Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Having to do prayers on Christmas Day

560 replies

Fretfulmum · 25/12/2023 23:50

DH is Christian and he and his family are quite religious- goes to church weekly etc. I’m not Christian and I don’t attend church or do anything religious, I’m pretty much an atheist. We hosted DH’s parents and siblings and partners today. His parents wanted to do prayers before Christmas lunch. I told DH I’m not happy about having to do it but just let them get on with it whilst I sat there. In the evening, they wanted to do more. I’d had enough and I left the room without saying anything and let them crack on with it. Half way through the DC (toddlers) realised I wasn’t there and left the room to see where I was so they missed some of it. DH was so angry with me that I didn’t partake as it was a “whole family unit” thing and it disrespected his whole family? Apparently I ruined the day and now he’s sleeping in the spare room. AIBU that’s it my house and if I don’t want to do religious prayers that I sit out and go into another room ?

OP posts:
Tacotortoise · 26/12/2023 22:23

LittleRedSnidyHood · 26/12/2023 22:16

Christmas is not a religious holiday. It's a pagan holiday that Christians stole and is now largely secular.

I'd be happy to rename btw, Midwinter Festival would be fine but I think it's a bit dull. Get shitfacedandovereatmas is too much.

Bollocks.

Christmas is a Christian festival (so religious) which was superimposed onto a variety of pagan festivals - Saturnalia, Yuletide etc - which were based around the winter solstice. These were also religious festivals, just ones that prayed to older gods.

CandyLeBonBon · 26/12/2023 22:21

LittleRedSnidyHood · 26/12/2023 22:16

Christmas is not a religious holiday. It's a pagan holiday that Christians stole and is now largely secular.

I'd be happy to rename btw, Midwinter Festival would be fine but I think it's a bit dull. Get shitfacedandovereatmas is too much.

😂😂😂

LittleRedSnidyHood · 26/12/2023 22:16

Christmas is not a religious holiday. It's a pagan holiday that Christians stole and is now largely secular.

I'd be happy to rename btw, Midwinter Festival would be fine but I think it's a bit dull. Get shitfacedandovereatmas is too much.

SpecialCharacters · 26/12/2023 22:13

LittleRedSnidyHood · 26/12/2023 21:52

Hmmm, I think it's a bit rude imposing your religion on a non religious house.
Put it this way, if op were humanist. Would it still be ok?
How about if she were Muslim?
How about if she had been Christian but left the church for a very good reason?
What if the in-laws were wiccan? Still ok? Or is it only Christianity that gets the pass?

No, it isn’t only Christianity that gets a pass. If you invite guests (who you know to be very religious) to observe a religious holiday in your home, I do not think it rude for the guests to ask if it’s okay for them to engage in an act of worship.

(Incidentally, I think it’s clear that the OP does ‘belong’ to a non-Christian faith and, while not a ‘believer’ anymore, values the cultural aspect).

1dayatatime · 26/12/2023 22:12

@LittleRedSnidyHood

"Hmmm, I think it's a bit rude imposing your religion on a non religious house."

+++

I completely agree but I would go further and question why is the religious Christian festival of Christmas being imposed on a country where the majority are not Christian.

And if for the majority it is just about time off work, booze, eating and presents then let's at least be honest about it and rename it

CandyLeBonBon · 26/12/2023 22:11

what is the actual point of Christmas.

To spend time with family, to come together and celebrate the end of the year and impending spring, and rest at a dark and miserable time of year, to take some much needed time to rest and recuperate from a busy year, to slow down and take stock. To spend time doing things you wouldn't otherwise do.

That works for me and not a manger in sight!

1dayatatime · 26/12/2023 22:04

CandyLeBonBon · 26/12/2023 19:58

Good luck getting the Christmas genie back in the bottle!

Quite!

The puritans tried to cancel Christmas- not sure it went very well!

I agree i can't see it ever happening.

But my logic is given that the majority of people in the UK don't identify as Christian then other than some bank holidays and an opportunity to get pissed, stuff your face and buy / give presents- what is the actual point of Christmas.

As an interim step it could be renamed say as "year end holiday" which would have the added benefit of being more inclusive to all religions and those that are not religious (I don't think winter festival would work for the southern hemisphere!) .

Then after a while and a further decline in the number of people identifying as Christian, the question then arises of what's the point of it or at least shift the one or two bank holidays to say the 30th & 31st Dec.

Fretfulmum · 26/12/2023 21:56

@SoreAndTired1 weve been hosting all day again today for friends so not had a chance to say much to each other but being civil in front of others. No idea what’s in store for me tonight yet!

OP posts:
LittleRedSnidyHood · 26/12/2023 21:52

Hmmm, I think it's a bit rude imposing your religion on a non religious house.
Put it this way, if op were humanist. Would it still be ok?
How about if she were Muslim?
How about if she had been Christian but left the church for a very good reason?
What if the in-laws were wiccan? Still ok? Or is it only Christianity that gets the pass?

