Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Having to do prayers on Christmas Day

560 replies

Fretfulmum · 25/12/2023 23:50

DH is Christian and he and his family are quite religious- goes to church weekly etc. I’m not Christian and I don’t attend church or do anything religious, I’m pretty much an atheist. We hosted DH’s parents and siblings and partners today. His parents wanted to do prayers before Christmas lunch. I told DH I’m not happy about having to do it but just let them get on with it whilst I sat there. In the evening, they wanted to do more. I’d had enough and I left the room without saying anything and let them crack on with it. Half way through the DC (toddlers) realised I wasn’t there and left the room to see where I was so they missed some of it. DH was so angry with me that I didn’t partake as it was a “whole family unit” thing and it disrespected his whole family? Apparently I ruined the day and now he’s sleeping in the spare room. AIBU that’s it my house and if I don’t want to do religious prayers that I sit out and go into another room ?

OP posts:
Workworkandmoreworknow · 27/12/2023 04:42

For 5 minutes, knowing that you had married into a religious family and it was one of the most important days in the religious calendar, you were rude to walk away.

I am atheist but get that Christmas is about more than Santa for many people. It's not difficult to respect that for 5 minutes. And especially not when it literally involves sitting there.

You should apologise and then put in place a plan going forwards otherwise it is going to become a thing in your marriage.

GuessItsANameChange · 27/12/2023 04:29

PurpleBugz · 27/12/2023 04:08

Yes I think you are unreasonable. It's Christmas they are Christian. But take the religion out of it because that always has atheists showing no respect for Christianity. Your own husband wanted you to stay in the room for 5 minutes to be with him for something that is important to him and has been important to him for a long time. Yes you are unreasonable. What if he had asked you to come see something important to him in the garden or watched him play a song on an instrument would you refuse because you don't want to put shoes on or his taste in music sucks? No you humor him because he's your husband and that is important to him

So if someone important to you insisted that you join them in praying to a non-Christian god, and chant things that you fundamentally did not agree with, you would duly oblige?

Aren’t people entitled to their own beliefs?

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/12/2023 04:16

because that always has atheists showing no respect for Christianity.

No, why should we? I have great respect for a great many Christians. But not Christianity. And you can't take the religion out of it. It isn't the same as looking at a flower or listening to an instrument.

Some of us have been forced to participate in Christian religion since school. Some of us were shamed for walking out of prayer in assembly 40 years ago. We're done. If you and yours hadn't insisted on everyone joining in using the law, we'd maybe retain some fellow feeling. Add everything from the Catholic Church abuse to the Magdalene laundries and residential schools... I certainly feel less inclined to join in with Christianity than any other religion.

Fraaahnces · 27/12/2023 04:16

I would make it very clear to DH that he married you knowing that you are not a Christian or a hypocrite. It is disrespectful of them to attempt to coerce you into a practice that makes you uncomfortable. I would point out that you respect that his beliefs are important to him and his parents and I would say that he and his parents are welcome to say prayers in your home - but as you have , shopped, cleaned and prepared the meal, etc, as a sign of respect for YOUR beliefs, you should be ASKED if you want to participate, as it is equally your house too. Make it clear that you and the kids will not be forced into participating. If the kids want to join in, then fine. If they wander off, that’s fine too.

SpecialCharacters · 27/12/2023 04:12

PurpleBugz · 27/12/2023 04:08

Yes I think you are unreasonable. It's Christmas they are Christian. But take the religion out of it because that always has atheists showing no respect for Christianity. Your own husband wanted you to stay in the room for 5 minutes to be with him for something that is important to him and has been important to him for a long time. Yes you are unreasonable. What if he had asked you to come see something important to him in the garden or watched him play a song on an instrument would you refuse because you don't want to put shoes on or his taste in music sucks? No you humor him because he's your husband and that is important to him

Those are ridiculous comparisons, but to stick with them.

It’s one thing to ask your spouse to listen to you play a musical instrument.

Its quite another thing to demand that you join the band.

PurpleBugz · 27/12/2023 04:08

Yes I think you are unreasonable. It's Christmas they are Christian. But take the religion out of it because that always has atheists showing no respect for Christianity. Your own husband wanted you to stay in the room for 5 minutes to be with him for something that is important to him and has been important to him for a long time. Yes you are unreasonable. What if he had asked you to come see something important to him in the garden or watched him play a song on an instrument would you refuse because you don't want to put shoes on or his taste in music sucks? No you humor him because he's your husband and that is important to him

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/12/2023 03:50

Castlerock44 · 27/12/2023 03:12

How dare those Christians want to pray on the most important date in their calender. 🥺 All religions have their practices that should be respected.

