Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed with SILs decision re new baby.

885 replies

ankara · 26/12/2023 09:02

Respecting that all parents are quite within their rights to determine interaction between others and their babies, I am very disappointed and a bit 🙄 at SILs decision to put up a big sign at baby's cradle saying no touching , no lifting, no kissing.
There are no medical reasons for this. Baby is three weeks old.
None of the family have been allowed to do the above unless baby has been handed to family to give a bottle or r change baby.
I understand; that this is their first and is of course most precious but we are all a bit Confused and also disappointed as we love babies and we're so looking forward to cuddles .
Brother just goes along with her.
Is this a new thing? My kids are nearly teens now and I've not seen this before .

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
ZiriForGood · 26/12/2023 12:41

It is interesting how many posters consider her rules (those 3 ) totally ok until she writes them down, than it becomes too much.

Kissing a newborn on a face is totally unnecessary. And the cuddles can wait until the parent offers, similarly there is no need to lift the baby.

uclpp · 26/12/2023 12:38

Well mine are nearly adult and I was told not to pass them about all the time in their first 4 weeks. A baby is not public property to be passed around like a toy. You need to respect the mother's wishes.

Bluela18 · 26/12/2023 12:37

It's her newborn baby , if they don't want anyone kissing touching or lifting then its a good idea to respect their boundaries and try not to question it or judge. There will be a lot of things they as parents will say and do that you might not agree with, 'as it wasnt how you did it' but if you want to remain close and trusted as an Aunty , grandma, you must respect what they say. If I visited family and they had that sign up next to newborn I wouldn't even question it. You say your brother just goes along with it , how do you know it's not his decision or joint decision.

Unicorns41 · 26/12/2023 12:37

Recently had a baby and whilst I think the signs a bit overkill, I wish I had the guts to do it.

Both me and DH have large families and most are respectful, quick cuddle and hand back baby when asked/needed. Others not so much, take baby from me and won’t give baby back when crying under pretence of giving me a break.

Drives me nuts as I’m naturally quite quiet but have had to get better at speaking up for baby and DH has to frequently intervene with his family to get him back to me when he’s upset.

Christmas has been difficult at points and had one event that was traumatic for baby as family member refused to give baby back who got so upset they vomited all over them and then obviously couldn’t hand him back fast enough.

I don’t understand why relatives withhold crying infants from their mums. MIL only hands baby to DH (who just hands baby to me) even though it’s clearly me he wants and we have a good relationship (won’t be seeing them again until they’re much bigger).

I am finished with family events for now, as feel like my baby has almost been through an ordeal.

So whilst I understand the sign might be slightly over the top, I completely get her reasoning. Babies aren’t dolls and although your family love babies it sounds like she’s stopping potential situations before they arise.

lapsedbookworm · 26/12/2023 12:36

My SIL took my son off upstairs at 8months old and refused to hand him back even though he was absolutely screaming. It was really distressing and I take my hat off to people who put down boundaries.

Weefreetiffany · 26/12/2023 12:36

MotherofChaosandDestruction · 26/12/2023 11:24

My goodness that was an aggressive response. I realize PND won't solely be contributed to this but in my opinion the lack of socialisation and insulation that new mothers feel pressure to do nowadays DOES impact mental health. If family and friends aren't able to interact and are actively kept at arms length then you won't feel able to ask for support when you need it. I know DMs and MILs are seen as inferring busy bodies but the wisdom of older women is so underrated, they've raised children. I don't think anyone is saying they were going to stick unwashed fingers in the babys mouth were they?

I had a baby at Christmas time not so long ago and I understand the anxiety, I do, but this is not normal behaviour and is why I said at the end if they had asked if she was okay? And are you okay?

So you don’t like being challenged and therefore I must be being aggressive? Are you ok?

My MIL stuck her unwashed fingers in my Christmas born baby’s mouth when he was less than a week old. I’m not alone in that experience. I wish I lived in a universe where the older generation supported the younger one, but as we see time and time again on mumsnet that’s not the case. Supporting new mums is crucial, and as many people have pointed out, the mum must already be dealing with unsupportive boundary stompers to feel like she needs a sign. That environment will contribute to pnd. Pnd is not the cause of the environment. Supporting the mum is taking some of the load off her, not expecting to play with the baby and saying she must have mental health issues if she tries to head that off at the pass. Come on now.

jays · 26/12/2023 12:36

As we love babies … there’s your problem … me me me… we we we. I feel sorry for her for the fact she had to put a sign up to be honest. It’s her baby , not your play thing. I don’t want that to sound harsh just honest.

