they can't cuddle baby.

So you were lucky. My baby was born at 40+13, no health problems at birth or after, proper chonker, exclusively breast fed, never lost birth weight, and ended up in paediatric ICU at 4 months old intubated, tube fed, on a ventilator machine for 4 days because someone with the common cold kissed him and he caught RSV. Worst week of my life.

peacockshrimp · 28/12/2023 08:11

it’s about the safety of the baby and what the new parents are comfortable with. your enjoyment of baby cuddles is not that important 🤷🏻‍♀️you wait until baby is 3 month+ to bond.
this can be difficult, especially for people who has babies pre-covid, but please remember how you treat her through this period will have a huge impact on your relationship with SIL, and brother.

is the sign a bit much? maybe. but a blanket statement is easier than having to verbalise and deal with reactions from each individual person.

ruby1957 · 28/12/2023 08:11

One thing I don't understand is why so many relatives, friends want to hold the baby when it is newborn anyway.
I come from a fairly undemonstrative family - none of the kissing and embraces that characterised interaction before Covid. It does not mean we don't care for the other person - just personal space.

Maybe I was 'lucky' but when my son was born in the 1970s he spent many weeks in hospital because he was premature - so no-one at all got to be close enough to even hold him except myself.

It seems to me very immature of relatives to think that a small baby is a suitable target for hugs and kisses.

But I agree that a blanket verbal warning to all visitors is more friendly than a notice. ;

Hopingtobeaparent · 28/12/2023 08:01

Agreed! I respect the boundaries if some family members are just helping themselves Willy nilly like picking up a cat, however, babies need to be exposed to germs and microbes from others for their immune system!! That’s how it builds. Also good for relatives to bond too. Not a good start, but she’s the mother… and no, babies are more robust than people think, and yes, they need their head to be supported etc of course, but most people know and are capable of doing that. Think SiL has lots of first baby anxiety, (and maybe some underlying OCD too? Or PND?)

Greymustard · 28/12/2023 07:51

I feel I have to come back and post on this again, because it has buzzed around my head all night.

People declaring lunacy and silliness in modern parenting - shame on you. I thought mumsnet was supposed to be somewhere we could raise other mothers up. It's her baby. If she doesn't want people slobbering over it then she should be allowed to say. Is a sign a bit blunt and clumsy? Yes. But now you know how she feels, so good for her.

I spent the first three years of my sons life sat next to him in hospitals, often intensive care, often on a ventilator. He was very small and very sick, and sadly even nice relatives are often dicks about wanting to cuddle a baby. "I won't stay long, I've got a stinker".... "Just a quick cuddle because I think I'm coming down with something".... "To be fair I felt like shit when I visited last week, but couldn't miss the chance for a cuddle'" I have heard every line.

At times I wasn't even "allowed" to hold him myself because even handling was deemed by the nurses to be exhausting for him.

That was more than 20 years ago, and despite me making a weak attempt to shield him from people who selfishly wanted a cuddle, he has grown up to have good relationships with his family.

We were lucky that he survived, many kids like him did not, and there was no obvious reason, no genetics, nothing to indicate why he was the one who got so sick. It was only when he was much older that they discovered he had no discernable immune system to respond to anything. Great Auntie Nora with a questionable cold sore brewing can't see whether a three week old has a good enough immine system when she lunges in for a cuddle....

This narrative about it being good for the baby.... its good for the newborn to be held by its mother, not every member of the family including snotty uncle Frank who always has huge boogers hanging out of his nose.

This is just the first few precious weeks, and she is full of hormones, probably has sore tits, and still needs to pee while holding a shower head pointed at her fanny...

Give her a break!

I have no doubt that when this kid is bringing home weekly snot and various other "infestations" from nursery and school you will be able to cuddle as much as you like, and the kid will be at a stage where they are able to build relationships, and return your snotty favours from when they were a newborn and you gave them a gift you didn't even know you were brewing.

We need to be more supportive of new mums at this time. It's emotional and exhausting and if she wants you to give space, then give it. I wish people had given it to me.

