Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed with SILs decision re new baby.

885 replies

ankara · 26/12/2023 09:02

Respecting that all parents are quite within their rights to determine interaction between others and their babies, I am very disappointed and a bit 🙄 at SILs decision to put up a big sign at baby's cradle saying no touching , no lifting, no kissing.
There are no medical reasons for this. Baby is three weeks old.
None of the family have been allowed to do the above unless baby has been handed to family to give a bottle or r change baby.
I understand; that this is their first and is of course most precious but we are all a bit Confused and also disappointed as we love babies and we're so looking forward to cuddles .
Brother just goes along with her.
Is this a new thing? My kids are nearly teens now and I've not seen this before .

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 26/12/2023 11:39

DewHopper · 26/12/2023 11:24

What mean spirited dreadful post.

It is, isn't it. I did wonder about responding to it but wasn't sure where to start- there's the assumption that children are public property for touching, cuddling and kissing for starters.

Tacotortoise · 26/12/2023 11:33

BubziOwl · 26/12/2023 11:25

It is very common knowledge that any animal with young babies will be very territorial and you shouldn't approach let alone try and remove their baby.

Yes, there are many mothers who have no problem with handing over their newborns for cuddles - more power to them. But maybe some of us are just still a bit more primitive and animal-like - when mine were very tiny, especially my first born, it felt almost physically uncomfortable to have other people holding my baby. I absolutely hated it. I couldn't explain it or justify it adequately, it just felt very unpleasant and wrong. I very much still had that primitive maternal instinct.

Secondly, yes the sign is a bit much. But if there's ever a time to excuse daft behaviour, it's when the person in question is swimming in a sea of postpartum hormones!

You'll live without hugging someone else's baby. Just be there for the new family.

Actually your first paragraph is nonsense. In social mammals the norm is that members of the pack/troop come and investigate (nuzzle, touch, groom) the new baby. In social primates this is especially true of related females (sisters aunts, grandmother's etc). In this way the baby is accepted as a member of the group and worthy of communal protection rather than, say, a snack.

General speaking though it's best not to directly extrapolate bw human and animal behaviour.

MacLaine · 26/12/2023 11:32

FlamingoQueen · 26/12/2023 11:30

Just wait until she has her second - all the pfb rules go out of the window! You can remind her of it then.

Edited

Perhaps with her own sign! 😂😂😂

MacLaine · 26/12/2023 11:31

It’s a bit dramatic isn’t it a leave her to it. Take a photo of the sign for a laugh at the child’s 21st though. 🤭

Smugandproud · 26/12/2023 11:30

I wouldn’t worry @ankara . Sil will be throwing baby no. 2 at you.

God knows how the human race has survived so long.

fungibletoken · 26/12/2023 11:30

ankara · 26/12/2023 10:17

I'm reading all replies with interest and what's jumping out at me is the difference between attitudes, generally 15 years ago for example... and now.
When discussing uncomplicated and relatively straightforward pregnancies , tiredness and lack of enerygy for many if not all of us was a thing esp in the first and last trimester. Support as minimal. We were just expected to get on with it and we did so continued working and were bloody exhausted. Wai to Ed until last minute for maternity leave, cooked the dates etc so as to have lots of time on the other side .
CS were emergency unless elective for genuinely serious reasons and in my world were rare.
Things have changed so much. I expect it is because the world is busier.
I know from a midwife friend that CS has become more common in her part of the world due to obesity and private ob/gynaes.
But in my own family, children 👦 f friends, especially younger colleagues circle, So many expectant mums are signing off at 20/24 weeks with tiredness/ exhaustion etc. so many unable to go to work, shops, pick up their kids ir do anything that involves expending too much energy. They do not have complications, underlying medical issues, normally these women are fit and healthy pre pregnancy.
Then when baby is born, they are stressed , anxious , thinking their child has any number of diseases they r potential disease.
I wonder if it's a post Covid thing? I would love to hear opinions and observations from midwives and or Drs on this.