MorningSunshineSparkles · 26/12/2023 12:31

If she’s only allowing people to hold the baby when her husband isn’t there have you maybe thought it’s her husband imposing the ban?

LightDrizzle · 26/12/2023 12:29

EmilyTjP · 26/12/2023 11:47

I’m a neonatal nurse and after covid we had a big problem with babies being readmitted to PICU with RSV and other illnesses because they hadn’t been exposed to other people. Babies need to be exposed to germs to build their immune system. This mumsnet mantra (which it is, as I don’t know anyone in real life who behaves like this) is damaging and harmful.

I’m a bit alarmed by this. Are you talking about older babies and children needing to be exposed to germs, - which they inevitably will as they become mobile and explore with hands and mouth? Could you post a link to the research this is based on - not the increase in admissions post COVID, but the benefit to newborns of being exposed to bacteria and viruses?

I thought newborn vulnerability was uncontroversial, as per this information for parents given online by John Hopkins.

^Are newborns more susceptible to germs and viruses?

Yes, newborns have not had time to develop their immune system, so they are at higher risk for developing infections from both bacteria and viruses. They are also more susceptible to developing serious infections, such as sepsis and meningitis. Newborns do not yet have the protection obtained from vaccinations, and their blood-brain barrier (protects infections from entering the brain) has not yet fully developed. This is why we consider a newborn younger than three months with a fever (temperature great than 100.4F) to be an emergency.^

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 26/12/2023 12:29

This is OTT and spoils the joy of a new baby in the family.

really? "Spoils the joy"? You'd have to be terribly small minded and self centred to think not being able to hold a new born to think that.

irisgg7 · 26/12/2023 12:29

@IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle

I always refuse newborn too, not because I don't want to hold them, I do. However I think they should be with mum. It's often traumatic having a baby, plus hormones etc. That loving bond establishes through smell and touch. I'm happy to smile and enjoy watching them, with their mum.

If you can't bond with a family member because you didn't hold them at 4 weeks. That's not due to the lack of holding, either you're sulking and spoiling it for yourself, or the parents are keeping you at arms length.

Has Op confirmed how many family members were present? because three visitors are very different to 20. and the baby becoming a pass the parcel.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 26/12/2023 12:27

Zanatdy · 26/12/2023 12:24

Because I’ve had 3 babies, my family and many friends / friends of friends have ever had a sign above their babies basket. You can simply ask people to follow a few rules. This is OTT and spoils the joy of a new baby in the family. The only couple I know who asked for family not to touch baby and had to go upstairs in groups to see baby had a premature baby and midwife advised against a big group seeing baby. My ex was fuming but I think that was sensible. A healthy baby meeting relatives at Christmas - sorry it’s OTT and people will be laughing about it if they are told someone had a sign above their babies crib

So your experience is the real world then?
That's not logical.

Mumaway · 26/12/2023 12:26

It's a you problem. Her baby, her rules, and they seem like sensible ones

DewHopper · 26/12/2023 12:26

Mariposistaa · 26/12/2023 12:16

She is a twat. Silly girl will learn soon enough when all friends and family steer away from her ultra clenched attitude. Her poor DH

Posts like this are so disgusting that I am lost for words.
Name calling aside, the absolute misogyny of assuming that the mother here called all the shots and that 'poor DH' is somehow a victim! Imagine thinking this way!

Nttttt · 26/12/2023 12:25

sunshinesupermum · 26/12/2023 12:18

*Ntttt" as a parent and grandparent I know not to kiss or cuddle a child if I have a cold etc. it's not just me wanting cuddles but bonding with my own flesh and blood.

You can have covid and be asymptomatic.

MissBuffyAnneSummers · 26/12/2023 12:25

I wonder if this crazy attitude has got worse since Covid.

I know there have always been uptight hormonal new parents in the grips of PFB syndrome - but what excuse for the defenders?

PixiePirate · 26/12/2023 12:25

It’s an unpopular view on MN but I agree with you OP. I’m sure people will be piling on to tell us we’re wrong but your DB and DSIL are not the first people to have a baby and presumably most of the family are parents themselves and are perfectly capable of behaving in a considerate way. It’s just insufferably PFB imo.

Zanatdy · 26/12/2023 12:24

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 26/12/2023 11:19

What makes you think that lots of MN is completely different from the real world in every aspect? Don't many of us inhabit a real world too?

