Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed with SILs decision re new baby.

885 replies

ankara · 26/12/2023 09:02

Respecting that all parents are quite within their rights to determine interaction between others and their babies, I am very disappointed and a bit 🙄 at SILs decision to put up a big sign at baby's cradle saying no touching , no lifting, no kissing.
There are no medical reasons for this. Baby is three weeks old.
None of the family have been allowed to do the above unless baby has been handed to family to give a bottle or r change baby.
I understand; that this is their first and is of course most precious but we are all a bit Confused and also disappointed as we love babies and we're so looking forward to cuddles .
Brother just goes along with her.
Is this a new thing? My kids are nearly teens now and I've not seen this before .

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
llizzie · 28/12/2023 16:28

hellsBells246 · Today 10:51

Babies survived for millions of years with wider family giving them cuddles and touching them!!
Show quote history

They did indeed, hellsbells246, but until the 20th century, when people became more knowledgeable, babies died in their thousands, especially in Victorian times, and we only have DNA since the 1990s. Technology only came to the fore in the 21st century, and we are still discovering new things.

llizzie · 28/12/2023 16:21

I was disabled by a virus. I went to bed well one night, but when I got up the next morning, my legs gave way. It was caused by a virus, diagnosed by a spinal tap - with dye they didn't test on me for allergy. I was very ill. I have GBS/CIDP and am on DLA for 30 years. That disease is rare, but babies and young children get it.

No one knows just what viruses are out there. I applaud this mother for her wisdom.

Andarna · 28/12/2023 15:14

arewedoneyet · 26/12/2023 09:32

There seems to be a trend lately of telling people what you are willing to prioritise over them. I don't think it's particularly nice to invite someone over to expect them spend time visiting you and your child to then set such rigid rules. I mean surely you're grateful for the love and kindness they're showing by coming to visit?!? It seems like the OP's relatives are acting rather entitled, yes it's their child but they could've asked them not to touch not put up a sign as if their child was an exhibition!

Really? I hated visitors in the first few months. I did it because it was expected and because I love my MIL and dad and didn't want to keep them away. I'd much rather be exhausted, spit on, breastfeed and bleed without visitors.

Andarna · 28/12/2023 15:11

ankara · 26/12/2023 09:27

Having my read replies, maybe it's a bonding thing? Mum is sore and baby is bottle fed so if this is the new ante natal advice and it's intent is to promote bonding, then that would make sense.

It's the medical advice in my country to keep germs away from the baby for the first three months.

Andarna · 28/12/2023 15:09

It sounds like your SIL has to put up boundaries because some of you aren't listening? Have your own baby if you know better.

Andarna · 28/12/2023 15:08

See now, as far as I'm aware new babies have been passed around for inspection/cuddles since forever. Most seem to weather 'big germs' ok. I don't think they ARE that fragile are they?

Are you aware of the higher number of infant deaths since forever?

Calliopespa · 28/12/2023 13:55

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 28/12/2023 13:45

People now feel like they lost so much during the lockdowns that they “need to live their lives”.

I had someone say that to me on Christmas Eve when I hit the roof at them randomly popping into my house when three of their four children have chicken pox and they themselves had d&v the day before.

Apparently their want to catch up with a relative that was staying with me as they hadn’t seen them for ages was more important than the risk to anyone else.

selfish is so much more prevalent

I guess it was a strange time and it has accordingly provoked extreme reactions in many.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 28/12/2023 13:45

Calliopespa · 28/12/2023 13:10

I do think precautions around passing on illness has become more of a heated issue post covid. Before, it was seen as pragmatic, but now there are those who associate it with loss of autonomy, being dictated to etc and it really raises indignant responses in many. I had even wondered if that was an aspect of OP’s post.

People now feel like they lost so much during the lockdowns that they “need to live their lives”.

I had someone say that to me on Christmas Eve when I hit the roof at them randomly popping into my house when three of their four children have chicken pox and they themselves had d&v the day before.

Apparently their want to catch up with a relative that was staying with me as they hadn’t seen them for ages was more important than the risk to anyone else.

selfish is so much more prevalent

ToWhitToWhoo · 28/12/2023 13:42

hellsBells246 · 28/12/2023 10:51

Babies survived for millions of years with wider family giving them cuddles and touching them!!

'Babies survived for millions of years'- well, a bit over half of them did. Until modern medicine, sanitation and vaccinations, an awful lot of babies did NOT survive, We should not equate the survival of the human race with the robustness of individual babies.

