Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed with SILs decision re new baby.

885 replies

ankara · 26/12/2023 09:02

Respecting that all parents are quite within their rights to determine interaction between others and their babies, I am very disappointed and a bit 🙄 at SILs decision to put up a big sign at baby's cradle saying no touching , no lifting, no kissing.
There are no medical reasons for this. Baby is three weeks old.
None of the family have been allowed to do the above unless baby has been handed to family to give a bottle or r change baby.
I understand; that this is their first and is of course most precious but we are all a bit Confused and also disappointed as we love babies and we're so looking forward to cuddles .
Brother just goes along with her.
Is this a new thing? My kids are nearly teens now and I've not seen this before .

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Calliopespa · 26/12/2023 18:09

bigyellowmoxi · 26/12/2023 16:37

I agree with @DewHopper that the resentment and disdain for them is so obvious from the way you post.
It feels like you can't wait for them to fuck up.

Just let them adjust to being parents ffs, it's only been a few weeks.

Yeah I’m not sure why they have caused such resentment. They are clearly finding their way. I was a little more cautious with my first. We all have to start somewhere. Some things I did were, in hindsight, unnecessary and, with more children, unsustainable ( anyone with more than one baby out there doing bath time by candlelight to keep baby chilled and loving life? Thought not!) . But trying not to let lots of people handle a newborn is a lot more down to earth and useful than my candlelight baths were. And I really don’t see what’s wrong with DB saying “ we are breastfeeding”? Because he doesn’t have breasts? Didn’t he mean the decision around it not the actual latching on? The sign I can see was a bit odd. The baby must have looked like a museum exhibit or a zoo animal: please do not feed the animals or put fingers in the cage. But she is clearly feeling over protective. I’m not sure if this resentment runs deeper than this incident?

CatMadam · 26/12/2023 18:03

ankara · 26/12/2023 16:13

Just catching up on posts having been at a family dinner. So many interesting posts.
I cannot remember posters name but it s my brother who goes with the flow. My SIL is a lot more chatty, outspoken and opinionated than he although when he announced that ' we have decided to breast feed exclusively' followed by' we have decided no t to breastfeed exclusively as we're not happy with level of support offered' my dear mother took him aside and politely told him to stop being a dick. That it was his wife who would be doing the breast feeding or not as the case ended up and he sounded like a twat.
The end up Of this AIBU is that brother , his wife and new baby have moved lock , stock and barrel to my mothers fr support today ... Fourteen adults and kids staying at the moment so the big sign will come in helpful , indeed.

I can definitely see why she thought the sign was necessary- your disdain for her and her boundaries are crystal clear from your posts!

thecatsthecats · 26/12/2023 17:56

festivepains · 26/12/2023 09:16

Again don't care. Respect mums decisions it will go a long way to helping her into mumhood and build a much better relationship for you going forward.

I agree. Respecting my boundaries helps me build my confidence in my own time, not by people playing with the baby like some kind of toy.

My little boy was unsettled and I had mastitis due to his low appetite after his jabs. I asked my MIL to give him back when he was clearly wriggling to come back to me for a feed, which I needed to give him to clear the infection.

She put on a baby voice and said, "it's ok mummy, I'm happy over here".

Stupid cow. Handed him back wailing and too agitated to latch.

NoraBattysCurlers · 26/12/2023 17:30

CHRIS003 · 26/12/2023 16:51

I think social media plays a part now too - influencers posting about their experiences - sometimes they post when they have a bad day maybe tired or feeling a bit tearful with new baby all completely normal things but young first time mums are perhaps getting too much negativity about pregnancy and birth.
The all post about their illnesses - their interventional birth experiences and their mental load and how they have no support - I think some first time mums who may otherwise sale through pregnancy and birth and the first 3 months after, take in too much negativity from influencers - This is not something that was as bad 15 years ago. Going back to early 2000's and 1990's most young mums still relied on the advice of their own mums and their midwives and health visitors, my sister is a midwife, she has been one for many years and now she says it is very different to the 1990's as mums question all the advice given - worry about the rarest of conditions in pregnancy and even question every aspect of routine monitoring thinking there is something wrong the baby, reading up on test results that they have no medical training on how to interpret.
On the other hand I have also saw a story recently about a minor celebrity who said she had a wonderful experience of birth and she was really enjoying life with new baby and partner and she was criticised for gloating and that she should have some consideration for women who didn't have a good experience!
What on earth was wrong with her saying everything was fine and she was happy ?

Infant mortality in 1990 was over twice what it is now.

Most deaths during childhood occur during the first year of life, particularly the first month of life (the neonatal period). Neonatal mortality accounts for between 70% and 80% of infant deaths.