And if OP had prevented them praying, you'd have a point. She just didn't want to join in.

Do you think atheists should be routinely forced to pray? Because that sounds, what's the word, abusive.

NumberTheory · 27/12/2023 03:32

comfyshoes2022 · 27/12/2023 03:12

I think leaving can feel to the people being left like “I can’t stand to be around this crap and so I must leave.” Whereas staying put seems to convey more tolerance and acceptance. I’m sure it’s not meant in this way but I do think it can inadvertently cause this impression.

That sounds more like an abusive relationship where you have to walk on eggshells so as not to cause offence.

SpecialCharacters · 27/12/2023 03:18

comfyshoes2022 · 27/12/2023 02:01

I have at various points in life been present for people praying in different faiths to mine ( Jewish and Muslim vs Christian). I do not speak the words but I have no problem being present quietly while others are praying. I don’t think it would make a difference whether it was in my home or somewhere else. I would even do it for a fairly extended length of time provided that it was on a one-off or occasional (as in, yearly or less) basis. So I am sorry but guess I do feel YABU. This just seems like being respectful of family members’ beliefs and not a particularly large sacrifice.

For me, I’d happily sit in respectful silence for something akin to The Lord’s Prayer or grace. That said, OP seems to imply that her in-laws prayers strike quite a different tone and involve saying a lot of things that she actively doesn’t agree with. If this is fire-and-brimstone stuff, for example, I wouldn’t want to be present for that.

This is also all against a backdrop of the OP’s family’s ongoing refusal to accept her beliefs.

That Christians deserve respect, but don’t have to afford it to others, feels like a running theme on this thread (although not a direct response to your comments).

SpecialCharacters · 27/12/2023 03:16

Castlerock44 · 27/12/2023 03:12

How dare those Christians want to pray on the most important date in their calender. 🥺 All religions have their practices that should be respected.

So why doesn’t that flow both ways? Why can DH’s family not respect that OP does not want to actively participate in their prayers?

Why is it okay for someone to demand that you worship their god?

Castlerock44 · 27/12/2023 03:12

How dare those Christians want to pray on the most important date in their calender. 🥺 All religions have their practices that should be respected.

comfyshoes2022 · 27/12/2023 03:12

NumberTheory · 27/12/2023 02:54

If you aren’t a believer, how is it disrespectful to give them the space to pray without you there?

I think leaving can feel to the people being left like “I can’t stand to be around this crap and so I must leave.” Whereas staying put seems to convey more tolerance and acceptance. I’m sure it’s not meant in this way but I do think it can inadvertently cause this impression.

SpecialCharacters · 27/12/2023 03:02

I’m actually going to walk back a little from saying that perhaps DH’s family didn’t do much wrong themselves - now noting the update that they gave DH a hard time for the OP’s non-participation.

That said, while they may be the root of the problem, her DH should shut that down, not enforce it.

NumberTheory · 27/12/2023 02:54

comfyshoes2022 · 27/12/2023 02:01

I have at various points in life been present for people praying in different faiths to mine ( Jewish and Muslim vs Christian). I do not speak the words but I have no problem being present quietly while others are praying. I don’t think it would make a difference whether it was in my home or somewhere else. I would even do it for a fairly extended length of time provided that it was on a one-off or occasional (as in, yearly or less) basis. So I am sorry but guess I do feel YABU. This just seems like being respectful of family members’ beliefs and not a particularly large sacrifice.

If you aren’t a believer, how is it disrespectful to give them the space to pray without you there?

ToWhitToWhoo · 27/12/2023 02:19

At first, I did think you were being rude and intolerant, but the additional information about them having told you that they would like to be a Christian rather changes things. It does seem as though they're trying to convert you, not just engaging in their own religious practices. I don't blame you for being fed up with it.

comfyshoes2022 · 27/12/2023 02:01

I have at various points in life been present for people praying in different faiths to mine ( Jewish and Muslim vs Christian). I do not speak the words but I have no problem being present quietly while others are praying. I don’t think it would make a difference whether it was in my home or somewhere else. I would even do it for a fairly extended length of time provided that it was on a one-off or occasional (as in, yearly or less) basis. So I am sorry but guess I do feel YABU. This just seems like being respectful of family members’ beliefs and not a particularly large sacrifice.

SpecialCharacters · 27/12/2023 01:58

No problem, it’s hard to track the conversation, not least because of the number of posters who are replying without actually reading/digesting what the OP has said.