If you're picking up on anything there then it is most likely a much greater sensitivity around risk of stillbirths/maternal death/other complications that has developed in the last decade or so.

There's an NHS action plan/set of guidelines called "Saving Babies' Lives" that was introduced around 2014-2016:

"In November 2014, Secretary of State for Health announced a new ambition to reduce the rate of stillbirths by 50 per cent in England by 2025, with a 20 per cent reduction by 2020.
Despite falling to its lowest rate in 20 years, one in every 200 babies is stillborn in the UK; this is more than double the rate of nations with the lowest rates."

https://www.tommys.org/research/research-topics/stillbirth-research/saving-babies-lives-care-bundle

I gave birth this year via emergency C-section. My pregnancy was very normal until it all sort of fell off a cliff at around 30 weeks. It was then very closely managed in accordance with the newer guidelines leading to an induction at 36 weeks. That undoubtedly saved at least one or both of us compared to a non-interventionist approach.

There's an implication in your post that people are just being fussy. No - we have serious issues in this country around maternal and neonatal health and anything that's being done about that is a positive thing.

Coming back to your OP - the newborn phase is very short. I wouldn't pay too much attention to whatever the parents need to do to get them through it, and just look forward to developing your relationship with your new family member over the years to come. "Newborn snuggles" are a fairly insignificant part of that in the grand scheme of things.

Saving Babies' Lives Care Bundle

This ‘care bundle’ action plan will help NHS England to make maternity care safer, alongside guidelines to reduce preterm birth.

https://www.tommys.org/research/research-topics/stillbirth-research/saving-babies-lives-care-bundle

Mrsm010918 · 26/12/2023 11:30

Katypp · 26/12/2023 10:17

Explain. I am not convinced the infant mortality rate has plummeted much in the past 25 years?

www.statista.com/statistics/1041714/united-kingdom-all-time-child-mortality-rate/

It doesn't look like much in comparison to the 1800s but that looks pretty significant still to me

FlamingoQueen · 26/12/2023 11:30

Just wait until she has her second - all the pfb rules go out of the window! You can remind her of it then.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 26/12/2023 11:30

My SIL gave birth on Christmas Eve and has been advised when leaving the hospital to serious limit interactions because RSV and covid are rife locally.

BubziOwl · 26/12/2023 11:29

BubziOwl · 26/12/2023 11:25

It is very common knowledge that any animal with young babies will be very territorial and you shouldn't approach let alone try and remove their baby.

Yes, there are many mothers who have no problem with handing over their newborns for cuddles - more power to them. But maybe some of us are just still a bit more primitive and animal-like - when mine were very tiny, especially my first born, it felt almost physically uncomfortable to have other people holding my baby. I absolutely hated it. I couldn't explain it or justify it adequately, it just felt very unpleasant and wrong. I very much still had that primitive maternal instinct.

Secondly, yes the sign is a bit much. But if there's ever a time to excuse daft behaviour, it's when the person in question is swimming in a sea of postpartum hormones!

You'll live without hugging someone else's baby. Just be there for the new family.

I will also add that despite not being very liberal with allowing baby cuddles, my family (inc in-laws) and friends are still very much here for me and my children in the way they always have been because they're not spiteful or self-centred bellends.

If you decide how much you care about someone based on how much you were allowed to monopolise their baby when they were fresh out the womb, then I'd suggest you're a bit odd.

Daveismyhero · 26/12/2023 11:26

Her baby her choice as far as I see it. Things like RSV and coldsores are very real though and I've seen friends that have perfectly healthy babies end up with them hospitalised with RSV with breathing complications etc. Also we have more resistant strains of virus and bacteria now than previous. I think the boundaries around physical touch and consent are a lot more prevalent now which is a good thing. I absolutely hated as a child being told to give a relative a kiss that I didn't want to, it made me feel so uncomfortable so it's good people are setting boundaries from the off set

BubziOwl · 26/12/2023 11:25

It is very common knowledge that any animal with young babies will be very territorial and you shouldn't approach let alone try and remove their baby.