Do we really want to go back to practices which lead to twice as many babies dying?

Dinkydoo17 · 26/12/2023 17:10

Her baby her rules. End of. I saw an article once where a new dad had kissed his new baby lots (totally natural to do so) with an active cold sore. Probably a one in a million chance but newborn got the virus and it overtook her poor little body and she died. Devastating. You don't have to understand you SILs reasons. Maybe she's scared. Maybe she's overprotective. Just be kind and understanding despite your disappointment.

CHRIS003 · 26/12/2023 16:51

ankara · 26/12/2023 10:17

I'm reading all replies with interest and what's jumping out at me is the difference between attitudes, generally 15 years ago for example... and now.
When discussing uncomplicated and relatively straightforward pregnancies , tiredness and lack of enerygy for many if not all of us was a thing esp in the first and last trimester. Support as minimal. We were just expected to get on with it and we did so continued working and were bloody exhausted. Wai to Ed until last minute for maternity leave, cooked the dates etc so as to have lots of time on the other side .
CS were emergency unless elective for genuinely serious reasons and in my world were rare.
Things have changed so much. I expect it is because the world is busier.
I know from a midwife friend that CS has become more common in her part of the world due to obesity and private ob/gynaes.
But in my own family, children 👦 f friends, especially younger colleagues circle, So many expectant mums are signing off at 20/24 weeks with tiredness/ exhaustion etc. so many unable to go to work, shops, pick up their kids ir do anything that involves expending too much energy. They do not have complications, underlying medical issues, normally these women are fit and healthy pre pregnancy.
Then when baby is born, they are stressed , anxious , thinking their child has any number of diseases they r potential disease.
I wonder if it's a post Covid thing? I would love to hear opinions and observations from midwives and or Drs on this.

I think social media plays a part now too - influencers posting about their experiences - sometimes they post when they have a bad day maybe tired or feeling a bit tearful with new baby all completely normal things but young first time mums are perhaps getting too much negativity about pregnancy and birth.
The all post about their illnesses - their interventional birth experiences and their mental load and how they have no support - I think some first time mums who may otherwise sale through pregnancy and birth and the first 3 months after, take in too much negativity from influencers - This is not something that was as bad 15 years ago. Going back to early 2000's and 1990's most young mums still relied on the advice of their own mums and their midwives and health visitors, my sister is a midwife, she has been one for many years and now she says it is very different to the 1990's as mums question all the advice given - worry about the rarest of conditions in pregnancy and even question every aspect of routine monitoring thinking there is something wrong the baby, reading up on test results that they have no medical training on how to interpret.
On the other hand I have also saw a story recently about a minor celebrity who said she had a wonderful experience of birth and she was really enjoying life with new baby and partner and she was criticised for gloating and that she should have some consideration for women who didn't have a good experience!
What on earth was wrong with her saying everything was fine and she was happy ?

bigyellowmoxi · 26/12/2023 16:37

ankara · 26/12/2023 16:13

Just catching up on posts having been at a family dinner. So many interesting posts.
I cannot remember posters name but it s my brother who goes with the flow. My SIL is a lot more chatty, outspoken and opinionated than he although when he announced that ' we have decided to breast feed exclusively' followed by' we have decided no t to breastfeed exclusively as we're not happy with level of support offered' my dear mother took him aside and politely told him to stop being a dick. That it was his wife who would be doing the breast feeding or not as the case ended up and he sounded like a twat.
The end up Of this AIBU is that brother , his wife and new baby have moved lock , stock and barrel to my mothers fr support today ... Fourteen adults and kids staying at the moment so the big sign will come in helpful , indeed.

I agree with @DewHopper that the resentment and disdain for them is so obvious from the way you post.
It feels like you can't wait for them to fuck up.

Just let them adjust to being parents ffs, it's only been a few weeks.

DewHopper · 26/12/2023 16:28

ankara · 26/12/2023 16:13

Just catching up on posts having been at a family dinner. So many interesting posts.
I cannot remember posters name but it s my brother who goes with the flow. My SIL is a lot more chatty, outspoken and opinionated than he although when he announced that ' we have decided to breast feed exclusively' followed by' we have decided no t to breastfeed exclusively as we're not happy with level of support offered' my dear mother took him aside and politely told him to stop being a dick. That it was his wife who would be doing the breast feeding or not as the case ended up and he sounded like a twat.
The end up Of this AIBU is that brother , his wife and new baby have moved lock , stock and barrel to my mothers fr support today ... Fourteen adults and kids staying at the moment so the big sign will come in helpful , indeed.

You really don't like either of these people do you? How about you let them be and crack on with your own Christmas?

Legendairy · 26/12/2023 16:25

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 26/12/2023 09:10

Well done to your SIL for making a stand.

