Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed with SILs decision re new baby.

885 replies

ankara · 26/12/2023 09:02

Respecting that all parents are quite within their rights to determine interaction between others and their babies, I am very disappointed and a bit 🙄 at SILs decision to put up a big sign at baby's cradle saying no touching , no lifting, no kissing.
There are no medical reasons for this. Baby is three weeks old.
None of the family have been allowed to do the above unless baby has been handed to family to give a bottle or r change baby.
I understand; that this is their first and is of course most precious but we are all a bit Confused and also disappointed as we love babies and we're so looking forward to cuddles .
Brother just goes along with her.
Is this a new thing? My kids are nearly teens now and I've not seen this before .

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
DewHopper · 26/12/2023 10:32

Brother just goes along with her

This part of your OP gives you away also. Your brother is a grown man and a father and also has say in what happens to his new baby. You don't like the fact that he and is wife presumably agree on this so you choose to infantalise him and pretend that it's all her 'fault'.

You just don't like your SIL.

Katypp · 26/12/2023 10:32

puddypud · 26/12/2023 10:26

@Katypp you're welcome to do your own research about infant mortality rates. It's hardly been kept a secret. I'm sure you'll claim it's fake news though after your silly comment.

www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/birthsdeathsandmarriages/livebirths/articles/trendsinbirthsanddeathsoverthelastcentury/2015-07-15

www.statista.com/statistics/1041714/united-kingdom-all-time-child-mortality-rate/

bigthink.com/health/child-mortality-progress/

😂
I think we can all agree mortality rates have gone down over the past 200 years.
But I assume this is mainly due to advances in medicine, living conditions and antenatal care maybe?
If you can point me to statistics that show mortality has gone down appreciably in the past 10/20 years due to parents limiting contact to their newborn I might think you are not being ridiculous

festivepains · 26/12/2023 10:31

DewHopper · 26/12/2023 10:28

Is it so hard to imagine that not everyone is the same as you? She may be feeling very anxious and protective over her brand new baby and need to do this for herself. You were different. So what?

I know I'm not sure why it's thar difficult to imagine!

lap90 · 26/12/2023 10:31

Putting a sign up is ridiculous.
It does seem to be a relatively new 'thing' in certain Western cultures, yes, with people listing their requirements for visitors meeting a baby and posting them on the gram and tiktok.

user1477391263 · 26/12/2023 10:30

NeverAloneNeverAgain · 26/12/2023 09:18

Maybe the sign is a bit much unless parents have asked for people not to pick baby up and being ignored and it's a last resort to get their point across. I love baby cuddles but it's parents right to lead this. I used to get really frustrated when I'd just got baby settled in crib and some well meaning visitor picked them up when they were settled and sleeping.

Also advice has changed over the years so maybe they're following that? We have a surprise 1yr old and when HV came for 5day weigh we were told only mum and dad should hold baby and do feeds 'to help bond'. Very different to when we had our older ones (19/17/12). We disregarded it but if it had been our 1st maybe we would have listened more

HVs do come out with some absolute tripe, don’t they? Glad you ignored them.

Weefreetiffany · 26/12/2023 10:30

ankara · 26/12/2023 10:17

I'm reading all replies with interest and what's jumping out at me is the difference between attitudes, generally 15 years ago for example... and now.
When discussing uncomplicated and relatively straightforward pregnancies , tiredness and lack of enerygy for many if not all of us was a thing esp in the first and last trimester. Support as minimal. We were just expected to get on with it and we did so continued working and were bloody exhausted. Wai to Ed until last minute for maternity leave, cooked the dates etc so as to have lots of time on the other side .
CS were emergency unless elective for genuinely serious reasons and in my world were rare.
Things have changed so much. I expect it is because the world is busier.
I know from a midwife friend that CS has become more common in her part of the world due to obesity and private ob/gynaes.
But in my own family, children 👦 f friends, especially younger colleagues circle, So many expectant mums are signing off at 20/24 weeks with tiredness/ exhaustion etc. so many unable to go to work, shops, pick up their kids ir do anything that involves expending too much energy. They do not have complications, underlying medical issues, normally these women are fit and healthy pre pregnancy.
Then when baby is born, they are stressed , anxious , thinking their child has any number of diseases they r potential disease.
I wonder if it's a post Covid thing? I would love to hear opinions and observations from midwives and or Drs on this.