Yes, there are many mothers who have no problem with handing over their newborns for cuddles - more power to them. But maybe some of us are just still a bit more primitive and animal-like - when mine were very tiny, especially my first born, it felt almost physically uncomfortable to have other people holding my baby. I absolutely hated it. I couldn't explain it or justify it adequately, it just felt very unpleasant and wrong. I very much still had that primitive maternal instinct.

Secondly, yes the sign is a bit much. But if there's ever a time to excuse daft behaviour, it's when the person in question is swimming in a sea of postpartum hormones!

You'll live without hugging someone else's baby. Just be there for the new family.

MotherofChaosandDestruction · 26/12/2023 11:24

Weefreetiffany · 26/12/2023 10:09

Ugh what gaslighting. You have PND because you won’t let Meeeee hold your baby. There’s a huge difference between not letting anyone cross the threshold and asking those that do to not pick up/kids/stick your unwashed fingers in the mouth of a new born at peak cold and flu season. Why are you conflating the two? It sounds like you think PND is a symptom of mothers being punished with isolation for not letting entitled people touch their baby? Maybe if they showed they cared about her and about baby’s health, she would be able to relax and depend on their care and maybe, in a few weeks when it’s not the “a&e is overwhelmed with sick people” time of the year, let people who turn up to help have their newborn cuddles. New mothers are really vulnerable and not having their needs and boundaries met and respected is a bigger cause of PND as it makes the mum feel powerless. How about we support mums, eh? Even the ones that don’t make the same choices as we do.

My goodness that was an aggressive response. I realize PND won't solely be contributed to this but in my opinion the lack of socialisation and insulation that new mothers feel pressure to do nowadays DOES impact mental health. If family and friends aren't able to interact and are actively kept at arms length then you won't feel able to ask for support when you need it. I know DMs and MILs are seen as inferring busy bodies but the wisdom of older women is so underrated, they've raised children. I don't think anyone is saying they were going to stick unwashed fingers in the babys mouth were they?

I had a baby at Christmas time not so long ago and I understand the anxiety, I do, but this is not normal behaviour and is why I said at the end if they had asked if she was okay? And are you okay?

DewHopper · 26/12/2023 11:24

Jioyt · 26/12/2023 11:10

🤣🤣🤣🤣 this is so funny and is super OTT. However, having come across a few posts where new mothers mothers complain about their In-laws (the complaints I've read are all against in-laws rather than any member of the family) touching, cuddling and/or kissing their baby, I wouldn't be surprised if your SIL has read these posts and come up with this daft idea.

It's a sad state of affairs when people start to put signs on a baby's cradle.

My advice to you OP is to bite your tongue, smile, and go along with it.
As life with a newborn starts to present the usual difficulties and SIL realises, there's a reason for why "it takes a village to raise a child," and she comes asking for babysitting help, please ensure you have your big sign ready on your door reading "NO BABYSITTING SERVICES".

What mean spirited dreadful post.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 26/12/2023 11:19

Zanatdy · 26/12/2023 11:17

in mumsnet world they agree with mum, in the real world people think she’s nuts and give her a year she will be asking for help from the people she banned cuddling her baby. Unless baby is premature or sick, cuddles are fine. As long as visitors are asked not to come in sick, wash hands and don’t kiss baby. She needs to chill a bit - people will be laughing at her sign for decades to come

What makes you think that lots of MN is completely different from the real world in every aspect? Don't many of us inhabit a real world too?

acupofteamakeseverythingbetter · 26/12/2023 11:19

I think some people think she had written the sign herself (she may well have done) but you can buy signs which say things like "STOP - please don't touch, I'm too little for big germs"

I had a few mums stop me when I had the sign on my sons car seat or pram to say they wish they had a sign like that when theirs were little.

I wish people would respect parents wishes, whatever they may be

TurquoiseDress · 26/12/2023 11:18

The sign is totally overkill IMHO

But I do understand the sentiment of a new baby not being smothered in kisses- I think people shouldn't need this pointing out to them but of course they do!