And in the past, the wider family usually lived very close to the immediate family, and were far less likely than nowadays to be bringing 'new' germs from a distance.

Thementalloadisreal · 28/12/2023 13:19

user1491396110 · 28/12/2023 12:52

Good for her for sticking to it. My baby got rsv and bronchiolitis, kept stopping breathing and ended up in hospital. Wished i had kept everyone away

So sorry to hear that. Hope baby is ok now

Thementalloadisreal · 28/12/2023 13:18

Just found out a friend’s new baby boy is in hospital now due to catching RSV over Christmas. What’s a cold to you and me is dangerous to babies! Definitely worth remembering that when demanding new baby cuddles.
The sister’s sign is fine, especially as it is a permanent reminder, if she feels like people will override her rules or not ask her if she leaves the room

Calliopespa · 28/12/2023 13:10

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 28/12/2023 12:09

That’s the issue though - many people aren’t. its something that’s become more problematic since covid and peoples selfishness has increased.

Pre covid people were incredibly considerate to us due to my youngest DD’s health. They’d give us a heads up at the slightest sniffle so we could avoid them.

She’s recently been - knowingly and deliberately - exposed to multiple colds, covid (positive tests) twice and chicken pox. All by people who felt their wishes to not see any plans changed were more important than the health of a child who has had two icu stints in the last year as well as 14 other hospital stays.

. I know several who wouldn’t think twice about visiting a newborn with a heavy cold or cold sore. People aren’t as considerate or intelligent as many people assume and it’s highly likely the SIL has experienced that if she’s resorted to such measures

I do think precautions around passing on illness has become more of a heated issue post covid. Before, it was seen as pragmatic, but now there are those who associate it with loss of autonomy, being dictated to etc and it really raises indignant responses in many. I had even wondered if that was an aspect of OP’s post.

user1491396110 · 28/12/2023 12:52

Good for her for sticking to it. My baby got rsv and bronchiolitis, kept stopping breathing and ended up in hospital. Wished i had kept everyone away

florasmama · 28/12/2023 12:52

@5128gap We don't know though do we? Obviously the cuddle itself isn't the killer but what the cuddler was carrying could have put the health of the baby in jeopardy. There were obviously lots of reasons why many children didn't survive past infancy back then but this could have been one of them. My grandma had a younger brother who died of quite a severe bout of illness as a baby. I can't remember what it was exactly but I remember being told that he got poorly and remained poorly for a while before passing away. Who knows how he got ill? Either way, if there's a way that visitors can remain considerate and mindful of a newborn baby's health then I really don't understand the problem. You can cuddle them when they get a bit older. As I said previously, the only person who really benefits from the interaction is you. So this insistence of holding a fresh out of the womb baby whom isn't your own is based on nothing but self indulgence at best.

festivepains · 28/12/2023 12:49

I think those of us who have been in hospital with our little ones due to a virus etc have a much different opinion to those who haven't

whittingtonmum · 28/12/2023 12:46

Stop judging. Respect her rules or don't bother with the baby. I'd be incredibly annoyed if my SIL would post stuff like this on Mumsnet. We never cut new mothers any slack it's always about in laws wanting cuddles or other stuff to satisfy their own needs when a new baby arrives and then being judgy when they don't get it...'in my days....' I'm sick to the teeth of this attitude. Have you asked SIL what you can do to support? Or too busy posting on Mumsnet slacking her off?

Cmonluv · 28/12/2023 12:21

Those who say it's not a problem unless there's a health conditionay never had had a newborn with a health condition because they're brand new, you don't know if they have underlying conditions yet. We didn't know about my son's low blood sugars or epilepsy until he almost died at 3 days old, we didn't know about his chronic tonsillitis linked to an actual issue with his tonsils until every virus almost took him out, we didn't know about my daughter's asthma when she got RSV at 5 weeks old, she has the flu now at 2.5 and it's been horrific for her chest so if she'd caught it around that time I can only imagine.

The reason you take precautions around a newborn is also because they are unknown entity. Some kids will sail through rsv, it'll look like a cold, some will even sail through flu, mine don't. We're far enough in now that everyone in our circle knows the score with being careful around ours but we got plenty of ridicule when they were babies even after several hospitalisations each.

Those saying they can't bond with a child if they can't kiss a newborn? Get a life, how narcissistic to treat a newborn like such a object.

Calliopespa · 28/12/2023 12:16

Rhaenys · 27/12/2023 20:51

Surely people realise that a 3 week old newborn baby is very different from a vaccinated 3 month old?

As for affection, newborns only need affection from their mother primarily.