SpecialCharacters · 26/12/2023 21:46

LittleRedSnidyHood · 26/12/2023 21:40

Your house, your rules your kids.
My religious parents have once or twice done a quick prayer when they are hosting, but tbh I think they've stopped because they probably feel awkward with us sitting there awkwardly. Both atheists.

They wouldn't dream of making me pray in my own house. We'll get god bless you, I'm praying for you messages, which, at some times seem annoyingly and downright insensitive we mostly just accept that's what they want to hear and part of their language. The odd religious book given at Christian festivals gets a polite thank you at the time and an eye roll or a giggle after they've gone. Unsurprisingly, children show zero interest in the books other than when they were very young and mostly wanted to eat them.

I haven't read the whole thread and I'm sure from your replies it's come up, but this is a husband problem, an in-laws boundaries problem and a values clash. It's not you.

I’m actually not sure if DH’s family have done anything wrong. It seems as though they asked DH if they could say a prayer, got the all clear, and and were happy enough to do so without OP in the room.

Its DH that’s the problem, here, by trying to coerce participation.

LittleRedSnidyHood · 26/12/2023 21:40

Your house, your rules your kids.
My religious parents have once or twice done a quick prayer when they are hosting, but tbh I think they've stopped because they probably feel awkward with us sitting there awkwardly. Both atheists.

They wouldn't dream of making me pray in my own house. We'll get god bless you, I'm praying for you messages, which, at some times seem annoyingly and downright insensitive we mostly just accept that's what they want to hear and part of their language. The odd religious book given at Christian festivals gets a polite thank you at the time and an eye roll or a giggle after they've gone. Unsurprisingly, children show zero interest in the books other than when they were very young and mostly wanted to eat them.

I haven't read the whole thread and I'm sure from your replies it's come up, but this is a husband problem, an in-laws boundaries problem and a values clash. It's not you.

NumberTheory · 26/12/2023 21:31

1dayatatime · 26/12/2023 19:50

@NumberTheory

"Even if you ignore the fact the celebration is rooted in other traditions, Christmas in the UK is a mainly non-religious festival because it was forced on the population as a whole and the majority of the population is no longer religious. "

+++

You are correct that the majority of the population no longer identifies as Christian .

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-63792408.amp

If as you say it has been forced on the population and is a non religious festival then I would totally be up for either scrapping it altogether or maybe changing the day to coincide with Amazon Prime Day - I mean what is the point otherwise?

The UK productivity would be massively boosted by not effectively shutting down the economy for the best part of a month as well as saving massive amounts of money on gifts, food etc.

Those that wish to celebrate it as a Christian festival can still take the day off work or give those that follow a religion of whatever faith x number of days off.

I could go for some of that, though quite value the somewhat shared expectations of a feast and a reason to decorate mid-winter.

Personally, I’d like to see the New Year celebration expanded and drop Christmas.

SoreAndTired1 · 26/12/2023 21:07

Fretfulmum · 26/12/2023 20:57

For those saying walking out is attention grabbing, our house has multiple rooms and we walk in and out of them all day, so me getting up and walking out of one room would make no one notice, it is normal behaviour.

@NumberTheory this did make me think as I’m now suspecting that DH would like to be as religious as his upbringing and family are, but he knows that I wouldn’t be partaking and he doesn’t know how to handle this. He knows we will never have a family life like his siblings due to my non religious beliefs and maybe he regrets thinking he would be happy with our current set up. I also think him seeing his siblings and their partners and children yesterday all being “happy and religious together” has made him yearn for that. These are big assumptions and I could be wrong but I’m willing to bet my bottom dollar that I’m right. I’m going to let all this blow over and talk about it next week.

@Fretfulmum Has he said anything to you at all today? Is he still in the spare room tonight?

SpecialCharacters · 26/12/2023 21:06

NumberTheory · 26/12/2023 21:01

Could you describe the scene you imagine where a woman walking out of a room in her own home to go and do something else while her kids, their father and her PiL are there is attention grabbing behaviour?

Because I would expect millions of women did this over Christmas as they got Christmas dinner on or avoided a family Pictionary session. Were they all just attention seeking rather than getting on with chores or giving the people that wanted to do X the space to do it? I find it hard to imagine how it would be attention grabbing unless they loudly declared a dislike and flounced.

I’d assume there’s a big overlap between those posters who believe that a woman must actively worship whatever deity her husband tells her to and those who think a woman must be excused before leaving a room in her own house.

(Okay, or people who don’t properly read a thread before responding).

NumberTheory · 26/12/2023 21:01

Thepossibility · 26/12/2023 20:08

I think you were rude. I'm not religious myself so when DH family pray I close my eyes and thank the universe for my healthy family.
I think what you did was especially strange because your children were there, so of course walking away was attention grabbing behaviour.

Could you describe the scene you imagine where a woman walking out of a room in her own home to go and do something else while her kids, their father and her PiL are there is attention grabbing behaviour?