Cuddles for a few minutes are fine.

At the end of the day, best to let the new mum (& partner to an extent) make these decisions.

It's an overwhelming time, hormones out of control and it's not easy to be reasonable about anything when you're sleep deprived!

Zanatdy · 26/12/2023 11:17

in mumsnet world they agree with mum, in the real world people think she’s nuts and give her a year she will be asking for help from the people she banned cuddling her baby. Unless baby is premature or sick, cuddles are fine. As long as visitors are asked not to come in sick, wash hands and don’t kiss baby. She needs to chill a bit - people will be laughing at her sign for decades to come

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 26/12/2023 11:17

Meowandthen · 26/12/2023 11:14

The more comments I read here, the more I understand why the new mother has put up a sign.

Agreed.
There's some horrible entitlement out there.

Meowandthen · 26/12/2023 11:14

The more comments I read here, the more I understand why the new mother has put up a sign.

RadRad · 26/12/2023 11:11

Fair play to the new mum, it's the virus season, the newborn hasn't been even vaccinated yet, I would respect what she wants for her own child. We didn't even allowed visits until after the first month.

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 26/12/2023 11:11

Dearover · 26/12/2023 09:11

The sign is ridiculous & I'm someone who would be horrified if I was asked to hold a baby.

I've never had the slightest desire to hold someone else's baby. Quite the opposite I find it really weird being offered a baby to hold and always refuse but from the responses on here we seem to be in a minority. Maybe the sign is necessary.

Jioyt · 26/12/2023 11:10

🤣🤣🤣🤣 this is so funny and is super OTT. However, having come across a few posts where new mothers mothers complain about their In-laws (the complaints I've read are all against in-laws rather than any member of the family) touching, cuddling and/or kissing their baby, I wouldn't be surprised if your SIL has read these posts and come up with this daft idea.

It's a sad state of affairs when people start to put signs on a baby's cradle.

My advice to you OP is to bite your tongue, smile, and go along with it.
As life with a newborn starts to present the usual difficulties and SIL realises, there's a reason for why "it takes a village to raise a child," and she comes asking for babysitting help, please ensure you have your big sign ready on your door reading "NO BABYSITTING SERVICES".

Meowandthen · 26/12/2023 11:10

ThirstyMeeples · 26/12/2023 11:05

She can specify whatever she likes and people should respect that. However it is likely to have an effect on that person's relationship with the child in the future. I have a SIL a bit like this, I was so monitored when interacting with my niece and it was very prescriptive, that I never really formed a bond. I was always a bit worried about pissing her off or overstepping a boundary.
I contrast, I was encouraged by my other SIL to interact with my nephew and she trusted me to hold him (and was grateful as she was knackered) I have a wonderful bond with him now.
I was always very flexible with my kids and let people hold and kiss them. They have fantastic robust immune systems and have grown into confident, not anxious at all teenagers.
So I do think this behaviour sounds anxiety driven rather than anything else.

Nonsense! You do not need to cuddle a child as a baby to develop a bond.

I have nieces and nephews on other continents that I see very infrequently but still have great bonds with them. I great on great with friends’ children who I never met as babies,

Forming bonds and relationships nothing to do with baby cuddles.

RedToothBrush · 26/12/2023 11:09

StephanieSuperpowers · 26/12/2023 11:01

I know these threads can be hard to follow, but the subject was other family members feeling pushed out and not as close to the family in years to come. And I think they may feel blindsided and rejected by that kind of rudeness. It may be that the parents feel a sign I'd warranted, but if you fo something like this, other people will have feelings. It's part of the deal.

You don't feel the need to put up a sign like this, unless there is an extensive backstory over family members overstepping the mark and not accepting no for an answer.

The idea about this starting an issue where family are distanced as a result is very naive - the fracture in the relationship is already well seeded, and I would argue is liable to manifest at some point anyway - the sign is just a clue to there being a massive underlying problem thats not going away.

Swipe left for the next trending thread