Pregnancy is hard and the generational difference is that women today don’t want to have their needs ignored and just suck it up for appearances, while giving themselves long term health issues from the stress. So good on them if they need signing off early and prioritise their needs over being a good economically productive worker. However all the women I know work to 38 weeks and the stress of it is a massive factor on birth and the first few weeks.

there are more C sections becuase modern birth is, for lack of a better word, an over medicalised shit show. Which more often that not seems to end in lasting trauma for the new mum. This is all over the news, midwifery is underfunded and under supported and women are bearing the consequences. But yes imply that women are fat and lazy as the cause 🙄

And women are called selfish and unable to hack it by older generations who had more support, provisions, governmental budget etc. and feel entitled to hold our babies and say we’re being OTT when we say no. Cool.

DewHopper · 26/12/2023 10:28

DappledThings · 26/12/2023 10:25

DD2 was born at Christmas. Spent most of Christmas Day sleeping in MIL's arms or getting a gentle cuddle with DC1 other than when she needed feeding.

Can't imagine telling family they aren't allowed to cuddle her. Bonkers.

Is it so hard to imagine that not everyone is the same as you? She may be feeling very anxious and protective over her brand new baby and need to do this for herself. You were different. So what?

Lavenderflower · 26/12/2023 10:28

I can appreciate your SIL point but I do think it a bit OTT and more likely to create a lack of interest in the child.

SouthLondonMum22 · 26/12/2023 10:28

The sign is OTT and I'd honestly just back off. Hopefully, some people will still show interest when baby is a toddler and she's desperate for a break.

festivepains · 26/12/2023 10:27

I hope she's on here and sees you mocking her and then never invites you again tbh

irisgg7 · 26/12/2023 10:27

People are shockingly selfish when it comes to newborn babies. Yes you want a cuddle but if every visitor does, mum is left empty-handed. Personally I wanted to hold my babies. I didn't want people kissing or touching them, especially in winter.
I didn't say no, and thankfully breast-fed so could easily take them back. I also wore my sling a lot.

But I had people, say "oh I'm just going to wake him up now, he won't mind"

She got a bollocking.

Someone else held up my 7 day old baby like a rugby ball. I honestly wanted to punch her.

There will be history of overstepping for her to have made that sign.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 26/12/2023 10:27

Tandora · 26/12/2023 10:24

Of course not. You are the one who seems concerned about establishing who has “rights over a baby” (and confusing it with issues around “consent” and “boundaries”) all of which I find deeply problematic .

Nobody has “rights over a baby”. A baby is an independent person, and they are the only “rights holders” in the scenario.

people have responsibilities to babies to care for them. primary (aka “parental” responsibility) resides with the legal parents, but others have responsibilities too. Parental responsibility is not about entitlement to power or control over what happens to the baby, it’s about having primary responsibility to act in the baby’s best interests and there are important limits to parental responsibility in place.

Your comments make no sense, especially the 'top dog' one.
Parental responsibility does include power, if people are trying to force their actions on you or the child for whom you are responsible. OPs SIL has the power to prevent those who think it's their right to pick her baby up whenever they like.