NumberTheory · 27/12/2023 01:54

@SpecialCharacters Sorry.

SpecialCharacters · 27/12/2023 01:53

@NumberTheory

In short, and depending on how the conversation went, I don’t think it’s necessarily rude that DH’s family wanted to say a prayer- I see the forced participation as the issue (or, at least, a much bigger issue).

LRSH disagrees and think that their wanting to pray at the table is rude in and of itself.

Personally, if I had invited some devout Christians to my home on Christmas, where my Christian DH also resides, I would half expect them to want to say a prayer and would not be affronted by it (in principle- in practice it may depend on the words). I wouldn’t be joining in, though.

SpecialCharacters · 27/12/2023 01:40

NumberTheory · 27/12/2023 01:19

OP had no problem with them engaging in worship.

The problem here is the DH who expected OP to pretend she’s religious around his parents.

Yes, I know, I’ve pointed that out about 10 times on the thread already - but in the above I was responding to LittleRedSnidyHood’s particular comments.

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/12/2023 01:34

WickDittington · 26/12/2023 23:48

These were also religious festivals, just ones that prayed to older gods.

Absolutely @Tacotortoise The ignorance of religious history on this thread is legion!

I just spent a chunk of time in a really interesting country where animist beliefs coexist with a lot of other religious traditions. Pretty much everyone we met observed a hodge-podge of traditions, vaguely religious and superstitious rituals, and a lot of interesting traditions like casting bones to tell the future.

No one said, "well actually you can only cast bones if you're animist, walk that way around the mosque if you're Muslim and touch that if you're Christian.". Everyone just respected everyone else doing as little or as much as they liked while having commonly observed cultural 'manners'. My favourite of which was that they believed if you didn't know the superstition it wouldn't affect you.

Just like the UK. People pick up what they want and drop what they don't. The trick is not to demand everyone participates in the exact way you want. The UK has Christmas a a mostly cultural break in the winter, just when we need one. It doesn't have to be more complicated than that. The ILs can pray, OP can quietly exit before they do. It's not rude, or bad, or disrespectful. She does her, they do them.

NumberTheory · 27/12/2023 01:19

SpecialCharacters · 26/12/2023 22:23

I’m well aware of the origins and the widespread secular practices (not least as a pagan-turned-atheist myself).

But it’s churlish in the extreme to suggest that there is no Christian element to Christmas. If you invite a devout Christian family to your home, on Christmas, I think you have to reasonably expect that they may want to engage in an act of worship at some point.

OP had no problem with them engaging in worship.

The problem here is the DH who expected OP to pretend she’s religious around his parents.

1dayatatime · 27/12/2023 00:52

SpecialCharacters · 26/12/2023 23:26

I’ll vote Santaday, which should fall on the last Saturday of the year.

Then we could have Whigfield slightly rework their 90s hit into a festive song.

Ahh but then we would simply get into another debate between those who believe in Santa and celebrate their beliefs with stockings by the fire with mince pies and carrots and those that don't believe.

SpecialCharacters · 27/12/2023 00:33

NaughtybutNice77 · 27/12/2023 00:23

I think it's wrong of your OH to expect you to 'join in'. I'm assuming you've already had a conversation about your children and how they will he brought up so no it isn't a whole family thing!
I'm unsure exactly what this partaking of prayers involved. If it was a quick bow your head and mutter 'grace' then I think it's quite intolerant to leave the room. If it's something that involves everyone giving thanks and 'praising the Lord' yes, that would grate.
It sounds to me like it's your OH not your guests that have the problem. Could it be that he's torn and has ambivalence about his faith which is the real issue?

I'm unsure exactly what this partaking of prayers involved. If it was a quick bow your head and mutter 'grace' then I think it's quite intolerant to leave the room. If it's something that involves everyone giving thanks and 'praising the Lord' yes, that would grate.
Radical thought, how about reading the OP’s posts?

NaughtybutNice77 · 27/12/2023 00:23

I think it's wrong of your OH to expect you to 'join in'. I'm assuming you've already had a conversation about your children and how they will he brought up so no it isn't a whole family thing!
I'm unsure exactly what this partaking of prayers involved. If it was a quick bow your head and mutter 'grace' then I think it's quite intolerant to leave the room. If it's something that involves everyone giving thanks and 'praising the Lord' yes, that would grate.
It sounds to me like it's your OH not your guests that have the problem. Could it be that he's torn and has ambivalence about his faith which is the real issue?

Swipe left for the next trending thread