Because I would expect millions of women did this over Christmas as they got Christmas dinner on or avoided a family Pictionary session. Were they all just attention seeking rather than getting on with chores or giving the people that wanted to do X the space to do it? I find it hard to imagine how it would be attention grabbing unless they loudly declared a dislike and flounced.

SpecialCharacters · 26/12/2023 21:00

@Fretfulmum , while you’re about, notwithstanding that you don’t believe in any of it, it sounds as though there are parts of these prayers that you find particularly objectionable,
would you mind sharing what they are?

Fretfulmum · 26/12/2023 20:57

For those saying walking out is attention grabbing, our house has multiple rooms and we walk in and out of them all day, so me getting up and walking out of one room would make no one notice, it is normal behaviour.

@NumberTheory this did make me think as I’m now suspecting that DH would like to be as religious as his upbringing and family are, but he knows that I wouldn’t be partaking and he doesn’t know how to handle this. He knows we will never have a family life like his siblings due to my non religious beliefs and maybe he regrets thinking he would be happy with our current set up. I also think him seeing his siblings and their partners and children yesterday all being “happy and religious together” has made him yearn for that. These are big assumptions and I could be wrong but I’m willing to bet my bottom dollar that I’m right. I’m going to let all this blow over and talk about it next week.

OP posts:
SoreAndTired1 · 26/12/2023 20:45

Thepossibility · 26/12/2023 20:08

I think you were rude. I'm not religious myself so when DH family pray I close my eyes and thank the universe for my healthy family.
I think what you did was especially strange because your children were there, so of course walking away was attention grabbing behaviour.

@Thepossibility READ THE FULL THREAD and ALL OP's posts! It was a ten minute (2 x 5 minutes) religious performance, and she wasn't allowed to sit silently, she was expected to hold hands, participate, recite and chant - THE WORKS. This wasn't merely saying grace, this was a full on production. She already did the first prayer session. This is more than enough! And she didn't 'walk away', if you bothered to read her posts you'd see she had been out of the room before they even started the second session. She didn't 'walk away' mid session.

SoreAndTired1 · 26/12/2023 20:41

Pieceofpurplesky · 26/12/2023 19:59

It's all about respect and teaching your DS respect. Whilst you are an atheist you know your DH isn't and showing respect by sitting silently for 5 minutes is not a big ask. You were rude and are teaching your DC to be rude.

Yet another poster who does not bother to READ THE FULL THREAD. @Pieceofpurplesky Please read all of the OP's posts, not just the first one, in a thread with several pages. It was a ten minute (2 x 5 minutes) religious performance, and she wasn't allowed to 'sit silently', she was expected to hold hands, participate, recite and chant - THE WORKS. This wasn't merely saying grace, this was a full on production. Being silent was not an option. Her husband and inlaws showed no respect for HER. She already did the first prayer session. This is more than enough!

Grimpo · 26/12/2023 20:21

RendeersDancingTowardsChristmas · 26/12/2023 00:04

I think you were rude. Sitting for 5 minutes in silence is a little thing for you, but obviously does mean the world to your DH.

Is there anything specific that you don't like about his faith, that collide with your own beliefs?

Why is it obvious that it means the world to OP's DH? He clearly doesn't do it normally, or this issue would have arisen a long time ago.

Grimpo · 26/12/2023 20:15

Hermittrismegistus · 26/12/2023 00:00

Christians want to say prayers during a Christian festival. Shock horror.

Atheist doesn't. Shock horror.

Grimpo · 26/12/2023 20:13

Assuming your husband doesn't do these prayers normally, he was being a real hypocrite. Tell him to think about that and stop sulking.

SpecialCharacters · 26/12/2023 20:12

Thepossibility · 26/12/2023 20:08

I think you were rude. I'm not religious myself so when DH family pray I close my eyes and thank the universe for my healthy family.
I think what you did was especially strange because your children were there, so of course walking away was attention grabbing behaviour.

And what if your DH and his family demanded that you start chanting with them, particularly if you didn’t agree with the things you were being required to chant?

Thepossibility · 26/12/2023 20:08

I think you were rude. I'm not religious myself so when DH family pray I close my eyes and thank the universe for my healthy family.
I think what you did was especially strange because your children were there, so of course walking away was attention grabbing behaviour.

CandyLeBonBon · 26/12/2023 20:04

Even in more religious times, it seems that people were too interested in having fun!!

On 19 December 1643, an ordinance was passed encouraging subjects to treat the mid-winter period 'with the more solemn humiliation because it may call to remembrance our sins, and the sins of our forefathers, who have turned this feast, pretending the memory of Christ, into an extreme forgetfulness of him, by giving liberty to carnal and sensual delights'. The rejection of Christmas as a joyful period was reiterated when a 1644 ordinance confirmed the abolition of the feasts of Christmas, Easter and Whitsun. From this point until the Restoration in 1660, Christmas was officially illegal.

So there you all go. 😂