What against relatives having a cuddle with the baby FFS 🙄

Obv people shouldn't be just picking baby up and should ask but I just cannot imagine not allowing people to have newborn cuddles (unless they are ill or have just been smoking)

Putting a sign up is embarrassingly ridiculous

ankara · 26/12/2023 16:13

Just catching up on posts having been at a family dinner. So many interesting posts.
I cannot remember posters name but it s my brother who goes with the flow. My SIL is a lot more chatty, outspoken and opinionated than he although when he announced that ' we have decided to breast feed exclusively' followed by' we have decided no t to breastfeed exclusively as we're not happy with level of support offered' my dear mother took him aside and politely told him to stop being a dick. That it was his wife who would be doing the breast feeding or not as the case ended up and he sounded like a twat.
The end up Of this AIBU is that brother , his wife and new baby have moved lock , stock and barrel to my mothers fr support today ... Fourteen adults and kids staying at the moment so the big sign will come in helpful , indeed.

OP posts:
irisgg7 · 26/12/2023 16:08

Angelsrose · Today 12:47

@Meowandthen I think it is simply the risk that this new mother is taking. It is alright for everyone to do what they think is best as I already said. However one cannot expect to have everything just as they would like it, it's not real life nor is it realistic. If you don't want people to ever hold your baby then those same people may not feel particularly bonded to the child and may feel uncomfortable having contact with the child or babysitting in the future. I'm not sure what's difficult for you to understand about that.Angelsrose · Today 12:47

@Meowandthen I think it is simply the risk that this new mother is taking. It is alright for everyone to do what they think is best as I already said. However one cannot expect to have everything just as they would like it, it's not real life nor is it realistic. If you don't want people to ever hold your baby then those same people may not feel particularly bonded to the child and may feel uncomfortable having contact with the child or babysitting in the future. I'm not sure what's difficult for you to understand about that.
--

Two of your posts. no ,I'm not agreeing to disagree. You are suggesting people will not feel bonded to a child, because they couldn't hold a four week old (vulnerable to infection) baby.
You said that would make you uncomfortable bonding or offering babysitting years later?
You would prefer to refuse contact with a family member because you didn't get a hug at 4 weeks?

Actually yes, one (a new mum)can expect to have everything just as they like it, they may need a sign. Powerful women can insist on exactly what they want!

Angelsrose · 26/12/2023 15:55

irisgg7 · 26/12/2023 15:46

@Angelsrose I never said it was nasty or evil..
It is ALWYAS the parents decision, you have to accept that, they are looking after their child, a tiny baby, who is seceptible to every bug and some Nasty winter viruses. (and following medical advice)

Refusing to babysit because you didn't get to snuggle a newborn, yes that's nasty. But ultimately it will be you that is worse off.
The joy of children and babysitting, that's a parents choice. No one will ask if you have been such a self centred adult when they were 4 weeks old!

Agree to disagree, it's that simple. You will always have your view and I shall have mine. I personally have not refused babysitting on this basis (birds of a feather tend to flock together so it is not normal for me to see people putting such a sign over their baby's cot) I can certainly understand that some people would.

ClottedCreamScone · 26/12/2023 15:51

A sign is a bit OTT but they’re not unreasonable rules. New babies shouldn’t be kissed by people - they are at serious risk from things like cold sores and respiratory viruses. And it’s not in the baby’s interests to be picked up and passed around by people - new babies really only want to be held by their parents, quick cuddles with others are of course fine but the parents should be able to decide if and when it’s the right time.

Maybe your sister in law feels the sign is needed as people might not listen to her otherwise, or maybe she feels less awkward with it written down. I know why you think it’s too much but I also totally understand why she’s anxious about having loads of relatives descending and all wanting a cuddle - she had to do what’s best for her and her baby.

irisgg7 · 26/12/2023 15:46

@Angelsrose I never said it was nasty or evil..
It is ALWYAS the parents decision, you have to accept that, they are looking after their child, a tiny baby, who is seceptible to every bug and some Nasty winter viruses. (and following medical advice)

Refusing to babysit because you didn't get to snuggle a newborn, yes that's nasty. But ultimately it will be you that is worse off.
The joy of children and babysitting, that's a parents choice. No one will ask if you have been such a self centred adult when they were 4 weeks old!

Angelsrose · 26/12/2023 15:25

@irisgg7 there's no backtracking as I have not been in this situation. I am not currently in this situation. Commenting that some may be unwilling to participate in future babysitting is not evil or nasty. It's simply a possibility to be considered. You have to accept in life that others will think differently to you and you can't control that.

irisgg7 · 26/12/2023 15:12

@Tandora

No child is the second coming of christ..but please explain why it's so important to hold a delicate newborn (when health advice is to shield them) and why if you don't get your way you will cut them out?