Justforxmas2023 · 28/12/2023 07:37

Benibidibici · 28/12/2023 07:32

New babies are just so precious and fragile and germs really are too big for them

Oh ffs its rubbish!! My baby was 6 weeks prem & weighed sod all and was delightedly passed round both our families.

If people are so bothered about protecting a baby, breastfeeding is a better thing to focus efforts on than telling people they can't cuddle baby.

Just because you threw caution to the wind and decided to let family pass around your tiny baby doesn’t mean others are happy to take that risk.

As PPs have commented, unfortunately it is RSV season and newborns are especially vulnerable to this and cold sores as well as numerous other pathogens as they have an underdeveloped immune system.

Breastfeeding doesn’t protect against everything - only those germs mum has been exposed and has developed immunity to herself so won’t be effective against new strains.

To use an analogy, you’d be fine 99% of the time to not wear a seatbelt while driving but wouldn’t you rather wear one just in case?

Benibidibici · 28/12/2023 07:32

New babies are just so precious and fragile and germs really are too big for them

Oh ffs its rubbish!! My baby was 6 weeks prem & weighed sod all and was delightedly passed round both our families.

If people are so bothered about protecting a baby, breastfeeding is a better thing to focus efforts on than telling people they can't cuddle baby.

Ilovecleaning · 28/12/2023 07:26

Is it possible that these precautions are aimed at one particular relative who might overstep the mark, take over and be a general PITA? If not, you will just have to accept your SIL’s decision.

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 28/12/2023 07:22

Wish i had the balls to do what your SIL did when my son was born.

People have NO respect for newborns and boundaries of the family. They feel entitled to kiss, cuddle, not pass back when crying etc and it’s so stressful to navigate when you are fresh out the hospital, sleep deprived etc.

Three weeks ago, we were in hospital with RSV with my son (now 17 months) who was on oxygen. It was terrifying and something I hope we never have to go through again. Luckily, he made a quick recovery and was out after 3 days but sadly, it wasn’t the same story for the 2 week old baby who was in the next room to us.

Justforxmas2023 · 28/12/2023 06:22

florasmama · 27/12/2023 23:15

I mean, the sign sounds a bit extreme but I completely understand SIL wanting to make her boundaries clear. As a fairly new mother to my first child (4 month old DD), I understand the overwhelming anxiety that you feel when you have a baby (first ever) as I would have thought you would too.

You might be disappointed but you are not entitled to hold the baby. The baby does not benefit at all at that tender age and only needs close interaction with their parents/primary caregivers. It may not have been this way 15 odd years ago but times have changed. As always, further research has happened since then and also we are living in a post COVID world now.

The only person who will benefit from that interaction is you. Don’t make it about yourself at this early stage. SIL is probably anxious and knackered and in need of support and understanding at this time. It already feels like a lifetime ago for me, albeit it only a few months, but that first month is exhausting. Truly exhausting. Nobody can ever make you understand what it feels like to first become a parent, you only know when you become one (again, as you must well know) and Jesus christ, I’ve only recently gotten over the exhaustion of it all myself. I feel for her.

This is a very sensible, thoughtful post. I totally agree.

Ukrainebaby23 · 28/12/2023 05:57

Imo it's about control, and that's whats different now, people want to control their boundaries and their babies boundaries.
However, I don't think this is the great thing some people believe as my baby, now 17m really thrived from being held by others especially as we are remote from family and friends. Even as a diddly he enjoyed comfort and it never occurred to me to stop family holding him. He is of course very opinionated and will say quite clearly if he doesnt want to be held. Ie he makes his own boundaries, he defo doesn't need me to make them for him.

Justforxmas2023 · 28/12/2023 05:18

florasmama · 28/12/2023 00:42

@Katypp I was a new parent to a 2 week old baby and an aggressive looking rash appeared on her. Her temperament seemed to change quite quickly too. So um, yeah? God I now remember why I rarely post on forums. You follow your rules and I'll follow mine.

Honestly wouldn’t bother with replying to this person. She is all over this thread talking about new mums being on power trips and behaving like princesses for wanting to protect their babies.