I think this sums it up. Three weeks is tiny - and I’m actually wondering how many of the memories of cuddles and passing babies round who loved it and formed incredible bonds with the people they probably didn’t even open their little screwed up eyes to glance at with their limited vision etc are not more related to this stage about 8 weeks on ( which arrives very quickly) when the baby is actually becoming properly interactive.

I couldn’t tell if this event with the sign was at SIL’s house but, if so, I think the oddest thing she has done is to be hosting on this level 3 weeks after a c section and new baby. Had she waited the sign might not have been necessary. Is that why so many of us find the sign odd? I can only really remember my parents and ILs and individual friends and relatives, perhaps with one dc in tow, coming in those first weeks. It goes fast - provided there is support.
A quick hug to all the mums on here who have recounted stories of scary times with their LO.

Liveafr · 28/12/2023 12:16

hellsBells246 · 28/12/2023 10:51

Babies survived for millions of years with wider family giving them cuddles and touching them!!

Interestingly, many non-western societies have centuries-old traditions of actually secluding/confining the mum and baby and limiting visits for about 6 weeks before introducing the baby to the wider world (eg. sitting the month, pantang, kyrkynan shygaru...)

5128gap · 28/12/2023 12:15

florasmama · 28/12/2023 11:02

@Justforxmas2023 Thank you Smile I hadn't read the previous posts involving this person. This is such a long thread already, I just read the OP and responded to that! There are some incredibly entitled posters on here. The amount of people arguing that babies have survived for a long time seem to forget at death in infancy used to be very common. My grandmother was one of fourteen and swear about half of them if not more died.

It wasnt cuddles that caused higher infant mortality in the past.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 28/12/2023 12:09

ScreamingBeans · 28/12/2023 11:21

I just assume that most people are intelligent enough not to go near a baby if they've got any suspicion of a cold or anything that would make the baby ill, but perhaps the OP's SIL's relatives are all idiots and can't be trusted.

That may actually be the case here and if it is then I agree with you. Thanks for your considered post, it's made me more sympathetic to the OP's SIL.

That’s the issue though - many people aren’t. its something that’s become more problematic since covid and peoples selfishness has increased.

Pre covid people were incredibly considerate to us due to my youngest DD’s health. They’d give us a heads up at the slightest sniffle so we could avoid them.

She’s recently been - knowingly and deliberately - exposed to multiple colds, covid (positive tests) twice and chicken pox. All by people who felt their wishes to not see any plans changed were more important than the health of a child who has had two icu stints in the last year as well as 14 other hospital stays.

. I know several who wouldn’t think twice about visiting a newborn with a heavy cold or cold sore. People aren’t as considerate or intelligent as many people assume and it’s highly likely the SIL has experienced that if she’s resorted to such measures

ChristmasEvemaddness · 28/12/2023 11:57

There are immunity issues with new born. As they get older they naturally crawl and put things in their mouths but new borns are incredible vulnerable and do need protection.
Especially in winter without a doubt.

The baby will not benefit from someone other than a parent holding them but you will benefit. But the baby could be at risk from whatever germs you are harbouring.

Put rhe baby first.

Calliopespa · 28/12/2023 11:53

Justforxmas2023 · 28/12/2023 08:15

You’re right about needing to be exposed to bugs in order to develop immunity but this does NOT apply in the first few months of life. A newborn baby has an underdeveloped immune system and what manifests as a cold in an adult can be life threatening. A newborn baby is NOT robust.

Yes , I remember explicitly asking GP and ped about this. Latter said don’t go looking for germs and the GP said : “ just being out of mum’s tummy is sufficient exposure at first.” There are environmental germs everywhere we don’t even blink at that babies haven’t yet developed immunity to and breast milk doesn’t cover everything.

GreyBlackLove · 28/12/2023 11:41

Hobbi · 28/12/2023 10:57

Seems the worries about contact with the baby are mysteriously suspended when someone might change its shitty nappy 🤔.

It's the opposite, did you not understand the OPs post? She's complaining that when a nappy needs changed, when a bottle is to be given or when the baby is upset the SIL is asking her DH to do it (or doing it herself) and only if then not available will a family member be allowed.

I dont remember it being specified that the family aren't being offered a chance to cuddle when the little one is up (she says at one point if they offer to do the above whilst they are having a cuddle - might be just how i read that), just that the above and that they aren't allowed to randomly pick up the child from its cot, or kiss him .

The sign is odd, but the stuff OP is complaining about not getting first dibbs on is a bit odder imo.