Babysitting Is a privilege when you love a child. It's a wonderful thing to do, so many memories are built on babysitting.

It's exorbitantly priced when someone doesn't love and cherish your child!! When someone does, it's a gift to them and your child, they are bonding and building memories.

See that's the time to make bonds, not when they are 4 weeks old, and just need mum.

Because your entire argument it based on your wants, your desires, not what's best for a tiny baby.

Justforxmas2023 · 26/12/2023 15:05

@Katypp it makes perfect sense that you think the sign is dramatic and unnecessary if you’ve not had the misfortune of dealing with overbearing relatives who won’t give back your crying baby/insist on kissing them on the face etc.
Sadly these people do exist. The sign is clearly not aimed at people who behave sensibly. It’s a shame this OPs SIL felt it would be necessary but it probably speaks volumes about her past experiences of behaviour of the family.

irisgg7 · 26/12/2023 15:00

@Angelsrose mine are late teens now, so good luck to anyone trying to cuddle them.

You can't flip back that you have made some awful comments and that you are willing to exclude yourself from a family member because you didn't get your own way when they were babies 🙄

You made very clear statements about not helping someone if you couldn't have your own way....

It's not your baby, you don't get to choose. Calling for grace now, it's bit late for that 😂

Katypp · 26/12/2023 14:48

Who are these people who are snatching, pawing and monopolising newborn babies? I can't say I've ever come across any of them.
I've also never come across anyone who would think it normal to put a 'do not touch' sign over a baby either.
I would tegard this sign as attention seeking and overly dramatic and totally unneccessary. The problem with pushing away oldergenerations as a pp mentioned and taking all advice from an echo chamber of like-minded people is there are no checks and balances.
There are plenty saying this is completely normal and others need to butt out, but it really isn't.

Alasar · 26/12/2023 14:43

In Ireland we have been told by the HSE to cocoon small babies and not let lots of people hold them due to RSV and flu being rampant and babies getting very ill from it

Justforxmas2023 · 26/12/2023 14:42

Tandora · 26/12/2023 13:48

I don’t see it as being about being vengeful. It’s about the parents attitude towards their wider family and friends. Some parents are so self absorbed and entitled. They think their baby is some kind of prize possession that they can use to confer status and power, because of the love and interest that others have in their baby, all the while totally failing to recognise, value and support/ nurture that love and those relationships and the importance of them. In my experience that attitude continues, until of course parents inevitably need / want help, then all of a sudden that “family” are expected to drop everything and be at their service. People understandably end up feeling unvalued, trodden on a used When involved in a dynamic like that. It’s completely one sided. Another attitude says that babies are not possessions but individuals born into a family. Yes the primary and most important bond is with the parents, but other family members are important too and those relationships should be valued, respected and nurtured as independent in their own right.

How is it self absorbed and entitled to put the safety of your baby over the need of someone to cuddle/kiss/whatever else a baby? Clearly OP is not that close as she states this is the only time she will see the baby in several months so this is not someone who is going to be offering regular childcare in future.

of course a newborn baby is not a prize possession- they aren’t a possession of anyone at all. As the mother of 3 month old who happens to err on the side of caution I don’t identify with what you say about conferring status or power at all. It’s very far from my way of thinking and this mother is just trying to keep her tiny baby safe while she gets to grip with things. Yes she’s possibly gone a bit OTT with the sign but she’s 3 weeks postpartum, hormonal and finding her feet as a new mum so think she could probably do with a bit of kindness rather than people telling her she’s pathetic/power hungry or whatever.

honestly some of these posts!

Calliopespa · 26/12/2023 14:33

Gymrabbit · 26/12/2023 13:22

Yanbu at all but there are always lots of nutjobs twats on mumsnet in favour of this sort of thing.
I think it’s fine and when your SIL inevitably wants help with stuff down the line you will
be able to say you oh no we could too ask boy touch your precious child.

That’s what’s known as malicious obedience.

megletthesecond · 26/12/2023 14:33

It it's true then I don't blame her. It was so disruptive trying to establish feeding and resting when every visitor would carry and jiggle my DC. They aren't toys.
I didn't have visitors second time around so I could recover and bf.

MmedeGouge · 26/12/2023 14:30

90yomakeuproom · 26/12/2023 09:07

I agree with your SIL and wish I'd have had the balls to do that.
When I had a newborn with a stream of people and someone said 'I need to have a go now' I was about to blow my top!
Like pp said, they're babies not toys!

Me too!

Angelsrose · 26/12/2023 14:26

@irisgg7 You do what you like and what makes you feel comfortable. Allow others the grace to do the same.