Because I’ve had 3 babies, my family and many friends / friends of friends have ever had a sign above their babies basket. You can simply ask people to follow a few rules. This is OTT and spoils the joy of a new baby in the family. The only couple I know who asked for family not to touch baby and had to go upstairs in groups to see baby had a premature baby and midwife advised against a big group seeing baby. My ex was fuming but I think that was sensible. A healthy baby meeting relatives at Christmas - sorry it’s OTT and people will be laughing about it if they are told someone had a sign above their babies crib

Riverlee · 26/12/2023 12:24

Regarding Covid, that certainly affected new parents. The nct/mother and baby etc groups weren’t around so people didn’t discuss their worries, baby’s progress etc. If a baby got a snuffle, in the olden days, you knew it was just a bug going around around.

A doctor friend commented how all the covid baby and tots are now older and getting chicken pox. They were getting lots of parents bringing their children in with chicken pox. In the past, this wasn’t seen and you would just get a bottle of calamine from the pharmacy.

SENDhelp2023 · 26/12/2023 12:24

Good for her, its a baby not a toy

Nttttt · 26/12/2023 12:24

Mariposistaa · 26/12/2023 12:16

She is a twat. Silly girl will learn soon enough when all friends and family steer away from her ultra clenched attitude. Her poor DH

Such a twat for not wanting her baby to risk contracting life threatening illnesses? It is bug season - everyone I know has cold/flu/covid/norovirus currently and not the mention the risk of cold sores/RSV to a tiny newborn.

You do realise midwives tell pregnant people to not allow ANYONE to kiss our babies once they are here, like it’s legit NHS recommendations.

Here is a legit poster from an NHS website.

Now you will say “well that’s not cuddles!!! Everyone should be able to cuddle the baby! When my first was born in 1851 everyone cuddled and kissed the baby!” Well for that I could also attach a picture of a baby in the ICU who has contracted flu or any other close contact contracted problem.

Also how do you know this woman’s In laws haven’t overstepped the mark. Maybe they were all saying she was being precious for laying basic rules “don’t kiss the baby” or “wash your hands” so she felt she needed to reinforce the rules but hard.

To be disappointed with SILs decision re new baby.
MabelQ · 26/12/2023 12:23

I’d like to bring balance to the older/younger viewpoints on this, as I’m currently 34 weeks pregnant after a 7yr gap. Nobody was talking about not letting anyone else hold babies back when our first children were born. Of course many of our friends/ourselves set some boundaries.

THIS time, it’s been strongly recommended that nobody outside our household be allowed to hold baby; or perhaps one designated relative. My OB/GYN flat out told me that children with RSV who would normally be hospitalized are being sent home because there is simply no room. RSV is simply raging right now and they are absolutely unable to cope with the load.

Combine that concept with renewed awareness of the potential impact of passing on cold sores to babies and I can understand why younger Moms are going tight with boundaries. It’s not that childhood illnesses are stronger now - it’s that at the moment in the region I live in, hospitals are overwhelmed and doctors are begging the general population to reduce their tiny family member’s risks of needing hospitalization. That’s a heavy burden for a younger Mom to carry; it’s one thing to accept that Aunt Sarah could inadvertently pass RSV to your newborn during that peaceful cuddle session, but it’s another thing to accept that if it gets bad for your child they may not be able to get the care they would normally.

The “husband first” then reluctant family involvement makes me suspect the SiL has been counseled on the only within household concept and is trying to balance challenging postpartum needs with that guidance.

yesyouareyouare · 26/12/2023 12:22

The sign is unbearably precious. I didn't mind people holding my babies.

HerMammy · 26/12/2023 12:21

Only on MN have I come across this preciousness, for generations babies were visited and cuddled. Be wise to remember the phrase it takes a village, starting out like this might find you short of help when you need it.
Also a bit cheeky that it's ok to lift if instructed to change or feed 🤣

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 26/12/2023 12:21

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 26/12/2023 12:11

This preciousness is IMO a new thing. And ‘fashionable’ if I can use such a word in this context.

Obviously nobody wants anyone with a cold or e.g. a cold sore anywhere near their baby, but otherwise surely it’s lovely for family to enjoy a cuddle with a new baby.

At 3 weeks my DD’s 3rd was passed around loads of ILs and their friends, but thank goodness dd has never been precious with her babies.

A baby isn't a cuddly toy to be passed around.