You obviously did absolutely the right thing taking your little one to A+E to get checked and were doing what any sensible, loving caregiver would do.

Mamasperspective · 28/12/2023 04:16

You have no entitlement to someone else's baby. It's flu season, covid is going round again and adults can be silent carriers. Be grateful she is letting you visit and stop questioning her decisions as a mother - this is her baby, not yours, you have no automatic right to hold LO. You need to better manage your expectations and stop being unreasonable with this mothers (very sensible) boundaries.

Lavender14 · 28/12/2023 04:15

sunglassesonthetable · 27/12/2023 22:04

It’s quite amusing to see people declaring it so ridiculous and claiming it has zero medical basis while ignoring the fact that some people have been told when leaving UK hospitals to do it,

Has OP's SiL been told to do it?

This is a good question? Op are you in Ireland? The current guidance is for all new parents to shield babies at the moment because of the increased risk of respiratory problems due to what's circulating rifely at the moment. I can't think of anything worse than trying to navigate having visitors and wanting to see and feel connected to people but also feeling massive responsibility to shield and protect your new baby from illnesses people may not even know that they are carrying yet. Even outside of having ds and worrying about germs for him, I had a section and was really worried about getting a cold and needing to cough. You'd be amazed at the number of people who came to visit slightly under the weather or who said "oh I know you're not meant to kiss wee babies but" while kissing ds on the head. People I genuinely thought would have known better. People really do lose all sense of themselves when presented with a cute baby because the natural response is to want to hold them.

Ponderingwindow · 28/12/2023 04:08

The sign shouldn’t be necessary. If the baby is on the cradle, no one should be reaching their hands in without permission.

not wanting people to potentially upset the baby with random poking is by not the same as saying no baby cuddles.

RandomButtons · 28/12/2023 04:03

For everyone who can’t get thier head around it yet. RSV is otherwise known as the common cold. If you’d had a baby in ICU on a ventilator you’d get it.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-67828720

“Hospital admissions from a winter virus could be reduced by more than 80% if babies are given a single dose of a new antibody treatment, a study says.
Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) usually causes mild, cold-like symptoms, but can lead to bronchiolitis and pneumonia.
More than 30,000 under fives are hospitalised with RSV in the UK. Resulting in 20 to 30 deaths.”

A boy using an inhaler to stop coughing

RSV: Jab for winter virus could cut baby hospitalisations by 80%, study says

More than 30,000 UK children under five are hospitalised with respiratory syncytial virus a year.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-67828720

Mommywomb · 28/12/2023 03:40

pictoosh · 26/12/2023 09:09

See now, as far as I'm aware new babies have been passed around for inspection/cuddles since forever. Most seem to weather 'big germs' ok. I don't think they ARE that fragile are they?

The baby is just three weeks so no vaccinations as well- yes! They are very fragile at this age!

and think if op and her children plus all others would be hugging and snuggling the baby taking turns- SIL has guts and us right!
probably a sign is a bit much but May be not if she has to tell that to 15 people in a day etc.

llizzie · 28/12/2023 03:36

I see nothing wrong with the sign. It states clearly that the baby is not to be touched by visitors. No one knows what the visitors touched before! What would you do, put up a sign, which applies to everyone, no questions invited, or ask each visitor where they have been and to clean their hands before touching the baby?

It saves visitors asking repeatedly to hold the baby. Some visitors can be very insistent, especially those who think they have first dibs at the baby. It saves arguments, and is just what would be in a hospital. Perhaps the mother saw similar in a baby unit?

BlueSelpress · 28/12/2023 01:41

I'm due soon and I'm doing the same as your SIL. I won't be putting a sign up but my husband and I will definitely be telling everyone we need time, space and they won't be able to touch or kissing our newborn. Obviously this won't the case forever, it's only for a short period of time. Don't take offence.

Redrosesandsunsets · 28/12/2023 01:27

Y’all know that babies can get herpes from your kissing? The kissing and cuddling you want with newborns is to satisfy yourselves. Relax. Let the parents do what they want and quit imposing on others what y’all want.