Sunriseandcoffee · 26/12/2023 10:27

I think it's a great sign to have. Infections & viruses seem sooo much more vicious post-Covid. I don't blame your SIL for trying to protect her newborn. Their immune systems are so weak at 3 weeks. I was incredibly anxious when my son was that small. Any sort of cough or cold near him made me feel awful and I wish I had the assertiveness back then to stop others handling him. I remember when a colleague stuck her thumb in his mouth (without washing her hands) to soothe him when he was crying. I internally lost my mind but didn't say anything.

puddypud · 26/12/2023 10:26

@Katypp you're welcome to do your own research about infant mortality rates. It's hardly been kept a secret. I'm sure you'll claim it's fake news though after your silly comment.

www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/birthsdeathsandmarriages/livebirths/articles/trendsinbirthsanddeathsoverthelastcentury/2015-07-15

www.statista.com/statistics/1041714/united-kingdom-all-time-child-mortality-rate/

bigthink.com/health/child-mortality-progress/

DewHopper · 26/12/2023 10:26

I guess the sign was a bit OTT but perhaps she felt uncomfortable saying it

Especially so if the family members are like some of he posters on here - unsympathetic with hides like a rhino.

DappledThings · 26/12/2023 10:25

DD2 was born at Christmas. Spent most of Christmas Day sleeping in MIL's arms or getting a gentle cuddle with DC1 other than when she needed feeding.

Can't imagine telling family they aren't allowed to cuddle her. Bonkers.

peonygrace · 26/12/2023 10:25

I guess the sign was a bit OTT but perhaps she felt uncomfortable saying it.

I had NICU babies in winter and I remember the nurses really hammering home to me how vital it was for them not to catch any bugs when they came home and to be careful who handles them in the early weeks. It did put the fear of God into me and I was an anxious first time Mum, so I can understand your SILs point here.

Tandora · 26/12/2023 10:24

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 26/12/2023 10:15

So, you think MIL has more right over a baby than the parents?

Of course not. You are the one who seems concerned about establishing who has “rights over a baby” (and confusing it with issues around “consent” and “boundaries”) all of which I find deeply problematic .

Nobody has “rights over a baby”. A baby is an independent person, and they are the only “rights holders” in the scenario.

people have responsibilities to babies to care for them. primary (aka “parental” responsibility) resides with the legal parents, but others have responsibilities too. Parental responsibility is not about entitlement to power or control over what happens to the baby, it’s about having primary responsibility to act in the baby’s best interests and there are important limits to parental responsibility in place.

PooHeads · 26/12/2023 10:24

An actual sign is just 🤪 In fact this thread is just insane and I say that having had a baby relatively recently.

Santaiswashinghissleigh · 26/12/2023 10:23

Absolutely batshit I tell you.. Assuming the sign is aimed at family and not strangers in a supermarket sil is nuts....

Meowandthen · 26/12/2023 10:22

Kittylala · 26/12/2023 10:19

Cos so many newborns have died by being handled. Get real.

No one has the right to touch anyone else’s baby.

Sadly too many people overstep boundaries. Sounds as if you would ignore them from your comment.

DewHopper · 26/12/2023 10:22

OP you sound quite entitled and your most recent post is a bit....odd. This new mother is quite within her rights to limit access to her tiny vulnerable baby (all newborns are vulnerable btw) and people can like it or not - I doubt that she cares.
Leave her be and stop passively aggressively slating her on the internet.

Codlingmoths · 26/12/2023 10:22

ankara · 26/12/2023 09:14

Picking baby up randomly was never y what I meant but when baby is to be comforted or fed or changed and an offer is made to do so whilst also having a cuddle, it's a hard no. Husband only unless he is not there and then she will allow a pick up for a feed or change so while her intention may be to reduce germs, her decision to all ow baby to be held is based on where her husband is, not a strict ban on all other people not touching baby.
Anyway I get the feeling I'm out of this game too long! In my time, exposing babies to others was considered the norm unless there was illness or immunity issues.

You lost me at exposing babies to illnesses was the norm. It hasn’t been for a long long time because no one wants their tiny babies to die. It’s totally different from letting your 2yo eat dirt.

CatMadam · 26/12/2023 10:22

I agree with her, especially during winter when bugs are going mental! I had my son during lockdown and was quite relieved not to have to tell people not to kiss my newborn. I’ll certainly be telling people when my daughter is born!

rwalker · 26/12/2023 10:21

I agree in principle but there’s better ways than a sign to deal with this
unless theres been some massive issues with boundaries

I would of followed her wishes and have nothing to do with baby or asked about it